Day 6: An Island in Chaos

[FM Ferengi]

Once again, two more people died last night. Tensions are still high!

Soul King Brook was attacked by CP9 last night. No one knows the motives behind their actions.

Soul King Brook's role was Citizen.

And on the shores of the island, another dead body was found, or at least what remained of it. The victim was apparently eaten by the sharks, and flesh and bones were bruised so much that it was beyond any recognition. The victime apparently wore the same clothes as Basil Hawkins. Coincidely, Hawkins himself was nowhere to be found. So this lead town to the conclusion that the dead person was probably Basil Hawkins.

The town was unable to determine Basil Hawkins's role.

The newspaper was ominously silent. No other bad news, but no good news either. What will happen in the island now?

List of players:

FM Bartholomew Kuma
FM Black Leg Sanji
FM Blackbeard
FM Buggy the Clown
FM Cat Thief Nami
FM Crocodile
FM Don Krieg
FM Donquixote Doflamingo
FM Dracule Mihawk
FM Fire Fist Ace
FM Gecko Moria
FM Jewelry Bonney
FM Jimbei
FM Marco the Phoenix
FM Red Haired Shanks
FM Roronoa Zoro
FM Straw Hat Luffy
FM Tony Tony Chopper
FM Wet Haired Caribou
FM X Drake

Graveyard:

FM Hody Jones (Detective) - Killed by CP9
FM Cyborg Franky (First Mate) - Killed by... Pirates?
FM Foxy the Silver Fox (Jailor) - Killed by Pirates
FM Trafalgar Law (Citizen) - Executed by Jailor
FM Boa Hancock (Citizen) - Killed by CP9
FM Nico Robin (Citizen) - Committed suicide
FM Urouge (Framer) - Lynched by the majority
FM Eustass Kidd (Rebel Leader) - Killed by Pirates
FM Whitebeard (Rebel Scout) - Killed by CP9
FM Big Mom (Citizen) - Lynched by the majority
FM Capone Bege (Citizen) - Killed by Pirates
FM Sogeking (Bus Driver) - Killed by CP9
FM Scracthmen Apoo (Arsonist) - Lynched by the majority
FM Soul King Brook (Citizen) - Killed by CP9
FM Basil Hawkins (???) - Eaten by the sharks

Day 6 has began, you can now continue your discussion. You need a majority of 11 players to lynch a person. If no majority occurs during 36 hours, the day ends without a lynch. Once again, I remind you to use vote tags. Day 6 will end at this time:

11 votes to hammer.

[FM Blackbeard]

I AM A NINJA

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

I AM A NINJA

DAMN YOU NINJA

[FM Blackbeard]

So, disguiser or janitor?? I think could be either because if witch had control of the pirate kill, they would either not use or miss with the cleanings, and basil seemed town to me, so idk.

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

basil mod killed?

it said eaten by sharks so pirates i think lacked something

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

There is a third person here. Come out.

Bonnie what happened?

[FM Straw Hat Luffy]

Hey, nothing happened to me.

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

Hmmmmm.... I think i figured something out

allow me to post disguisers role and what it says

Disguiser - Once per game, can kill and steal the identity from target player. Is not a separate kill from other Pirates. Target's role will be cleaned.

So if basil was cleaned he was possible disguiser who faked claimed doc. But he showed ns. So I'm inclined to beivle jan got a lucky clean off.

Oh btw to clear myself of vantrill the number 30 is a refrence to the konami code. Prefrebly contra. I'm becoming lazy on how i type so i'm doing this.

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

Well I got quite a few hours before work so I'll be around and about. But i do want to do this

-vote FM Gecko Moria

what he showed up as is beond me

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

I dont get why they would clean basil though becasue he claimed doc. If we have the real doc hidden its best that it gets revealed now so we can truly tell if diguiser or janitor.

[FM Wet Haired Caribou]

Well that is quite surprising.
Caribou was vented yesterday.
Caribou repeats;
CARIBOU WAS VENTED YESTERDAY.

Caribou was right about Big Mom. He was most likely vented since the very first day, hence the EM posts.
Caribou still can't believe you let the fact that Caribou simply claimed ''OH CARIBOU LOST HIS WALLET SO HE WON'T BE BACK FOR THE REST OF THE DAY'' and that you guys paid no mind to it.

Zoro is actually the only one that was on the right track. A shame you didn't push your questions further; but good job for at least paying attention to these details.

Caribou was also WITCHED last night. To no effect; obviously. Caribou has a hard time figuring out why the CP9 would even bother doing that. Caribou was pretty sure he would be Vented until the rest of the game and was hoping for an Interview from Bonney or a lucky Roleblock on the Vent; He thought he was out of this game for good.

The code was my own fault. From where Caribou was, the site to make codes did not work and Caribou had to hastily make one; which turned out to be way too simple (Caribou used a really basic cipher.), since the CP9 figured it out and posted it. Caribou was pretty shocked when he saw that.

This also means that
Crocodile is full of shit
and that he is pretty much confirmed CP9, with a really high chance of being the Ventriloquist himself
(Caribou did follow the game yesterday; his posting style is also extremely similar. It also fits that he did seem to be a rather good player yet he lurked most of the game, probably being on Big Mom's account, and that yesterday, he made some bullshit excuse to go off my account and go on Crocodile to be active.)

[FM Jewelry Bonney]

i am so confused. i am soooooo. confused.

[FM Jewelry Bonney]

i'll check you out caribou. and i interviewed croc last night. why no interview????

[FM Jewelry Bonney]

maybe he was disguised?

[FM Wet Haired Caribou]

maybe he was disguised?

Even if he was disguised, the Interview is at the very beginning of the order of operations.
If he did die/get disguised, then his interview, if he would've wrote one, should've been posted.

And Caribou highly doubts it did happen; They have vented someone else.
If they did intend to Vent Caribou again, then why would they witch Caribou?
That would make absolutely no sense.
He may have been disguised; but we cannot be sure.


What did Basil die of? Could you be a bit more specific please?

[FM Marco the Phoenix]

CARIBOU WAS VENTED YESTERDAY.

Caribou was also WITCHED last night.

Crocodile is full of shit

Too Long, Didn't Read : Fix.

Crocodile is bad then. Strange enough, someone were cleaned by a Janitor while Caribou claim witched.
I am on a conspiracy theory that the CP9 has made their ally of Pirates and that they made a compromise to kill the town.

[FM Jewelry Bonney]

The victime apparently wore the same clothes as Basil Hawkins.
-disguised. can't be more clear than that. basil was a disguiser.

[FM Marco the Phoenix]

disguiser.

Nami, what's 30?

[FM Jewelry Bonney]

caribou, what if you're vented today, and you're directing a mislynch?

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

30 was my konami code. prefably contra. your turn plz tell me something from last night that i said

[FM Marco the Phoenix]

30 was my konami code.

You're obviously not disguised if you know that.

"It's my old role!"

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

well disguiser and pirate kills are 2 seprate entities. basil claimed doc but apeared ns when cheack a few nights ago.

What i still dont get is how Gecko is still alive yet has not posted one bit.

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

You're obviously not disguised if you know that.

"It's my old role!"

cleared of vantrill and disgise

[FM Don Krieg]

well disguiser and pirate kills are 2 seprate entities. basil claimed doc but apeared ns when cheack a few nights ago.

What i still dont get is how Gecko is still alive yet has not posted one bit.

That's a good point if you ask me. Let's wait until everyone has posted and decide for one target to lynch.

[FM Jewelry Bonney]

well disguiser and pirate kills are 2 seprate entities. basil claimed doc but apeared ns when cheack a few nights ago.

What i still dont get is how Gecko is still alive yet has not posted one bit.

basil was swapped. i need to go and finish all the rest of the days notes. i didnt think i'd survive the night.
and i need someone to confirm something that happened to me last night.

[FM Jewelry Bonney]

That's a good point if you ask me. Let's wait until everyone has posted and decide for one target to lynch.

don krieg, still on my scumlist.
specially that caribou seems vented today.

[FM Wet Haired Caribou]

caribou, what if you're vented today, and you're directing a mislynch?

How is Caribou even supposed to answer that?
The Vent didn't even bother posting a code yesterday; which is very unlike Caribou.

Do you seriously think that if Caribou was seriously vented again and that he would try to push a mislynch, he would claim he had been Witched?

Just take a closer look at the situation:
Brooks was killed by the CP9's regular night kill.
Basil disguised away or was cleaned by the Janitor.

If Caribou wasn't witched for real/is trying to pull a mislynch, How do you think the CP9 could have figured out who the Disguiser/Janitor was? How would both CP9 and Pirates coordinate?

Let's NOT exclude the fact that Caribou being affected by the Drug Dealer is also possible, which Caribou think is very likely.

[FM Marco the Phoenix]

basil was swapped.

How do you know?

[FM Wet Haired Caribou]

don krieg, still on my scumlist.
specially that caribou seems vented today.

Quite odd;
Caribou is starting to believe that YOU are the vented one today.
You're being irrational; if you take two steps back and look at Caribou's posts, It's really obvious he was vented. Caribou would never post like 10 times, make some bullshit excuse to be off for the rest of the day without even posting a code, which he has done since the very beginning.

[FM Jewelry Bonney]

How do you know?

doctor was supposed to be swapped so pirates/cp9 wouldn't target him, so if/when nami checked him, he checked the swapped person.

[FM Don Krieg]

Quite odd;
Caribou is starting to believe that YOU are the vented one today.
You're being irrational; if you take two steps back and look at Caribou's posts, It's really obvious he was vented. Caribou would never post like 10 times, make some bullshit excuse to be off for the rest of the day without even posting a code, which he has done since the very beginning.

Additionally to that, she just points her finger at me and calls me a Ventriloquist, and I don't even know why, no explanation. She did that last day too.

[FM Marco the Phoenix]

Just take a closer look at the situation:
Brooks was killed by the CP9's regular night kill.
Basil disguised away or was cleaned by the Janitor.

Yay, I can't quote.

https://www.sc2mafia.com/forum/showth...l=1#post289549

Post #722,

As a recap....
Pirates need to target FM Basil Hawkins and we will target one of the following, to make Basil's job harder:
FM Wet Haired Caribou
FM Jewelry Bonney
FM Fire Fist Ace
FM Bartholomew Kuma

[FM Jewelry Bonney]

Quite odd;
Caribou is starting to believe that YOU are the vented one today.
You're being irrational; if you take two steps back and look at Caribou's posts, It's really obvious he was vented. Caribou would never post like 10 times, make some bullshit excuse to be off for the rest of the day without even posting a code, which he has done since the very beginning.

everyday i have to deal with this bullshit of 'oh maybe your the vented target.' can we stop with today?

can coroner determine basil hawkins information?

[FM Jewelry Bonney]

Additionally to that, she just points her finger at me and calls me a Ventriloquist, and I don't even know why, no explanation. She did that last day too.

additionally, you are supporting your vent target. again.
and you jumped on that wagon yesterday.

[FM Jewelry Bonney]

caribou, its just a theory. i'll prove it when i get home today, currently in class, and i didn't expect to survive last night. so lucky i wasn't burned

and thats why i was hoping cp9 would kill me nami, to get a double kill off me.

[FM Wet Haired Caribou]

Yay, I can't quote.

https://www.sc2mafia.com/forum/showth...l=1#post289549

Post #722,

Indeed, but let's not forget that it was Brooks that was killed, which wasn't on this list.
As stated above, the RP points towards a disguiser. We should wait for the host's confirmation about this.

[FM Wet Haired Caribou]

caribou, its just a theory. i'll prove it when i get home today, currently in class, and i didn't expect to survive last night. so lucky i wasn't burned

and thats why i was hoping cp9 would kill me nami, to get a double kill off me.

... Have you even paid attention? The Arsonist was lynched; why would you have burned last night?
Do you even pay attention to the game at all?

[FM Jewelry Bonney]

not what i meant. of course i'm paying attention to the game.
i was the last one doused, and was hoping i'd get hit because i didnt think we'd lynch the arson.
so lucky. i should not be alive today. =DD

[FM Don Krieg]

additionally, you are supporting your vent target. again.
and you jumped on that wagon yesterday.

You mean the one on the Arsonist? That was what everyone wanted, no?

[FM Marco the Phoenix]

Quotes from Crocodile.

https://www.sc2mafia.com/forum/member...4-FM-Crocodile

Pirates need to target FM Basil Hawkins and we will target one of the following, to make Basil's job harder:
FM Wet Haired Caribou
FM Jewelry Bonney
FM Fire Fist Ace
FM Bartholomew Kuma

Soul King Brook's role was Citizen.

Soul King Brook are not mentioned, yet the kill on Basil did actually occur.

Anyway, to the Marines we need to make a play also. I want you guys to feed useless information to the town. Not like that needed any saying... and besides, with that said you might as well tell them truthful information.

This message feels like a compromise that there's an actual spy.

Buggy the Clown :

#148

I am the Smoker
*stares at you intently*

Buggy must be the spy, because Smoker is something very... Information sensitive regarding the night chat.




Crocodile :

But we are going to control the Captain to kill FM X Drake. If that player is the other pirate, let him disguise, otherwise alert us somehow that we need to change targets.

Deduction : CP9

FM Crocodile
FM Buggy the Clown
FM X Drake (otherwise, pirate)

[FM Jewelry Bonney]

You mean the one on the Arsonist? That was what everyone wanted, no?

nope, cp9 wanted a mislynch on a townie. town just go SOOOO lucky.
And croc was on that lynch too.

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

basil was swapped. i need to go and finish all the rest of the days notes. i didnt think i'd survive the night.
and i need someone to confirm something that happened to me last night.

what night was he swaped i need to see who i accaly checked then

[FM Jewelry Bonney]

what night was he swaped i need to see who i accaly checked then

can you repost who you checked every night? including last night?

[FM Don Krieg]

nope, cp9 wanted a mislynch on a townie. town just go SOOOO lucky.
And croc was on that lynch too.

That doesn't mean anything since the majority of the players was on that lynch.

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

can you repost who you checked every night? including last night?

give me 5 mins to find them all. but to quicken things all appeared ns

[FM Jewelry Bonney]

That doesn't mean anything since the majority of the players was on that lynch.

no it does, cuz confirmed townies like tony and black leg werent on that lynch. so cp9 was definitely in on that.

[FM Jimbei]

-vote FM Blackbeard

[FM Marco the Phoenix]

I'm guessing my post is being ignored.

[FM Don Krieg]

List of players who were on the Arsonist lynch:

FM Crocodile
FM Bartholomew Kuma
FM Don Krieg
FM Black Leg Sanji
FM Jimbei
FM Fire Fist Ace
FM Dracule Mihawk
FM Straw Hat Luffy
FM Jewelry Bonney
FM Donquixote Doflamingo
FM Cat Thief Nami
FM Blackbeard

And you are telling me that my vote on that train makes me look like a Ventriloquist?

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

Quotes from Crocodile.

https://www.sc2mafia.com/forum/member...4-FM-Crocodile




Soul King Brook are not mentioned, yet the kill on Basil did actually occur.



This message feels like a compromise that there's an actual spy.

Buggy the Clown :

#148


Buggy must be the spy, because Smoker is something very... Information sensitive regarding the night chat.




Crocodile :



Deduction : CP9

FM Crocodile
FM Buggy the Clown
FM X Drake (otherwise, pirate)

GO READ THE POST PPL