M-FM XXV Batman Gamethread - Page 11
Register

User Tag List

Page 11 of 31 FirstFirst ... 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 21 ... LastLast
Results 501 to 550 of 1515
  1. ISO #501

    Re: M-FM Batman [Gamethread]

    the login time thing. i dont know what its called but like when you last login.

    also with that same logic you could apply that i am citizen so ( i understand what you mean though, on my old forum maf site Citizens were also inactive goofs)
    cant i just watch anime tbh i didnt realise this game was this complicated and shit maybe i shouldnt have joined idk

  2. ISO #502

  3. ISO #503

  4. ISO #504

  5. ISO #505

  6. ISO #506

  7. ISO #507

  8. ISO #508

    Re: M-FM Batman [Gamethread]

    Quote Originally Posted by MFM Snake View Post
    I'm also going to do probability for being scum thing lets go lol run on sentence unpunctuated arson

    MFM Armadillo - This guy is still alive? 5/10 might be jester
    MFM Beaver - My highest Riddler candidate for now but his post timing might mean nothing, lurker 7/10
    MFM Cat - Joker candidate 7/10
    MFM Dolphin - This guy hasn't posted like at all ???/10
    MFM Elephant - Same as dolphin ????/10
    MFM Frog - Posts like once a day and has like a consigliere code wow idk lol 6/10
    MFM Jellyfish - This guy posted like once? ???/10
    MFM Kangaroo - Essentially my only townread right now 2/10
    MFM Llama - This guy posts a lot but doesn't mean a lot with it also a possible joker candidate 7/10
    MFM Moose - Scum 10/10
    MFM Narwhal - wow obviously scum totally not mayor 12/10
    MFM Octopus - Too many lurkers zzzzzz ???/10
    MFM Rabbit - I feel like this person posted day 1 but never posted again ???/10
    MFM Snake - such an obvious scum wow
    MFM Tiger - I'm sorry but this guy has been screaming scum to me all game long, I dunno why 8/10

    as you can see my grammar value has gone down dramatically and I am also really bad at this forum mafia thing
    ? I've been making a solid 3-5 posts everyday with actual FoSes and reasoning to back them up...

  9. ISO #509

  10. ISO #510

  11. ISO #511

    Re: M-FM Batman [Gamethread]

    Quote Originally Posted by MFM Beaver View Post
    js if you are gonna accuse me of being riddler then therr needs to be something more than "oh he came online after riddler guessed". when would I have time to even read back to see what gorilla could be? i literally was late to day yesterday because of school and stuff, and literally came online just to post my night action, my login thingie can prove as well.

    so yeah please explain how i could magically know what gorilla was.

    also wasnt there a thing in sign ups or something about riddler not being able to guess gordon? ill check back.
    You probably just made a guess of a lurker as citizen so as to get a kill off. You being riddler is more likely than other for now.

  12. ISO #512

    Re: M-FM Batman [Gamethread]

    Quote Originally Posted by MFM Rabbit View Post
    this plus the extensive discussion of Riddler mechanics = found the Riddler
    Well I don't really see any other roles that have mechanics to be debated at all. The joker is also more reliable kpn than the riddler, lynching the riddler isn't bad but killing the joker will benefit us more.

  13. ISO #513

  14. ISO #514

    Re: M-FM Batman [Gamethread]

    Quote Originally Posted by MFM Kangaroo View Post
    Even if he is lynching the Riddler, lynching the Joker is still much smarter. Please explain (or re-explain) why you think lynching Beaver is a smart idea.
    Because he's my heaviest scum read.

    Joker is a KPN, true, but he also is a blind one that has a higher chance of hitting Mafia than Riddler.

  15. ISO #515

    Re: M-FM Batman [Gamethread]

    Quote Originally Posted by MFM Snake View Post
    Well I don't really see any other roles that have mechanics to be debated at all. The joker is also more reliable kpn than the riddler, lynching the riddler isn't bad but killing the joker will benefit us more.
    Are you Mafia? I feel like that's a Mafia point of view, since the biggest threat is Joker. Town's too fucking inactive this game or just plain not reading.

  16. ISO #516

  17. ISO #517

  18. ISO #518

    Re: M-FM Batman [Gamethread]

    Quote Originally Posted by MFM Narwhal View Post
    Just gonna say that the current votes on Llama match the type of posters we where looking for

    MFM Cat, MFM Kangaroo, MFM Snake, MFM Jellyfish

    Two Lurker Types, Two Active types.

    Would be really amusing if they where all Mafia!
    I have a feeling that you just listed 4 town players. I think the scums are pretty passive on their votes.

  19. ISO #519

  20. ISO #520

    Re: M-FM Batman [Gamethread]

    Quote Originally Posted by MFM Narwhal View Post
    Just gonna say that the current votes on Llama match the type of posters we where looking for

    MFM Cat, MFM Kangaroo, MFM Snake, MFM Jellyfish

    Two Lurker Types, Two Active types.

    Would be really amusing if they where all Mafia!
    I'm certainly not scum, however I do find it odd that no one has even questioned me until now. For that reason I'm leaning a town read on Rabbit, odd as it seems.

  21. ISO #521

    Re: M-FM Batman [Gamethread]

    I'll give you all a little read. Tell me what you think of it.

    Spoiler : Night 3 Arty Chat :


    Night Three
    Postby Cryptonic » Sat Oct 11, 2014 3:03 am

    GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
    Cryptonic
    -------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Postby Arch1 » Sat Oct 11, 2014 3:35 am

    Batman is dead.
    Commissioner Gordon is useless.
    Harvey Dent might be Two-Face.
    There seemed to be six Citizens.
    Four PRs remaining!
    -------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Postby Arch2 » Sat Oct 11, 2014 6:48 am

    Two-Face here.
    Who are you?
    -------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Postby Arch2 » Sat Oct 11, 2014 6:49 am

    Or just what are you?
    -------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Postby Arch1 » Sat Oct 11, 2014 7:08 am

    Toxicodendron radicans.

    Can I join your gang?
    -------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Postby Arch1 » Sat Oct 11, 2014 7:41 am

    Since you are Two-Face, can you will me who you are?
    -------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Postby Arch2 » Sat Oct 11, 2014 8:54 am

    MFM Moose.
    -------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Postby Arch1 » Sat Oct 11, 2014 9:20 am

    You are not welcoming me to join your gang?
    -------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Postby Arch1 » Sat Oct 11, 2014 9:41 am

    Now I don't think you are Two-Face nor MFM Moose.
    -------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Postby Arch2 » Sat Oct 11, 2014 12:25 pm

    True. I'm Harvey Dent and MFM Narwhal.
    -------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Postby Arch1 » Sat Oct 11, 2014 12:52 pm

    Why do you think I'm town?
    -------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Postby Arch1 » Sat Oct 11, 2014 12:58 pm

    And told ya guys Batman is dead. Still think you are Godfather. Anyways, since you claimed town that wouldn't be dieing tonight, I had to act town too, just in case you snitch me out tomorrow.

    Arch1 wrote:
    N2: Arch1 made 1 post. Arch2 made 2 posts. Basically they discussed nothing.


    Members snapshot, taken on 2014 Oct 10, 11.30 PM

    Cryptonic 9 Wed Aug 13, 2014 4:03 pm
    Mafia1 3 Wed Aug 13, 2014 4:12 pm
    Mafia2 4 Wed Aug 13, 2014 4:13 pm
    Mafia3 10 Wed Aug 13, 2014 4:14 pm
    Mafia4 9 Sat Oct 04, 2014 2:59 am
    Arch1 3 Sat Oct 04, 2014 3:00 am
    Arch2 4 Sat Oct 04, 2014 3:01 am
    Kidnapper 5 Wed Oct 08, 2014 2:10 am
    Spy 4 Wed Oct 08, 2014 2:11 am

    On N2, Mafia3 and Mafia4 were quite active while Mafia1 and Mafia2 had low post counts. Latter two are likely inactive day posters. MFM Llama might be in Architect chat N2, probably as a Gangster. Architect chat might by controlled by Gangster too.

    Am sure the accounts are for MFM Batman since the first three Falcone Gangster accounts were made earlier, when the number of players were not met. Fourth was added later, together with Arch1 and Arch2 accounts. Quite likely that the fourth is the Gangster Architect.

    Arch2 claimed Two-Face and asked for my identity. By claiming Two-Face, Arch2 suggested that he was attacked N2. Unlikely that he is Two-Face since if he is he will grovel for his life. Maybe testing me whether I’m Gangster? Obviously not checking whether I’m Two-Face or Commissioner Gordon, since I was not attacked N2.


    8.00 PM, Mafia 3 logged in.
    11.00 PM, Mafia 2 logged in.


    Here ya go, my pro-town contribution.
    -------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Postby Arch1 » Sat Oct 11, 2014 1:03 pm

    I can discuss my read with you too. As long as you put in a good word for me tomorrow. Lets cooperate for now, you know, just in case you turn into Two-Face.

    So what kind of reads do you want, Boss?
    -------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Postby Arch1 » Sat Oct 11, 2014 1:05 pm

    Or most likely MFM Llama is in Architect chat N2, and since his counterpart was not posting, he hinted to his counterpart that he is also scum so that he won't die tonight.
    -------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Postby Arch1 » Sat Oct 11, 2014 1:11 pm

    If you are Mafia trying to backstab me, I have put everything in my last will. You will to need to clean or disguise as me if you want to betray me.
    -------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Postby Arch1 » Sat Oct 11, 2014 1:13 pm

    If you are some other Town, they trust me more than they trust you! :P
    -------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Postby Arch1 » Sat Oct 11, 2014 4:12 pm

    Hi Crypt!
    -------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Postby Arch2 » Sat Oct 11, 2014 4:38 pm

    Good work Sherlock. The bat might be dead, but his legacy lives on.
    If either of us two get shot, we know the architect is evil.

    I will be online more tonight, about 4 hours before the day begins. Reads will be great, as I can post them anonymously for you, silent witness.

    If the artitech is town. It can be used to avoid riddle trouble if one person. Passes the others information.

    Very interesting about the post counts. Thank you.
    -------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Postby Arch1 » Sat Oct 11, 2014 4:45 pm

    So...
    -------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Postby Arch1 » Sat Oct 11, 2014 4:49 pm

    Cancel MFM Batman, make it MFM Sherlock Holmes. Hi Watson.
    -------------------------------------------------------------------------

    Re: Night Three
    Postby Arch1 » Sat Oct 11, 2014 4:54 pm

    Nighty nite.

    And PLEASE DON'T KILL ME! MY HAND IS FORCED! HE IS THE MAYOR! BLAME YOURSELVES!
    -------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Postby Arch2 » Sun Oct 12, 2014 12:23 am

    Interesting.

    But honestly, this "Member posts" Thing, is it alright? Kinda against the night chat isn't it?

    Although. They can also see the information.
    -------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Postby Arch1 » Sun Oct 12, 2014 2:26 am

    Cryptonic 10 Wed Aug 13, 2014 4:03 pm
    Mafia1 3 Wed Aug 13, 2014 4:12 pm
    Mafia2 6 Wed Aug 13, 2014 4:13 pm
    Mafia3 13 Wed Aug 13, 2014 4:14 pm
    Mafia4 14 Sat Oct 04, 2014 2:59 am
    Arch1 16 Sat Oct 04, 2014 3:00 am
    Arch2 8 Sat Oct 04, 2014 3:01 am
    Kidnapper 5 Wed Oct 08, 2014 2:10 am
    Spy 4 Wed Oct 08, 2014 2:11 am
    -------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Postby Arch1 » Sun Oct 12, 2014 2:27 am

    Pathetic activity from Gangsters. Boring.
    -------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Postby Arch1 » Sun Oct 12, 2014 2:33 am

    To Gangsters,

    When it is safe for me to reveal, look for first word, first post of the day

    Joker: asdfg
    Riddler: asdfgh
    Amnesiac: lolololol
    Executioner: I found scum!
    Jester: I'm Joker, I'm immune, who should I kill?
    Student: -
    Survivor: Please don't kill me.
    Two-Face: That's it!
    Witch: I'm Poison Ivy.
    -------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Postby Arch1 » Sun Oct 12, 2014 2:37 am

    So that I know who to listen to, please use: shitshitshitshitshitshittttttttt during the day, or use last will.

    Order
    Not to lynch: HE IS TOWN!
    To lynch: HE MIGHT BE SCUM!
    -------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Postby Arch1 » Sun Oct 12, 2014 2:38 am
    For more specific orders, replace HE with MFM [insert name].

  22. ISO #522

  23. ISO #523

  24. ISO #524

  25. ISO #525

  26. ISO #526

    Re: M-FM Batman [Gamethread]

    Quote Originally Posted by MFM Llama View Post
    Confirmed scum > suspected joker?
    I wouldn't call him confirmed, honestly, but I will unvote for now until things become clearer.
    -vote unvote

    This is my first forum mafia game, so i'll admit i'm a little lost. The joker seems to me like a bigger priority than lynching a mafia, but lynching a mafia is a good as well. I dunno, I'm trying to take points from people who seem like more experienced players such as Kangaroo, however, I don't know if I can trust them.

    \\

  27. ISO #527

    Re: M-FM Batman [Gamethread]

    Okay I guess I'm going to make a read chart.

    Town
    Non-killing Neutral
    Killing Neutral
    Scum
    Mafia / Budding
    No read / Lurker

    MFM Armadillo Lurking, but a slight scum read.
    MFM Beaver I don't like his lurkieness and post timing, but I'm not positive of him.
    MFM Cat Lurkiness and lack of post content make me dislike him.
    MFM Dolphin No read, Lurking
    MFM Elephant Lack of post count and content.
    MFM Frog Obv consig codes.
    MFM Jellyfish No read.
    MFM Kangaroo Seems like an okay guy, but not the highest town read.
    MFM Llama I'm town.
    MFM Moose Pretty much confirmed mafia architech.
    MFM Narwhal obv town.
    MFM Octopus lurking
    MFM Rabbit eh.
    MFM Snake Doesnt seem to give a fuck either way.
    MFM Tiger I like his posts.

    Honestly I'm a terrible scum reader so don't take any of my reads to heart.

  28. ISO #528

  29. ISO #529

  30. ISO #530

    Re: M-FM Batman [Gamethread]

    Quote Originally Posted by MFM Llama View Post
    Okay I guess I'm going to make a read chart.

    Town
    Non-killing Neutral
    Killing Neutral
    Scum
    Mafia / Budding
    No read / Lurker

    MFM Armadillo Lurking, but a slight scum read.
    MFM Beaver I don't like his lurkieness and post timing, but I'm not positive of him.
    MFM Cat Lurkiness and lack of post content make me dislike him.
    MFM Dolphin No read, Lurking
    MFM Elephant Lack of post count and content.
    MFM Frog Obv consig codes.
    MFM Jellyfish No read.
    MFM Kangaroo Seems like an okay guy, but not the highest town read.
    MFM Llama I'm town.
    MFM Moose Pretty much confirmed mafia architech.
    MFM Narwhal obv town.
    MFM Octopus lurking
    MFM Rabbit eh.
    MFM Snake Doesnt seem to give a fuck either way.
    MFM Tiger I like his posts.

    Honestly I'm a terrible scum reader so don't take any of my reads to heart.
    I guess I can agree with a lot of this. I can see where I would be under neutral, for in many situations I like to stay equivocal, but I'm quickly finding out that's something not good to do in mafia....
    I think that I do see Cat as more of a joker candidate than llama at this point, but for now, I'll help lynch what is apparently confirmed scum.
    -vote MFM Moose

  31. ISO #531

    Re: M-FM Batman [Gamethread]

    I'll take a crack at it. More green is more of a town read. Yellow is middle of the road leaning Town. Orange is middle of the road leaning scum. Red is scummy. Blue means they're lurking fags. Not gonna say what roles I think people are (Other than Joker/Riddler) (Fuck the Riddler).


    MFM Armadillo: His claim about being doused and then being proved wrong seemed scummy. Since then he turned into a lurker. Really that one event is the only thing I can get reads on, yet it wasn't a pro-town move. I don't see any reason as to why a Townie would fake that claim. I honestly suspect a Jester.
    MFM Beaver: Lurking Fag. Yet from what I read today he actually seems rather nooby, honestly I think he's a noob. That ruins any potential reads I could have gotten from him.
    MFM Cat: Lurking Fag. He's had chances to participate, and I've seen him a lot, yet he hasn't. Scummy.
    MFM Dolphin: Lurking Fag. Literally I can't get anything at all on him.
    MFM Elephant: See MFM Dolphin.
    MFM Frog: Scum as fuck in my eyes. I seriously doubt him not being one. I gave him one orange due to the very slight chance of me being wrong.
    MFM Jellyfish: See MFM Elephant.
    MFM Kangaroo: This guy... he is not just a Town, but a mother fucking badass townie. I mean seriously, holy shit I almost shat myself from his badassery. This guy is neigh God level.
    MFM Llama: I doubt him being Mafia. Yet the potential for him being Joker is pretty good in my eyes. His post count D1 was uber high and then afterwards it just dropped. That's scummy in a sense...
    MFM Moose: He pretty much just claimed scum, and he pulled so much bullshit over the course of this game.
    MFM Narwhal: Being serious here. We had two nights with no kills. One was Batman but for all we know the second could have been him. He could be Two-Face for all we know.
    MFM Octopus: See MFM Jellyfish.
    MFM Rabbit: Ehh. this guy is wish-washy in my eyes. Yet... I almost think he's Town.
    MFM Snake: I personally think him Town. My reads on him have been Townie reads. Yet I've had nothing substantial to prove him Town other than a weak gut feeling.
    MFM Tiger: His post count is low. Yet like I said earlier in the game. Post Quality > Quantity and his posts have been rather pro-town in my readings. Yet still there is a lack of certainty.

  32. ISO #532

    Re: M-FM Batman [Gamethread]

    Quote Originally Posted by MFM Kangaroo View Post
    I'll take a crack at it. More green is more of a town read. Yellow is middle of the road leaning Town. Orange is middle of the road leaning scum. Red is scummy. Blue means they're lurking fags. Not gonna say what roles I think people are (Other than Joker/Riddler) (Fuck the Riddler).


    MFM Armadillo: His claim about being doused and then being proved wrong seemed scummy. Since then he turned into a lurker. Really that one event is the only thing I can get reads on, yet it wasn't a pro-town move. I don't see any reason as to why a Townie would fake that claim. I honestly suspect a Jester.
    MFM Beaver: Lurking Fag. Yet from what I read today he actually seems rather nooby, honestly I think he's a noob. That ruins any potential reads I could have gotten from him.
    MFM Cat: Lurking Fag. He's had chances to participate, and I've seen him a lot, yet he hasn't. Scummy.
    MFM Dolphin: Lurking Fag. Literally I can't get anything at all on him.
    MFM Elephant: See MFM Dolphin.
    MFM Frog: Scum as fuck in my eyes. I seriously doubt him not being one. I gave him one orange due to the very slight chance of me being wrong.
    MFM Jellyfish: See MFM Elephant.
    MFM Kangaroo: This guy... he is not just a Town, but a mother fucking badass townie. I mean seriously, holy shit I almost shat myself from his badassery. This guy is neigh God level.
    MFM Llama: I doubt him being Mafia. Yet the potential for him being Joker is pretty good in my eyes. His post count D1 was uber high and then afterwards it just dropped. That's scummy in a sense...
    MFM Moose: He pretty much just claimed scum, and he pulled so much bullshit over the course of this game.
    MFM Narwhal: Being serious here. We had two nights with no kills. One was Batman but for all we know the second could have been him. He could be Two-Face for all we know.
    MFM Octopus: See MFM Jellyfish.
    MFM Rabbit: Ehh. this guy is wish-washy in my eyes. Yet... I almost think he's Town.
    MFM Snake: I personally think him Town. My reads on him have been Townie reads. Yet I've had nothing substantial to prove him Town other than a weak gut feeling.
    MFM Tiger: His post count is low. Yet like I said earlier in the game. Post Quality > Quantity and his posts have been rather pro-town in my readings. Yet still there is a lack of certainty.
    I honestly agree with all of this, but much better worded than I could have put

    yes, i'm buddying with Kangaroo, what you gonna do about it

  33. ISO #533

  34. ISO #534

  35. ISO #535

    Re: M-FM Batman [Gamethread]

    Quote Originally Posted by MFM Jellyfish View Post
    HELLO

    sorry i hadn't checked in yet.
    nothing happened to me again last night

    [vote]MFM Llama[/vote[
    i was gonna place my vote on Elephant, but he's being voted for low activity and i didn't want to be a hypocrit
    ill check in before night if someone has q's
    He did post.
    [

  36. ISO #536

  37. ISO #537

  38. ISO #538

  39. ISO #539

  40. ISO #540

  41. ISO #541

  42. ISO #542

  43. ISO #543

  44. ISO #544

    Re: M-FM Batman [Gamethread]

    Quote Originally Posted by MFM Llama View Post
    Look we all need to agree on a lynch target today, if we don't lynch a scum today we will most likely lose.

    I suggest Moose (he overconfidently claimed scum/joker and then slinked back into lurk after Narwhal revealed)
    Well chances are we should go with what Narwhal decides since we might not have him tomorrow the way things are going.

  45. ISO #545

  46. ISO #546

  47. ISO #547

  48. ISO #548

    Re: M-FM Batman [Gamethread]

    I've discovered a magical thing called tapatalk, so I can stay a bit longer. I can't quote though sadly.

    Narwhal stated previously that he would probably be voting Moose, and that is one of the reasons I am currently voting him.

    Also, it's likely we will have him for at least one more day if not more; his vest has allegedly not been hit (if it had he would have said so and made scum win" and no protective roles have died yet assuming Gorilla and Wolf weren't as such.

  49. ISO #549

    Re: M-FM Batman [Gamethread]

    -vote MFM Moose


    I'm going with it. After seeing votes pass around and reading up I think Moose is the best person for us to lynch. I simply don't want to risk lynching a Town and I am neigh certain Moose is not Town, and if he is then he has done some serious stupid shit or game throwing. Honestly I see no way at all that a Townie could benefit from doing what he did. Mafia would know he's BS, and if he thought it would drive out the Joker and Riddler to reveal themselves and form a voting block then he is just flat out stupid and we deserve to lose.

    Honestly, if there weren't as many lurkers as there are... this would have been so much better...

  50. ISO #550

 

 

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •