Quote Originally Posted by Real Razbrox View Post
I totally agree to that, of course These numbers are just a personal listing of whom to check if there are no suspects yet Of course I will investigate suspects that didn't Trial other Mafia members for example or gave wrong hints. Don't see it as a complain about the mechanics, I just wanted make clear how I see things because a player lost his mind because I called out 2 of 3 Mafia member at day 1 and called me a cheater. It is in no way a complain.
The probability of calling out 3 names and 2 of them being mafia isn't exactly low either, it's roughly a 1 in 12 chance after all. If you had been calling out names while making your excel (which seems to indicate that you have done this 55 times) then I would be more surprised if you failed to call out mafia rather than you succeeding.

Either way, the distribution of roles is random, any perception otherwise is the result of confirmation bias and the nonrandom distribution of night 1 killings.

In fact, what I think would be far more interesting is to see what roles die night 1 rather than what roles are evil.