M-FM XXV Batman Gamethread

[MFM Llama]

Frog are you claiming Batman, Commisioner, or Harvey Dent?


If so please confirm.

[MFM Narwhal]

Frog are you claiming Batman, Commisioner, or Harvey Dent?


If so please confirm.

He can only claim Batman without being Killed by the Riddler.
Unless he reveals if Mr Dent.

[MFM Llama]

He could confirm he is one of those three.

I would be happy with at least that.

[MFM Moose]

Returning my vote to the confirmed bad MFM Narwhal.

-vote MFM Narwhal

Don't be tricked by his Batman softclaim!

[MFM Llama]

Please elaborate on how he is "confirmed" bad.

[MFM Moose]

On MFM Armadilllo, witching from Drug Dealer to confuse investigation, dousing from Jester to be caught as Joker. Or MFM Armadillo is lying.

[MFM Narwhal]

Or its Real Witch + Drug Dealer

[MFM Moose]

Also I know investigative roles should not be outing due to getting killed every five minutes yet in the event they do would you think it smart for them to simply say "I'm an investigative role and got so and so as scum" not giving any details as to how they know. This would give the Riddler a 1/3 (1/4 if you consider Escort) chance. Which wouldn't be in his favor to guess.

MFM Kangaroo is wise.

[MFM Narwhal]

Please elaborate on how he is "confirmed" bad.

Jealous of my Tusk. Main Reason.

He's not saying my Avatar is a clue or something.
Because all I did was Type Batman Narwhal Avatar onto the search Engine and pick it because it fits. And its Cool.

I explained Invisible.

What else was there?

[MFM Rabbit]

A few possibilitys

1. They attacked an immune target.

2. Roleblock.

3. Target attacked and healed.

4. They utilized every one of their night abilitys, and did not attack anyone.

Personally I think 4 or 1 is most likely.

What? 4 is the most unlikely, I've never seen any Mafia with the ability to kill not use it. Elaborate on your point, because I don't see how that's a reasonable thought.

[MFM Zebra]

What? 4 is the most unlikely, I've never seen any Mafia with the ability to kill not use it. Elaborate on your point, because I don't see how that's a reasonable thought.

My thoughts exactly. I suppose 1 is the most likely, considering there's a night-immune neutral, potential bulletproofs/survivors, and Batman+Gordon+Dent with autovests. That's 4-6 targets, and out of the 16 non-mafia that's a 1/4 or better chance.

[MFM Llama]

Think about it, if you had a tailor, a consig, a drug dealer, and a agent. Would you rather use those abilitys to gain knowledge and disrupt the town (which can have a lasting affect) or off someone (which may or may not be your potential ally).

[MFM Wolf]

I don't think that we would be able to lynch anyone today at this rate. But I'm worried that the one who was killed by Joker could have been a Town PR.

Well, assuming that Batman is still alive, we should take it slowly from here as we try to gather leads one by one. He should jail someone tonight and extract from his target as much information as possible.

[MFM Moose]

Please lynch MFM Narwhal! I'm confirmed not Executioner, so my lead should be trusted.

[MFM Moose]

Those ignoring my lead are stupid or scums.

[MFM Llama]

So according to you 18 people are scum?

Last time I checked it was a max of 7 (including witch).

[MFM Pig]

Reading

[MFM Frog]

I figured it would be helpful if I addressed the questions directed me so here goes.

No Comment.

[MFM Llama]

Hm.

Well I feel it is too late and I do not have the influence to start a pressure train, nor do I want too.

[MFM Moose]

So according to you 18 people are scum?

The rest are stupid. You are either Joker or Consigliere.

[MFM Llama]

The rest are stupid. You are either Joker or Consigliere.

Elaborate on your guess.

[MFM Llama]

And If you assume I am one of those why are you not voting me?

[MFM Rabbit]

Think about it, if you had a tailor, a consig, a drug dealer, and a agent. Would you rather use those abilitys to gain knowledge and disrupt the town (which can have a lasting affect) or off someone (which may or may not be your potential ally).

Uhh..no...I'd kill no matter what. I'm pretty sure killing someone has a lasting effect too.

[MFM Llama]

Uhh..no...I'd kill no matter what. I'm pretty sure killing someone has a lasting effect too.

Heh, I would make a terrible scum.

[MFM Pig]

-vote MFM Narwhal

I'm willing to play and see where this goes.

Also in general, this should be a lynch day, as we have an odd number alive. Though I guess the chance of double night kills changes that a bit so idk

[MFM Pig]

Day ends in less than 24 hours, so let's start consolidating?

Seriously, everyone should at least be placing a RVS vote. A night has already happened, start voting please. We should definitely not have this many people not voting, it's pretty useless

[MFM Llama]

-vote MFM Moose

I do not like his behavior, it is very erratic.

[MFM Llama]

I shall return tomarrow.

See you in 10 hours.

[MFM Narwhal]

Nah don't vote moose. He seems like a fool.

[MFM Narwhal]

Well, since he was apparently targeted twice, once by a Drug Dealer/Jester, the other by Jester/Witch. Which seems unlikely but still possible.
Or he is Lieing for some reason.
Or just perhaps the Jester himself.

-vote MFM Armadillo

I would like to see him talk about something other than himself. I'd rarther not lynch him incase he is Jester.

[MFM Narwhal]

I'm also not the only invisible one.

[MFM Kangaroo]

MFM Kangaroo is wise.

Could work, though, after the person he accused dies, the Riddler would probably be able to deduct what role they are or narrow it down to detective/lookout.

Didn't think of that.

See, this is why you ask other peoples opinions.

This has already been talked about.

If the person turns out to be some random Maf role like Consig then it would be obvious what you are.

Yet I am willing to see where it turns up.

-vote MFM Narwhal

[MFM Kangaroo]

Alright there was my morning post, going to school now. I'll be back later.

[MFM Narwhal]

Any other reason to vote on me apart from to see "What turns up"?

[MFM Moose]

Spider says MFM Elephant logged in again but did not post at all. MFM Beaver, Wolf, Gorilla and Octopus also logged in but did not post.

[MFM Pig]

Well, since he was apparently targeted twice, once by a Drug Dealer/Jester, the other by Jester/Witch. Which seems unlikely but still possible.
Or he is Lieing for some reason.
Or just perhaps the Jester himself.

-vote MFM Armadillo

I would like to see him talk about something other than himself. I'd rarther not lynch him incase he is Jester.

So why vote him to lynch him? Isn't that a huge waste of time considering we have 18 hours left?

Let alone how a jester would very likely be more grating/obvious then that imo. What if noone was ignited today?

Who's your biggest scumread and townread?

[MFM Moose]

I'm also not the only invisible one.

Flail more.

[MFM Moose]

How do we deal with one-post wonders such as MFM Jellyfish?

[MFM Wolf]

I do not think that we would see any consolidation today. Especially with so many lurkers.

[MFM Rabbit]

How do we deal with one-post wonders such as MFM Jellyfish?

Lynch or threaten to lynch them all.

[MFM Rabbit]

Spider says MFM Elephant logged in again but did not post at all. MFM Beaver, Wolf, Gorilla and Octopus also logged in but did not post.

I do this all the time. What's the big deal about it?

[MFM Rabbit]

I do not think that we would see any consolidation today. Especially with so many lurkers.

-vote MFM Wolf

ok

[MFM Rabbit]

We should be lynching every single day since Batman can jail regardless. The biggest train atm is Narwhal, but I disagree with it. I really dislike him using invisible mode as a point. In fact, even my case against Wolf is stronger and it's a blank vote.

[MFM Narwhal]

As stated. The reason I use Invisible mode, Is because sometimes I have the means to read what is being posted. But have no way to reply to it. And I do not wish to be labelled as lurking and not posting.

[/COLOR]

So why vote him to lynch him? Isn't that a huge waste of time considering we have 18 hours left?
I just wanted to hear what else he has to say

Let alone how a jester would very likely be more grating/obvious then that imo. What if noone was ignited today?
Sorry, didn't understand that question XD


Who's your biggest scumread
MFM Moose, because I know I'm Town.

and townread?
MFM Frog.

[MFM Cat]

Hi!

[MFM Beaver]

The reason I logged on is because I had a quick 15 minutes before leaving for school, so I decided to skim up on the posts.

Before I do howevrr, I forgot something from my last post.

-vote MFM Armadillo

He is my biggest scumread so far. Even if he is Jester, it can still eliminate Mafia. I also already explained how lynching him still gives off information as well.

[MFM Pig]

As stated. The reason I use Invisible mode, Is because sometimes I have the means to read what is being posted. But have no way to reply to it. And I do not wish to be labelled as lurking and not posting.

Why include the fact that you know you're town when I asked your scumreads? Like, just whaa?

[MFM Pig]

I do not think that we would see any consolidation today. Especially with so many lurkers.

Congratulations on earning a scum-read!

-vote MFM Wolf

It's reasonably possible noone can be lynched today just by the low level of activity, but we're literally wasting a day if we sit on our hands and just wait for day to expire.

And building wagons is useful for later analysis.

People need to start placing votes, even if it's RVS votes. Such disappointment in the rest of you townies.

[MFM Pig]

As stated. The reason I use Invisible mode, Is because sometimes I have the means to read what is being posted. But have no way to reply to it. And I do not wish to be labelled as lurking and not posting.

Wait. I didn't even read the actual scumread name.

Why Moose? Any reason beyond him voting you?

[MFM Llama]

The idea that he got targeted by two different scum teams seems more unlikely the more I think about it...

-vote MFM Armadillo