Day 5

[FM Monroe]

Scratch that... Earle just posted his interviewed claims.

So we're waiting on Fontaine to confirm or deny. Interesting... if Fontaine confirms, this gets interesting. We have either Earle + Fontaine as scum or Buchwalter as scum.

Or one of them is blackmailed, which would screw everything up.

[FM Parker]

-vote unvote

I can reveal and hammer Earle. I just want to be ready if this train changes direction.

Did Cafarelli claim drugged today?

[FM Earle]

Earle is invincible. Earle cannot be lynched!

[FM Monroe]

-vote unvote

I can reveal and hammer Earle. I just want to be ready if this train changes direction.

Did Cafarelli claim drugged today?

Yes, but I blocked her. So I'm not sure what she was trying to accomplish there. Could be faking executioner/jester. Could be genuinely feedback blocked and didn't get my RB feedback.

[FM Earle]

I can reveal and hammer Earle. I just want to be ready if this train changes direction.

What is your excuse to hammer Earle. No counterclaim. Earle is the journalist with unknown alignment!

FM Earle (10 [L-4]):
FM Rose, FM Cafarelli, FM Buchwalter, FM Mendez, FM Galloway, FM Kalou, FM Phelps, FM Leary, FM Black, FM Lichtmann

---

FM Lichtmann (2 [L-12]):
FM Chapman, FM Galletta

---

FM Cafarelli (1 [L-13]):
FM Earle

---

FM Dunn (1 [L-13]):
FM Ackerman

[FM Parker]

Yes, but I blocked her. So I'm not sure what she was trying to accomplish there. Could be faking executioner/jester. Could be genuinely feedback blocked and didn't get my RB feedback.

If Cafarelli was drugged to have no feedback, then Earle's soma could not have been drugged. If Earle's soma could not have been drugged, his claims are totally lies. However, if Earle was genuinely drugged, then both Buchwalter and Cafarelli are scum barring two drug dealers.

[FM Monroe]

Yes, but I blocked her. So I'm not sure what she was trying to accomplish there. Could be faking executioner/jester. Could be genuinely feedback blocked and didn't get my RB feedback.

I feel stupid for not seeing this before. If she is mafia with Phelps, it would help her to make me the suspect instead of him after I claimed. Because she could just claim to have never received the roleblock.

[FM Parker]

Earle, I'm playing it safe because I think there is a possibility the mafia tried to set you up. Not sure though.

[FM Earle]

Who do you want Earle to interview. Easily done. Dunn please protect Earle.

Mafia it is your fault to set up Earle. Earle could have been a helpful Corrupt Journalist.

[FM Parker]

So we have Earle or Buchwalter as scum. We have Earle or Cafarelli as scum (barring two drug dealers).

I don't think Fontaine is blackmailed. The mafia would have no way of knowing who Earle would interview even if it is a setup by the mafia... they'd have to get really lucky.

[FM Earle]

Earle, I'm playing it safe because I think there is a possibility the mafia tried to set you up. Not sure though.

Those who claim that they "know" Earle cannot be Mafia. Else they are fools.

Earle using bad words because Earle's plan to stay alive until endgame is foiled.

[FM Parker]

Monroe (and all you lurkers), do you think it's possible that the mafia framed Earle by drugging him and then using the soma themselves?

[FM Earle]

And what about Soma from Mason? Where did they go?

[FM Monroe]

So we have Earle or Buchwalter as scum. We have Earle or Cafarelli as scum (barring two drug dealers).

I don't think Fontaine is blackmailed. The mafia would have no way of knowing who Earle would interview even if it is a setup by the mafia... they'd have to get really lucky.

I meant Buchwalter or Earle as possibly set up with blackmail, not Fontaine.

Buchwalter can really only be a consigliere if he's mafia. Drug dealer maybe, but only if Morgan lied about getting blackmailed night 2.

Earle can be any mafia role, especially godfather or blackmailer who was sent to kill on his off-night. Both would be absolutely fantastic to lynch.

[FM Monroe]

Monroe (and all you lurkers), do you think it's possible that the mafia framed Earle by drugging him and then using the soma themselves?

Definitely possible. Not very likely.

As I've said, it would require Buch to either be consig, blackmailed, or Morgan lied about being blackmailed.

[FM Parker]

Monroe, Buchwalter was not blackmailed to claim he received the soma. He actually did receive the soma.

The mafia would also have to know Buchwalter had received the soma in order for their plan to work. The message Buchwalter posted contained no identifying details. I doubt Buchwalter would be foolish enough to send a message to the mafia with identifying information.

Earle could be blackmailed... but what would his blackmail be? Claim journalist? I'm not seeing that either.

Actually, Earle has to be the GF or Buchwalter is the mafia who somehow got the soma to the GF (maybe he held it maybe he passed to a teammate). Only the Godfather can kill twice using the soma it's in the setup.

[FM Parker]

I don't think any of those are required for the mafia plan.

Scenario A (most likely)
Buchwalter receives Soma
Earle receives Soma
Earle uses Soma

Scenario B
Buchwalter receives Soma
Buchwalter holds soma or passes it to the GF on his team
Drug Dealer drugs Earle to receive Soma

[FM Parker]

If Scenario B is accurate (and we can find out by lynching Earle), then Cafarelli must be mafia or there are two drug dealers.

[FM Monroe]

Monroe, Buchwalter was not blackmailed to claim he received the soma. He actually did receive the soma.

I was thinking more about his claim to have given soma to Earle being a blackmail task, not necessarily the part where he received it. It would require extreme coincidence though, you're right.

[FM Monroe]

If Scenario B is accurate (and we can find out by lynching Earle), then Cafarelli must be mafia or there are two drug dealers.

Good point. I'm going to sleep now though.

You don't need me to lynch if you want to.

[FM Ackerman]

L2R


D1 BISHOP I call BS, this interviewee claimed invest, and revealed a lead, Bishop flipped detective
D2 ROSE Already claimed
D3 DUNN Just jumping on the prior accusation
D4 FONTAINE Possible?

-vote unvote

I can reveal and hammer Earle. I just want to be ready if this train changes direction.

Did Cafarelli claim drugged today?

You can put the vote back on now.

Monroe, Buchwalter was not blackmailed to claim he received the soma. He actually did receive the soma.

The mafia would also have to know Buchwalter had received the soma in order for their plan to work. The message Buchwalter posted contained no identifying details. I doubt Buchwalter would be foolish enough to send a message to the mafia with identifying information.

Earle could be blackmailed... but what would his blackmail be? Claim journalist? I'm not seeing that either.

Actually, Earle has to be the GF or Buchwalter is the mafia who somehow got the soma to the GF (maybe he held it maybe he passed to a teammate). Only the Godfather can kill twice using the soma it's in the setup.

It's got to be earle

-vote FM Earle

[FM Parker]

Ok, the question is which articles is Earle responsible for... Bishop would have had a lead though in either one. Ackerman is right there. He would have said X didn't visit anyone. None of the articles look like that and Bishop isn't around to counterclaim.

-vote FM Earle

Off to bed. I can reveal and hammer tomorrow, so no one get too close.

[FM Ackerman]

Ok, the question is which articles is Earle responsible for... Bishop would have had a lead though in either one. Ackerman is right there. He would have said X didn't visit anyone. None of the articles look like that and Bishop isn't around to counterclaim.

-vote FM Earle

Off to bed. I can reveal and hammer tomorrow, so no one get too close.

I'd also like to point out that Rose claimed the delta interview for n1 already.

[FM Earle]

Earle's defense which nobody bothered to counter

1) Did anyone counter claim Journalist/Savage/Corrupt?

2) Has Coroner confirmed Bishop's last will yet?

https://www.sc2mafia.com/forum/showth...767#post320767

Earle, checking in.

Earle offers sagely advice.

Last will

The truth will prevail

3) Not even giving the Journalist a chance to interview? Since I'm Godfather I can't run.

4) Are you even sure that there are no Interceptor's/Poisoners?

5) What about soma from Mason?

6) Has Fontaine even posted?

7) Rose claimed delta? I hinted even before that:

https://www.sc2mafia.com/forum/showth...l=1#post321822

5. Rose may claim Delta but are you even an Investigator?

NONE OF THESE ARE ANSWERED AND YOU WANT TO LYNCH ME ALREADY? TOWN YOU ARE BEING FOOLED BY SCUM!

[FM Earle]

ANYONE WHO WAS INTERVIEWED INSTEAD CAN COUNTERCLAIM!

ANYONE WHO IS THE REAL JOURNALIST CAN COUNTERCLAIM!

AND THERE WILL BE NONE!

[FM Earle]

FM Earle (12 [L-2]):
FM Rose, FM Cafarelli, FM Buchwalter, FM Parker, FM Mendez, FM Galloway, FM Ackerman, FM Kalou, FM Phelps, FM Leary, FM Black, FM Lichtmann

---

FM Lichtmann (2 [L-12]):
FM Chapman, FM Galletta

---

FM Cafarelli (1 [L-13]):
FM Earle

Six mafia on me and six misguided towns. Lynching a confirmed Journalist. Pfft.

[FM Earle]

I'd also like to point out that Rose claimed the delta interview for n1 already.

N1 Bishop
N2 Rose

Come on...

[FM Earle]

Will know if Rose, Mendez, Galloway, Kalou, Phelps, Leary, Black , Licchtmann are actually town.

Depend on their response to Earle's defense.

[FM Earle]

Come on. Gimme a chance to interview two person today. Then you all will have a confirmed Journalist.

[FM Earle]

Come on Fontaine where are you?

Coroner show yourself and solve Bishop's puzzle

Curse you Bishop.

[FM Galloway]

Earle claiming journalist makes sense with all his post styles and habits. We still have the issue of the double soma kill and buch saying Earle got the soma.

I could suggest having the claimed inves check earle to verify his claim but that is risky due to the kidnapper possibility and the drug dealer.
Thoughts?

-unvote

[FM Earle]

Remember the lynch on McKelty and Biggs. Innocent they are. Now you are lynching town PR.

[FM Earle]

At last, Galloway town coming to save Earle. Take that Mafia!

[FM Mason]

Shit, this cookie dough is the bomb.
Also this day has been eventful.

[FM Earle]

Earle's defense which nobody bothered to counter

1) Did anyone counter claim Journalist/Savage/Corrupt?

2) Has Coroner confirmed Bishop's last will yet?

https://www.sc2mafia.com/forum/showth...767#post320767



3) Not even giving the Journalist a chance to interview? Since I'm Godfather I can't run.

4) Are you even sure that there are no Interceptor's/Poisoners?

5) What about soma from Mason?

6) Has Fontaine even posted?

7) Rose claimed delta? I hinted even before that:

https://www.sc2mafia.com/forum/showth...l=1#post321822



NONE OF THESE ARE ANSWERED AND YOU WANT TO LYNCH ME ALREADY? TOWN YOU ARE BEING FOOLED BY SCUM!

If you cannot answer these and voted me, I will recommend that you join me tomorrow. Lynch those scums.

[FM Black]

Earle, didn't you state that you used the soma?

[FM Earle]

Use soma yesterday. Interview two today. Same thing for jailor. Already asked.

Host please confirm!

[FM Black]

Use soma yesterday. Interview two today. Same thing for jailor. Already asked.

Host please confirm!

Yet you only targeted Fountaine?

[FM Earle]

I can only interview two today.

[FM Earle]

Day4
Receive soma
Send interview Fountain

Night5
Use soma

Day5
Interview two person

[FM Earle]

Use soma yesterday. Interview two today. Same thing for jailor. Already asked.

Host please confirm!

Maybe not yesterday. Should say use soma Night5, Interview two on Day5.

[FM Ferengi]

Use soma yesterday. Interview two today. Same thing for jailor. Already asked.

Host please confirm!

I am not quite sure if there is a question here for me to answer, although it is written in green. As such, I shall simply refer you to the setup thread since it holds most of the answers: https://www.sc2mafia.com/forum/showth...9219-The-Setup

[FM Ryan]

I came back, and what do I see now? The whole train have been shifted to Earle!

But I do believe that his Journalist claim is legit, as no one has counterclaimed him yet. So does Monroe's escort role claim. I still think that either Cafarelli or Phelps is mafia.

[FM Earle]

I am not quite sure if there is a question here for me to answer, although it is written in green. As such, I shall simply refer you to the setup thread since it holds most of the answers: https://www.sc2mafia.com/forum/showth...9219-The-Setup

Journalists and Corrupt journalists, when given soma, can -use Soma during the night to be able to -interview two players during the following day.

[FM Earle]

Earle needs to more people to unvote me before Mad Mayor hammers me.

[FM Earle]

Black not unvoting. Suspicious. Black unvote NAO!

[FM Ackerman]

I'm still not convinced, but I don't think the real journalist will reveal. How about that final interview. Please confirm.

[FM Rose]

Who did you interview night 5?

[FM Earle]

Who did you interview night 5?

Messed up night and day. Sorry.

D1/N2 Bishop
D2/N3 Rose
D3/N4 Dunn
D4/N5 Fontaine

[FM Earle]

I recommend lynching useless Fontaine if his replacement is also lurking.