M-FM XXV Batman Gamethread

[MFM Narwhal]

Ah. Good timing Pussy.

I feel Llama is a neutral. Hence the hammer.

[MFM Cat]

If we want to lynch another mafia member then octopus is a good choice.

-vote Mfm octopus

[MFM Octopus]

Hey I´m back sry for yesterday kangoroo, Llama was the one trieng to buddy with you not you with him, my bad. Also i had a power failure yesterday (damn technicans), so I couldn´t do anyhting anymore yesterday. Then no feedback from this night.

Anyway why are we voting Cat right now?

Also Dolphin claims Detectiv/Lookout out of nowhere? (hopefully a falseclaim otherwise gj suiciding)

Then no witch, blocked or doused claim so far? (gonna hope joker was afk this night like serious)

[MFM Octopus]

Oh, well he is voting me out of nowhere then I can do the same, also claims doused and bulletproof.

-vote MFM Cat

[MFM Narwhal]

Hey cat. What the fuck up with Rabbit? Surly we should get someone we have a lead on.

[MFM Cat]

Hey cat. What the fuck up with Rabbit? Surly we should get someone we have a lead on.

I would be fine with lynching rabbit aswell.

-vote Mfm Rabbit

[MFM Octopus]

Also the Riddler can go on a killing streak right now, if he didnt messed up his first guess I prey for everyone.

I´m not completly sure with the lead on Rabbit. Narwhal doesnt this look more like a lurking mafia member that tries to get some town lynched now with a false invest claim after they lost their gf (I highly doubt gf can be tailored, espacially, since host said earlier that Gf will appear in graveyard)? I mean what should they lose now and riddler can´t kill him, if he just false claimed.

[MFM Cat]

Also the Riddler can go on a killing streak right now, if he didnt messed up his first guess I prey for everyone.

I´m not completly sure with the lead on Rabbit. Narwhal doesnt this look more like a lurking mafia member that tries to get some town lynched now with a false invest claim after they lost their gf (I highly doubt gf can be tailored, espacially, since host said earlier that Gf will appear in graveyard)? I mean what should they lose now and riddler can´t kill him, if he just false claimed.

You are trying to encourage the riddler to go on a killing spree and you disagree with all the mafia lynches. How are you not a mafia member?

[MFM Octopus]

You are trying to encourage the riddler to go on a killing spree and you disagree with all the mafia lynches. How are you not a mafia member?

I don´t, I just want ppl to stop mass claiming lol. Also I was in for Tiger, if you would read my posts. Then I would be perfectly fine with Llama as lynch, his buddying and the hammering at the end was scummy as fuck.

[MFM Octopus]

Under my conclusion above I´m going to vote Dolphin for now, also cat unvoted me so i have nothing against him anymore.

-vote MFM Dolphin

[MFM Dolphin]

My scum suspects so far are btw:
Tiger (just look at his posts like seriously pls)
Elephant (Did nothing seems similar to Mafia1 from the architect chat with 3 posts, did you proof that clue Nahrwhal?)
Llama (as the Joker based at his desperate burn as he was L-1, Tiger buddying with him and Kangoroo)
Kangoroo (buddying with Tiger)
Frog (stated earlier why, also probably lies about witch feedback n3 to save Elephant?)

Claimed he suspected me and used false info to drop the hints, didn't mention me in his scumreads. In fact, the first mention of me at all by him is when I give scum feedback on Rabbit. And then immediately I'm scum he caught last night? Yeah bullshit thanks

Also the Riddler can go on a killing streak right now, if he didnt messed up his first guess I prey for everyone.

I´m not completly sure with the lead on Rabbit. Narwhal doesnt this look more like a lurking mafia member that tries to get some town lynched now with a false invest claim after they lost their gf (I highly doubt gf can be tailored, espacially, since host said earlier that Gf will appear in graveyard)? I mean what should they lose now and riddler can´t kill him, if he just false claimed.

He's interested in me now because I claimed Rabbit is scum, not for any other reason. He also blatantly stated he made up false info on why I was "scum" so he didn't have to release results. But wait...why didn't he do that in his 5 scumread post. Hell, he could have just said "lurker prob scum." That's literally the argument he uses...after I claim Rabbit is scum.

Under my conclusion above I´m going to vote Dolphin for now, also cat unvoted me so i have nothing against him anymore.

-vote MFM Dolphin

Blatant OMGUS vote retracted, also signaling neutrals he won't lynch them if they leave him alone.

Like do I REALLY have to find more examples of why Octopus and Rabbit are scum? Like legit does noone see how blatantly obvious this is?

[MFM Narwhal]

Snake received a vest. Dolphin saw rabbit visit snake.

Rabbit claimed citizen randomly.

[MFM Octopus]

Snake received a vest. Dolphin saw rabbit visit snake.

Rabbit claimed citizen randomly.

Thats why it would be perfect to frame someone right now, he coudl have just as said, that cat visited Snake or anyone else. But since Rabbit claimed citizen, he can´t defend himself with an lw or anything.

[MFM Narwhal]

Dolphin has claimed to be replaced twice. The host is more lilekly to replace town investigation than other roles.

[MFM Octopus]

Dolphin has claimed to be replaced twice. The host is more lilekly to replace town investigation than other roles.

You mean like Mafia? Despite the fact that he could ahve simply lied.

[MFM Octopus]

Also, the replaced claim is a perfect cover to don´t ahve any more clues as the one on Rabbit.

[MFM Dolphin]

Yeah, but don´t forget that Not Town =/= mafia, also I found the last 2 clues the last 2 nights and yesterday was Tiger more wanted.
I would have revealed today anyway, if nothing had happened.

Said he would claim anyways so why hide his results? Specifically, there's no argument that he didn't want to name me in his scumreads post when he had a "not town" result on me.

Hey I´m back sry for yesterday kangoroo, Llama was the one trieng to buddy with you not you with him, my bad. Also i had a power failure yesterday (damn technicans), so I couldn´t do anyhting anymore yesterday. Then no feedback from this night.

Anyway why are we voting Cat right now?

Also Dolphin claims Detectiv/Lookout out of nowhere? (hopefully a falseclaim otherwise gj suiciding)

Then no witch, blocked or doused claim so far? (gonna hope joker was afk this night like serious)

Actually toys with the idea I'm town here when his night results theoretically say I can't be true claiming at all "gj suiciding"

Like do I need to go on or can I stop now?

[MFM Narwhal]

So what?
Cat was the first person to vote Tiger. Tiger had not been tailored.

I refuse to vote Cat. Cat is also douse so Joker can fuck him over. Buy I prefer if he didn't

Octopus you acted like scummy shit for most of the game.

Does any one else claim to be an investigation role? I don't see anyone. And Dolphin has been replaced, just look at his previous postings.

[MFM Narwhal]

No one else claims to be tailored. So I do think that Mafia have some suits. Question is who?

[MFM Octopus]

No one else claims to be tailored. So I do think that Mafia have some suits. Question is who?

the tailor is limited to 3 suits, i believe Snake so that would amke 1. 2 left lets assume Moose got one then 1 left, question is was it used, then on whom? I honestly can´t tell we only know for sure that Gorilla was a citizen, since riddler killed him.

[MFM Octopus]

Oh well, I don´t ahve anythign against cat, i just voted him for a short time, because he voted me for no reason, i switched to Dolphin afterwards. Also I can say Llama and Dolphin are Not Town.

[MFM Narwhal]

Are you claiming investigation role?

[MFM Octopus]

Are you claiming investigation role?

I do. I just hope riddler guessed already wrong today. But, after Dolphins claim i have no choice.

[MFM Narwhal]

Moose or Wolf could of been mafia.

Although snake could of been visited by drug dealer?

[MFM Octopus]

I can say, that Horse and Armadillo are Town and Frog also is Not Town.

To continue the suit search, pig and Jellyfish were killed by mafia i don´t think they tailored them as PRs there wouldn´t be a reason for it I guess and Pigs last will says also he is coroner.

Zebra wasn´t tailored missing kill n1 and then died through Joker, aswell as missing detains after that.

Why I don´t think Tiger was tailored I stated earlier, wich leaves Wolf and Moose, as you thought.

But I dont think both got tailored, Moose would be my priamry guess, since even after claiming citizen,
the riddler didn´t killed him, the reason for it is still unclear, but it would be safe to assume that he wasn´t citizen.

[MFM Beaver]

Sigh.

Just gonna say this. I am a non witching neutral. Explain Armadillo being both fake doused and fake witched without lying. Drug Dealer can only do one, remember? I'd like to throw off the possibility that he didn't think Joker would burn right away, decided to fake douse to reveal the existance of the Drug Dealer. When he/his teammates starting fake witching afterwards to keep playing me off as a Witch/Jester which would explain both his actions.

ofc today, if there is no witched claim we can conclude suited was from Drug Dealer, or a lie. if someone can explain the whole two action thing I'd really like it tbh because im tired and need everything spoonfed to me rn

[MFM Octopus]

Sigh.

Just gonna say this. I am a non witching neutral. Explain Armadillo being both fake doused and fake witched without lying. Drug Dealer can only do one, remember? I'd like to throw off the possibility that he didn't think Joker would burn right away, decided to fake douse to reveal the existance of the Drug Dealer. When he/his teammates starting fake witching afterwards to keep playing me off as a Witch/Jester which would explain both his actions.

ofc today, if there is no witched claim we can conclude suited was from Drug Dealer, or a lie. if someone can explain the whole two action thing I'd really like it tbh because im tired and need everything spoonfed to me rn

That is actually interesting, thanks i didn´t thought of it. What if the mafia has 2 drug dealers and no tailor? Lets follow this, their were blocks and witches all time (except d1 their was a doused instead of block), but nothing of both today, instead we have a suit claim. If this is true i highly suspect Elephant as one of the Drug dealers, who was sent by the gf after n1, since the gf is dead now his action dropped or he was sent for the kill, but I guess he has less priority as Dolphin atm, since this would conclude he left the game at d2 already.

[MFM Octopus]

*d1 = d2

[MFM Octopus]

A question to the host in that regard: Can the Mafia Architect still be sent for the kill while using his ability?

[The Jester King]

COHOST

Can Tailor suit someone to look like a godfather?

I do not know know the answer to that, I have left a message for crypt to give an official resposne

A question to the host in that regard: Can the Mafia Architect still be sent for the kill while using his ability?

Yes.

[MFM Narwhal]

When I get home to night. I will sort out night feedback, voting patterns, roles and player possibilities and maybe even my views on people.

[MFM Snake]

I'm starting to think that the host pulled a BNW on us and there are 2 drug dealers, though one of those drug dealers could also be a jester

[MFM Snake]

Well, I guess you guys will know the suit is real if I flip some random shit like one of the neutrals - Doesn't really matter anyway because last wills

[MFM Kangaroo]

Well, I guess you guys will know the suit is real if I flip some random shit like one of the neutrals - Doesn't really matter anyway because last wills

This set off massive alarms to me.

He is trying to make us think that when he comes up as the Joker/Riddler that he was actually Town and we should still be afraid of that specific role, yet although I don't see the Joker benefitting nearly as much, the Riddler would due to the fact that the Town might still be afraid to claim.

Also, he was rather fast to say he knew Gorilla was probably a Citizen. I know I did too, but from MY POV as a Townie he was rather scummy, yet then I didn't give it a second guess.

His tailor claim is BS. Why would the Mafia EVER randomly hand out a suit? I see 0 gain from it. No one else currently living (unless they're Mafia and are hiding it) has received a suit. And we know that Narwhal was attacked last night. I don't see why they wouldn't attack someone the same night they give them the suit.

I mean sure, the Mafia might have tried to kill him last night but Beaver and his witchiness caused them to hit Narwhal, but it doesn't add up that well to me.

Sorry Snake, I really thought you were Town until this post.

[MFM Armadillo]

-vote MFM Frog

I still don't think Frog is town so going to vote him for now.

[MFM Snake]

With recent revelations along with uncertainty I will switch my vote with Armadillo, if not just for now

-vote MFM Frog

[MFM Octopus]

Well, Frog appeared as Not Town to me, so if you prefer to vote him over Dolphin I could live with that, though I will wait on Nahrwahls decision or for more votes on him, before moving.

[MFM Kangaroo]

-vote MFM Frog

Alright, I'll eat my words and say I was wrong about you Cat, you aren't the Joker.

Anyways, I see Llama as the Joker, Frog and either Rabbit/Dolphin as Mafia (They aren't on the same team) Beaver as the Witch, and I am honestly thinking Snake is the Riddler. In the event Moose wasn't Mafia I will do a bit more digging.

Note, due to the potential difficulty of figuring out, Llama and Snake might be swapped.

More on Snake in a minute.

[MFM Kangaroo]

Beaver is either a Witch or a Jester. I Can't see him being any other Neutral from his actions.

[MFM Frog]

I was doused.

[MFM Kangaroo]

I was doused.

Well... you claimed this now?

But I was thinking... what if Cat is the Joker and he decided to douse nobody? His burn would kill no one and he would appear to be what he says he was.

The lack of a Riddler kill on him is disturbing.

[MFM Snake]

Maybe that's exactly what the mafia want you to think. Super scary. But no if I was suited it's Probably a mafia suit or the riddler, but considering all false feedback it's probably not eeal

[MFM Snake]

Oh yeah and riddler should be our #1 target if we can find them, so if you think I'm him fire away

[MFM Snake]

Meh, i think that we might be making the classic mistake of pressuring active people while ignoring some of the lurkers. I'll look this over more when I'm actually home

More at 6

[MFM Kangaroo]

Meh, i think that we might be making the classic mistake of pressuring active people while ignoring some of the lurkers. I'll look this over more when I'm actually home

More at 6

And here we go again.

Tiger, who was relatively active in my book, was lynched, and guess what he was? Not just the Mafia Architect, but the Godfather.

[MFM Octopus]

And here we go again.

Tiger, who was relatively active in my book, was lynched, and guess what he was? Not just the Mafia Architect, but the Godfather.

Yeah and on the opposite lurker towns Jellyfish Doctor, Pig Coroner and Cat bulletproof.
(Thought I don´t understand why you try to stand in the background as bulletproof, but he is confirmed anyway so)

[MFM Narwhal]

Also. Suits come after death so they cant suit and death same night.

[MFM Kangaroo]

Also. Suits come after death so they cant suit and death same night.

Even so, the post he made that I quoted screams scum to me.

[MFM Kangaroo]

Also. Suits come after death so they cant suit and death same night.

And that just disproves the Witch theory I had. Considering there is a distinct possibility of a Bodyguard, and the fact last wills destroy Tailors, suiting a non-mafia at this point doesn't seem smart. It could just as easily be a lie as it could have been a drug deal.

Also, what is there at all to gain by drugging a suit? Make us think they have a Tailor? I don't see a smart Mafia doing that.

[MFM Octopus]

Ok, i guess I can switch now 3 is fair enough (with so many inactives), I tried to lynch him a few times before anyway, since i knew he was Not Town, but I could hardly reveal with the Riddler around at that point.

-vote MFM Frog