M-FM XXI Avatar the Last Airbender Gamethread

[Pathik]

I meant my post was questioned, as you/someone else pointed it out specifically.

Did you all here the good news?? Rumor has it the Avatar has returned! What degrees of training he must have reached in that time! 100 hundred years have I been waiting for this day.

Read on the wiki that Pathik predates Aang's birth by 43ish years, but was still alive 100 years after Aang's disappearance. Additionally, the way season 1 of the show begins, everyone is shocked Aang has reappeared and rumors begin to spread of the Avatar's return. So I tried to word it as if I really was a guru that had spent a 100 years meditating/whatever else I do, and then heard the rumors that the Avatar had returned. Also as I am a teacher for him and he's the Avatar, I was jesting about how he must have disappeared off for a 100 years to train/stuff, and maybe he could teach me a few things.

Good morning to all! It seems Admiral Zhao is on the hunt in our midst.

Good morning to all being a standard-ish first time check in post.
The second line was just additional flavoring, I meant to push more for an RP-ish way of saying "oh dear, the fire nation has sent one of their military officers to find him." Plus unlike the show there's a bunch of us all in a room together spending the next few days. But Admiral Zhao is hiding among us ala Mafia style, though everyone has names of great figures from the show's time period.

Have I elaborated enough on my RP post?

I added the link post in as I have deemed them useful in the past, and I figured it'd also allow me to see who hadn't shown up yet through missing links.

[Kyoshi Warrior #3]

Hey guys, I'm back. Thanks to everyone who's filled out my "just for fun survey." If anyone still wants to fill it out, please do. When at least five people have filled it out, I'll comment a little on my motivation for creating the survey and some people's responses to it that I've found scummy.

Until then, please either fill it out or comment on the survey so I have more to analyze.

Yours Truly,
Kyoshi Warrior #3

[Pathik]

Sorry, to clarify on the list post:

The list is an alphabetical order from the day 1 mod post, with links to each player's page. With the exception of players that had not yet posted. I then proceeded to vote the first no-link player on the list to encourage them to post once they show up.

[Yangchen]

I meant my post was questioned, as you/someone else pointed it out specifically.



Read on the wiki that Pathik predates Aang's birth by 43ish years, but was still alive 100 years after Aang's disappearance. Additionally, the way season 1 of the show begins, everyone is shocked Aang has reappeared and rumors begin to spread of the Avatar's return. So I tried to word it as if I really was a guru that had spent a 100 years meditating/whatever else I do, and then heard the rumors that the Avatar had returned. Also as I am a teacher for him and he's the Avatar, I was jesting about how he must have disappeared off for a 100 years to train/stuff, and maybe he could teach me a few things.


Good morning to all being a standard-ish first time check in post.
The second line was just additional flavoring, I meant to push more for an RP-ish way of saying "oh dear, the fire nation has sent one of their military officers to find him." Plus unlike the show there's a bunch of us all in a room together spending the next few days. But Admiral Zhao is hiding among us ala Mafia style, though everyone has names of great figures from the show's time period.

Have I elaborated enough on my RP post?

I added the link post in as I have deemed them useful in the past, and I figured it'd also allow me to see who hadn't shown up yet through missing links.

Ok. Thank you.

-unvote

Suspects? Directed to Pathik





@KW #3

Situation comments?

[Hama]

Hey guys, I'm back. Thanks to everyone who's filled out my "just for fun survey." If anyone still wants to fill it out, please do. When at least five people have filled it out, I'll comment a little on my motivation for creating the survey and some people's responses to it that I've found scummy.

Until then, please either fill it out or comment on the survey so I have more to analyze.

Yours Truly,
Kyoshi Warrior #3

I will participate because I'm interested to see what you come up with.

Just for fun:

Pick one of these:
(a) red
(b) blue
(c) green
(d) white

Pick two of these:
(a) lemur
(b) unagi
(c) sky bison
(d) canyon crawler
(e) dragon moose
(f) hermit crab
(g) purple pentapus

Pick three of these:
(a) water bending scroll
(b) Katara's mom's necklace
(c) purple berries
(d) headpiece of the crown prince of the Fire Nation
(e) rare first edition book
(f) Aang's wanted poster
(g) specially-tied knot
(h) Sozin's comet

Pick four of these:
(a) wooden monkey
(b) stuffed cat
(c) wooden hand drum
(d) paper airplane
(e) clay turtle
(f) redemption orb
(g) water from the spirit oasis
(h) pull-string propeller

[Pathik]

Due
Hama
Huu
Jin Wei
June
Koh
Kuruk
Kyoshi
Kyoshi Warrior #3
La
Lion Turtle
Momo
Monk Gyatso
Pathik
Sangok
Tho
Yangchen
Wan Shi Tong
Wang Fire
Wei Jin

Updated player list. Three players have yet to check in as of yet.

Need to pop out for a bit, will return with a preliminary reads list.

[Kyoshi Warrior #3]

@KW #3

Situation comments?

Just a second, busy taking some notes on the state of the game. Still need at least three more people to take the survey and as many more people to comment on it as possible.

[Yangchen]

I also dislike the extremity of Lion Turtles attempts to be townish today.

[Kuruk]

I am angry with scmafia.com right now. To be blunt I dont like the players that make posts with no content. I dont like the FoS on active players with some that have hardly posted. I do not like the the pictures and 'Omg Lol' conversation that is instigated with them. I think it is scummy that a player (Tho) would make posts and then hide. I think it is scummy that a player (Hama) would lurk/troll so hard and then try to play so town when called out. I also do not like these last second check in posts. 'Omg I just noticed the game is going so take my check in as a town that skipped a day of town contribution without notice.' Yeah. I took notice.


My original post was a hell of a lot more detailed with information on every player but this will have to do because I am still pissed off at my wasted time.

[Kuruk]

I would also like to point out that having a profile picture makes your statements memorable and that not having one helps you blend.

[Lion Turtle]

I also dislike the extremity of Lion Turtles attempts to be townish today.

Riiiight. So just because everybody else is being unproductive means I should go along with it and blend? K. 'Scuze me while I go lurk. Cause apparently being active and trying to spark conversation is scummy. Make note, guys.

[Hama]

(Hama) would lurk

When did I ever lurk?

[Yangchen]

Riiiight. So just because everybody else is being unproductive means I should go along with it and blend? K. 'Scuze me while I go lurk. Cause apparently being active and trying to spark conversation is scummy. Make note, guys.

Lul. That way to defensive reply.

Make conversation. Don't ask others to make conversation for you. Pro tip.

[Yangchen]

I am angry with scmafia.com right now. To be blunt I dont like the players that make posts with no content. I dont like the FoS on active players with some that have hardly posted. I do not like the the pictures and 'Omg Lol' conversation that is instigated with them. I think it is scummy that a player (Tho) would make posts and then hide. I think it is scummy that a player (Hama) would lurk/troll so hard and then try to play so town when called out. I also do not like these last second check in posts. 'Omg I just noticed the game is going so take my check in as a town that skipped a day of town contribution without notice.' Yeah. I took notice.


My original post was a hell of a lot more detailed with information on every player but this will have to do because I am still pissed off at my wasted time.

You can be angry at "wasted time" all you want. That doesn't mean you leave the entire game for an unknown about of time because of that one small occurrence.

[Yangchen]

When did I ever lurk?

During the period of time between your last post and KW #3's. All lurk.

[Yangchen]

Also there is an observation I made.

My profile was set to have it show when I was online and viewing things. Hama's is turned off. Curious

[Hama]

Let's get some ideas on what roles the Mafia/Fire Nation might have. The Mafia looks to be in a similar format to the last FM(also hosted by Slaol) (1 leader and a number of unspecified roles). They weren't random mafia. They had been assigned and I would suspect that is exactly the same case here.

There are 3 of the following:

War Minister Qin
You may Arm a player not in your Fire Nation night chat with weapons at night. They may use them 1-time to Strike with them to kill a target.

Yuyan Archer
1-time you may Shoot a player at night. Killing them.

Fire Sage Shyu
You will have the power of another role, but require Admiral Zhao to die before you can win.

Malu the Magician
You may Amaze a player at night. Sending all that visit you to effect them.
You start with 1 charge, and earn another charge every 2 nights.

Bruiser
May Eliminate a player one time.
This kill bypasses swapping, healing, and role blocks.

Consgiliere
Can Investigate a player for their role at night.

Consort
Can Role Block a player at night, preventing them from acting. Can not be role blocked.

Framer
Can Frame a target at night, making them appear.
Fire Nation to Hakoda
Visiting the Mafia kill to Sokka and The Duke.

Blackmailer
May Silence a player at night, preventing them from talking or voting the next day.

Mafioso
May leave a Death Note if acting out the Fire Nation night kill.

Oin: Initially, I thought he was underpowered because they'd have to give the weapons to opposing factions which doesn't sound like a grand recipe for success. Though maybe a shrewd player could make this work in their favour. This role looks like more of a curse than a boon, but it does require clever thinking so it's possible.

Yuyan/Bruiser/Mafioso: Yuyan looks like a weaker version of the Bruiser. I've already spoken about the Bruiser in an earlier post. The Mafioso would seem like a terrific waste of a slot when there are only 4 mafia, not to mention that the name Mafioso doesn't remotely fit with the RP. I suspect there's only 1/3 of these roles and that it's the Yuyan archer.

Consigliere/Consort/Blackmailer: These are powerful and very useful mafia roles. I'd expect at least one of them.

Malu/Shyu: The uniqueness of these roles makes me almost certain they're in the setup. If it was me I would make Shyu the Yuyan archer.

Framer: Less useful in this setup than in others. Seems unlikely to appear.

My proposed role list:

Admiral Zhao
Fire Sage Shyu the Yuyan Archer
Malu the Magician
Consort/Consigliere/Blackmailer

[Hama]

Also there is an observation I made.

My profile was set to have it show when I was online and viewing things. Hama's is turned off. Curious

I don't want my enemies to be able to see if I'm repeatedly online at night, because it would suggest I'm participating in a night chat: Examples: If I am jailed by Zuko/ Bumi or even that I'd been recruited to the Freedom Fighters (not that I'm claiming Earth Citizen).

It pays to be prepared.

[Kyoshi Warrior #3]

Here are some preliminary reads. (Mostly people that need to contribute more and my FoS):

Spammy/lurky, need to post more content (Please fill out my survey in post #103 as an easy way to contribute):
Due – posts really annoying lolcats, it's hard to understand what this guy is even saying because of the format of his posts

Jin Wei - no read

June - anti-Traitor b/c wants to sacrifice Iroh

Koh - no read

Kuruk – a little trolly, seems angry. Says his long useful posts keep getting lost/not posting.

Monk Gyatso – no read

Sangok – very trolly, attacks Hama

Tho – no read

Wan Shi Tong – no read

Wei Jin - no read

FoS:
Hama - pro-traitor, wants aang to reveal (yes, this is really pro-traitor) although his plan doesn't work if mafia has a bruiser. I feel like he's hiding something and isn't town because of his willingness to gamble Aang's life that mafia doesn't have a bruiser. Or does he know something we don't (i.e. is mafia with a bruiser). I'm noting that Hama's proposed mafia role list does not have a bruiser on it.

Lion Turtle – keeps backtracking statements and waffling. Tries hard to seem anti-fire nation and pro-traitor

Pathik – votes systematically, seems odd like he wants to come up with justifications for everything he does. Responds promptly to pressure, seems like there is something to hide



...and I have some more things to say after at least 5 people have taken my survey. We are now at 3/5.

[Yangchen]

I don't want my enemies to be able to see if I'm repeatedly online at night, because it would suggest I'm participating in a night chat: Examples: If I am jailed by Zuko/ Bumi or even that I'd been recruited to the Freedom Fighters (not that I'm claiming Earth Citizen).

It pays to be prepared.

What a bad answer. Thank you.


@KW #3

Are you withholding information to get people to use your.. rather bland questionnaire?

[Hama]

Inb4 I break the game.

[Wei Jin]

Just for fun:

Pick one of these:
(a) red
(b) blue
(c) green
(d) white

Pick two of these:
(a) lemur
(b) unagi
(c) sky bison
(d) canyon crawler
(e) dragon moose
(f) hermit crab
(g) purple pentapus

Pick three of these:
(a) water bending scroll
(b) Katara's mom's necklace
(c) purple berries
(d) headpiece of the crown prince of the Fire Nation
(e) rare first edition book
(f) Aang's wanted poster
(g) specially-tied knot
(h) Sozin's comet

Pick four of these:
(a) wooden monkey
(b) stuffed cat
(c) wooden hand drum
(d) paper airplane
(e) clay turtle
(f) redemption orb
(g) water from the spirit oasis
(h) pull-string propeller

Well I filled it out for you. So here you go.

[Wan Shi Tong]

I just picked the coolest:

Pick one of these:
(a) red
(b) blue
(c) green
(d) white

Pick two of these:
(a) lemur
(b) unagi
(c) sky bison
(d) canyon crawler
(e) dragon moose
(f) hermit crab
(g) purple pentapus

Pick three of these:
(a) water bending scroll
(b) Katara's mom's necklace
(c) purple berries
(d) headpiece of the crown prince of the Fire Nation
(e) rare first edition book
(f) Aang's wanted poster
(g) specially-tied knot
(h) Sozin's comet

Pick four of these:
(a) wooden monkey
(b) stuffed cat
(c) wooden hand drum
(d) paper airplane
(e) clay turtle
(f) redemption orb
(g) water from the spirit oasis
(h) pull-string propeller

[Kyoshi Warrior #3]

Framer: Less useful in this setup than in others. Seems unlikely to appear.

Interesting. Inb4 Sokka/Hakoda/The Duke claim from Hama with a "[insert player name here] came up mafia, and framer is unlikely therefore we should lynch [insert player name here]"

I think that if we don't end up lynching today, Sokka would use his follow ability since it seems pointless to encourage someone at this stage of the game since alignments are still unknown.

I'm just wary of how Hama is constantly trying to shape the way we view the hidden mafia roles. He seems over obsesed with it to the point of being suspicious.

[Due]

Due – posts really annoying lolcats, it's hard to understand what this guy is even saying because of the format of his posts
.

[Wei Jin]

I don't want my enemies to be able to see if I'm repeatedly online at night, because it would suggest I'm participating in a night chat: Examples: If I am jailed by Zuko/ Bumi or even that I'd been recruited to the Freedom Fighters (not that I'm claiming Earth Citizen).

It pays to be prepared.

In the set-up they specifically answered night chats were on an off-site forum so you being invisible to prevent your "enemies" from seeing you is flawed.

[Yangchen]

In the set-up they specifically answered night chats were on an off-site forum so you being invisible to prevent your "enemies" from seeing you is flawed.

+1

[Yangchen]

With that.

-vote Hama

[Hama]

Hmmm. I have been giving some thought to this.

The setup allows us to side with another faction. I agree that it makes sense to try and bring the Traitors into alignment with us. The only alternative would be the Freedom Fighters, but they are not a viable alternative because it would involve having to expose Katara AND sell out Aang. That's not much of an option.

So in order for us to align with the Traitors Aang needs to be jailed by Zuko.

The logical way to expedite this process is for Aang to reveal himself and Zuko to jail him tonight. The Fire Nation then can't visit Aang, because if they do so Zuko will automatically slay the first visitor. Appa the BD is confirmed in the setup and can protect Aang on subsequent nights.

This is a gamble though, because if the Fire Nation has a Bruiser then they'd surely use it on Aang. However, that Bruiser would inevitably be killed by Zuko in the attempt. To be honest, I doubt the presence of a Bruiser. As a role it is not very powerful in the long-term beyond its single use. Its true power exists in its WIFOM possibility in the setup and I would hazard that was the hosts' intention all along. The Bruiser possibility exists to try and dissuade us from such strategies as this. However, I doubt the Fire Nation actually has one.

Therefore!

In summary: Aang should reveal himself today. Zuko should jail him tonight.

I have figured it out!

Aang reveals today.
Zuko jails him tonight.
Zuko informs Aang the identity of Uncle Iroh.
Day 2 Aang informs us of the identity of Uncle Iroh.
We lynch Uncle Iroh.
Zuko automatically becomes the Blue Spirit.
Aang is subsequently immune to all death.

The Fire Nation never has the opportunity to hurt Aang. N1 he is protected by Zuko's jail. N2 onwards he is immune because of the Blue Spirit.

[Yangchen]

I have figured it out!

Aang reveals today.
Zuko jails him tonight.
Zuko informs Aang the identity of Uncle Iroh.
Day 2 Aang informs us of the identity of Uncle Iroh.
We lynch Uncle Iroh.
Zuko automatically becomes the Blue Spirit.
Aang is subsequently immune to all death.

The Fire Nation never has the opportunity to hurt Aang. N1 he is protected by Zuko's jail. N2 onwards he is immune because of the Blue Spirit.

Super flimsy yo

[Hama]

In the set-up they specifically answered night chats were on an off-site forum so you being invisible to prevent your "enemies" from seeing you is flawed.

Uhhh what... Where is this stated? I can't see it in the setup anywhere. I know full well that vbulletin is capable of producing invisible night chats on-site and this was what we used for FMs 4-12 that I played in. Why would night-chats be off-site? Can Roku confirm this?

[Yangchen]

Uhhh what... Where is this stated? I can't see it in the setup anywhere. I know full well that vbulletin is capable of producing invisible night chats on-site and this was what we used for FMs 4-12 that I played in. Why would night-chats be off-site? Can Roku confirm this?

To my immediate knowledge there has never been a single M-FM that has had on site night chats. Additionally he states the answer to off site night chats on the first page of the setup thread.

Tots not a liar.

[Wei Jin]

I have figured it out!

Aang reveals today.
Zuko jails him tonight.
Zuko informs Aang the identity of Uncle Iroh.
Day 2 Aang informs us of the identity of Uncle Iroh.
We lynch Uncle Iroh.
Zuko automatically becomes the Blue Spirit.
Aang is subsequently immune to all death.

The Fire Nation never has the opportunity to hurt Aang. N1 he is protected by Zuko's jail. N2 onwards he is immune because of the Blue Spirit.

Thing is it doesn't say he automatically becomes the Blue Spirit.

Where in the OoO does Zuko turn into the blue spirit?

If he turns into the blue spirit at the beginning of the night then the plan could possibly work. If we fear a bruiser and Zuko becomes the blue spirit at the end of the night then the plan isn't worth the risk at all.

[Hama]

To my immediate knowledge there has never been a single M-FM that has had on site night chats. Additionally he states the answer to off site night chats on the first page of the setup thread. Tots not a liar.

I have never played an M-FM here before. Check if you want. And I have already scoured the setup. It is not in there.

[Wei Jin]

I have never played an M-FM here before. Check if you want. And I have already scoured the setup. It is not in there.

Posts 19 and 20 on the set-up thread.

[Yangchen]

Anyways. Wan Shi Tong, responses to the current discussion point?

[Hama]

Super flimsy yo

You provide opposition to this plan without stating reasons. Here is a list of roles who would want to oppose a Zuko/Avatar alliance. Admiral Zhao Mafia Mafia Mafia Uncle Iroh Jet Cabbage Merchant

[Hama]

Posts 19 and 20 on the set-up thread.

I see. I admit I didn't bother reading any of the pre-game questions because I always assume anything that's not clear pre-game will be clarified by the hosts in the final setup post, and because trolls ask 1000 questions about obscure mechanics that will never come to pass.

I was mistaken about the night chats. I admit I am surprised, because as I stated before, the software here (vBulletin) is more than capable of producing invisible night chats and it takes literally 10 seconds to setup.

You win this round, Mr Bond.

[Yangchen]

You provide opposition to this plan without stating reasons. Here is a list of roles who would want to oppose a Zuko/Avatar alliance. Admiral Zhao Mafia Mafia Mafia Uncle Iroh Jet Cabbage Merchant

Im a realist. Realistically there is little reason that Aang would put his all into a risky play made on day one by someone who is assuming, with slaol as a host, that the mafia are a certain way with no chance of it being anything else. Not only that but it has been made obviously clear that you have not fully read the setup thread.

I'm fine with being considered scum. It hasn't slowed me down before

[Pathik]

Returned now, will put together the promised preliminary leads list.

I could be wrong, but aren't a lot of night chats made with anonymous accounts? Wouldn't that be the same for Zuko and Iroh? Do Zuko and Iroh know each others' identities? If they're known to each other, I'm pretty sure Zuko throwing Iroh under the bus is one of the most obvious plans in terms of Traitor-strategy

@K#3
Systematic voting is akin to random (no bias involved), which I figure is the best course of action with no prior/relevant knowledge.

[Hama]

Im a realist. Realistically there is little reason that Aang would put his all into a risky play made on day one by someone who is assuming, with slaol as a host, that the mafia are a certain way with no chance of it being anything else. Not only that but it has been made obviously clear that you have not fully read the setup thread.

I'm fine with being considered scum. It hasn't slowed me down before

Yang, please hear the plan out. I have highlighted the line you posted that seems to be in error. The updated plan works regardless of the Mafia configuration. The Mafia could have 3 Bruisers and they still wouldn't be able to kill Aang because he will be immune every night.

The only point that needs clarification is when the Blue Spirit takes his form, and when Aang gains invulnerability.

I am more than happy to hear objections to my plan, but I will continue to debate them if they don't seem to make sense.

[Hama]

Thing is it doesn't say he automatically becomes the Blue Spirit.

Where in the OoO does Zuko turn into the blue spirit?

If he turns into the blue spirit at the beginning of the night then the plan could possibly work. If we fear a bruiser and Zuko becomes the blue spirit at the end of the night then the plan isn't worth the risk at all.

I've been thinking about this and there is even a solution to that.

In the unlikely event that Zuko doesn't become the Blue Spirit immediately, Zuko can merely jail Aang n2 as well until he becomes the Blue Spirit later that night.

[Wei Jin]

I've been thinking about this and there is even a solution to that.

In the unlikely event that Zuko doesn't become the Blue Spirit immediately, Zuko can merely jail Aang n2 as well until he becomes the Blue Spirit later that night.

Thing is while he is jailed though he isn't converting anyone into pr's. In the long run with being night immune he doesn't have to be afraid with Appa in the game who can switch Zuko, but what if there is a consort in game? After we know Zuko became the blue spirit then Appa has to keep on switching Aang while leaving the blue spirit open to attack. I just don't think Aang revealing is the best option.

[Wan Shi Tong]

Anyways. Wan Shi Tong, responses to the current discussion point?

I am not seeing a flaw in the plan to be honest. If the OoO works for the plan and we go through with this then Zuko only has to eliminate Admiral Zhao to win which would benefit him very much.. or am I missing anything?

[Hama]

Thing is while he is jailed though he isn't converting anyone into pr's. In the long run with being night immune he doesn't have to be afraid with Appa in the game who can switch Zuko, but what if there is a consort in game? After we know Zuko became the blue spirit then Appa has to keep on switching Aang while leaving the blue spirit open to attack. I just don't think Aang revealing is the best option.

Nobody will know the identity of the blue spirit save Aang.

[Guru Pathik]

Does this mean that each Earth Kingdom Citizen has a predetermined hidden RP name that will be revealed to them when they become converted to the Freedom Fighters? Or does this mean that the hosts have predetermined that Jet's first recruit will receive RP name/role X, his second receives RP name/role Y, etc?

The Citizens have predetermined roles that they will get when recruited to the Freedom Fighters or met by Aang. Predetermined by player.

Is there feedback for being attacked and healed?

Perhaps

Is there feedback for being attacked but surviving via other means than being healed?

Perhaps

Is Yuyan Archer's shot in addition to the mafia's faction kill?

Yes

Is the Bruiser's elimination in addition to the mafia's faction kill?

Yes

Will the Consigliere detect exact role and RP name?

Yes

Will the Consigliere be able to tell if a player started out as Water Tribe or Earth Tribe or Katara if they are converted?

No they will not.

Is there notification that someone avoided being role blocked?

No.

Does role blocking give a notification?

Perhaps

If a third person visits Zuko's captured target, what happens?

Does it say anything happens? No. Then nothing happens.

Does Zuko have unlimited executions?

Unlimited +1

Does Aang get to choose what RP role to give a player, or is it predetermined like Jet's?

Predetermined.

Is Sokka's encouraging one use only, or does it apply for the entirety of the rest of the MFM?

It applies for the following night

If the Yue chooses to avoid a player who is targeting Yue, does it role block that player? Does it redirect their action?

It operates more like a role block

Is there feedback for being enchanted?

Perhaps

Is there feedback for being avoided?

If it does not impact actions it definitely won't, i mean, come on. If it does impact action it might.

Is there feedback for being airbended?

Perhaps

King Bumi: does the execution-escaping guess occur via PM to the hosts or in the jail chat?

Rock Candy Prison*

Does the execution command occur via PM to the hosts or in the jail chat? (I'm just wondering if Zuko can fake being King Bumi)

Your question is moot. However, either PM or in Jail Chat would be acceptable.

Is there feedback for being forced to fight suki?

Perhaps

Does Huu's transform attack all players who attack him, or all players who visit him on the night he transforms?

Visit

There are only 4 Freedom Fighter RP names (besides Jet). Can more than 4 players be converted to the Freedom Fighters?

Technically there are 5 players that can be converted to 4 PR slots. Good luck.

If a Freedom Fighter RP name dies, can Jet recruit another Freedom Fighter bearing the same RP name?

Who would see their friend die, and then go find another friend and just give him his old friend's name?

Evolved win conditions: A lot of the evolved win conditions say that people only have to defeat Admiral Zhao. Does this mean that only Admiral Zhao has to die and not the rest of the Hidden Fire nation members?

Basically.

[Yangchen]

Yang, please hear the plan out. I have highlighted the line you posted that seems to be in error. The updated plan works regardless of the Mafia configuration. The Mafia could have 3 Bruisers and they still wouldn't be able to kill Aang because he will be immune every night.

The only point that needs clarification is when the Blue Spirit takes his form, and when Aang gains invulnerability.

I am more than happy to hear objections to my plan, but I will continue to debate them if they don't seem to make sense.

The plan is fine in theory. The only flaw is in human tendencies. If Aang is played by a player who is cautious it'll fail because they wont want to risk it. Aside from that I don't care enough.

[Pathik]

Preliminary Reads List ([COLOR="#800080"]Non-posters[/COLOR
Neutral denotes central on the spectrum of Town-Mafia

Due - Townish; but his cat pics still annoy me. Annoying spoiler buttons plus if I wanted to see cats, I would not visit sc2mafia.com
Hama - Neutral-town; Useful meta post on mafia faction, most other posts fluff
Huu - Neutral; Don't see anything useful from him yet, one post that contributes but indirectly
Jin Wei
June - Confused town/True Neutral; My first suspect for cabbages, otherwise gut feeling town but not much usefulness in posts
Koh
Kuruk - Neutral; Liked his post on avatars, otherwise nothing specific
Kyoshi - Scummy-Neutral; Main contributions focus on Traitor faction
Kyoshi Warrior #3 - Neutral-town; Contributes a lot but mostly through setup questions & may have something useful coming with the "puzzle" but judgement deferred
La - Neutral; Mostly just setup question posts
Lion Turtle - Neutral; Was getting a slight town read til the post containing justification for future lurkiness, which I consider scummy
Momo - Townish; Agree with posts, not much fluff
Monk Gyatso
Sangok - Scummy-Neutral; Posts a lot about how others troll, but contains little substance beyond that
Tho - Neutral; Basically posted nothing of interest yet
Yangchen - Townish; Slowly circling into town leader position
Wan Shi Tong - Neutral; Not much contribution from posts yet
Wang Fire - Slight scummy-Neutral; Stopped posting once troll-phase of the day ended, but may be due to time zone. slightly scummy for now
Wei Jin - Neutral-town; More contribution than most players, nothing concrete though

Not posting yet is slightly more excusable than usual due to the onset of the FM with no warning, but it won't continue to be excusable forever, thus they are considered neutral.

[Yangchen]

I am not seeing a flaw in the plan to be honest. If the OoO works for the plan and we go through with this then Zuko only has to eliminate Admiral Zhao to win which would benefit him very much.. or am I missing anything?

Nope. Only the large benefit to Zuko.

[Hama]

The plan is fine in theory. The only flaw is in human tendencies. If Aang is played by a player who is cautious it'll fail because they wont want to risk it. Aside from that I don't care enough.

It's not that it will fail. Aang initiates the plan by revealing today. If Aang refused to go ahead the plan would simply never be enacted. Nothing lost because nothing was ever started.