Day 6 discussion

[FM Ferengi]

Day 6 has been started, you can now continue your discussion. Who is going to win this game?

[FM Soul King Brook]

i hope town + marines win^^ still 10 town left + 1 rebel + 2 marines
we got so lucky with the arso last day^^ probably best lynch if he had burned
and i'm really surprised they didn't lynch me (though me accepting the lose was just pretended to stay alive). the defense that all cp9 actions went through didn't even come to my mind. i see the intention of the marines to side with town because they defended me. but then he voted me, which made the town trust me^^ so the town doesn't trust the marines
the janitor kill (i think it was janitor, idk why bonney thinks it is disguiser, maybe you should make clear that it could mean both, host, unless it doesnt) surprises me, now i believe mihawk a bit. but i can't believe that the rebels targeted 2 TPR and no scum. and also that he refused his invitation instantly. but i still think don krieg is cp9
i wonder why cp9 killed me, because i was obviously only citizen and i was almost lynched. and it was also only my first FM. damn, i wanted to survive till the end ;) but the worst thing is that i absolutely can't do anything to make town win now... i can just hope on the others
now that caribou claims vented i wonder what croc is. maybe cp9? probably not town, because why would he claim vented then... but the cp9 didn't do what he said. and why didn't the cp9 vent caribou again? now everyone knows that croc wasnt vented. might be indeed a lucky rb. and why did they witch him? maybe it was drugged? but this would mean they didn't try to vent him again
and why didn't pirates kill a marine, that's what i would do to ensure the cp9 as allies
imo there can't be a spy because all slots are already used; vent, dd, witch are confirmed. so is it just a coincidence?
and why doesn't bonney solve his code? he made one yesterday. but i don't think he's vented though because he said that he was doused
and what's that about gecko? marines said he is ns, low chance he is captain. why the hell do they think that every ns guy is most likely pirate captain?

can i replace an other citizen? there are so many lurkers... if they're scum lurking might be good for them but if they're citis it's really baaad for town. also so many replacements say they're are replacement and then go on with lurking. i also don't have any special information. and why did you let trafalgar play again... he talked so much shit and played so bad, probably LVP. he didn't only sacrifice for nothing, he is also the reason why both rebels died so early (though it's also their own fault. btw whitebeard why did you reveal? wasn't kidd enough?)

btw can you tell me which dead players were already reincarnated?

and i want to know bonney's COM today

[FM Ferengi]

Jewelry Bonney's real name is Boss.

[FM Soul King Brook]

well jimbei is obviously ns because he was swapped with basil n2 when NA checked basil
luffy shouldn't claim imo, there's no use and he'll die now

[FM Soul King Brook]

mhm considering caribou's posting style has changed on d5 i believe him. so i agree that crocodile is the best lynch

these are just 2 examples:
-he didn't write factions and roles with uppercase letters as usual
-he faked the ';' but always forgot to write uppercase after it, as he usually (but not always) does

these are such tiny details that caribou wouldn't do it intentionally to be able to claim vented.

[FM Soul King Brook]

this is my personal cp9/pirate list right now

crocodile
drake
kuma
doflamingo

shanks
blackbeard

[FM Capone Bege]

Yeah Blackbeard seems like a good candidate for Janitor. I disagree with Shanks though, I think he might just be a Citizen. Witch needs to die so Pirate can hit a Marine instead of a Town.

First Mate, what was Basil Hawkin's role?

[FM Whitebeard]

I think Caribou is clever enough to fake being ventriloquisted while being CP9 himself. Claiming to be charged night 1 was his way of dodging night kills. If he is CP9, he will have seen that mislynching a townie today will yield a critical turning point, so he could easily have planned this ahead of time and used Crocodile to frame himself, just like Big Mom was.

He was constantly saying that my suggestion that the charged claims and Big Mom's disguiser code were orchestrated in CP9 chat was an interesting, but false. Now he is turning around and saying the charge was probably faked by a drug dealer.

I'm still highly suspicious of that guy, since he has been buddying with the marines since the start and all of the CP9 kills look very convenient from his perspective so far if he is ventriloquist.

Props if he gets away with it though.

[FM Whitebeard]

Marines will side with CP9 if they're smart. And they're actually actively proclaiming it in day chat now.

Town should have protected the rebels because we had no real intention of siding with the pirates, as cp9 was far too strong

[FM Capone Bege]

I think Town would be fine if Witch hadn't found Captain. Even at the expense of Basil Hawkins being witched onto scum, Pirate Captain might have hit a few CP9 on accident.

[FM Whitebeard]

Well it was known that the witch was controlling the pirate kill since the first night, so naturally that should be taken into account when trying to determine faction allegiances.

[FM Soul King Brook]

i disagree, if i was marine i would side with town. because they have a fair chance to win then. and i wouldn't want the cp9 to decide if we or pirates win. and sooner or later the pirates will definitely kill marines so the cp9 will most likely choose pirates then

[FM Soul King Brook]

btw i still read day chat, is there even a chance i will be a replacement?

[FM Ferengi]

Everyone seems fairly active, even hard lurkers like X Drake and Gecko Moria were slapped up, so it's unlikely that someone will be replaced at this point.

[FM Soul King Brook]

btw why was gecko not replaced earlier?

[FM Soul King Brook]

well actually i have to admit i didn't trust kuma's coroner claim either, however i wouldn't have lynched one of the coroner claimers yet because i was unsure who lies and next day they had info to prove. now we'll never know what basil was
anyway, now 2 scums are clear, mihawk and sanji which matches with my ealier list which i had to change because they were 'cleared'
i wonder whether we have a real escort then. don krieg claimed blocked n1 and caribou claimed drugged. could mean caribou is cp9 (marines could be lying). this would make crocodile non cp9

cp9 list:
sanji (drug dealer)
mihawk (witch)
don krieg (vent)
doflamingo/drakex ?? (infiltrator)

i hope town get's enough votes tomorrow but i doubt it. first mate, do you think town has still a chance?

edit: added don krieg

[FM Ferengi]

Heh... Let's just say that I love keeping even dead people in the dark.

[FM Soul King Brook]

mihawk might also be the janitor because of his coroner claim... but cp9 could fake that claim aswell

[FM Soul King Brook]

do you tell us another COM? for the night or for the past days. because i want to know who fire fist ace is, because he talks crap so often

[FM Basil Hawkins]

Yeah Blackbeard seems like a good candidate for Janitor. I disagree with Shanks though, I think he might just be a Citizen. Witch needs to die so Pirate can hit a Marine instead of a Town.

First Mate, what was Basil Hawkin's role?

I was the doctor. I knew it was coming when the bus driver died. Oh well...

[FM Ferengi]

Fire First Ace's real name is Numbertwo.

[FM Soul King Brook]

hm maybe luffy is a doctor too (one PR left because sanji and dracule are scum) or he wants to die tonight. or he is scum. i tend to the second one