Arsonist in my opinion is the most difficult role to win as. I just played a game as an Arsonist with 4 mafia (3 mafia and amnesiac), a serial killer, and ANOTHER arsonist. I had night invulnerability, and my targets didnt know they were doused. There was only "Random Any" as well as "Random Town". The rest of the roles including Arsonist were already taken.
The first arsonist got lynched randomly first, and the mafia got detected and lynched throught the game. I doused an invest the second night when the first arsonist already died, which got me a good defense since it was unlikely the random any could be another arsonist. Luckily the serial killer killed the invest so it said he had been stabbed, not burned. Eventually, there were 3 people left. The Sk, Me, and a town player who basically gave up and voted for me. Eventually, me and the SK (didnt know he was SK at the time) voted for him and he was lynched. The following night I doused the Serial Killer and he tried attacking me but I survived. The following mourning the game ended and the Serial Killer was awarded with the victory.
My question is why wasn't I awarded with the victory? I had the SK doused and fire kills even with night immunity. Not only that but Arsonist is harder to win even than SK. If i didnt already get a lukcy Arsonist win in the past id be pissed.