Marshall change

[ypmagic]

Make that Marshall cannot reveal on a no-lynch Day 1.

[SuperJack]

That makes sense.

[cxx]

No.
There is no need. There might be some setups where revealing on day 1 is useful. But in most cases, it will just limit the Marshall's power to inexperienced players, who are somewhat likelier to use his power wrong if it comes to effect. That's a good thing.

[ypmagic]

No.
There is no need. There might be some setups where revealing on day 1 is useful. But in most cases, it will just limit the Marshall's power to inexperienced players, who are somewhat likelier to use his power wrong. That's a good thing.

How the hell would it be fkin useful when theres only one execution group with four executions?

[creedkingsx]

How the hell would it be fkin useful when theres only one execution group with four executions?

Instant confirmed town.
(most OP thing in the game of Mafia)

[ypmagic]

Instant confirmed town.
(most OP thing in the game of Mafia)

Confirmed town with 4 executions in the drain. I would prefer doing it the next day where you could lynch. It's only Day 2.

[Dagaen]

We can't change the role just because people can't use it correctly. What would be next, Jailor who can only execute Mafia members?

[cxx]

Who says there is only one group execution? The setup may allow 2. And, as I said, in specific setups, you might consider it.

[creedkingsx]

Confirmed town with 4 executions in the drain. I would prefer doing it the next day where you could lynch. It's only Day 2.

inb4 dead

[Anguss]

Yeah, I'd much rather have it so that the town can randomly execute 4 townies so that the group lynching doesn't go to waste!

[ypmagic]

Yeah, I'd much rather have it so that the town can randomly execute 4 townies so that the group lynching doesn't go to waste!

This is the situation where the Marshall reveals when its a NO-LYNCH DAY 1.

[kyle1234513]

This is the situation where the Marshall reveals when its a NO-LYNCH DAY 1.

and the marshall should have the choice to reveal day 1 and get a doc/bg on him n1. so he doesn't die n1.

*choice* is what matters here. its the marshalls choice to reveal day 1 and auto confirm himself.

if the marshall wants to blow his only use for some protection and auto confirmation that's his view as whats more important.

[Anguss]

and the marshall should have the choice to reveal day 1 and get a doc/bg on him n1. so he doesn't die n1.

*choice* is what matters here. its the marshalls choice to reveal day 1 and auto confirm himself.

if the marshall wants to blow his only use for some protection and auto confirmation that's his view as whats more important.

Being able to random lynch a bunch of innocent townies on day 2 is FAR more important.

[kyle1234513]

Being able to random lynch a bunch of innocent townies on day 2 is FAR more important.

and since when have the auth of mafia started forcing people to play their roles a certain way?

[Anguss]

Jailors and Vigilantes should have unlimited kills, also.

[powerofdeath]

Jailors and Vigilantes should have unlimited kills, also.

4 kills for vigilante are very high
Show me a replay where vigilante shot all 4 scums, and desperately need a fifth bullet
I personally hate vigs having so much bullets, they usually just kill random towns. I usually give them either one or two bullets so they have to save their bullet until they can shoot comfirmed mafia, or be an idiot and random shoot and waste your only bullet on night 2

[Shadowstrike2]

I'd recommend setting it so marshal cant reveal till day 3. With a message something like. "You must wait two days for warrants and execution papers from your superiors."

[Damus_Graves]

No

[Shadowstrike2]

If you don't mind me asking... Why do you not like that change idea?

[Damus_Graves]

Because Marshall is really just an OP one shoted mayor that doesn;t have multiple votes. Its only as good as the player behind him.

[maccabbe]

To me, removing marshall ability to reveal day 1 makes more sense than not letting vig shot n1.

[Shadowstrike2]

But alot of the time its not a bad player its just someone deliberately trolling with the role.

[Cryptonic]

I like that he can't reveal d1. Also, make it so the Marshall can't be lynched on days he reveals.