How prob NOT to play as executioner

[ariel135]

Well, i've been in a match with a guy, who yelled at day 2: "I'M SHERIF/INVEST! X IS FRAMER! STUPID TOWN! RAGE RAGE RAGE"
he was accused as EXE.
The funny thing is, that he was JAILED AT NIGHT 1!!!
he was about to be executed, then by the last second he said "im witch", so i guess he thought it was a kidnapper.

i checked his target the following night, saw that he is indeed a sherif, as he revealed when he was accused.

he still raged day 3, i was jailed at night 3.
i told everything to the jailor, that the guy lies.

he kept spamming the chat that X is mafia, and town is stupid and gonna lose, then the jailor executed him as suggested by me.

after that, we talked several times, he claimed that he played the executioner "perfectly", and this is how you play it.
also, he claimed that "smart town" should atleast send him to trial on day 2, (and this is my addition-) so he can reveal his role soon and be a target for the mafia. - and thats exactly what town did, and by that, outed the sheriff.


we were together several games, and i wrongly told him that he played a game badly as godfather aswell (though i took it back - he still raged), jailor got him n1, no maf kill, also jailed him at n3, then he said that X is mafia, and jailor told town that he was jailed and lied. so he got jailed again - executed.
he told me that it was perfectly played, because jailor could RB him the entire game,
i told him - that jailor could STILL do that, but jailor executed him.

another funny thing, is that they had a kidnapper that game, and i explained him that kidnapper would be able to kidnapp the jailor before the jailor can jail (who jails first wins), but still he told me i dont know how to play.

and another game, where i saved his ass (as BG), and he failed to finish off the last mafia member.

anyway, i claim that the "day 2 claim, i'm sherif/invest, X is mafia" is the most noob way of playing as an exe.

what do u say?

attaching replayfailexe.SC2Replay

[Ash]

jailor OP obviously

[ariel135]

jailor OP obviously

jailor played well, we couldnt hear the exe anymore at day with his raging

[Deantwo]

i... even when a real Sheriff or Investigator... NEVER give clues on D2... mostly just because no one believe a D2 clue anyway...
only horrible Executioners yell out D2... i mean... really... it's WAY tooooo easy to guess

as for the whole acting as if you weren't jailed... that's just plain stupid... unless you know you can get someone lynched so the Jailor can't execute you the very next night...
as for trying to get someone lynched when he's GF and being chain blocked... that's good idea... but again Town won't want to lynch anyone when they know that the Mafia is being chain blocked...

when i am Executioner... i always act like the rest of the Town... until day 3 or 4... i'll show a nice long (FAKE) LW with random people checked as NS... and then have the latest entry be my target with a big fat MAFIA painted next to him!

[Lazers]

Depends on the town you're with

Some towns will follow you, some will instalynch

I sometimes use it when there's a bunch of idiots ingame

[Admiral]

If you say it right people will believe Day 2 and yes even Day 1 accusations. I used to get people killed like that all the time.