Bringing Standard Setup Back

[RainHeaven]

..

[louiswill]

The majority of players dislike SOTD

I don't think so tbh. Also I hate standard save.

[McKinley]

I personally feel as if the sotd needs to be play tested a few times by in-house players before it gets approved. Some of them sound fun, sure... but there's no real "scum hunting" in a a setup where the only two non-evil roles are amnesiac and survivor, with a triad and mafia team of 4 members, 2 mms, and a SK...

[louiswill]

I personally feel as if the sotd needs to be play tested a few times by in-house players before it gets approved. Some of them sound fun, sure... but there's no real "scum hunting" in a a setup where the only two non-evil roles are amnesiac and survivor, with a triad and mafia team of 4 members, 2 mms, and a SK...

I believe that DR is already adjusting the weight of frequency according to poll.

I think another possible solution is to design a more comprehended system such as this:

Three options:
SotD Type A: emphasis on scum hunt and standard, classic balance between Town Vs The Others.
SotD Type B: emphasis on crossing fire and chaotic situation.(we can throw chicago and lawless in those too)
SotD Type C: For Unbelievable Testing Purpose of all kind of awkwardness Trolling setups, once in a while.
---------------

And then in each option:
adjust the weight of those more exotics type by calculate the amount of experienced players in the game.
(by simply use existing data of players totalgameplayed & total win)
i.e. : 'Double trouble' require more experienced players to play triad.

[AppleyNO]

On this topic, we still have Classic as an option if you want Mafioso/Consort/Citizen/Doctor/Sheriff save.

Otherwise, submit your setups or make your own save slot :P. We also have... I think 2(?) "Standard" 9-3-3 saves, and many of the setups are balanced.

We have an RandD section for donors, and we had a vote to see how the setups should be weighted. The "Standard" saves were voted down for more unique saves. The Aldrais-type saves have low weight values as well.

[McKinley]

The Aldrais-type saves have low weight values as well.

I am not going to lie, leave trains happen in a lot of Aldaris' setups.

[Aldaris]

Haters gonna hate what can I say. I've been updating some of my earlier saves as I can and I think they've improved.
Some people just don't want to try *shrugs*, but every save I submit has already been tested and tweaked several times and the final version comes post feedback from those who played them.

[Voss]

i like aldaris's saves.

[Tony]

Whenever I see a save by Aldaris, I know it's gonna be a bad game.

[louiswill]

Whenever I see a save by Aldaris, I know it's gonna be a bad game.

The phenomenon suggests general public players are not ready for those.


I think Tony totally knows how to play Aldaris's setup for sure.



Some experience detector should do the job.

[Tony]

I think Tony totally knows how to play Aldaris's setup for sure.

The only winning move is not to play.

[Orpz]

The only winning move is not to play.

that was a good movie

favorite movie from the 1980's

[kyle1234513]

step 1 make a standard save. step 2 open game to public. step 3 ????????? step 4 enjoy beloved standard save of mafia. i do it all the time when i know there are trolls around on some nights. this way i ensure at least some games go smoothly.

[AAA]

Remove SOTD. That's what needs to happen. SOTD killed Mafia. It's all troll saves. Is there even a single 9-3-3?

[Aldaris]

There's a couple of 9 3 3. Look up the sotd submission thread and different is not the same as troll. Check the troll save thread.

[Aldaris]

Just happened in a game I was in. Host selected SOTD Advanced. Before the game started, I said, "Aldaris save, gg." And what do you know, it was. Serial Justice V2. Every1 was freaking out and 8 people left the first night.

Still checking out this SOTD difficulty thing and seeing how it is so far.

So you incited a leave train on a perfectly fine setup and you're complaining that people leave?