Day 4: Traffic Cops needed.

[FM Anubis]

Indiana Jones, i'm dissappointed that i'm that high on your scum list, but i'll be posting my own list soon as i come back.

[FM Prince Thrakhath]

If we do not get a lynch off I recommend this:

Vigilante shoot FM Prince Thrakhath
Jailor Jail Hungry.

Good luck shooting a night immune. Plebs, plebs everywhere.

[FM Anubis]

If we do not get a lynch off I recommend this:

Vigilante shoot FM Prince Thrakhath
Jailor Jail Hungry.

lynch Hungry, and shoot Sherlock

[FM Jack Sparrow]

lynch FM Starvin', 'n shoot FM Sherlock +1

[FM King Arthur]

If we do not get a lynch off I recommend this:

Vigilante shoot FM Prince Thrakhath
Jailor Jail Hungry.

I'm inclined to agree, although the gaoler shouldst still consider Sherlock as a possible prisoner as well if Sherlock art not the gaoler himself.

[FM King Arthur]

Indeed, the gaoler hath not shown competence in his last night's imprisonment, but if it turneth out that Sherlock is the gaoler for real then his death wouldst not be desirable right now, especially not at our own hands. Therefore, mayhaps tis better if we doth give the gaoler one last chance.

[FM King Arthur]

I shalt

-unvote

for now. Wouldst not like to see the day end prematurely.

[FM Sherlock]

I'm back, and it seems that you started to follow some reasoning.

I really don't get what Prince Thrakhath says, but he is either scum, or doesn't read the game at all. Just look at this:

My list of scum.

Master Chief : Ultimate scum, everything about him is trollish.

Master Chief is dead, dumbass, and he was escort.
I advise the Vigilante to shoot Prince Thrakhath, becuse I do not see any town vibes from him. Unless we hear more explanations from him.

[FM Jack Sparrow]

oh wait i meant t' lynch FM Starvin' 'n shoot FM Cluseau. Me Bad!

[FM The Joker]

By not stating what his (Anubis) role is I'm convinced he is not Doctor.

[FM Sherlock]

I want everyone to post their FoS's, From the Top to the Bottom, reasoning would be nice but not needed for now.

Well, as I previosly said, my FoS were Caesar and Anubis during the first half of the day, but for now the big suspects for me are Hungry and Prince. And King Arthus's big post made me to suspect Hungry even more. Incidentally, Hungry replies to that:

You put alot of effort into saving your scum buddy, have you forgotten that you wanted to lynch Master chef yesterday? Dont make me laugh

Joker seems to be completely focused on Anubis. I don't blame him for that. But right now we have better targets to lynch/kill than Anubis. We do not need for doctors to claim now. However, in case if one of doctors dies, then if Anubis is not a doctor, a second doctor should claim himself so we can kill another scum. Ather that the blacksmith should only give out vests to sheriff instead of guns.

So my Heavy FoS are Hungry and Prince, and Mid FoS are Anubis, Caesar and Hamburglar. And Gimli should get a life.

[FM Agahnim]

[FM Anubis]

By not stating what his (Anubis) role is I'm convinced he is not Doctor.

i already role claimed. go read posts from day one. and day 2 AND day 3

Well, as I previosly said, my FoS were Caesar and Anubis during the first half of the day, but for now the big suspects for me are Hungry and Prince. And King Arthus's big post made me to suspect Hungry even more. Incidentally, Hungry replies to that:



Joker seems to be completely focused on Anubis. I don't blame him for that. But right now we have better targets to lynch/kill than Anubis. We do not need for doctors to claim now. However, in case if one of doctors dies, then if Anubis is not a doctor, a second doctor should claim himself so we can kill another scum. Ather that the blacksmith should only give out vests to sheriff instead of guns.

So my Heavy FoS are Hungry and Prince, and Mid FoS are Anubis, Caesar and Hamburglar. And Gimli should get a life.

cesar, im sorry for my first post that has tied the two of us together, even though i have renounced it at least twice.

[FM Hungry]

Your reason to lynch me is laughable, there are alot of more scummy people then me. the only thing you will accomplish by lynching me is getting rid of another citizen.

[FM Ceasar]

For Anubis's comment, I do believe that it may have been a scum move, as I said during D2...

Having said that, there was one tiny 4-word post which I don't particularly like from Anubis right at the very beginning of the game...

why is cesar mafia?

Quite simply, I found the post too similar to buddying. It's so insignificant that it's hard to peg him for much, since technically he isn't in any way claiming that I'm not scum. However, he is still somewhat coming to my defence at the very beginning of the game, which is somewhat of a scum move. If I die and flip town, Anubis gets town points for defending a town. If Anubis dies and flips scum, I could get some major scum points for having been defended by scum. If we both survive, my view of Anubis could be skewed to the town side since I feel a sense of loyalty. Either way, it's a win-win situation for a scum player if you can get close to a town player, presuming you don't get caught doing so.

Of course, I didn't find this one post enough to try and push a full-blown waggon, but you asked:P

I do think that it's a scum move. However, if you think that Anubis decided to create a conection between the 2 of us D1 we are mafia buddys, give me a break.

[FM SpongeBob]

Looks like a irl name slip.

You're so dead.

-vote FM Indiana Jones

Next time ya'll will be more cautious.

Stop trying to confuse everyone. Crowd controllers need to be shot before they cause more trouble.

[FM Hungry]

-unvote

Im not convinced that sherlock is a scum, i will let the vigi or jailor decide who they want to kill

[FM Jack Sparrow]

Glad ye be here Spongebob tell us wha' ye reckon about everyone so far. IN DETAIL!

[FM SpongeBob]

-unvote

Im not convinced that sherlock is a scum, i will let the vigi or jailor decide who they want to kill

its a bad idea to let the jailor handle things now. I thought this was obvious.

[FM Hungry]

its a bad idea to let the jailor handle things now. I thought this was obvious.

Lynching townies is also a bad idea. I know im a townie and i suspect sherlock is a townie aswell.

[FM SpongeBob]

I don't believe sherlock is scum either....... he seems to always be pushed into a hole

My FOS has been on Hungary and the Capt since yesterday. Hungary seems to sheep into Capt too easily. Now the Capt seems to jump onto Hungary without a word as if to break connections.

[FM Jack Sparrow]

I don't believe sherlock is scum either....... he seems to always be pushed into a hole

My FOS has been on Hungary and the Capt since yesterday. Hungary seems to sheep into Capt too easily. Now the Capt seems to jump onto Hungary without a word as if to break connections.

Oh god why? WHY GOD WHY? WHYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY???????????????????????? ????????!!!

[Inspector Cluseau]

It's been quite a while since I was in the spotlight, let's see what we think about Cluseau's Jailor claim, and who he may or may not want to put a bullet into.

[Inspector Cluseau]

So far, my Feet-orange-Starship goes towards the bowl of salad. I may or may not have already eaten, and I don't currently own a blue hoodie. So, clearly he is scum.

/discuss.

[FM Anubis]

As the sheriff has directed me and everyone else to do:

MY SCUM LIST


-evil
1. Sherlock
2. Hungry
3. prince thrakhath(wtf is with this trolling?)
4. robin hood (vigi that hasn't talked since d1 saying he'll shoot cluseau)
-evil seeming lurkers
5. king tut
6. rubber ducky
7. spongebob
8. lone ranger
-inbetween read and lurkers
9. the joker (why the sudden interest in trying to get me lynched?
10. dracula
11. gimli
12. locutus
13. count von count(checks in and says nothing happened to him)
14. inspector cluseau
15. mr. t
16. wolverine
17. wile e coyote
18. kermit (possible dubaxx GF but not probable)
-town read
19. captain obvious
20. agahnim
21. cookie monster
22. jack sparrow
23. hamburglar
24. cesar
25. king arthur
26. michigan j frog
27. Yosemite Sam
28. Indiana Jones
29. Anubis (of course I'm going to put myself at the bottom of the list....)

[Inspector Cluseau]

Anubis, who should I shoot?

[Inspector Cluseau]

Seeing as I am proven, proven, Jailor. I would like everyone to let me know who I should shoot tonight.
Anyone that does not comment will be selected instead of the people suggested, and executed on 1 account of 'trying to avoid being on a team'

[FM Anubis]

Anubis, who should I shoot?

i'm in favor of jailor doing nothing tonight, and vigi shooting according to my list

Seeing as I am proven, proven, Jailor. I would like everyone to let me know who I should shoot tonight.
Anyone that does not comment will be selected instead of the people suggested, and executed on 1 account of 'trying to avoid being on a team'

how are you proven jailor? you've claimed doctor?

[Inspector Cluseau]

you've claimed doctor?

So have you. Are you claiming Jailor now?

Well, even if Jailor should take no action, we may or may not have townsfolk with guns a foot. Who should they target. I feel they are just about gamethrowing for the Town, and need more direction.

[FM Hamburglar]

wait, so cluseau claimed jailor?
Cuz if you don't get executed for that claim, i'm inclined to believe you actually are.
I'd rather stick to the lynch now, gain information that way plan.
Also, has Spongebob brought up anything relevant ever? To me he seems like the biggest sheep of em all, and we don't have that many sheeps around. That gives me more of a scumvibe than citizenvibe tbh. Anyone else's thoughts on this matter?

Note: I'm sticking with my vote on sherlock and am in favor of headshotting hungry at night.

[FM Sherlock]

We already know that Cluseau is trolling us. He could as well give the real Jailor suggested actions.

In case if both me and Hungry are citizens... you will probaly waste your time by lynching either of us... and Jailor will not be happy about that. However, I'm still inclined to believe that Hungry is scum. My personal suggestion is to jail Hungry (jn case if he is SK) and shoot Prince Thrakhath. No personal hate Hungry, but right now we are still on you.

[FM Agahnim]

We already know that Cluseau is trolling us. He could as well give the real Jailor suggested actions.

In case if both me and Hungry are citizens... you will probaly waste your time by lynching either of us... and Jailor will not be happy about that. However, I'm still inclined to believe that Hungry is scum. My personal suggestion is to jail Hungry (jn case if he is SK) and shoot Prince Thrakhath. No personal hate Hungry, but right now we are still on you.

Have you made a single original thought in this entire game?

[FM Sherlock]

Yeah, I once said that Citizen's vote power doesn't mean anything as long as Jailor and Vigilante are doing their job well.

But from your point of view, they both were doing bad, and so you came to thought that lynch must be made once again. And who screamed "Vigilante shoot Pinkie Pie!" when most of us decided that Pinkie should be jailed?

It's a matter of trust. If you don't trust both Jailor and Vigilante, feel free to push a lynch. But if you want to give the Jailor another chance to redeem himself... listen to what I had to say. I'm saying this as a concerned citizen.

During last night, Jailor was used solely for Pinkie Pie's execution. But this time, jail chat should be used as the means to obtain valuable information. If the Jailor jails and finds out a Town PR, they can devise a good plan against Mafia. Ideally the ones who should be jailed are SK/Witch suspects, so we can account missing kill/witching. That's why jailing Hungry should be a preferable option. Even if Hungry will not become executed, we'll be able to find out if he is SK or not tomorrow.

[Inspector Cluseau]

Yeah, I once said that Citizen's vote power doesn't mean anything as long as Jailor and Vigilante are doing their job well.

But from your point of view, they both were doing bad, and so you came to thought that lynch must be made once again. And who screamed "Vigilante shoot Pinkie Pie!" when most of us decided that Pinkie should be jailed?

It's a matter of trust. If you don't trust both Jailor and Vigilante, feel free to push a lynch. But if you want to give the Jailor another chance to redeem himself... listen to what I had to say. I'm saying this as a concerned citizen.

During last night, Jailor was used solely for Pinkie Pie's execution. But this time, jail chat should be used as the means to obtain valuable information. If the Jailor jails and finds out a Town PR, they can devise a good plan against Mafia. Ideally the ones who should be jailed are SK/Witch suspects, so we can account missing kill/witching. That's why jailing Hungry should be a preferable option. Even if Hungry will not become executed, we'll be able to find out if he is SK or not tomorrow.

Jailer Cluesau has chosen to rape and murder Sherlock violently in his sleep tonight. If the lynch doesn't take he would like no one else to attempt to do so.
*looking at you, Vigilante*

[FM Yosemite Sam]

Obvious evils are prince, hungry, king Arthur (semi-possible) and ofc, Sherlock the stupid witch.

[FM Anubis]

Jailer Cluesau has chosen to rape and murder Sherlock violently in his sleep tonight. If the lynch doesn't take he would like no one else to attempt to do so.
*looking at you, Vigilante*

i fear if we let jailor jail execute, were going to have vigi and jailor target same person, so we should do the lynching ourselves

[FM King Arthur]

But from your point of view, they both were doing bad, and so you came to thought that lynch must be made once again. And who screamed "Vigilante shoot Pinkie Pie!" when most of us decided that Pinkie should be jailed?

This comment doth not make sense, especially if it was in response to Agahnim.

Pinkie Pie for Vigilante yesterday (if not lynched):
Frog
Animal
Master Chef
King Arthur
Hungry
Dracula
Jack Sparrow <- "I agree wholeheartedly with Jack's post above." quoth Agahnim
Hamburglar
Cookie Monster

Pinkie Pie for Gaol yesterday:
Hungry?
Wolverine?
Agahnim

Most people decided Pinkie Pie shouldst be imprisoned? I think not. The only person who decidedly sayeth now that the Vigilante messed up is Agahnim. And maybe thyself.

[FM King Arthur]

i fear if we let jailor jail execute, were going to have vigi and jailor target same person, so we should do the lynching ourselves

Execution as a reason to use the gaol is unwise. At least until tis no longer possible to get lynch majorities we desire. A lynch is advantageous over using the gaol as a night kill only.

Gaol shouldst be mainly for interrogation purposes right now, if tis used at all. Execution shouldst be an option only if the gaoler decides his captive's responses are unsatisfactory.

[FM Prince Thrakhath]

Some of you need to read FM3. Plebs.

[FM Sherlock]

Obvious evils are prince, hungry, king Arthur (semi-possible) and ofc, Sherlock the stupid witch.

You still suspect me as the witch? I once offered myself to be jailed back at Day 2 in order to prove that you are wrong.

[FM Hungry]

I don't believe sherlock is scum either....... he seems to always be pushed into a hole

My FOS has been on Hungary and the Capt since yesterday. Hungary seems to sheep into Capt too easily. Now the Capt seems to jump onto Hungary without a word as if to break connections.

How do you put me and captain jackass together? the only reason im now considered a scum is becouse of his post that lacks logic. It's ridiculous to think im the serial killer becouse the escort supposedly blocked me 1 night. If i was the serial killer he would have simply blocked me again last night and indiana claims to have been witched so its impossible that the witch could have controlled the escort to block someone else.

Obvious evils are prince, hungry, king Arthur (semi-possible) and ofc, Sherlock the stupid witch.

While i like that you put king arthur on that list it also seems like you haven't payed mutch attention to this Fm. Im the one that started calling king arthur a scum and it seems like your list is based on what other people are thinking about other players.

[FM King Arthur]

How do you put me and captain jackass together? the only reason im now considered a scum is becouse of his post that lacks logic. It's ridiculous to think im the serial killer becouse the escort supposedly blocked me 1 night. If i was the serial killer he would have simply blocked me again last night and indiana claims to have been witched so its impossible that the witch could have controlled the escort to block someone else.



While i like that you put king arthur on that list it also seems like you haven't payed mutch attention to this Fm. Im the one that started calling king arthur a scum and it seems like your list is based on what other people are thinking about other players.

Truly? I thought Count von Count, Pinkie Pie and Master Chef preceded thee in thine accusations.

[FM Hungry]

Truly? I thought Count von Count, Pinkie Pie and Master Chef preceded thee in thine accusations.

But they are trolls/scums

[FM Lone Ranger]

Currently catching up the day, but there were some questions relevant to me in the first few pages so I will just give what I have.

I'm a Citizen, replaced on Night 2 after dying Night 1.

I was blocked the last two nights. I didn't report it yesterday because there was an SK kill missing and I haven't been active much this FM; I'm sorry for that, it's not like me to be a lurker. The missing SK kill would have implicated me and being a Citizen I would have had no real defense.

Catching up on the rest of the day now.

[FM Hungry]

Currently catching up the day, but there were some questions relevant to me in the first few pages so I will just give what I have.

I'm a Citizen, replaced on Night 2 after dying Night 1.

I was blocked the last two nights. I didn't report it yesterday because there was an SK kill missing and I haven't been active much this FM; I'm sorry for that, it's not like me to be a lurker. The missing SK kill would have implicated me and being a Citizen I would have had no real defense.

Catching up on the rest of the day now.

So this means that the serial killer hit a scum then or forgot to give a night action.

[FM King Arthur]

But they are trolls/scums

Yet ye copy their reasoning for calling thine King evil and add to it that ye think I was attacked by the serial killer, which is entirely baseless.

I fail to see the big difference.


Thank ye Lone Ranger. I think that settles the search for roleblocks, if we are to assume Chef didst not submit an action night 1.

[FM Hungry]

Yet ye copy their reasoning for calling thine King evil and add to it that ye think I was attacked by the serial killer, which is entirely baseless.

I fail to see the big difference.


Thank ye Lone Ranger. I think that settles the search for roleblocks, if we are to assume Chef didst not submit an action night 1.

I would expect you or some other town leader to be attacked by the Sk Night 3. Lone rangers post allmost proves that a scum was hit.

[FM Jack Sparrow]

How do you put me and captain jackass together? the only reason im now considered a scum is becouse of his post that lacks logic. It's ridiculous to think im the serial killer becouse the escort supposedly blocked me 1 night. If i was the serial killer he would have simply blocked me again last night and indiana claims to have been witched so its impossible that the witch could have controlled the escort to block someone else.



While i like that you put king arthur on that list it also seems like you haven't payed mutch attention to this Fm. Im the one that started calling king arthur a scum and it seems like your list is based on what other people are thinking about other players.

You reaction is bad. You react like a scum who was cought for the wrong reason.

[FM Hungry]

You reaction is bad. You react like a scum who was cought for the wrong reason.

Becouse only scums defend themselves? Im actually worried about how little effort sherlock puts into defending himself.

[FM King Arthur]

It doth certainly make it likely that he targeted an evil, I concur. Looking at his assault against the Terminator the night before, I wouldst assume he chose Frog, Agahnim, Sparrow or one of the sheriffs. Possibly Ceaser or Locutus.

Just to be entirely certain, as the rules page doth not explicitly state it:
If someone is attacked and healed, does the target receive night feedback about it?