Day 5

[FM Parker]

Oh Earle's legend is not strong medium weak on mafia... just if Earle has figured them out. Gotcha Earle.

Parker wants to know which faction Earle has Buchwalter in. Parker thinks Buchwalter is an active lurker.

[FM Mendez]

Oh Earle's legend is not strong medium weak on mafia... just if Earle has figured them out. Gotcha Earle.

Parker wants to know which faction Earle has Buchwalter in. Parker thinks Buchwalter is an active lurker.

Mendez wishes Parker would stop talking like this with Earle.

[FM Monroe]

I mean if she was really blackmailed to rage like mad, she wouldn't be deliberately trying to confuse people about feedback she received like this.

last night i was drugged AGAIN!!!!!!! i was not drugged last night so i think the drug dealer was roleblocked. i said block same, but noo what are escorts doing of course...

Drugged again last night. Not drugged last night. Requests to block the same, yet drug dealer was not in the pairing she posted on Phelps and if anything, what feedback we had yesterday indicated that a bus driver or kidnapper may have been blocked at the time. Now she claims to have guessed Cohen's pairing right on a role of which no evidence existed and implies that she was drugged night 3, as well as night 1. The latter of which seems extremely doubtful.

Also Parker it is not confirmed that Cafarelli isn't savage investigator, because if I read the rules right they could still try to recruit her normally.

You may not -recruit players as [insert hidden gamma roles] that are duplicates of hidden gamma roles currently in the cult.

This only mentions the recruit as option. Not the normal recruit player option.

Using the recruit as option on a gamma role would have made an investigator a standard savage.

If you -recruit a gamma or epsilon as [insert hidden gamma role], they will lose their role abilities and become savages.

Also the idea that Cafarelli may be a consigliere didn't come from Ackerman originally. Hogeboom posted it first at the start of the day, and Cafarelli seemed to feel the need to discourage his thoughts with what seemed like a very hollow defense.

www.sc2mafia.com/forum/showthread.php/20284-Day-4?p=323553&viewfull=1#post323553

The witch is probably real as the random any.

I do think the arsonist only managed to douse scum and dead people, as Cohen was talking about the mafia screwing him over and wanting to return the favor. He was likely really looking for mafia. If my assumption that nobody got blackmailed night 1 is true, then either the mafia waited with their blackmail to pick a good target after a day of seeing people talk or the blackmailer was roleblocked.

Galletta has become very silent since the start of the game and was one of the first people Cohen decided to pick on. Maybe she's trying to keep us from comparing her writing style to those blackmail messages? Maybe Cohen doused her and tried to connect the dots from there? This is just a hunch and I'm not sure I'm willing to act on it yet.

Hi everyone, nothing happened to me.


What if the Mafia decided to throw the Arsonist under the bus? One of their people (Biggs) was doused, they saw Cohen's claim and let Cafarelli, their Consigliere, check him as to have confirmation. Then he pushed the lynch with a different accusation (him being Drug Dealer or what was it?), knowing that Cohen was the Arsonist which would give Cafarelli credibility.

Of course, I could also be talking out of my ass.

cohen said the mafia screwed him over because they didn't drug deal me that night or anything else to prevent me from checking him. the mafia just let him die, probably they even supported the lynch to look protown. so yes, i agree with you that he indeed tried to get the mafia.
however i am not a consig, i really thought he was mafia after i received that pairing, because noone ever claimed doused. even cohen said he thinks i'm an investigator and the mafia wouldn't lynch the arsonist.

Don't give Ackerman too much credit. I don't trust the article that was posted at the end of yesterday for multiple reasons.