D6: No more Shepherds!

[Forum Mafia GM]

In late evening of Fuzzywuzzytown, the great king pin Locutus was pinned to the wall and executed by the masses. The mafia were swift about getting their revenge though. "If we can't hide from detection, then you shall not detect at all!" they shouted into the darkness of night.

In the Royal court yard. King Arthur was practicing his sword skills with a friend. What he didn't know was that his opponent had no intention of backing off once Arthur slipped and dropped his sword. With a cleaving blow to the head, King Arthur who was but a lowly citizen, was no more.

In other news, Yosemite Sam, the Sheriff, was shot in the knee. Not to worry though, since the Doctors are still alive! Yosemite crawled over to the medical clinic (which happened to be in plain view and the mafia aren't bright enough to search for Doctors there... ) but on his way up the steps, a loud crack broke the silence of night. A sniper on the roof tops had shot Yosemite Sam, this time, a fatal wound to the head. There was nothing the doctor could do.

The GM rejoiced at this new turn of events. Finally, the town can't rely on the shepherds to find the scum of the earth. And so it was that the GM fired the Framer and turned him into a Mafioso. Time to see if town can pull it together.

Role list:
1-Citizen: FM Batman - Struck down by Sith Lightning!
2-Citizen: King Arthur - Killed by the SK
3-Citizen
4-Sheriff: Yosemite Sam - Attacked by the Mafia and killed by the Vigilante.
5-Mafioso
6-Citizen: FM Col Jack ONeill - Killed by the Mafia
7-Citizen: FM Hungry - Killed by the Vigilante
8-Citizen: FM Yoda - Killed by the Mafia
9-Doctor
10-GodFather: FM Locutus - Killed by the town
11-Citizen
12-Citizen: FM Lone Ranger - Struck down by Sith Lightning!
13-Citizen: FM Count von Count - Struck down by Sith Lightning!
14-Vigilante
15-Consort: FM Watson - Killed by the town
16-Citizen
17-Citizen
18-Citizen: FM Frankenstein - Killed by a gun man.
19-Escort: FM Master Chef - Killed by the SK
20-Serial Killer
21-Citizen: FM Bridge Keeper - Killed by the Vigilante
22-Citizen
23-Citizen: FM Robin Hood - Struck down by Sith Lightning!
24-Blacksmith
25-Consigliere: FM Dracula - Struck down by Sith Lightning!
26-Citizen: FM Mr T - Struck down by Sith Lightning!
27-Citizen: Jack Sparrow - Killed by the Mafia
28-Citizen
29-Doctor
30-Framer Mafioso
31-Citizen: FM Yehat - Killed by the Mafia
32-Citizen: FM Mr Bunny - Killed by the Mafia
33-Citizen
34-Sheriff: FM Indiana Jones - Killed by the SK
35-Witch
36-Citizen: FM Gandalf - Killed by an angry town mob.
37-Citizen: FM Prince Thrakhath - Struck down by Sith Lightning!
38-Citizen: FM The Terminator - Killed by the SK
39-Jailor: FM Kermit - Struck down by Sith Lightning!
40-Mafioso: Pinkie Pie - Executed by the Jailor
41-Citizen: FM Cookie Monster - Killed by a gun rocket man.
42-Citizen: FM Animal - Killed by a gun man.


Player List:
01- FM Agahnim
02- FM Animal Citizen - Killed by a gun man
03- FM Anubis
04- FM Batman: Citizen - Struck down by Sith Lightning!
05- FM Bridge Keeper: Citizen - Killed by the Vigilante
06- FM Captain Obvious
07- FM Ceasar
08- FM Col Jack ONeill: Citizen - Killed by the Mafia
09- FM Cookie Monster: Citizen - Killed by a gun rocket man.
10- FM Count von Count: Citizen - Struck down by Sith Lightning!
11- FM Dracula: Consigliere - Struck down by Sith Lightning!
12- FM Frankenstein: Citizen - Killed by a gun man.
13- FM Gandalf: Citizen - Killed by an angry town mob.
14- FM Gimli
15- FM Hamburglar
16- FM Hungry: Citizen - Killed by the Vigilante
17- FM Indiana Jones: Sheriff - Killed by the SK
18- FM Inspector Cluseau
19- FM Jack Sparrow: Citizen - Killed by the Mafia
20- FM Kermit: Jailor - Struck down by Sith Lightning!
21- FM King Arthur: Citizen - Killed by the SK
22- FM King Tut
23- FM Locutus: GodFather - Killed by the Town
24- FM Lone Ranger: Citizen - Struck down by Sith Lightning!
25- FM Master Chef: Escort - Killed by the SK
26- FM Michigan J Frog
27- FM Mr Bunny: Citizen - Killed by the Mafia
28- FM Mr T: Citizen - Struck down by Sith Lightning!
29- FM Pinkie Pie: Mafioso - Executed by the Jailor
30- FM Prince Thrakhath: Citizen - Struck down by Sith Lightning!
31- FM Robin Hood: Citizen - Struck down by Sith Lightning!
32- FM Rubber Ducky
33- FM Sherlock
34- FM SpongeBob
35- FM The Joker
36- FM The Terminator: Citizen - Killed by the SK
37- FM Watson: Consort - Killed by the Town
38- FM Wile E Coyote
39- FM Wolverine
40- FM Yehat: Citizen - Killed by the Mafia
41- FM Yoda: Citizen - Killed by the Mafia
42- FM Yosemite Sam: Sheriff - Attacked by the Mafia and killed by the Vigilante.


Players alive: 15 (11 town vs 4 scum)
8 votes to hammer.

Day will end Wednesday Jan 9th 8pm GMT-5

[FM Captain Obvious]

Anubis, were you the one that healed the sheriff or was it the other doctor?

[FM Anubis]

Anubis, were you the one that healed the sheriff or was it the other doctor?

i honestly didn't think i would survive the night so... i haven't reviewed 'yesterday''s notes, but i plan to as i think they hold the key to what everyone might actually be. so i didn't heal the sheriff, that and because of wifom that he would already have died.

tldr, i didn't heal him. i used my healing on Cesar.

[FM Hamburglar]

We need to hit scum today, business as usual
Vigi no kill? Shame on you
I'm all for Sams investigation result and for the ones that didn't hammer Loc when they had the chance to

[FM Anubis]

We need to hit scum today, business as usual
Vigi no kill? Shame on you
I'm all for Sams investigation result and for the ones that didn't hammer Loc when they had the chance to

for the vigilante, kill, the sheriff was killed by the vigilante. so sad =(
as for the ones that didn't hammer Locutus, they are probably part of the mafia. but WE CANNOT LYNCH ANOTHER MAFIA. (i think, I haven't done the math yet, but i think we can't.)

[FM Captain Obvious]

We need to hit scum today, business as usual
Vigi no kill? Shame on you
I'm all for Sams investigation result and for the ones that didn't hammer Loc when they had the chance to

Vigi killed the sheriff...

[FM Captain Obvious]

We must lynch the serial killer or witch to lower scum KPN. Simple math

[FM SpongeBob]

so the framer turned into a mafiaso? that means there can be 5 KPNs now...
2 mafiasos
sk
vig
blacksmith giving out guns

[FM Anubis]

Does the Mafia have two kills per night now?

[FM Agahnim]

so the framer turned into a mafiaso? that means there can be 5 KPNs now...
2 mafiasos
sk
vig
blacksmith giving out guns

no you retard.

Its 4 KPN possible

Mafia
Sk
Witch/Vigilante
Blacksmith gun.

[Forum Mafia GM]

GM is now refusing to answer all questions that can be answered by reading the rules/game mechanics/role cards.

[FM Anubis]

GM is now refusing to answer all questions that can be answered by reading the rules/game mechanics/role cards.

apologies.

[FM Hamburglar]

11 town 4 scum.
lynch maf if witch ctrls vigi next day worst case 8 town 3 scum
lynch scum worst case next day 6 town 2 scum
lynch town 3 town 2 scum
lynch scum 2 town 1 scum
lynch scum win
even in the worst case scenario

[FM Agahnim]

FM Watson (23 [L--2]):
FM The Terminator, FM Jack Sparrow, FM Robin Hood, FM Agahnim, FM Michigan J Frog, FM Inspector Cluseau, FM Yoda, FM Indiana Jones, FM Ceasar, FM Yosemite Sam, FM King Arthur, FM Master Chef, FM Hamburglar, FM Hungry, FM Wile E Coyote, FM Dracula, FM Kermit, FM Captain Obvious, FM Animal, FM Locutus, FM Col Jack ONeill, FM Anubis, FM Cookie Monster

---

FM Gandalf (20 [L-0]):
FM Cookie Monster, FM Ceasar, FM Inspector Cluseau, FM Captain Obvious, FM Michigan J Frog, FM Col Jack ONeill, FM Indiana Jones, FM Wile E Coyote, FM SpongeBob, FM The Joker, FM Sherlock, FM Anubis, FM Hungry, FM Batman, FM Jack Sparrow, FM Pinkie Pie, FM Yosemite Sam, FM Wolverine, FM Hamburglar, FM Count von Count

---

FM Locutus (10 [L-0]):
FM Captain Obvious, FM Anubis, FM Wolverine, FM Gimli, FM Agahnim, FM Michigan J Frog, FM Yosemite Sam, FM Hamburglar, FM King Arthur, FM Wile E Coyote

---

Alive Players:
01- FM Agahnim
03- FM Anubis
06- FM Captain Obvious
07- FM Ceasar
14- FM Gimli
15- FM Hamburglar
18- FM Inspector Cluseau
22- FM King Tut
26- FM Michigan J Frog
32- FM Rubber Ducky
33- FM Sherlock
34- FM SpongeBob
35- FM The Joker
38- FM Wile E Coyote
39- FM Wolverine

Possible Roles Left:
3-Citizen
5-Mafioso
9-Doctor
11-Citizen
14-Vigilante
16-Citizen
17-Citizen
20-Serial Killer
22-Citizen
24-Blacksmith
28-Citizen
29-Doctor
30-(Framer) Mafioso
33-Citizen
35-Witch

---

01- FM Agahnim - Citizen
03- FM Anubis - Claimed Doctor
06- FM Captain Obvious
07- FM Ceasar - Claimed Blacksmith
14- FM Gimli
15- FM Hamburglar - WIFOM'd Citizen
18- FM Inspector Cluseau - WIFOM'd Citizen
22- FM King Tut
26- FM Michigan J Frog - Citizen?
32- FM Rubber Ducky
33- FM Sherlock - Vigilante
34- FM SpongeBob
35- FM The Joker - Assigned Citizen from Me
38- FM Wile E Coyote
39- FM Wolverine

---

Watson Lynch: FM Agahnim, FM Michigan J Frog, FM Inspector Cluseau, FM Ceasar, FM King Arthur, FM Wile E Coyote, FM Captain Obvious

---

Gandalf Lynch: FM Ceasar, FM Inspector Cluseau, FM Captain Obvious, FM Michigan J Frog, FM Wile E Coyote, FM SpongeBob, FM The Joker, FM Sherlock, FM Anubis, FM Wolverine, FM Hamburglar,

---

FM Locutus: FM Captain Obvious, FM Anubis, FM Wolverine, FM Gimli, FM Agahnim, FM Michigan J Frog, FM Hamburglar, FM King Arthur, FM Wile E Coyote

[FM Agahnim]

01- FM Agahnim - Citizen
03- FM Anubis - Claimed Doctor
07- FM Ceasar - Claimed Blacksmith
15- FM Hamburglar - WIFOM'd Citizen
18- FM Inspector Cluseau - WIFOM'd Citizen
26- FM Michigan J Frog - Citizen?
33- FM Sherlock - Vigilante
35- FM The Joker - Assigned Citizen from Me

---

14- FM Gimli
38- FM Wile E Coyote
39- FM Wolverine
34- FM SpongeBob
32- FM Rubber Ducky
22- FM King Tut
06- FM Captain Obvious

---

King Tut has been a bit too trolly and suspect to be scum imo. I would think him Citizen. If I am correct:

01- FM Agahnim - Citizen
03- FM Anubis - Claimed Doctor
07- FM Ceasar - Claimed Blacksmith
15- FM Hamburglar - WIFOM'd Citizen
18- FM Inspector Cluseau - WIFOM'd Citizen
26- FM Michigan J Frog - Citizen?
33- FM Sherlock - Vigilante
35- FM The Joker - Assigned Citizen from Me
22- FM King Tut - Citizen

------
14- FM Gimli
38- FM Wile E Coyote
39- FM Wolverine
34- FM SpongeBob
32- FM Rubber Ducky
06- FM Captain Obvious

------
3-Citizen - King Tut
5-Mafioso - ???
9-Doctor - Anubis
11-Citizen - Inspector Cluseau
14-Vigilante - Sherlock
16-Citizen - The Joker
17-Citizen - ???
20-Serial Killer
22-Citizen - Hamburgler
24-Blacksmith - Ceaser
28-Citizen - Frog
29-Doctor - ???
30-(Framer) Mafioso - ???
33-Citizen - Agahnim
35-Witch - ???

---

14- FM Gimli
38- FM Wile E Coyote
39- FM Wolverine
34- FM SpongeBob
32- FM Rubber Ducky
06- FM Captain Obvious

-----
Gimli; Spongebob; Captain Obvious; Rubber Ducky
Are the biggest suspects to me. We should discuss about them.

Wile E looks a bit more like a Citizen to me as does Spongebob.

[FM Agahnim]

14- FM Gimli
38- FM Wile E Coyote
39- FM Wolverine
34- FM SpongeBob
32- FM Rubber Ducky
06- FM Captain Obvious
-----
Gimli; Spongebob; Captain Obvious; Rubber Ducky
Are the biggest suspects to me. We should discuss about them.

Wile E looks a bit more like a Citizen to me as does Spongebob.
----

So assuming that Wile E and Spongebob are both town:

3-Citizen - King Tut
5-Mafioso - ???
9-Doctor - Anubis
11-Citizen - Inspector Cluseau
14-Vigilante - Sherlock
16-Citizen - The Joker
17-Citizen - Spongebob/Wile E Coyote
20-Serial Killer - ???
22-Citizen - Hamburgler
24-Blacksmith - Ceaser
28-Citizen - Frog
29-Doctor - Spongebob/Wile E Coyote
30-(Framer) Mafioso - ???
33-Citizen - Agahnim
35-Witch - ???

----
Which would leave:

14- FM Gimli
39- FM Wolverine
32- FM Rubber Ducky
06- FM Captain Obvious


As the Scum suspects.
Any thoughts?

[FM Agahnim]

So of the four:

14- FM Gimli
39- FM Wolverine
32- FM Rubber Ducky
06- FM Captain Obvious

I would assign roles as this:

06- FM Captain - Mafia
39- FM Wolverine - Mafia

14- FM Gimli - Witch/SK
32- FM Rubber Ducky - Serial Killer/Witch

[FM Hamburglar]

oh wait i misunderstood the RP or whatever it's called. Sam dead, so we have to go for hardcore lynches now

[FM Rubber Ducky]

So i'm here, and will be here for 1 more hour. I am a doctor.
I did what a decent doc would do in a setup with 1 million citizens. I blended pretending i was a citizen who hated being a citizen and didn't care about the FM hoping that the mafia/sk would leave me as they think im a citizen.

[FM Hamburglar]

FM Agahnim, FM Michigan J Frog, FM Inspector Cluseau, FM Ceasar, FM King Arthur, FM Wile E Coyote, FM Captain Obvious

FM Captain Obvious, FM Anubis, FM Wolverine, FM Gimli, FM Agahnim, FM Michigan J Frog, FM Hamburglar, FM King Arthur, FM Wile E Coyote

FM Ceasar, FM Inspector Cluseau, FM Captain Obvious, FM Michigan J Frog, FM Wile E Coyote, FM SpongeBob, FM The Joker, FM Sherlock, FM Anubis, FM Wolverine, FM Hamburglar,

People who didnt vote

FM King Tut
FM Rubber Ducky

The 4 in red didn't vote or only voted on the citizen lynch.
Also Spongebob and Ducky both had the chance to place their vote on Locutus, yet failed to do so
Spongebob / Ducky mafia ?
King Tut / Joker Witch+SK ?

Just going by lynch dynamics

[FM Hamburglar]

i left out sherlock cuz he had the only feasible unCCd vigi claim, which makes him 99% town in my eyes. Thoughts on the previous post?

[FM Hamburglar]

Agahnim, the only person we both find scummy according to votes is Rubber Ducky, who supposedly claimed doc.

Do we have any other doc claims? I remember Cluseau claiming it, but i believe he wifom'd and will retract that claim if asked about it.

If we don't have any CC on Ducky's claim i guess that'd make him the second doc.

Also, tell me again why you don't find King Tut and Spongebob scummy?

[FM Rubber Ducky]

Agahnim, the only person we both find scummy according to votes is Rubber Ducky, who supposedly claimed doc.

Do we have any other doc claims? I remember Cluseau claiming it, but i believe he wifom'd and will retract that claim if asked about it.

If we don't have any CC on Ducky's claim i guess that'd make him the second doc.

Also, tell me again why you don't find King Tut and Spongebob scummy?

I didn't vote the GF last day because i wanted time to finish my postings. But someone had hammered, And the other hammers were around when i was away with family

[FM Hamburglar]

"Also
-vote FM Robin Hood


After reviewing the evidence I believe him to be scum as well.

Current Joker's Scum List:

Anubis
Robin Hood
Agahnim

Possible Scum(Pending more review on my part):
Michigan J Frog
King Arthur"

Jokers vote at the end of D5. He doesn't even consider the 4 most scummiest people, which i find rather intriguing. In my eyes that's a scumslip.
that said

-vote FM The Joker

[FM Captain Obvious]

mafia/sk/witch still hopes to catch me at one point and lynch me. don't be that person LOL

The above quote is from Day 5 #82 after I asked why he wasn't dead considering he has claimed doctor for a few days.
I believe he has planned to use this excuse when he claimed doctor. I don't buy this excuse. The Mafia have obviously been hunting for PRs. As a doctor the Mafia would want to kill him instead of wait a couple of days for town to mistakenly lynch him. For this reason I don't buy Anubis' claim of doctor now.
That said people may think this post of mine is just adding to the circular logic around Anubis' doctor claim. Not much I can do about that. Just stating what I'm thinking as a town member.

i honestly didn't think i would survive the night so... i haven't reviewed 'yesterday''s notes, but i plan to as i think they hold the key to what everyone might actually be. so i didn't heal the sheriff, that and because of wifom that he would already have died.

tldr, i didn't heal him. i used my healing on Cesar.

He claims that the other doctor healed Yosemite Sam.
He has always said he deviated heals between the two sheriffs with random.org, why change?
He also claims he Healed Yosemite Sam the night Indiana Jones died. Claims it with too little hesitation in my eyes.
Considering Yosemite Sam had a really high chance of being attacked(three KPN for scum) why didn't he heal Yosemite Sam? Indiana Jones is already dead. Yosemite sam is the obvious best option, with the small amount of players a live sheriff would be invaluable at this moment. I don't buy this explanation.

[FM Hamburglar]

I once said that posting several posts one after another is scummy. Also changing your behavior suddenly is that aswell.
I will now state 2 simple reasons for my actions:
2 extremely difficult exams. One is due in 8 hours, the next one 24 hours after that. I'll be busy studying and won't have time to contribute as actively.
Since we lost the last investigative role we had (doctors, srsly?), i feel the need to atleast start off the discussion and pressure on certain people.

I bid you good night for now. I'll take a few looks at the thread tomorrow, but don't expect me to analyze everything in depth. I'll be more free after jan 9 again

[FM Captain Obvious]

-vote FM Anubis

[FM Hamburglar]

OMGUS is a scumtell aswell. I'm just sayin

[FM Captain Obvious]

i left out sherlock cuz he had the only feasible unCCd vigi claim, which makes him 99% town in my eyes. Thoughts on the previous post?

Sherlock is now 100% confirmed vigilante in my eyes. The fact the vigilante killed the confirmed sheriff means the witch controlled the vig, and who was the obvious vigilante for witch to control last night? Sherlock of-course.

[FM Agahnim]

Sherlock is now 100% confirmed vigilante in my eyes. The fact the vigilante killed the confirmed sheriff means the witch controlled the vig, and who was the obvious vigilante for witch to control last night? Sherlock of-course.

Why is Sherlock all of a sudden confirmed in your eyes?

He should have been confirmed when he claimed it and the Sheriff said he was town by checking him. <-- Which happened yesterday

[FM Captain Obvious]

Why is Sherlock all of a sudden confirmed in your eyes?

He should have been confirmed when he claimed it and the Sheriff said he was town by checking him. <-- Which happened yesterday

What do you mean by all of a sudden? You say that as if I said "Sherlock could still be witch" at the beginning of the day. Yes I know Yosemite Sam said he checked Sherlock. I didn't mention it because the fact vig killed the sheriff was additional proof. I didn't expect to have to state evidence from yesterday again.

[FM Agahnim]

14- FM Gimli
38- FM Wile E Coyote
39- FM Wolverine
34- FM SpongeBob
32- FM Rubber Ducky
06- FM Captain Obvious
-----
Gimli; Spongebob; Captain Obvious; Rubber Ducky
Are the biggest suspects to me. We should discuss about them.

Wile E looks a bit more like a Citizen to me as does Spongebob.
----

So assuming that Wile E and Spongebob are both town:

3-Citizen - King Tut
5-Mafioso - ???
9-Doctor - Anubis
11-Citizen - Inspector Cluseau
14-Vigilante - Sherlock
16-Citizen - The Joker
17-Citizen - Spongebob/Wile E Coyote
20-Serial Killer - ???
22-Citizen - Hamburgler
24-Blacksmith - Ceaser
28-Citizen - Frog
29-Doctor - Rubber Ducky (His posts, after going back and checking, match up with What I'd expect Town to do)
30-(Framer) Mafioso - ???
33-Citizen - Agahnim
35-Witch - ???

----
Which would leave:

14- FM Gimli
39- FM Wolverine
06- FM Captain Obvious
SpongeBob/Wile E Coyote

As the Scum suspects.
Any thoughts?



Personally I find Spongebob (Mafia) to be much more suspect than Wile E (Mafia)

I'd like Gimli + Spongebob + Wile E + Obvious to posts why they would suspect each other

[FM Agahnim]

Ceasar + Frog:

Can the two of you take a look at Obvious' and Wile E's Posts and conclude a read please

[FM Anubis]

i think in case rubber ducky is trying to take a hit, or i'm trying to take a hit,
OTHER DOC(S) PLEASE DON'T CLAIM

treat the other docs as citizens. i think it might be safer, as i dont believe rubber ducky is the other doctor.

[FM Agahnim]

4 other not talking


Anyways:

Captain Obvious
Wile E. Coyote
Gimli
Wolverine



^

My FoS for now

[FM Agahnim]

i think in case rubber ducky is trying to take a hit, or i'm trying to take a hit,
OTHER DOC(S) PLEASE DON'T CLAIM

treat the other docs as citizens. i think it might be safer, as i dont believe rubber ducky is the other doctor.

You go back and forth between im not doc/im doc in this post.
I believe you are town tho

[FM Agahnim]

I'll get the pressure rolling on:

-vote FM Wile E Coyote

[FM Anubis]

The above quote is from Day 5 #82 after I asked why he wasn't dead considering he has claimed doctor for a few days.
I believe he has planned to use this excuse when he claimed doctor. I don't buy this excuse. The Mafia have obviously been hunting for PRs. As a doctor the Mafia would want to kill him instead of wait a couple of days for town to mistakenly lynch him. For this reason I don't buy Anubis' claim of doctor now.
That said people may think this post of mine is just adding to the circular logic around Anubis' doctor claim. Not much I can do about that. Just stating what I'm thinking as a town member.



He claims that the other doctor healed Yosemite Sam.
He has always said he deviated heals between the two sheriffs with random.org, why change?
He also claims he Healed Yosemite Sam the night Indiana Jones died. Claims it with too little hesitation in my eyes.
Considering Yosemite Sam had a really high chance of being attacked(three KPN for scum) why didn't he heal Yosemite Sam? Indiana Jones is already dead. Yosemite sam is the obvious best option, with the small amount of players a live sheriff would be invaluable at this moment. I don't buy this explanation.

someone, which i will be going through day 4, DIRECTED that the sheriff is going to die from vigilante, so i thought it best to heal someone else.

[FM Anubis]

You go back and forth between im not doc/im doc in this post.
I believe you are town tho

you agree that if there are other real doc claims, they shouldn't call. right now at least.

[FM Agahnim]

someone, which i will be going through day 4, DIRECTED that the sheriff is going to die from vigilante, so i thought it best to heal someone else.

Bad choice. You should have known that Sheriff would be double tapped

[FM Agahnim]

I'll get the pressure rolling on:

-vote FM Wile E Coyote

er wat no. I believe he could be mafia

-vote FM Gimli

[FM Anubis]

Bad choice. You should have known that Sheriff would be double tapped

i thought he was going to be triple tapped.

YOU KNOW. IF THE SHERIFF HAD REVEALED WHO HE CHECKED EARLIER, WE WOULD NOT BE HAVING THIS PROBLEM.

[FM Captain Obvious]

i thought he was going to be triple tapped.

YOU KNOW. IF THE SHERIFF HAD REVEALED WHO HE CHECKED EARLIER, WE WOULD NOT BE HAVING THIS PROBLEM.

You can't really blame the sheriff for not logging on before sherlock made the claim.

And to Agahnim, what do you expect me to say? Give me a direct question.

[FM Agahnim]

What do you mean by all of a sudden? You say that as if I said "Sherlock could still be witch" at the beginning of the day. Yes I know Yosemite Sam said he checked Sherlock. I didn't mention it because the fact vig killed the sheriff was additional proof. I didn't expect to have to state evidence from yesterday again.

You said he "is now" confirmed.

"is now"

interesting choice of words. Implies you "had doubts" about it earlier.

[FM Agahnim]

You can't really blame the sheriff for not logging on before sherlock made the claim.

And to Agahnim, what do you expect me to say? Give me a direct question.

Hm

Would you think Spongebob is town over Wile E and why

[FM Agahnim]

Captain Obvious:

Why even bring up Sherlock's townness for a second day? He was 100% confirmed on the previous day and it took a shoot at the sheriff to confirm him in Obvious' eyes. Very Strange.

Said:

I can't really imagine a Mafioso being completely silent, I feel like Robin Hood is a citizen who has lost interest and is busy irl. He could be scum that's busy with irl just the same though.
Same with Gimli. This is nothing short of a random lynch.

and when questioned:

I was intending to say "Mafia", but when I noticed I wrote "Mafioso" I decided to correct it to scum instead. I never meant Mafioso is a word for scum.
As for your theory us three are Mafia, you can think that if you want. However I know that theory is false.

This is just very very strange.

It's so strange I do not know to label him a Citizen or Mafioso.

[FM Captain Obvious]

Hm

Would you think Spongebob is town over Wile E and why

I haven't been paying much attention to Wile E, and that may be saying something about him. Will take me some time to compile thoughts.

Captain Obvious:

Why even bring up Sherlock's townness for a second day? He was 100% confirmed on the previous day and it took a shoot at the sheriff to confirm him in Obvious' eyes.

Because of this:

i left out sherlock cuz he had the only feasible unCCd vigi claim, which makes him 99% town in my eyes. Thoughts on the previous post?

[FM Hamburglar]

i'll change that to 100% once i read up on the framer settings (whether or not he can make teammembers look unsuspicious)
reasons why i think doc claims would be appreciated:
Docs don't rlly do much work anymore, investigative roles are gone and we can only have them on the confirmed town members. We only have 1 if that is correct and that would be Sherlock, with Cesar being the possible other PR.

These are the confirmable PRs. Although the Witch could have CC-d either. The docs on the other hand are nothing more than citizens, they got shot at like they are citizens and are just about as confirmable as citizens. Having doc claims atleast gives us room to speculate which one is a false claim. Not much epic mafia experience there i believe =\.
Might be worth to reconsider every post of Locutus to see if he covered or purposely left out his teammates names.

Okay 5 am, i should rlly go sleep now lulz. Wish me luck D:

[FM Anubis]

i'll change that to 100% once i read up on the framer settings (whether or not he can make teammembers look unsuspicious)
reasons why i think doc claims would be appreciated:
Docs don't rlly do much work anymore, investigative roles are gone and we can only have them on the confirmed town members. We only have 1 if that is correct and that would be Sherlock, with Cesar being the possible other PR.

These are the confirmable PRs. Although the Witch could have CC-d either. The docs on the other hand are nothing more than citizens, they got shot at like they are citizens and are just about as confirmable as citizens. Having doc claims atleast gives us room to speculate which one is a false claim. Not much epic mafia experience there i believe =\.
Might be worth to reconsider every post of Locutus to see if he covered or purposely left out his teammates names.

Okay 5 am, i should rlly go sleep now lulz. Wish me luck D:

i disagree, but i can't say why. docs don't claim.

[FM Agahnim]

Locutus posts made before he was ever fully suspected:

Ok, I kind of agree with this part. Rubber Ducky and Robin Hood and Gimli all had to take time to PM the GameMaster and tell then that they were still playing so they wouldn't get modkilled.
So far, Gimli has posted. But I don't foresee the other two posting, unless maybe we put pressure on them?
If they were citizens who didn't care they should've taken the modkill so we could scumhunt better, instead of having random lurkers that we can't read because they won't post.

Listing these players, when he might have been feeling secure about the mislynch inbound on Robin Hood, could mean that they are not mafia. It does not clear them of being scum but it semi clears them of being mafia. imo of course.