M-FM XXV Batman Gamethread

[MFM Armadillo]

Who is Joker, Who is Riddler, Who is Mafia.

And all why?

Riddler- He is harder to deduce for me. He hasn't tried to guess anyone's roles much this game besides Gorilla. I believe Riddler is within the bulletproof claims. This also leads me to believe the Riddler got the night immunity since then he can claim into the bulletproofs. So unless he can survive during day with it then I believe it is Frog. As for Elephant it is possible because for the lack of kills from him, but I don't know if I for sure believe he is a lurker, although Frog kinda acts like it by popping in and not really offering anything helpful besides a random comment or what he says ends up confusing town more.

[MFM Llama]

Who is Joker, Who is Riddler, Who is Mafia.

And all why?

I know who the Joker is... And he isn't me.

[MFM Llama]

Hehe, vote me if you want. I'm not going to stop you.

[MFM Armadillo]

Going to check some older posts for a bit to see who I for sure believe to be mafia. As of now I have a feeling the last 2 mafia are within

MFM Elephant
MFM Frog
MFM Octopus
MFM Snake

Not Dolphin because I get why he would reveal me visiting you since he thought I was scum and nobody knew you were still Harvey Dent. I'll explain why I believe to be in this 4 soon.

[MFM Narwhal]

MFM Snake, the one who received the fake Suit. Is Mafia?

[MFM Armadillo]

MFM Snake, the one who received the fake Suit. Is Mafia?

Yea scratch that when I was reading back I saw that Dolphin saw Rabbit visit Snake and with Rabbit's flip it proves snake isn't mafia.

[MFM Narwhal]

Also. Explain Octopus.

Night Five. 3 Mafia. 1 Consort 1 Drug Dealer.
You saw Dolphin as Non-Town. He Could NOT be Framed. (As ??? Mafia went and attacked)

Dolphin is not mafia, since he correctly deduced Rabbit visiting snake, and Armadillo visiting me.

The ONLY WAY. Octopus is innocent. Is if we have an Escort.

[MFM Llama]

I'm perfectly fine with that.

[MFM Llama]

Unless you want a story.

But I'm still not telling you his name.

[MFM Narwhal]

Unless you want a story.

But I'm still not telling you his name.

Why?

[MFM Cat]

-vote Mfm Llama

It's possible that llama is the last mafia member if moose was an actress.

[MFM Llama]

Actually, I will tell who he is. He IS Beaver.


We met in the N4 chat, I revealed my role, and he trusted me enough to say his name.

We talked a little bit about the town, the mafia and the Riddler.

But then we got down to business.

We each had a goal we needed to accomplish. He needed to kill people, and I had my win condition to attend to. I gave him a list of people that I thought would be good targets (Narwhal, Cat, Kangaroo, etc) And in return he told me he would do whatever he could so I could win as well.

He told me I was going to be doused night 5, in case I betrayed him. But however he doused you instead... How stupid of him.

He told me he was the one that got attacked N2.

Also I was roleblocked n4 (but it was prob fake)

[MFM Narwhal]

Actually, I will tell who he is. He IS Beaver.


We met in the N4 chat, I revealed my role, and he trusted me enough to say his name.

We talked a little bit about the town, the mafia and the Riddler.

But then we got down to business.

We each had a goal we needed to accomplish. He needed to kill people, and I had my win condition to attend to. I gave him a list of people that I thought would be good targets (Narwhal, Cat, Kangaroo, etc) And in return he told me he would do whatever he could so I could win as well.

He told me I was going to be doused night 5, in case I betrayed him. But however he doused you instead... How stupid of him.

He told me he was the one that got attacked N2.

Also I was roleblocked n4 (but it was prob fake)

Joker has Immune Detection.
Ridder has Shirt Protection.

[MFM Llama]

Joker has Immune Detection.
Ridder has Shirt Protection.

False, the mafia gave joker Death immunity
The Riddler has Detection immunity.

[MFM Cat]

False, the mafia gave joker Death immunity
The Riddler has Detection immunity.

They probably attacked you during night 2, which is how they were able to figure out that you were the joker.

[MFM Llama]

Please lynch Beaver! He's going to kill me if you don't.

[MFM Armadillo]

Please lynch Beaver! He's going to kill me if you don't.

Why do you claim neutral?

[MFM Armadillo]

BTW As I am reading I see Elephant is on apparently so just watch that if Riddler kills.

[MFM Cat]

i would actually be fine with ending the day early just becouse the riddler might fuck uss up.

[MFM Narwhal]

Your Role Llama?
Because your win conditions sound like shit.



Also, MFM Cat, please View my post showing that Octopus is evil. Unless Consort is really Escort.

[MFM Cat]

Your Role Llama?
Because your win conditions sound like shit.



Also, MFM Cat, please View my post showing that Octopus is evil. Unless Consort is really Escort.

octupus is mafia for sure. he and tiger both defended llama for some reason.

[MFM Llama]

Your Role Llama?
Because your win conditions sound like shit.



Also, MFM Cat, please View my post showing that Octopus is evil. Unless Consort is really Escort.

Jester/Executioner/Survivior. I promise you it is one of those.

[MFM Dolphin]

Jester/Executioner/Survivior. I promise you it is one of those.

Wait you're the neutral?

[MFM Dolphin]

Narwhal, I highly suggest you hammer Octopus as soon as possible. Like when you see this post.

[MFM Llama]

I can assure you I'm not mafia.

[MFM Armadillo]

Something to ponder on for a while, but I have to go for now. I will be back.

[MFM Llama]

-vote MFM Beaver

You need to die...

[MFM Cat]

-vote MFM Beaver

You need to die...

Give it up joker.. Nothing can save you now.


Octupus and tiger fucked themselves up when they made it so obvious that they were defending you. They probably did it becouse they wanted to send you a message that they were mafia members so you wouldn't douse any of them. they thought that they had allready won this game and just needed to make sure that the joker wouldn't kill any of them.

[MFM Snake]

NONE of the claims today are dead. I'm thinking now that the Riddler is Elephant, there's no reason for the riddler to be this passive.
I don't think we should jump on Llama so fast, but Llama is still a decent lynch.

[MFM Frog]

Have you guys considered the possibility that he is telling the truth? I think everything would make a TON of sense if MFM Llama was Jester, and MFM Beaver was Joker.

[MFM Kangaroo]

Just going to clarify for Narwhal. I am NOT the Doctor. I mean, I saw your list and if I'm correct I saw you assumed that I am.

Now then once again my role list must be totally changed to compensate for the fact we have a Mayor confirmed Doctor and an unCCed claim with no Riddler killing him (which makes me suspect Elephant).

Sorry for my relative inactivity today. School had a blood drive and I donated and now I'm feeling all weird...

[MFM Kangaroo]

Joker
Riddler
Random Falcone Gangster
Random Falcone Gangster
Commissioner Gordon
Harvey Dent
Kangaroo's Role
Bulletproof
Detective/Lookout
Doctor
Random Neutral

If I did my subtraction right and subtracted the right amount of people due to deads, this leaves 0 room for Octopus's claim. Even if I was Escort (Not Confirming or Denying) Octopus is not what he says he is. Although this list does confirm me claiming that I am NOT Commissioner Gordon. (I know who is though. )

-vote MFM Octopus

I think Llama is scum, but at this point, the Joker fucked up too much to win, and with us having a Dent who still has his vest lynching the Mafia is in our best interests. (I mean, we have come to the conclusion that if Octopus is Scum then he is Mafia, right?)

Even if Armadillo isn't the Doctor, there is no room for Octopus's claim. The only chance he has of not being Mafia is if there is a dead Actress, which I sincerely doubt at this point.

[MFM Kangaroo]

And best of all Octopus even thinks I'm Town.

Watch him turn on me instantly when he sees that. (Unless I did my math wrong)

[MFM Kangaroo]

So unless we get another Doctor claim, or Moose is Actress I pretty much know exactly who the scum are.

(I know we got two BP claims, yet still. I also know Frog is claiming Gordon, but I have a feeling I l know who the real one is)

[MFM Kangaroo]

So unless we get another Doctor claim, or Moose is Actress I pretty much know exactly who the scum are.

(I know we got two BP claims, yet still. I also realize some people think that Frog is Gordon, but I have a feeling I l know who the real one is)

Fix'd.

[MFM Kangaroo]

I actually think Llama is Mafia. He buddied with Tiger and only lynched on the hammer, he isn't voting Octopus... I could almost see Frog as the Joker. Thoughts?

[MFM Dolphin]

What's more important, lynching mafia or lynching joker?

[MFM Dolphin]

Fuck it, I think this is more important.

Llama is the Joker. I tracked him into Narwhal, I didn't actually track Armadillo.

I was waiting on the reveal because I didn't want to risk revealing him if he was doctor (which is what I had him chalked up as in my notes), but that's impossible if he role claimed to mafia architect.

If he were actually Jester he would have played today differently imo.

So Riddler is night immune.

Deal with the fake doctor claim tomorrow, lynch the Joker today, unless you want to proceed otherwise Narwhal.

-vote MFM Llama

Narwhal, hammer one of them immediately please (Llama or Octopus)

Good luck all, there's no way I'm not dead tonight considering doc will keep Harvey Oswald alive

[MFM Kangaroo]

Fuck it, I think this is more important.

Llama is the Joker. I tracked him into Narwhal, I didn't actually track Armadillo.

I was waiting on the reveal because I didn't want to risk revealing him if he was doctor (which is what I had him chalked up as in my notes), but that's impossible if he role claimed to mafia architect.

If he were actually Jester he would have played today differently imo.

So Riddler is night immune.

Deal with the fake doctor claim tomorrow, lynch the Joker today, unless you want to proceed otherwise Narwhal.

-vote MFM Llama

Narwhal, hammer one of them immediately please (Llama or Octopus)

Good luck all, there's no way I'm not dead tonight considering doc will keep Harvey Oswald alive

I'm unsure as to what makes you think Armadillo is lying. But anyways, at this point I gotta sleep, answer and I'll read in the morning?

[MFM Frog]

My vote is hammering octopus, I think we should get the mafia so we know what we are dealing with, because I strongly suspect a Jester is in play somewhere.

[MFM Cat]

Could we end this day befeore this elephant replacement figures out our roles and kills uss all?

We know that llama is the joker.

[MFM Narwhal]

For the power of voting. If I lynch one more Mafia, It lowers the possible team votes to, Two Scum.
Where as if I kill the Joker, they still have three votes. (2 mafia, 1 Riddler)

Due to no Escort Claim. Now Unless Dolphin is really Mafia (Which I doubt) Then Octopus is evil.

So hence I vote Octopus.


Tomorrow, I want Elephant to post his whole story, his whole views on people.
I want Llama to reveal his pretend role.

With Me, Detective (If Octopus is scum) and Doctor. WIFOM it.

-vote MFM Octopus

[The Godfather]

MFM Octopus has been lynched! Stand by for the host's review and day-end post!


MFM Octopus (6 [L-0]): MFM Frog, MFM Kangaroo, MFM Beaver, MFM Narwhal (Mayor)
MFM Beaver (1 [L-5]): MFM Llama
MFM Llama (3 [L-3]): MFM Cat, MFM Armadillo, MFM Dolphin

[The Jester King]

Night Seven

MFM Octopus was lynched!

MFM Octopus (6 [L-0]): MFM Frog, MFM Kangaroo, MFM Beaver, MFM Narwhal (Mayor)
MFM Llama (3 [L-3]): MFM Cat, MFM Armadillo, MFM Dolphin
MFM Beaver (1 [L-5]): MFM Llama

MFM Octopus' role was Consort.

Night Seven ends at the usual time, at 8:00PM PST, October 24.

[The Jester King]

Day 8

Nobody died last night.

Day 8 ends at 8:00PM PST, October 26.

10 alive, 6 votes to hammer.

[The Jester King]

Night Eight

MFM Elephant was lynched!

MFM Elephant (8 [L--2]): MFM Frog, MFM Dolphin, MFM Cat, MFM Kangaroo, MFM Snake, MFM Narwhal (Mayor)

MFM elephants' role was Drug Dealer.

Night eight ends at the usual time, at 8:00PM PST, October 26.

[The Jester King]

Day9TV

Nobody died last night.

Day 9 ends at the usual time, at 8:00PM PST, October 27.

9 alive, 5 votes to hammer.

[The Jester King]

Endgame

MFM Llama was lynched!

MFM Llama (4 [L-0]): MFM Dolphin, MFM Narwhal (Mayor)
MFM Frog (1 [L-3]): MFM Cat
MFM Kangaroo (1 [L-3]): MFM Frog

MFM Llama' role was Joker.
MFM Armadillo' role was Doctor
MFM Beaver' role was Survivor
MFM Snake' role was Riddler

Towns wincon has been met

Congratulations to MFM Horse, Zebra, Pig, Wolf, Gorilla, Moose, Jellyfish, Armadillo, Cat, Dolphin, Frog, Kangaroo and Narwhal

[The Jester King]

Co-host: Thoughts, roles, ect later I stayed up till almost 5 in the morning waiting to do this.

Crypt may come in and say before me.

[MFM Elephant]

Jesus I can finally speak. I was M-FM Horse Day 1 T.T That's what I meant by "I died day one."

This account is Escort. I went ahead and roleblocked M-FM Narwhal to prove myself. There were no other actions submitted by the other player of this account.