Day 3: End of the Brig

[FM Jewelry Bonney]

Oh, because totally changing his writing style and shit wasn't enough gotcha :P

it wasn't a 'gotcha.' it was
"OH SHIT, i have an interview, if i don't respond, bonney's going to call me out, and i'll get lynched."

[FM Roronoa Zoro]

Oh, because totally changing his writing style and shit wasn't enough gotcha :P

Just realized why do I have to spell this out, after all its "Elementary" my dear Watson.

[FM Jewelry Bonney]

i never wrote that...?

[FM Roronoa Zoro]

it wasn't a 'gotcha.' it was
"OH SHIT, i have an interview, if i don't respond, bonney's going to call me out, and i'll get lynched."

And yet he had enough time to think put his own name in?

[FM Roronoa Zoro]

Ciao I'll be back later.

[FM Jewelry Bonney]

And yet he had enough time to think put his own name in?

yes?

[FM Straw Hat Luffy]

Hey guys... Sorry I've been rather busy today but now I have like a whole hour and maybe more!
About Basil...I don't think he's the Doctor. Claiming an important role like that is not smart. I'm sure he did this to "protect" the real Doctor
who is still anonymous (hopefully).

Also, Urouge needs to show up quickly... I want to hear (read) what he have to say. (Even though I doubt it will be enough to save him.)

[FM Basil Hawkins]

To answer Big Mom’s questions from yesterday:

Based on Cyborg Franky's train, who do you think is mafia?

Analysis of my train:
(Big Mom, Fire Fist Ace, Cat Thief Nami, Soul King Brook, Straw Hat Luffy, Whitebeard, Tony Tony Chopper, Black Leg Sanji, Urouge, Jewelry Bonney, Capone Bege, Boa Hancock, Foxy the Silver Fox)

Cyborg Franky Train: (Boa Hancock, Urouge, Wet Haired Caribou, Big Mom, Soul King Brook, Don Krieg, Straw Hat Luffy, Buggy the Clown, Tony Tony Chopper, Fire Fist Ace, Jewelry Bonney, Capone Bege)

I think that the people who voted me but not Cyborg Franky are the most likely to be pirates. (Since I am not a mafia)

I am also suspicious of Big Mom for pushing a train on me with really poor evidence. I never tried to derail the train on Cyborg Franky. I just asked Big Mom why he would say that pressuring lurkers isn’t effective and then vote a lurker.

What do you think about the Bonney situation and her refusal to claim her interview target?

N/A because Bonney claimed it. Since he confirmed, I think Bonney isn’t ventriloquisted and she is actually a journalist.

What are your reads on Roronoa Zoro and Urouge?

Spoiler : ”Roronoa Zoro” :

#305

Meh I don't care when he gets hammered just let it be done.

This sounds like a faction member who doesn’t care who gets lynched as long as its not someone from his night chat. I don’t think this sounds particularly towny.

#376

You guess need to get back on the right person. Law needs to be lynched. Straw is TOWN wouldn't be at all surprised if he was DOCTOR

Roronoa Zoro wants to lynch Law who is either a rebel or a jester. Either of those would be bad for town to lynch at the moment.

#378

I repeat Bonnie is not the Journalist

Continues to discredit Jewelry Bonney

#612

I did not, my post count is my code, and your analysis is my solution.

Isn’t very worried about disguisers/ventriloquists possibly because he is on one of their factions and doesn’t need to worry about them?

#641

Citizen wouldn't? I sure as heck would if I were citizen, but no, I honestly believe she is Bus Driver and bussed herself last night.

Spreads false information about the role cards.

#669

Suggested he left hints, and I could see some of his posts as hinting doctor or bodyguard

Calls Straw Hat Luffy out as a potential doctor or bodyguard. (Not townie to call out someone you read as protective)

Conclusion: I’m not sure what Roronoa Zoro is, but it doesn’t seem like it’s town due to #305 and calling out a protective role read. Could be a faction member or a jester due to obvious scumminess.

Spoiler : ”Urouge:” :

#521

-vote FM Cyborg Franky

Not likely to be a pirate since Cyborg Franky flipped mafia.

#276

I dislike the sudden notion of changing up the pressure on somebody, when the person in question hasn't even tried to defend himself yet. I must admit that we are wasting time by switching pressure targets like this.

First i'd like to hear from Law. The Straw Hat crew is next on the list.
I repeat, i do not wish to aimlessly hop on one wagon from the other. When we have someone pressured at blade's edge, we should at least get something out of it, that's what "pressure" is for after all.

This is a really pro town post.

#319

So, since Law hasn't shown a life sign as of late here is my take on his situation:

Probably vented/jester/ghost.

I concur with the suspicions on Zoro.

-vote FM Roronoa Zoro

Jumps to Roronoa Zoro’s train after posting about not wanting to jump around on different trains. (Not as pro-town)

#422

Umm, i dno why people insist on Bonney being ventrilo'd. She's pretty much acting and typing the same way she did the day before. Unless we have a really excellent ventriloquist, he shouldn't be able to nail Bonney that well. Where did all the insistent scrubs go that post analysis is half the game? Mannerisms and inherent logic are hard to counterfeit, as well as a rough grasp of ones vocabulary.

Defends Bonney against being ventriloquisted. Pro-town.

#558

we are running out of time i apparently have to sheep to get something done.

I'll be changing my vote on the most voted person now.
Also, note that
Zoro voted for Law
whilst
Luffy voted for Basil

Keep this in mind.
That said
-vote FM Basil Hawkins

I don't understand the purpose of his note here.

#791

I had literally 5 minutes to write the interview. As i had never had a chance to write an interview in an FM before i had no idea what to write about, other than my thoughts on the game. Which i had elaborated on immensely on the day before.
I can claim if that makes everybody happier.
Now that i'm writing this, why don't we all just mass claim. Apparently people are scummy for going to sleep or having nothing to do at night so they don't check the site every 5 minutes.

I have 3 things i'd like to make clear about the current state of the game:

Stop spamming. Useless oneliners and most meh posts just pollute the game and motivate people to pay less attention to read trash. (Yes i'm looking at you Big Mom)
I'll ignore anybody who is irrelevant or blatantly dumb. Or possibly ventriloquisted and just seems dumb because of that.
The amount of lurking sheep is too damn high in this game. I have votes on me from Buggy and Blackbeard, 2 people i don't remember having posted anything worth of value.

Note: In case people missed my Day 1.5 and one of my previous Day 2 posts: I will post a rather in-depth analysis on how factions should be acting, starting from Day 1 to the current state of the game. The reason why i'm not posting it yet is because we don't have many posts that we could analyze for this. We need
a) more participation from people in Day chat
b) more night actions / deaths to be able to discern certain changes in behavior patterns certain factions will show after they assess the graveness of having their respective faction weakened, either by losing possibly allies or their own teammembers.

Me writing this post may already distort the future actions of the scum in question, so props to that. I'd have liked to leave my point of view on everything to a somewhat more advanced state of the game.

Seems pro-town. Can’t wait to read this post later today.

Conclusion: Seems like a really skilled player so I can’t get a good read on him. Probably not a pirate is the best I can do.

[FM Jewelry Bonney]

To answer Big Mom’s questions from yesterday:


Analysis of my train:
(Big Mom, Fire Fist Ace, Cat Thief Nami, Soul King Brook, Straw Hat Luffy, Whitebeard, Tony Tony Chopper, Black Leg Sanji, Urouge, Jewelry Bonney, Capone Bege, Boa Hancock, Foxy the Silver Fox)

Cyborg Franky Train: (Boa Hancock, Urouge, Wet Haired Caribou, Big Mom, Soul King Brook, Don Krieg, Straw Hat Luffy, Buggy the Clown, Tony Tony Chopper, Fire Fist Ace, Jewelry Bonney, Capone Bege)

I think that the people who voted me but not Cyborg Franky are the most likely to be pirates. (Since I am not a mafia)

I am also suspicious of Big Mom for pushing a train on me with really poor evidence. I never tried to derail the train on Cyborg Franky. I just asked Big Mom why he would say that pressuring lurkers isn’t effective and then vote a lurker.


N/A because Bonney claimed it. Since he confirmed, I think Bonney isn’t ventriloquisted and she is actually a journalist.

Spoiler : ”Roronoa Zoro” :

#305


This sounds like a faction member who doesn’t care who gets lynched as long as its not someone from his night chat. I don’t think this sounds particularly towny.

#376


Roronoa Zoro wants to lynch Law who is either a rebel or a jester. Either of those would be bad for town to lynch at the moment.

#378


Continues to discredit Jewelry Bonney

#612


Isn’t very worried about disguisers/ventriloquists possibly because he is on one of their factions and doesn’t need to worry about them?

#641


Spreads false information about the role cards.

#669


Calls Straw Hat Luffy out as a potential doctor or bodyguard. (Not townie to call out someone you read as protective)

Conclusion: I’m not sure what Roronoa Zoro is, but it doesn’t seem like it’s town due to #305 and calling out a protective role read. Could be a faction member or a jester due to obvious scumminess.

Spoiler : ”Urouge:” :

#521


Not likely to be a pirate since Cyborg Franky flipped mafia.

#276


This is a really pro town post.

#319


Jumps to Roronoa Zoro’s train after posting about not wanting to jump around on different trains. (Not as pro-town)

#422


Defends Bonney against being ventriloquisted. Pro-town.

#558


I don't understand the purpose of his note here.

#791


Seems pro-town. Can’t wait to read this post later today.

Conclusion: Seems like a really skilled player so I can’t get a good read on him. Probably not a pirate is the best I can do.

tldr, you don't think Urouge will flip scum?

[FM Basil Hawkins]

Buggy is a actually a neutral candidate as well.

@Basil

Have you been charged?
Now that you have claimed and have no reason to hide, will you be taking a more active role in discussion and trying to lead town?
Who did you heal last night and why?
Why don't you think you were killed last night?

Can you explain your neutral read on Buggy? I haven't had a chance to read him thoroughly yet.

No, I have not been charged.

I hope to take a more active role in the discussion but my schedule and time zone prevents me from coming on and posting a lot at the beginning of the day. Refer to the post right before this one for some of my personal FoS targets.

Last night I healed Jewelry Bonney because I believe her role claim and the more confirmed town we have to lead us the better.

I don't know why I wasn't killed last night. If the CP9 has a witch maybe they think they can control me and prevent me from getting off successful heals so I'm not a threat. (I was not witched last night though).

[FM Capone Bege]

gah so lame how Saturday and Sunday were nights and day starts Monday

-vote FM Urouge

Screw you Sogeking.

Sogeking aside, Tony's post interested me. What do you guys think of Buggy?
I don't think Buggy is Marine anymore despite his soft claim, I think he is...something sinister
He claimed Vigilante in invisible ink in post 284697, yet Eustass Kidd, a Rebel claimer, is left intact. A Marine Vigilante would have known Trafalgar was jailed and then shot Eustass.

The plot certainly thickens!
I have three buggy balls. I'm loading one tonight

Were you roleblocked or something? I didn't hear no buggy ball last night

[FM Basil Hawkins]

tldr, you don't think Urouge will flip scum?

I'm mostly used to sheeping PR results so it's hard for me to know in a game like this where all the evidence seems circumstantial. Honestly I have absolutely no clue about Urouge other than he probably wont' flip pirate. That is literally the only thing I was able to determine about him.

[FM Jewelry Bonney]

Last night I healed Jewelry Bonney because I believe her role claim and the more confirmed town we have to lead us the better.

thanks bud, i'll try not to let you down :')

[FM Basil Hawkins]

As a follow up to my train's analysis from yesterday, I would really like to know if Eustass Kidd can confirm Whitebeard as a Rebel. If he is not confirmed then he is likely to be a pirate. I hope the rebels won't lie to protect the pirates just because they are potential allies.

Also they said that Black Leg Sanji could not be recruited meaning he is a PR? Based on my analysis he is likely to be a pirate looking for a mislynch on a townie.

[FM Sogeking]

A Marine Vigilante would have known Trafalgar was jailed and then shot Eustass.

Were you roleblocked or something? I didn't hear no buggy ball last night

I'm not sure what you mean buy this. How would a marine know if someone is jailed? Do they have Night Chat?

[FM Big Mom]

To answer Big Mom’s questions from yesterday:


Analysis of my train:
(Big Mom, Fire Fist Ace, Cat Thief Nami, Soul King Brook, Straw Hat Luffy, Whitebeard, Tony Tony Chopper, Black Leg Sanji, Urouge, Jewelry Bonney, Capone Bege, Boa Hancock, Foxy the Silver Fox)

Cyborg Franky Train: (Boa Hancock, Urouge, Wet Haired Caribou, Big Mom, Soul King Brook, Don Krieg, Straw Hat Luffy, Buggy the Clown, Tony Tony Chopper, Fire Fist Ace, Jewelry Bonney, Capone Bege)

I think that the people who voted me but not Cyborg Franky are the most likely to be pirates. (Since I am not a mafia)

I am also suspicious of Big Mom for pushing a train on me with really poor evidence. I never tried to derail the train on Cyborg Franky. I just asked Big Mom why he would say that pressuring lurkers isn’t effective and then vote a lurker.


N/A because Bonney claimed it. Since he confirmed, I think Bonney isn’t ventriloquisted and she is actually a journalist.

Spoiler : ”Roronoa Zoro” :

#305


This sounds like a faction member who doesn’t care who gets lynched as long as its not someone from his night chat. I don’t think this sounds particularly towny.

#376


Roronoa Zoro wants to lynch Law who is either a rebel or a jester. Either of those would be bad for town to lynch at the moment.

#378


Continues to discredit Jewelry Bonney

#612


Isn’t very worried about disguisers/ventriloquists possibly because he is on one of their factions and doesn’t need to worry about them?

#641


Spreads false information about the role cards.

#669


Calls Straw Hat Luffy out as a potential doctor or bodyguard. (Not townie to call out someone you read as protective)

Conclusion: I’m not sure what Roronoa Zoro is, but it doesn’t seem like it’s town due to #305 and calling out a protective role read. Could be a faction member or a jester due to obvious scumminess.

Spoiler : ”Urouge:” :

#521


Not likely to be a pirate since Cyborg Franky flipped mafia.

#276


This is a really pro town post.

#319


Jumps to Roronoa Zoro’s train after posting about not wanting to jump around on different trains. (Not as pro-town)

#422


Defends Bonney against being ventriloquisted. Pro-town.

#558


I don't understand the purpose of his note here.

#791


Seems pro-town. Can’t wait to read this post later today.

Conclusion: Seems like a really skilled player so I can’t get a good read on him. Probably not a pirate is the best I can do.

I find your response satisfactory. I wish you would take a stand on Urouge though.

[FM Big Mom]

I'm not sure what you mean buy this. How would a marine know if someone is jailed? Do they have Night Chat?

Pay attention.
Jailor and vigilante are both marine roles that share a night chat.

[FM Capone Bege]

I'm not sure what you mean buy this. How would a marine know if someone is jailed? Do they have Night Chat?

Jailors are Marines, all Marines share a night chat. It would be silly if Foxy didn't tell the Marines who was jailed.

[FM Big Mom]

I'm not sure what you mean buy this. How would a marine know if someone is jailed? Do they have Night Chat?

{This guy is a bloody awful player if he is town}

[FM Big Mom]

Jailors are Marines, all Marines share a night chat. It would be silly if Foxy didn't tell the Marines who was jailed.

What do you think about Caribou being possible witch?

[FM Straw Hat Luffy]

Last night I healed Jewelry Bonney because I believe her role claim and the more confirmed town we have to lead us the better.

thanks bud, i'll try not to let you down :')

@Bonney: Did you get any notification of being healed? (Does people who get healed get notification of that even if they were not targeted?)

[FM Big Mom]

{Placeholder}

[FM Sogeking]

"All faction members (except for Town) have shared night chat. " I didn't see this. I feel stupid now

[FM Capone Bege]

What do you think about Caribou being possible witch?

Possible but I think Mihawk is Witch.

That would count, yes. But it would appear the witch had other plans.

I also confess myself very surprised by Trafalgar's citizen flip. It seems I was wrong about him. With that in mind, I think we were onto something with Urouge yesterday, and Zoro's post about him has further convinced me of his guiltiness.

-vote FM Urouge

In Day 2, he wrote a pretty solid post about why Trafalgar was not Rebel Leader, and when he got to the part about Citizen, he just wrote "I doubt he's Citizen" as rationale. Seems like he just wanted the mislynch. Though if Urouge flips CP9, I'll probably feel safer around Mihawk.

I'm the witch. Interesting. That's news to me, but hey maybe you know more than I do.

He's already explained this but I felt it applied to my argument.

[FM Roronoa Zoro]

Can you explain your neutral read on Buggy? I haven't had a chance to read him thoroughly yet.

No, I have not been charged.

I hope to take a more active role in the discussion but my schedule and time zone prevents me from coming on and posting a lot at the beginning of the day. Refer to the post right before this one for some of my personal FoS targets.

Last night I healed Jewelry Bonney because I believe her role claim and the more confirmed town we have to lead us the better.

I don't know why I wasn't killed last night. If the CP9 has a witch maybe they think they can control me and prevent me from getting off successful heals so I'm not a threat. (I was not witched last night though).

One side didn't kill you because you are healing them maybe. The other I don't fucking know.

[FM Capone Bege]

One side didn't kill you because you are healing them maybe. The other I don't fucking know.

Hmmm, as Mihawk said, maybe the Witch found the Pirate Captain n1 since Mihawk and Jimbei were bussed apparently. If Bonney was ChildPorn9, it would make sense that the Witch witch'd the Pirate Captain onto a random ass random target, while letting Hawkin heal her.

[FM Roronoa Zoro]

I'm not sure what you mean buy this. How would a marine know if someone is jailed? Do they have Night Chat?

WTF RED FLAG

[FM Capone Bege]

"All faction members (except for Town) have shared night chat. " I didn't see this. I feel stupid now

I'm not sure if this is your way of saying "I'm Town!" or ...

[FM Big Mom]

Hmmm, as Mihawk said, maybe the Witch found the Pirate Captain n1 since Mihawk and Jimbei were bussed apparently. If Bonney was ChildPorn9, it would make sense that the Witch witch'd the Pirate Captain onto a random ass random target, while letting Hawkin heal her.

Who do you think witch would control on N1?

[FM Big Mom]

WTF RED FLAG

Are you implying you think he is a pirate?

[FM Capone Bege]

Who do you think witch would control on N1?

Thinly veiled "Who do you think Pirate Captain is"?

Hmm....Fire Fist Ace. ATM, he is not confirmed Rebel by Kidd/WB. He wifom'd Rebel Leader/Scout day1. It's logical if Witch controls him onto someone very scummy (Cyborg Franky) to fail his recruit/scout.

[FM Big Mom]

Thinly veiled "Who do you think Pirate Captain is"?

Hmm....Fire Fist Ace. ATM, he is not confirmed Rebel by Kidd/WB. He wifom'd Rebel Leader/Scout day1. It's logical if Witch controls him onto someone very scummy (Cyborg Franky) to fail his recruit/scout.

Interesting. I like the way your mind works.

[FM Dracule Mihawk]

Back guys. I've been unexpectedly busy today. Still am, actually. Anyway, thought I'd check in.

Hmmm, as Mihawk said, maybe the Witch found the Pirate Captain n1 since Mihawk and Jimbei were bussed apparently. If Bonney was ChildPorn9, it would make sense that the Witch witch'd the Pirate Captain onto a random ass random target, while letting Hawkin heal her.

Are you saying you think Bonney is CP9?

[FM Roronoa Zoro]

Back guys. I've been unexpectedly busy today. Still am, actually. Anyway, thought I'd check in.



Are you saying you think Bonney is CP9?

That's what I'm fucking saying, Urouge and bonney both.

[FM Capone Bege]

Are you saying you think Bonney is CP9?

It was a hypothetical statement.

Neither CP9 or Pirates hit the Doctor claim, which is surprising. The day before, the doctor thought Bonney was a confirmed town . I'm saying, if she was CP9, she might have told the Witch to make sure Doctor wasn't hit so she could continue to be healed.

Yesterday, I suspected her of being CP9 more than Pirate because of the vent ordeal where she wouldn't reveal the interviewee. Today, I guess she can be pirate, but I don't think she is Pirate because of the lynch on Cyborg Franky and if she was Pirate, CP9 wouldn't know that, so they'd probably think she is Journalist and let the doctor die.

Right now, I think she's more CP9 than Town because she said she could write an article alongside the interviewee but has failed to do so.

What do you think of Bonney?

[FM Big Mom]

Bonney, why didn't you write an article for the paper, or are you not really the journalist since you couldn't solve your vent code.

[FM Big Mom]

That's what I'm fucking saying, Urouge and bonney both.

[FM Eustass Kidd]

Is everyone missing the fact about Sanji being rather scum?
And also: why are there 22 voptes to lynch but it was 17 yesterday o_O
I guess Urouge isn't hammered yet!

[FM Dracule Mihawk]

That's what I'm fucking saying, Urouge and bonney both.

Yes, I read your long post about it. The problem I have with it is I see no reason for the real journalist not to counter claim. The counter claim would get bonney lynched (-1 scum. yay!) and give us a confirmed town (yay!) that could be healed/busses to stay alive. Plus, the interviewee would've claimed. I think Urouge put himself in the article to hide the fact that he wrote it. Though I still agree that he is scummy, I think the Bonney FoS is a bit lacking.

It was a hypothetical statement.

Neither CP9 or Pirates hit the Doctor claim, which is surprising. The day before, the doctor thought Bonney was a confirmed town . I'm saying, if she was CP9, she might have told the Witch to make sure Doctor wasn't hit so she could continue to be healed.

Yesterday, I suspected her of being CP9 more than Pirate because of the vent ordeal where she wouldn't reveal the interviewee. Today, I guess she can be pirate, but I don't think she is Pirate because of the lynch on Cyborg Franky and if she was Pirate, CP9 wouldn't know that, so they'd probably think she is Journalist and let the doctor die.

Right now, I think she's more CP9 than Town because she said she could write an article alongside the interviewee but has failed to do so.

What do you think of Bonney?

I believe Bonney's claim for the following reasons:
1. Claiming journalist day 1 is only going to be done by a journalist in this setup. Journalist isn't certain to be in the game, so claiming it day 1 without knowing it exists is stupid, because it's one of a few roles that confirm its existence in the game, so if no article appears and you claimed journalist, you're fucked.

2. No counter claim. If someone else came out and said "I am the one true journalist" we would lynch one of the journalist claimers, and if we ended up lynching the wrong one, we'd lynch the other one next time. But no one has done that. Furthermore, if Urouge didn't write the article, who did? The real article writer could've counter claimed Urouge, which would have probably gotten him lynched yesterday, with Bonney slated for a lynch today.

The interviewee could be dead, but how would CP9 Bonney and Urouge know that they had killed the interviewee? The interviewee is chosen during the day (like jailing), so witch/bussing has no effect on it. They would've had to guess. And maybe if their WIFOM is really good, they could narrow it down, but it would still be a gamble.

I'll admit that she's said some weird things (like the interview alongside the article nonsense) but I attribute that more to her misunderstanding of mechanics than anything else. So until someone else claims journalist, or can prove that she doesn't know who wrote the article, I'll believe her.

I'm also beginning to think all this pressure on her is just a ploy to get her to reveal who wrote her articles. Perhaps a Pirate/CP9 method of choosing who to target for attack.

[FM Jewelry Bonney]

Bonney, why didn't you write an article for the paper, or are you not really the journalist since you couldn't solve your vent code.

i solved my code.


and apparently zoro checked with the FM. i didn't know i couldn't do my own article. but in my defense the FM gave me a vague answer.

[FM Big Mom]

Is everyone missing the fact about Sanji being rather scum?
And also: why are there 22 voptes to lynch but it was 17 yesterday o_O
I guess Urouge isn't hammered yet!

It changes to 15 after 24 hours passes.

[FM Big Mom]

i solved my code.


and apparently zoro checked with the FM. i didn't know i couldn't do my own article. but in my defense the FM gave me a vague answer.

Your first code solution was WRONG.

[FM Big Mom]

Yes, I read your long post about it. The problem I have with it is I see no reason for the real journalist not to counter claim. The counter claim would get bonney lynched (-1 scum. yay!) and give us a confirmed town (yay!) that could be healed/busses to stay alive. Plus, the interviewee would've claimed. I think Urouge put himself in the article to hide the fact that he wrote it. Though I still agree that he is scummy, I think the Bonney FoS is a bit lacking.



I believe Bonney's claim for the following reasons:
1. Claiming journalist day 1 is only going to be done by a journalist in this setup. Journalist isn't certain to be in the game, so claiming it day 1 without knowing it exists is stupid, because it's one of a few roles that confirm its existence in the game, so if no article appears and you claimed journalist, you're fucked.

2. No counter claim. If someone else came out and said "I am the one true journalist" we would lynch one of the journalist claimers, and if we ended up lynching the wrong one, we'd lynch the other one next time. But no one has done that. Furthermore, if Urouge didn't write the article, who did? The real article writer could've counter claimed Urouge, which would have probably gotten him lynched yesterday, with Bonney slated for a lynch today.

The interviewee could be dead, but how would CP9 Bonney and Urouge know that they had killed the interviewee? The interviewee is chosen during the day (like jailing), so witch/bussing has no effect on it. They would've had to guess. And maybe if their WIFOM is really good, they could narrow it down, but it would still be a gamble.

I'll admit that she's said some weird things (like the interview alongside the article nonsense) but I attribute that more to her misunderstanding of mechanics than anything else. So until someone else claims journalist, or can prove that she doesn't know who wrote the article, I'll believe her.

I'm also beginning to think all this pressure on her is just a ploy to get her to reveal who wrote her articles. Perhaps a Pirate/CP9 method of choosing who to target for attack.

I think it is still possible that Bonney is vetrio'd for the past two days.

[FM Dracule Mihawk]

Is everyone missing the fact about Sanji being rather scum?
And also: why are there 22 voptes to lynch but it was 17 yesterday o_O
I guess Urouge isn't hammered yet!

I didn't miss it, I just don't believe you. I'm not buying any of this rebel claiming nonsense. It's an easy role to claim to get town off your back without risking a counter claim because the real rebels want to stay hidden. As such, I don't believe a word you say, including your "code" garbage. Either prove Sanji is scum using text, or stop wasting everyone's time.

[FM Jewelry Bonney]

Yes, I read your long post about it. The problem I have with it is I see no reason for the real journalist not to counter claim. The counter claim would get bonney lynched (-1 scum. yay!) and give us a confirmed town (yay!) that could be healed/busses to stay alive. Plus, the interviewee would've claimed. I think Urouge put himself in the article to hide the fact that he wrote it. Though I still agree that he is scummy, I think the Bonney FoS is a bit lacking.



I believe Bonney's claim for the following reasons:
1. Claiming journalist day 1 is only going to be done by a journalist in this setup. Journalist isn't certain to be in the game, so claiming it day 1 without knowing it exists is stupid, because it's one of a few roles that confirm its existence in the game, so if no article appears and you claimed journalist, you're fucked.

2. No counter claim. If someone else came out and said "I am the one true journalist" we would lynch one of the journalist claimers, and if we ended up lynching the wrong one, we'd lynch the other one next time. But no one has done that. Furthermore, if Urouge didn't write the article, who did? The real article writer could've counter claimed Urouge, which would have probably gotten him lynched yesterday, with Bonney slated for a lynch today.

The interviewee could be dead, but how would CP9 Bonney and Urouge know that they had killed the interviewee? The interviewee is chosen during the day (like jailing), so witch/bussing has no effect on it. They would've had to guess. And maybe if their WIFOM is really good, they could narrow it down, but it would still be a gamble.

I'll admit that she's said some weird things (like the interview alongside the article nonsense) but I attribute that more to her misunderstanding of mechanics than anything else. So until someone else claims journalist, or can prove that she doesn't know who wrote the article, I'll believe her.

I'm also beginning to think all this pressure on her is just a ploy to get her to reveal who wrote her articles. Perhaps a Pirate/CP9 method of choosing who to target for attack.

that's right. i won't be pressured again to reveal my target. i will NEVER reveal my interview target to prove myself again. code should just take care of that.

[FM Dracule Mihawk]

Your first code solution was WRONG.

I seem to have missed this. Mind quoting/linking me to the post where she solved it incorrectly?

[FM Eustass Kidd]

I didn't miss it, I just don't believe you. I'm not buying any of this rebel claiming nonsense. It's an easy role to claim to get town off your back without risking a counter claim because the real rebels want to stay hidden. As such, I don't believe a word you say, including your "code" garbage. Either prove Sanji is scum using text, or stop wasting everyone's time.

Rebel Scout can check whether his target is or is not Citizen. He checked Black Leg Sanji last night and gave me a code in his first message today that his target is NOT a Citizen. So he's 21% town and 79% not town.

[FM Big Mom]

that's right. i won't be pressured again to reveal my target. i will NEVER reveal my interview target to prove myself again. code should just take care of that.

[FM Jewelry Bonney]

Your first code solution was WRONG.

one letter? are we back to this shit again? you should really direct your energies somewhere else.

[FM Jewelry Bonney]

I seem to have missed this. Mind quoting/linking me to the post where she solved it incorrectly?

he means that i missed a letter, and it was off by one incremented letter.