Is this reportable?

[marinebase7]

Honest question. Everytime I get doc I start off day 1 by pming everyone "hey im doc shoot me first"
-pm 1 hey im doc shoot me first
-pm 2 hey im doc shoot me first
-pm 3 hey im doc shoot me first
...
-pm 15 hey im doc shoot me first

is this a reportable offense? If so I won't do it anymore.

[creedkingsx]

Minor game-throwing, imo.
Playing against his win condition

Edit: Moved to Mafia Discussion.

[TimeTrx]

Minor game-throwing, imo.
Playing against his win condition

What if hes vet?

[Deantwo]

yeah... it's at least close to game-throwing... or (Wiki link) WIFOM... i'd say do it when your Citizen... would be more helpful for your team

but yeah... are you doing it cause you wanna lose/die? then yes

playing to lose isn't allowed... it ruins the game for the rest of your team

[creedkingsx]

I am currently assuming that the person he is thinking of reporting was actually doctor.
Otherwise, why would he make the thread?

[Ash]

yeah... it's at least close to game-throwing... or (Wiki link) WIFOM... i'd say do it when your Citizen... would be more helpful for your team

but yeah... are you doing it cause you wanna lose? playing to lose (or against your team) isn't allowed...

Or it could be a double-layered WIFOM. (no average player is smart enough to plan WIFOM though)

Also what kind of stupid idea is PMing everyone saying you are doc?

Retarded person whispered Red.
Retardede person whispered Blue.
Retatrted person whispered Teal.
Retadrfd person whispered Green.

im losing brain cells. lock this thread please

[Deantwo]

I am currently assuming that the person he is thinking of reporting was actually doctor.
Otherwise, why would he make the thread?

he seem to be asking if he's doing something wrong...

Honest question. Everytime I get doc I start off day 1 by pming everyone "hey im doc shoot me first"
-pm 1 hey im doc shoot me first
-pm 2 hey im doc shoot me first
-pm 3 hey im doc shoot me first
...
-pm 15 hey im doc shoot me first

is this a reportable offense? If so I won't do it anymore.

[Ash]

Minor game-throwing, imo.
Playing against his win condition

Edit: Moved to Mafia Discussion.

I also thought it was game-throwing. But what is worse, minor game-throwing or role-quitting? I figured he is doing this because he doesn't want to role-quit.

[Deantwo]

I also thought it was game-throwing. But what is worse, minor game-throwing or role-quitting? I figured he is doing this because he doesn't want to role-quit.

depends... it's easier to report you if you game-throw...
role-quitting we can't say why you left... (could be your house caught fire)

[Jim]

Idk I pm people saying I am doctor when I am vet do people might just think he is trolling.

[Deantwo]

Idk I pm people saying I am doctor when I am vet do people might just think he is trolling.

that can then backfire on you too... but yeah

some times the line between game-throwing and WIFOM is thin... depends on how you use it and what the outcome is

your team could say you were game-throwing if you end up killing half the town with that little trick... but you'll be called a god if you killed all the evil people

[Slaol]

Wanting to die outside of these reasons...
- Proving you are Sheriff/Invest/Whatever to prove a lead
- Jester being lynched
- A Mafia being repeatedly RB'ed, and wanting to transform another player into the killer.
- Bodyguard after a successful kill
- Citizen/weak role trying to draw attention from Sheriff/Power role
- Exec that got it's win and no longer cares about the outcome of the game.

... should be considered game throwing and reported.

There are plenty of reasons to want to be ATTACKED. Wanting to DIE is game throwing.

[Force20]

Wanting to die outside of these reasons...
- Proving you are Sheriff/Invest/Whatever to prove a lead
- Jester being lynched
- A Mafia being repeatedly RB'ed, and wanting to transform another player into the killer.
- Bodyguard after a successful kill
- Citizen/weak role trying to draw attention from Sheriff/Power role
- Exec that got it's win and no longer cares about the outcome of the game.

... should be considered game throwing and reported.

There are plenty of reasons to want to be ATTACKED. Wanting to DIE is game throwing.

So is it gamethrowing if a Witch/Serial Killer/Arsonist/Mass Murderer commits suicide?

[Slaol]

So is it gamethrowing if a Witch/Serial Killer/Arsonist/Mass Murderer commits suicide?

Technically- yes. But no one will give a crap since it doesn't bring anyone down with you. It is also kind of hard to prove. My legitimate SK strategy is to claim it on d1, then repeatedly hard claim Jester by suggesting my own lynching.

- "Hey guys, Purple here. I am Sheriff. I checked Purple, and he came up as Serial Killer."

Similar to my SK plan is my Arson plan.

- "I am Arson, I doused him, and it told me he was Arson."

I have won many a game with this strategy. God, the lulz on d6 when they are like "Wait, you are actually Arson?"

Some might think I am game throwing, but 9 times out of 10 the people don't know that to do.

[marinebase7]

Idk I pm people saying I am doctor when I am vet do people might just think he is trolling.

This is true. Most of the time I don't even get killed or lynched because they think I'm jester/vet.
I don't auto-lose by pming everyone I'm doc.

There are plenty of reasons to want to be ATTACKED. Wanting to DIE is game throwing.

But jester strat is legit.
Need moderator opinion on this. Preferably the savior of Jews.

[Slaol]

Need moderator opinion on this.

K.

I guess if you are REALLY trying to claim Jester to avoid lynchings it is fine, but most times Town benefits more from you playing correctly. We can thank Yayap for that fact. On the topic of Jester claim- I ALWAYS include Any Random to make it nigh-impossible to rule out Jester until all roles are proven.

[creedkingsx]

But jester strat is legit.
Need moderator opinion on this. Preferably the savior of Jews.

Right now, give exactly what situation.
The role you are and what you are doing that you want to know if is reportable.

[Admiral]

Wanting to die is not always game-throwing. Sometimes a death is necessary to find a liar.

I've played legit a few times, and one of those times I offed myself (as a Doctor) via suicide at night. It proved the other "doctor" was a fake and the town listened to the will which ended up getting the other baddie hanged.

[marinebase7]

Right now, give exactly what situation.
The role you are and what you are doing that you want to know if is reportable.

Well in the case I am talking about, I am doctor.
I did however win couple games by doing this with other roles (most notably citizen sickle and scythe win) but I am asking in case of actually being doctor.

Also no I don't die first night. If anything I'll get attacked and get healed.

[Raptorblaze]

I wouldn't call it reportable unless it was near the end of the game and you being alive was important to town.

[marinebase7]

Thank you Raptor you are a hero.

Hero Raptor and Savior Land 2012.

[Slaol]

I wouldn't call it reportable unless it was near the end of the game and you being alive was important to town.

Answered.