Day 5: Trust the Jailor you say?

[FM Wolverine]

If you doubt that I am the vigilante, then explain why Bridge Keeper was shot on Night 3?

God you're thick. How many times must I say the same thing? I acknowledge that you are the vigilante.

And because you're the vigilante, we have to lynch you. Because otherwise you become the best christmas present ever for the witch. The only alternative is to find and lynch the witch today, but unless Yosemite found the witch last night, we've got roughly a 9% chance of guessing correctly, which means about a 90% chance that the witch will use you to kill us all.

[FM Sherlock]

I'll tell you one thing.

In my honest intentions, I wanted to shoot Anubis instead of Hungry. But because Jailor failed to do his job properly, I had no choice but to shoot Hungry.
It's not my fault. Blame Yayap for being a nazi and modkilling our jailor (who killed Pinkie Pie). Even Kermit refused himself to be modkilled.

[FM Michigan J Frog]

If you doubt that I am the vigilante, then explain why Bridge Keeper was shot on Night 3?

Why did you pick to shoot Bridge Keeper. Just wondering.

And what did you mean by:
Day 4, #185

And one more thing:
The black sheep beats down the wolves.

You try to find out what that means.

I guess after re-reading your posts, I guess I could buy that you're vigilante. Either that or you've been purposefully laying hints at it. I guess it's just a bit odd to me that someone of your skill level hasn't hit scum yet.

[FM Agahnim]

Interesting the people who think I am scum.
I guess its just not a game if I don't get suspected to be scum.

[FM Anubis]

Anubis, you idiot, Dracula IS dead. Stop doing pointless things.

I'm not going to vote anyone yet until Yosemite Sam gives out some information.

i'm sorry i'm derping. i meant Aghanim,

just offering this scenario of Sherlock, who realizes he's screwed, tries to get the real vigilante to counterclaim, so witch knows who to really control tonight. seems farfetched but i rest my case on Sherlock, unless town really decides to lynch the true vigi. which would be freakin sad.

and i liked what Michigan said, up to the part where he goes against King Arthur. and since when did you, Michigan, have such a pro town read of Hamburglar?

[FM Sherlock]

We all agreed to kill Hungry. And what? He flipped citizen.

Bridge Keepar voted me after Sam revealed himself, so I tought that he acted like a scum would do. I had a thought that he would turn out to be a citizen.

[FM Anubis]

I'll tell you one thing.

In my honest intentions, I wanted to shoot Anubis instead of Hungry. But because Jailor failed to do his job properly, I had no choice but to shoot Hungry.
It's not my fault. Blame Yayap for being a nazi and modkilling our jailor (who killed Pinkie Pie). Even Kermit refused himself to be modkilled.

so its thanks to the mod that i'm still participating in this FM. thanks mod

[FM Sherlock]

Now that I revealed myslef, it's not that difficult to find scum among those who pushed their lynch on me. Excluding Ceasar and Yosemite Sam. King Arthur is also town - why else he defended me last day?

[FM Agahnim]

If you pay attention:

Rubber Ducky,
Robin Hood,
Gimli,
Wile E Coyote (Iffy on scumminess tbh),
And Spongebob

All were at threat to be modkilled if they did not provide a summary of the game to the FMGM for penance of their lurking. They all did so.
If it were me facing the threat of modkilling and I was a role such as Citizen, <-- ooh. look at the "slip", I would allow myself to be killed to prove to the town that I am town aligned and spur the focus onto better scum targets.

Since none of them did that, and we have claims of Vigilante Sheriff and Blacksmith, they should each be citizens. But if they were citizens, and each of them scummy just so you know, they should have allowed their deaths (imo) to prove their townness.
I believe that a couple of the people in the list are scum.

[FM Agahnim]

What say the rest of you?

[FM Locutus]

I think I'm missing something.
Why do we need to lynch Sherlock because he's the vigilante?
I understand that the witch will control him, but then that frees up the Sheriff.

[FM Agahnim]

Town Reads:
01- FM Agahnim
03- FM Anubis
07- FM Ceasar
15- FM Hamburglar
21- FM King Arthur
26- FM Michigan J Frog
42- FM Yosemite Sam

Iffy reads:
33- FM Sherlock
22- FM King Tut
23- FM Locutus
18- FM Inspector Cluseau
06- FM Captain Obvious

Scum Reads:
14- FM Gimli
34- FM SpongeBob
35- FM The Joker
38- FM Wile E Coyote
32- FM Rubber Ducky
31- FM Robin Hood
39- FM Wolverine

---

29- FM Pinkie Pie: Mafioso - Executed by the Jailor
11- FM Dracula: Consigliere - Struck down by Sith Lightning!
37- FM Watson: Consort - Killed by the Town


36- FM The Terminator: Citizen - Killed by the SK
27- FM Mr Bunny: Citizen - Killed by the Mafia
28- FM Mr T: Citizen - Struck down by Sith Lightning!
30- FM Prince Thrakhath: Citizen - Struck down by Sith Lightning!
19- FM Jack Sparrow: Citizen - Killed by the Mafia
20- FM Kermit: Jailor - Struck down by Sith Lightning!
02- FM Animal Citizen - Killed by a gun man
04- FM Batman: Citizen - Struck down by Sith Lightning!
05- FM Bridge Keeper: Citizen - Killed by the Vigilante
08- FM Col Jack ONeill: Citizen - Killed by the Mafia
09- FM Cookie Monster: Citizen - Killed by a gun rocket man.
10- FM Count von Count: Citizen - Struck down by Sith Lightning!
12- FM Frankenstein: Citizen - Killed by a gun man.
13- FM Gandalf: Citizen - Killed by an angry town mob.
16- FM Hungry: Citizen - Killed by the Vigilante
17- FM Indiana Jones: Sheriff - Killed by the SK
24- FM Lone Ranger: Citizen - Struck down by Sith Lightning!
25- FM Master Chef: Escort - Killed by the SK
40- FM Yehat: Citizen - Killed by the Mafia
41- FM Yoda: Citizen - Killed by the Mafia

[FM Sherlock]

Everything was fine for me until Yayap did THAT. If town loses this game, it will be because of what Yayap did.

And Wolverine, by claiming myslef, I gave the town a choice. If I had not claimed myslef, you would had no choice but to lynch me instead of finding scum. Before there were 29 players alive I was fine with that, but with the current conditions we cannot allow ourselves a mislynch.

I wanted the jailor to actually jail me so that we can devise a plan, but Yayap crumpled my plans to dust. I even wanted to claim myself as jailor.

[FM Wolverine]

I think I'm missing something.
Why do we need to lynch Sherlock because he's the vigilante?
I understand that the witch will control him, but then that frees up the Sheriff.

Tonight: Witch vig onto sheriff. Tomorrow night and beyond: witch & vig bffs

[FM Agahnim]

Scum: 5
Mafioso
Godfather
Framer
Serial Killer
Witch

vs

Town: 14
Sheriff
Doctor
Doctor
Blacksmith
Vigilante
Citizen
Citizen
Citizen
Citizen
Citizen
Citizen
Citizen
Citizen
Citize

---

5 vs 14

If Vigilante suicides tonight + Scum Kills with no heals
5 vs 11

^
Acceptable loss.

I feel like the Vigilante should suicide

[FM Sherlock]

But we have two doctors alive, aren't we? Sheriff will still be fine. And we also have the Blacksmith. Witch won't try to control the Blacksmith, so he can give his gun to someone else.

Speaking of blacksmith... Ceasar, did you gave a gun last night? If your target received a gun, we can still have a chance to win this.

[FM Wolverine]

Everything was fine for me until Yayap did THAT. If town loses this game, it will be because of what Yayap did.

And Wolverine, by claiming myslef, I gave the town a choice. If I had not claimed myslef, you would had no choice but to lynch me instead of finding scum. Before there were 29 players alive I was fine with that, but with the current conditions we cannot allow ourselves a mislynch.

I wanted the jailor to actually jail me so that we can devise a plan, but Yayap crumpled my plans to dust. I even wanted to claim myself as jailor.

It's not yayap's fault Kermit didn't respond when faced with the threat of being mod-killed. And the mafia lost their consigliere, which I'd say is probably more valuable to them than Kermit was to us. And either way, it's not going to be reversed, so there's no use bitching about it.

[FM Anubis]

Tonight: Witch vig onto sheriff. Tomorrow night and beyond: witch & vig bffs

if we don't lynch vig, then witch makes vig target sheriff, mafia target sheriff, and SK target sheriff. goodbye afk yosemite. double docs can't heal stuff like that.

[FM Locutus]

Rubber Ducky and Robin Hood didn't even post yesterday...

Tonight: Witch vig onto sheriff. Tomorrow night and beyond: witch & vig bffs

Okay. But there are doctors, that SHOULD'VE been on the sheriffs. <_<

[FM Wolverine]

Scum: 5
Mafioso
Godfather
Framer
Serial Killer
Witch

vs

Town: 14
Sheriff
Doctor
Doctor
Blacksmith
Vigilante
Citizen
Citizen
Citizen
Citizen
Citizen
Citizen
Citizen
Citizen
Citize

---

5 vs 14

If Vigilante suicides tonight + Scum Kills with no heals
5 vs 11

^
Acceptable loss.

I feel like the Vigilante should suicide

I'm inclined to agree with you, but based on his replies, I doubt he will do so. And if he won't, then we really have no choice but to lynch.

[FM Agahnim]

Rubber Ducky and Robin Hood didn't even post yesterday...



Okay. But there are doctors, that SHOULD'VE been on the sheriffs. <_<

^
^
^
^
^
^


>>
<<
>>
<<






>.<

[FM Anubis]

Scum: 5
Mafioso
Godfather
Framer
Serial Killer
Witch

vs

Town: 14
Sheriff
Doctor
Doctor
Blacksmith
Vigilante
Citizen
Citizen
Citizen
Citizen
Citizen
Citizen
Citizen
Citizen
Citize

---

5 vs 14

If Vigilante suicides tonight + Scum Kills with no heals
5 vs 11

^
Acceptable loss.

I feel like the Vigilante should suicide

what if Sherlock modkills himself, forcing the mod to kill Sherlock, then we're up to 12. just throwing that out there as a last resort. (and i'm not buddying up with Aghanim, even though he did put me near the top of his town-read list)

[FM Anubis]

Rubber Ducky and Robin Hood didn't even post yesterday...



Okay. But there are doctors, that SHOULD'VE been on the sheriffs. <_<

i was on the wrong sheriff. i'm sorry =(

[FM Captain Obvious]

Scum: 5
Mafioso
Godfather
Framer
Serial Killer
Witch

vs

Town: 14
Sheriff
Doctor
Doctor
Blacksmith
Vigilante
Citizen
Citizen
Citizen
Citizen
Citizen
Citizen
Citizen
Citizen
Citize

---

5 vs 14

If Vigilante suicides tonight + Scum Kills with no heals
5 vs 11

^
Acceptable loss.

I feel like the Vigilante should suicide

That is if Sherlock is vigilante...
Can a vigilante shoot someone and suicide on the same night?

[FM Captain Obvious]

Woopsies forgot bold
Can a vigilante suicide and shoot someone on the same night?

[FM Sherlock]

if we don't lynch vig, then witch makes vig target sheriff, mafia target sheriff, and SK target sheriff. goodbye afk yosemite. double docs can't heal stuff like that.

That's only one kill in a single night. We'll have about 17 people left alive in that case.

[Inspector Cluseau]

Why is Cluseau always on the Iffy level. I am SO TOTALLY TOWN. I mean, I am not the Godfather at all. Facts.

[FM Agahnim]

what if Sherlock modkills himself, forcing the mod to kill Sherlock, then we're up to 12. just throwing that out there as a last resort. (and i'm not buddying up with Aghanim, even though he did put me near the top of his town-read list)

Are you naturally retarded?

[FM Wolverine]

Okay. But there are doctors, that SHOULD'VE been on the sheriffs. <_<

Agreed. But they weren't. So now we have this mess.

We don't have to lynch Sherlock if he agrees to suicide. But that only benefits us if we can lynch scum in his place. So, for the sake of argument, if Sherlock were to suicide, who would we lynch in his stead?

[FM Locutus]

i was on the wrong sheriff. i'm sorry =(

You should be! You and the other doctor both should be sorry! *slap*

if we don't lynch vig, then witch makes vig target sheriff, mafia target sheriff, and SK target sheriff. goodbye afk yosemite. double docs can't heal stuff like that.

This was horrifically scummy to me. Makes me think you're a mafia/witch/sk trying to direct everyone at Yosemite tonight.
Don't do that.

[FM Agahnim]

Agreed. But they weren't. So now we have this mess.

We don't have to lynch Sherlock if he agrees to suicide. But that only benefits us if we can lynch scum in his place. So, for the sake of argument, if Sherlock were to suicide, who would we lynch in his stead?

Rubber Ducky
Robin Hood
Gimli
Spongebob
Maybe even Wile E.




I honestly think one of those people are scum!!@!#@!#!@#@!#!@$!%$#^@!%#&@@!%@$&$^*&(#&%$^%$ *^&(%$@!@$!#@$%&*^&*(&^%$#@!~%&^%#^%#YT$#%$#&#%^&^ Y%$^&

[FM Locutus]

Rubber Ducky
Robin Hood
Gimli
Spongebob
Maybe even Wile E.

I honestly think one of those people are scum!!@!#@!#!@#@!#!@$!%$#^@!%#&@@!%@$&$^*&(#&%$^%$ *^&(%$@!@$!#@$%&*^&*(&^%$#@!~%&^%#^%#YT$#%$#&#%^&^ Y%$^&

Why not all 5? GG we win. Lynch them all.

[FM Agahnim]

@Sherlock


If you are Vigilante you have to suicide if we do not lynch the witch.

[FM Michigan J Frog]

i'm sorry i'm derping. i meant Aghanim,

just offering this scenario of Sherlock, who realizes he's screwed, tries to get the real vigilante to counterclaim, so witch knows who to really control tonight. seems farfetched but i rest my case on Sherlock, unless town really decides to lynch the true vigi. which would be freakin sad.

and i liked what Michigan said, up to the part where he goes against King Arthur. and since when did you, Michigan, have such a pro town read of Hamburglar?

I think Hamburglar pre-day 4 when he was replaced was just a bad player. Hamburglar post day-4 replacement has been reading pretty pro-town to me. For example, most recently Day 5 #59 is such a huge towntell.

I seriously give up on this game, Sherlock not dead after clearly being scum on D2.
Also too many citizens acting too fucking scummy

Well prior to the Hungry and Cookie Monster flip, my guess at the scum team was:
Cookie Monster - Mafia
King Arthur - Mafia
Sherlock - Mafia
Hungry - sk
Agahnim - witch

based on daychat interactions/general scumminess. My scum read on King Arthur really only stems from my scum read on Sherlock. If Sherlock is indeed vigilante (which looks pretty likely) then my most pressing King Arthur scum argument is gone. I'm not ruling King Arthur out as scum yet though.

[Inspector Cluseau]

Why not all 5? GG we win. Lynch them all.

I actually have all 5 of theme on the upper end of my list. Doesn't seem to bad to me. I will jail them all tonight.

[FM Agahnim]

Agahnim - witch


No love.

[Inspector Cluseau]

Agahnim - witch


No love.

Shut up, Witch.

[FM Agahnim]

Shut up, Witch.

It insanely obvious what my role is.
I don't hide anything

[Inspector Cluseau]

It insanely obvious what my role is.
I don't hide anything

Agahnim, if I were to weight you next to a duck...

[FM Agahnim]

Agahnim, if I were to weight you next to a duck...

I would be among the crowd crying out for justice.

[Inspector Cluseau]

I would be among the crowd crying out for justice.

In the 'mob' of people, you say?

[FM Wolverine]

In the 'mob' of people, you say?

mob is another name for mafia. Agahnim is mafia! GASP!

[FM Agahnim]

In the 'mob' of people, you say?

Yes.
The collection of citizens shouting out the likelyhood that their captive is evil.

[FM Locutus]

I love waiting all day for our sheriff.

...36 hours later...

Yosemite Sam: Guise I was witched!

[Inspector Cluseau]

I love waiting all day for our sheriff.

...36 hours later...

Yosemite Sam: Guise I was witched!

Locutus is the Witch

[FM Locutus]

Locutus is the Witch

Don't jail me!

[FM Agahnim]

-vote FM Rubber Ducky

[FM Michigan J Frog]

Rubber Ducky
Robin Hood
Gimli
Spongebob
Maybe even Wile E.




I honestly think one of those people are scum!!@!#@!#!@#@!#!@$!%$#^@!%#&@@!%@$&$^*&(#&%$^%$ *^&(%$@!@$!#@$%&*^&*(&^%$#@!~%&^%#^%#YT$#%$#&#%^&^ Y%$^&

lolwtf I just checked, and Rubber Ducky, Robin Hood, and Gimli haven't even posted in days. Too hard to find town or scum motivation in posts that don't exist!

[FM Wolverine]

Don't jail me!

Too late. He's already sent the "-jail everyone" PM. It's all over now.

[FM Agahnim]

lolwtf I just checked, and Rubber Ducky, Robin Hood, and Gimli haven't even posted in days. Too hard to find town or scum motivation in posts that don't exist!

Have you read the same game I have?
Everyone but You, Hamburgler, Jack, and Cookie Monster have dropped both town tells and scum tells