M-FM XXV Batman Gamethread

[MFM Moose]

MFM Llama what happened to your Architect chat lol?

[MFM Narwhal]

Hello People. Dent here.
I was role blocked last night, and I was in an architect chat.

Who was with me?

[MFM Narwhal]

Tonight. Place me in the chat again, with a town pr.

[MFM Llama]

MFM Llama what happened to your Architect chat lol?

I was never in such Architect chat.

[MFM Llama]

Go away then. I won't bother replying to someone who made only one or two posts in Architect chat.

You're "allys" lied to you.

[MFM Llama]

Your "allies", lied to you.

Fixed.

[MFM Beaver]

oh hello friends

rip my insctivity yesterday haha ! um so like yeah i was in the arch n2 chat since im such a bad meme.

so how is everyone this lovely night

[MFM Llama]

Notice how Moose saw this thread, then left.

[MFM Narwhal]

Get an avatar. What you talk about. And welcome back to first Time riddler makes a guess. Such good timing.

[MFM Narwhal]

Dolphin also has not spoken since replacement.

[MFM Narwhal]

I think we are looking for two active scum. And two lurking scum. Moose claims architect not sure if town or scum.

[MFM Narwhal]

Also. My Target is to lynch Mafia. I will not be voting for Riddler or Joker. The Dent act shall see us get rid of the mafia.

[The Jester King]

Pig had a will, that i forgot about

Spoiler : will :

Oink Oink.

Well fuck. Made a last will in the tiny event I get night killed and if it happened...bleh. (actually not sure if N0 there's a night kill but just in case lol)

I'm Coroner, so if I flip otherwise there's some shenanigans going on with Tailor suits.

Probably going to ask to join the replacement list since I have no mechanical info or anything at all as I died before game started so maybe see you all around!

Oink.

[MFM Snake]

Well, I guess the riddler took personal offense to my statement since Gorilla died right after I said I thought he was the Riddler. Brilliant.

Also, there's a 99% chance that Gorilla was a citizen unless the riddler knows something we don't. gorilla posted a good two times I think.

[MFM Kangaroo]

Oh hey, how convenient. My guess is that Gorilla was a Citizen and the Riddler made a wild guess due to the inactivity.

And hey I was right about Moose and Narwhal not being on the same team.

Anyways I was RBed last night and was unable to due what I normally do at night.

I won't be able to post too much today, but I will tomorrow. 48 hour days help.

The lurkers in this game smashed us.

Give me a minute to come up with someone I think we should lynch.

[MFM Kangaroo]

Well, I guess the riddler took personal offense to my statement since Gorilla died right after I said I thought he was the Riddler. Brilliant.

Also, there's a 99% chance that Gorilla was a citizen unless the riddler knows something we don't. gorilla posted a good two times I think.

Agh, you beat me to the Gorilla being a cit by like, five seconds.

[MFM Kangaroo]

I think we are looking for two active scum. And two lurking scum. Moose claims architect not sure if town or scum.

I'm positive he is scum.

[MFM Snake]

oh hello friends

rip my insctivity yesterday haha ! um so like yeah i was in the arch n2 chat since im such a bad meme.

so how is everyone this lovely night

The riddler only guesses once and that just happens to be when Beaver comes back.. Hmmm...
I also was not expecting Narwhal to be the mayor at all. Could still be two-face, though, considering the mafia have missed two kills.

[MFM Tiger]

Well, I guess the riddler took personal offense to my statement since Gorilla died right after I said I thought he was the Riddler. Brilliant.

Also, there's a 99% chance that Gorilla was a citizen unless the riddler knows something we don't. gorilla posted a good two times I think.

Maybe you're so sure that Gorilla is a citizen because you guessed that he was and he died, isn't that right....RIDDLER???

Nah if Gorilla was anything but citizen then the Riddler either got extremely lucky or has some communication method with a mafia's investigative role.

Seeing MFM Pig's role sucks because it almost assures that the mafia have a tailor or less likely, a janitor.

[MFM Kangaroo]

Just saying, I lied about not being detained due to being told not to tell anyone I was detained unless completely necessary.

And when I asked he refused to state why he detained me.

[MFM Snake]

Maybe you're so sure that Gorilla is a citizen because you guessed that he was and he died, isn't that right....RIDDLER???

Nah if Gorilla was anything but citizen then the Riddler either got extremely lucky or has some communication method with a mafia's investigative role.

Seeing MFM Pig's role sucks because it almost assures that the mafia have a tailor or less likely, a janitor.

I don't think there's a tailor.. All the last wills seem to match up and there are no suit claims, and there are no cleanings so probably not a Janitor either, I dunno. It could have been put into the game to find out the Joker's night burn roles, but none of that has happened yet. But you already considered that, right.... JOKER???

I would also like to point out that the Joker will probably be aiming for the Riddler now. He's essentially the only thing preventing him from winning.

[MFM Snake]

Assuming both people who died today are town, it's 7 scum vs 8 town.
If a town is lynched and the Riddler dies tonight, scum win without question.
If a town is lynched and the Joker dies tonight, the town is essentially still screwed but the Riddler has to either get a correct guess or town has to be lynched.
If a mafia is lynched, it still becomes 6v6 after you consider mafia kill and joker burn, but then the Joker and riddler have to fight it out and Town could still have a chance.
If a town is lynched and a town dies tonight, the Riddler and Joker have to fight it out similar to the previous scenario.
If Riddler is lynched, it's 5v8 but the mafia still maintains an almost certain 2 kpn with the Joker.
If Joker is lynched, it's 5v8 and the mafia have a potentially good kpn but nothing is certain with the Riddler.
This is all assuming that the Neutral is scum sided and that the Mayor is actually still town.

So, lynching the Joker is probably the best option if we can get it, followed by lynching a mafia, followed by lynching the Riddler.

i sure hope this is all right or else i look dum

[MFM Narwhal]

Joker and Riddler can win together. Joker cannot kill Riddler I guess. And I'm not Twoface. I have no idea who a two face is. My name is Harvey Dent. Consort, Drugdealer, Gf and maybe Artitect.

[MFM Narwhal]

Don't forget my extra votes.

[MFM Snake]

Joker and Riddler can win together. Joker cannot kill Riddler I guess. And I'm not Twoface. I have no idea who a two face is. My name is Harvey Dent. Consort, Drugdealer, Gf and maybe Artitect.

Joker can kill Riddler if joker is night immune. Riddler can kill joker if Riddler is night immune. All depends on what the mafia gave them.

[MFM Snake]

And every single member of the mafia has to be dead for the Riddler and Joker to win together, which I see as incredibly unlikely/

[MFM Narwhal]

Depends on what wolf is.

[MFM Kangaroo]

Can you guys figure out why the Joker would burn Wolf of all people? Wolf wasn't exactly a pro-town in my opinion... It seems like a weird choice.

[MFM Tiger]

Can you guys figure out why the Joker would burn Wolf of all people? Wolf wasn't exactly a pro-town in my opinion... It seems like a weird choice.

Maybe the Joker was trying to go for the Riddler?

[MFM Snake]

Can you guys figure out why the Joker would burn Wolf of all people? Wolf wasn't exactly a pro-town in my opinion... It seems like a weird choice.

Maybe he knows something we don't.. He could be communicating with the Mafia through architect chat, seeing as he killed Batman day 2 after the mafia attacked him.. "We night killed someone and they didn't die, could you burn him incase he's Batman or Gordon please?"

[MFM Kangaroo]

Maybe he knows something we don't.. He could be communicating with the Mafia through architect chat, seeing as he killed Batman day 2 after the mafia attacked him.. "We night killed someone and they didn't die, could you burn him incase he's Batman or Gordon please?"

Well with Batman dead that wouldn't matter, and Gordon is trash with no Batman.

Also, Gordon has a vest, and that effectively makes him invulnerable, which means the Riddler cannot kill him.

Can the Riddler kill Gordon while he still has his vest?

If the host says that Gordon can't be killed and still has his vest I would recommend he claim, him dying doesn't hurt us and without a CC he becomes pretty much a confirmed Townie.

[MFM Snake]

This is not getting us anywhere. Good thing we only lost 2 people so far. We don't know Zebra's role yet, but... we should be ready for the worst]

This could have also contributed.

[MFM Snake]

Well with Batman dead that wouldn't matter, and Gordon is trash with no Batman.

Also, Gordon has a vest, and that effectively makes him invulnerable, which means the Riddler cannot kill him.

Can the Riddler kill Gordon while he still has his vest?

If the host says that Gordon can't be killed and still has his vest I would recommend he claim, him dying doesn't hurt us and without a CC he becomes pretty much a confirmed Townie.

Well, I guess the Riddler could just guess him twice and kill him, idk. I don't think that an auto-vest hit would count as an incorrect guess.

[MFM Kangaroo]

Well, I guess the Riddler could just guess him twice and kill him, idk. I don't think that an auto-vest hit would count as an incorrect guess.

Doesn't hitting an immune count as an incorrect guess though? That would prevent him from guessing again for the rest of the day.

Best let the host answer for clarity.

[MFM Snake]

Doesn't hitting an immune count as an incorrect guess though? That would prevent him from guessing again for the rest of the day.

Best let the host answer for clarity.

The setup says it doesn't pierce immunity, but not that it counts as an incorrect guess, so yeah, we wait for the host

[MFM Kangaroo]

The setup says it doesn't pierce immunity, but not that it counts as an incorrect guess, so yeah, we wait for the host

Or since it is an incorrect guess it means there is no kill attempt at all and the vest isn't used anyways.

[MFM Kangaroo]

Or since it is an incorrect guess it means there is no kill attempt at all and the vest isn't used anyways.

Derp that came out bad. *since he can't kill immune it means he didn't attack at all on the guess*

[MFM Kangaroo]

I'm not liking Frog.

[vote]MFM Frog]/vote]

His posts and voting seem scummy. Hidden posts, voting Narwhal after Moose retracted his claim... it doesn't add up to me.

[MFM Kangaroo]

I'm not liking Frog.

[vote]MFM Frog]/vote]

His posts and voting seem scummy. Potential hidden messages in posts, voting Narwhal after Moose retracted his claim... it doesn't add up to me.

Derp. I'm on a roll today.

[MFM Kangaroo]

Wow. I really am on a fail roll, I didn't even notice my vote failed...

-vote MFM Frog

[The Jester King]

Can the Riddler kill Gordon while he still has his vest?

CO-HOST

This is not the official answer but this is what i rule it as,

If the Riddler guesses correctly, the player will immediately die (subject to host availability).

The only role that is specifically immune is batman. I would rule it that a correct guess would instantly kill him b/c the vest is not a full-on immunity.

I will PM crypt to give an official response

[MFM Snake]

I'm also going to do probability for being scum thing lets go lol run on sentence unpunctuated arson

MFM Armadillo - This guy is still alive? 5/10 might be jester
MFM Beaver - My highest Riddler candidate for now but his post timing might mean nothing, lurker 7/10
MFM Cat - Joker candidate 7/10
MFM Dolphin - This guy hasn't posted like at all ???/10
MFM Elephant - Same as dolphin ????/10
MFM Frog - Posts like once a day and has like a consigliere code wow idk lol 6/10
MFM Jellyfish - This guy posted like once? ???/10
MFM Kangaroo - Essentially my only townread right now 2/10
MFM Llama - This guy posts a lot but doesn't mean a lot with it also a possible joker candidate 7/10
MFM Moose - Scum 10/10
MFM Narwhal - wow obviously scum totally not mayor 12/10
MFM Octopus - Too many lurkers zzzzzz ???/10
MFM Rabbit - I feel like this person posted day 1 but never posted again ???/10
MFM Snake - such an obvious scum wow
MFM Tiger - I'm sorry but this guy has been screaming scum to me all game long, I dunno why 8/10

as you can see my grammar value has gone down dramatically and I am also really bad at this forum mafia thing

[MFM Kangaroo]

CO-HOST

This is not the official answer but this is what i rule it as,



The only role that is specifically immune is batman. I would rule it that a correct guess would instantly kill him b/c the vest is not a full-on immunity.

I will PM crypt to give an official response

Curses. This makes it more difficult...

[MFM Snake]

I feel bad doing this because he was the one friend I had one day one, but I think this guy is the joker too much to pass up.

-vote MFM Llama

I think we should lynch between him and Cat... Lynching a Joker candidate is our best bet for today.

[MFM Beaver]

js if you are gonna accuse me of being riddler then therr needs to be something more than "oh he came online after riddler guessed". when would I have time to even read back to see what gorilla could be? i literally was late to day yesterday because of school and stuff, and literally came online just to post my night action, my login thingie can prove as well.

so yeah please explain how i could magically know what gorilla was.

also wasnt there a thing in sign ups or something about riddler not being able to guess gordon? ill check back.

[The Jester King]

Can the Riddler kill Gordon while he still has his vest?

The Riddler can kill Gordon if he guesses him twice. Redundant, but w/e lol

[MFM Kangaroo]

The Riddler can kill Gordon if he guesses him twice. Redundant, but w/e lol

Double curses.

[MFM Beaver]

oh so i mixed up gordon and harvey?? these names are really confusing

also no to a previous post I already explained why I can't get an avi because of tablet

[MFM Kangaroo]

js if you are gonna accuse me of being riddler then therr needs to be something more than "oh he came online after riddler guessed". when would I have time to even read back to see what gorilla could be? i literally was late to day yesterday because of school and stuff, and literally came online just to post my night action, my login thingie can prove as well.

so yeah please explain how i could magically know what gorilla was.

also wasnt there a thing in sign ups or something about riddler not being able to guess gordon? ill check back.

Woah there... that defense was very aggressive. Question, what is the "login thingie"?

Gorilla was obvious. So so obvious... people only do what he does if they're Citizens.

If Gorilla isn't a Citizen then I will be so dumbfounded it's not even funny.

And the host already said how the Riddler can in fact kill Gordon... shame...

[MFM Kangaroo]

Hey Cat, I see you there. You gonna do anything?