I don't say that your argumentation is neccesarily wrong. In fact you are probably right if we would play with a bunch of players who actually care about the game like you do. The last games i was lucky to have been a part of tought me that there are a lot of guys who shouldn't be signing up in the first place.
I don't say he is town by any means. He might be scum. But meta dictates me he is probably trolling town, since scum usually doesn't troll on day 1, as hard as town does.
It's like Subject 16 . We tell him every game that suggesting town power roles what they should do and what not is con town. Still he never gets it. This makes me sad.
I wouldn't be surprised if something happens to him tonight.
I wonder who those 4 people are who haven't responded yet.
I still believe a succesful day 1 lynch is contra productive.