Cookie Monster - How can it be, that when town has a hunch/lead whatever on somebody you immediately start finding another scapegoat? That's indirectly defending suspects/scum, which in turn, make you look way scummier
Sherlock - Scum, i don't think i need to go into detail about how many scumtells and scumslips he makes with every second post
hungry/animal - i was suspicious of them since day 2, their behavior is extremely unbeneficial to town
jack/cluseau - Once, they were suspected. Following that, the suspicions started dying down for a reason, that til now remains a mystery to me. They both have their ups and downs when contributing to scumhunting, but they occasionally try to rolefish, make bad claims, even more ridiculous claims and simply OMGUS everybody while trying to maintain a low profile.
How can you even put me and FM Cluseau together? That's retarded.
where exactly did i rolefish or claim any role? Wut? I surely don't try to have a low profile.
But nice try. Sigh
Hey, I'm here!
Sorry for the blatant lurkyness during D3 and this one so far. I ended up being way busier than I should've been.
Also, I'll be fully supporting lynches instead of jailings from now on. What I was afraid would happen (and mentionned a few times) happened; our Jailor cannot pick good targets.
Why you you think that jailing Pinkie Pie was bad?
Well, if you were a Jailor, then who would be your target for the next night?
Well this time we don't have any clear suspects like Pinkie, so Jailor can jail anyone else he wants. I don't think that he'll cross with vigilante again.
Don't make our jailor sad, you're making him almost as useless as citizen.
Because, obviously, not lynching Pinkie Pie was to let the Jailor jail someone, while the Vigilante would shoot him/her.
Jailor should've jailed another of our suspects to have a nice and polite discussion with him, and an execute if need be.
And if I had to jail someone, It would be, again, one of the people that have been suspected the most. Not going to give out names here, as we aren't even close to the end of the day.
It would definitely not be the one person with the most votes. This one should be left to the Vigilante.
Your reason for pressuring me is silly. jacks reason for starting a vote on me is becouse he thinks im a serial killer and that i was blocked by master chef. But if i was the serial killer and blocked by master chef then how did he get killed by a serial killer? I don't understand why everyone follows jack like sheeps, his not exacly a confirmed townie.
Not to be someone who is against the town on this one, but quite frankly the reasoning behind lynching Hungry is shaky at best.
Call me an inept FM player who needs to stop playing, but because Master Chef called him a Bitch, he was the serial killer? What the fuck? That is terrible evidence.
-vote FM Sherlock
This doesn't need any more explanation. Why is this player still alive?
yay the sheriff is following my push!
-vote FM Sherlock
Sherlock is my FoS for scum right now.
On day one:
We estblished this point already but I'd like to bring it up again. This post by itself may have just been a bad choice of words that people jumped on.
On day two:
He starts to get trained on, defends himself a little bit until the sheriff claims that Gandalf is mafia. Then disappears once the pressure is off of him.
On day three:
Good job not actually voting for FM Pinkie Pie, the mafioso. Good job not fixing your mistake.
On day four:
Paranoid overposting.
-vote FM Sherlock
Its funny that Cookie Monster brings that up cause I could say the same thing about Frog and Jack and Yosemite Sam and Indiana Jones.
-vote FM Sherlock
Cookie Monster fail.
Seeing how the jailor failed us, and how unbeneficial jailing in this setup is, i'd rather have a lynch on hungry and a shot on anybody the vigi suspects.
I still don't know why sherlock hasn't been shot
Reasons why jailor is more or less useless in this setup:
What kind of info can he get for us? None.
What will scum claim in jail? Most likely citizen, there are a dozens of those.
We get immediate info after the lynch, which is a million times better than having the jailor die at the end of the night.
The jailor can't communicate info with LWs, other than that he'd have to reveal himself. Do we want the jailor to reveal himself? No.
The jailor could communicate using code, but there don't seem to be any codelike posts floating around.
I think we should lynch 1 suspect and have the vigi shoot whoever he believes to be the most scummiest.
My personal votes for the day are Sherlock/Hungry
Why take a chance with someone who is probably going to be healed, when instead kill off the unknown probable citizens?
One of the sheriffs do not need to be attacked, since the witch has him, and there are still 2 doctors. Better to kill the people who will not be healed.
That is why we all still alive.
So you are starting this train again. Isn't it more simple to jail one of us and have vigilante shoot another?
I'm going to be away for 10 hours, but i'll tell you one thing: Don't do anything rash until I return. And one more thing:
The black sheep beats down the wolves.
You try to find out what that means.
-vote FM Sherlock
vote mechanics own me
Yosemite and Indiana probably have a doctor, scum won't risk it.
Frog and Jack are nowwheRe near as"thought to be town" than you.
Also mis-reaction much? Cough post 176 cough.
I don't know how I feel about this sherlock lynch, I'm getting town motivation from his posts. But I'll train with you guys-vote FM Sherlock
@Jack yes I forgot to include ceasar, though I've already said why I suspect him D3
Sherlock has been scummy as hell during the game, and I am still puzzled why no one has shot him. However, I do not think that he is SK, so it does not matter that much if we kill him today or during the night. Therefore, I favour leaving him to the Vigilante. However, Hungry has a strong chance of being the SK. Lynching the SK during the day prevents him from killing before death, so he should be lynch priority.
Truly? He didst write a scum read on you, but nowhere hath I seen him attempting to push for thine lynch. Tis probably him thinking that at least one of the more vocal attendees of this meeting must be a corrupt smooth talker. As unfortunate as that is, I shalt confess that my mind is troubled with similar thoughts, although I am not yet certain who the traitor might be. Why, if may be so bold to ask, art thou so certain that Frog is to be trusted?
He is laying the foundation (scum view of him is what im reading) of which to sow distrust and get me mislynched. It's in its infancy right now but if cookie Monster is scum it'll be coming.
Frog has been a general intelligent player who has provided reads that have, thus far, only benefited town.
At least to me it is as that
About Sherlock, I have mixed feelings. At first I thought he couldst be the witch, but all in all I get a stumbling town impression from him. I doth believe that he hath been WIFOMing a PR quite some time now and he hath done so in such a way that I wouldst not expect it from evil. But then again, some of his messages art conflicting and he hath been read by others as possible scum enough not to be at risk of being killed by evil.
Behold.
This here statement doth seem like a complaint about reliance on PRs and he doth halfway imply being a citizen, yet he hath been constantly cheering on the use of the gaoler. And sometime on the second or first day, I doth not remember, I think he claimeth being a role that was difficult to prove. Not impossible, but difficult.Originally Posted by FM Sherlock
In another post he made yesterday, he wert asking what shouldst be done with Pinkie Pie, as if searching confirmation.
Incidentally, Hungry didst post a fishy reply to that.Originally Posted by FM Sherlock
He sayeth that the gaoler shouldst gaol, but didst that fully answer Sherlock's question?Originally Posted by FM Hungry
Nay. He posts something that didst suggest an answer, but that's just as easily withdrawn like so.
"Oh, but I did not mean he should jail Pinke Pie! Don't be silly!"
Which is exactly what his stance seemeth to be today. Like I sayeth to Pinkie Pie yesterday, failing to post with elaborate explanation is an easy method for scum to get back on what they said previously.
In another possibly suspicious post by Hungry, albeit in the same league as a post made earlier by Jack, Hungry comments someone shouldst shoot Master Chef. Is it possible that Hungry hath been attacked by the serial killer, and their consigliere found out what Chef's role was?
In that light, Agahnim's gaoler target list is suspicious too.
Didst not include Master Chef after I gave fairly good reasons for the gaoler to have a chat with him, not kill him. Twould have saved his life, too. And he could have given the gaoler his missing roleblock targets and made a code. But that be aftertalk.Jailor: Pinkie Pie, Gimli, Joker, Prince Thrakan(?)
Vigilante: Any of the trolly lurking useless 1-2 posters
His entire gaoler target list were good vigilante targets. Wert he, as a trusted townsperson, looking to cause the failure that befell us last night, by chance? Was the murder of our local whore orchestrated? I cannot say for certain, but tis an interesting theory if I may say so myself!
Before I do sidetrack further, this all (in addition to former finds and a feeling in my gut) doth lead me to support the pressure vote against Hungry rather than Sherlock. And my trust in Agahnim has waned a wee bit too, though his shooting was good and proper, as was his questioning to get reads out in the open... So he gets the benefit of doubt for now, same as Frog with his hypothesis plan (which is, in my eyes, his main redeeming quality. He hath not done overly much to serve the town after that).
-vote FM Hungry
Yes I didst move on from Sherlock to Hungry in one post and thou canst call it diversion all thou wanteth, but twas a natural turn of events while I was sorting through Sherlock's posts and the responses he received. He hath been WIFOMing gaoler for a long time and that be a rather stupid thing to do if he were truly evil, thus it required further investigation.
Oh and I am PR hunting too! The nerve! Thing is, with the people behind Sherlock's train tis likely that he wouldst indeed get offed by the town if none brought up his WIFOM. If he art truly a gaoler, he canst prove himself because the gaoler messed up last night and thus he hath no defense. If he art a simple citizen, I'd still not say good riddance as I would with Frankenstein or Prince Trakhath.
The King doth not care if thou seest mine actions as signs of trickery, for the blind doth see what they want to see regardless. The King is wise, and the wise do listen to him as he listened to Merlin's wise counsel. That is all that matters.
False.In that light, Agahnim's gaoler target list is suspicious too.
I said jail Pinkie and Vigilante shoot ANYONE ELSE.
l2context