Rapist (and/or Bigot)

[Aganos]

Seing the amount of negative feedback and (mainly) bad manners deriving from this post i'm gonna delete it. GG

[Bunny]

this is offensive..

[Gzz]

The name is forbidden on SC2 , he doesen' t add anything , and.. the thing of female role is bullshit

[Damus_Graves]

This role idea is one of the bad ones and not just for the name.

[RLVG]

The only way this would be appropriate, would be the role name Johnny Bravo, the description would be a man using a scope to track women, and the ability to take picture of the women what they did that night E.G target someone. Goal is to take picture of three women. 7 players are male, 7 players are female, and 1 are random.

And it still is a bad idea.

[Aganos]

this is offensive..

How is this offensive? This is a game about murder, corruption (see Blackmailer), primitive law enforcement (lynching based on voting, regardless of actual evidence, leading to the execution of innocents) and all kinds of violence. How is rape more offensive than this? Also, i'm italian: should i feel offended because you guys play and have fun with a game that lets you impersonate a criminal organization that brings death and suffering to my people on a daily basis? I really don't understand your point: either you take this game for what it is (something to have fun with) or you don't, in which case you shouldn't play it to begin with. Anyways, if you want to suggest a better name you are more than welcome, i chose this because i found it fitting with his effects.

The name is forbidden on SC2 , he doesen' t add anything , and.. the thing of female role is bullshit

For the "bullshit" part refer to the above paragraph. I didn't know it was forbidden (i find it a bit odd actually), but since i'm not the one who implements the game ( him being DR), it is none of my business: what i'm interested in suggeting is the role/mechanic, not the name per se. On the contribution of this role to the game.....i'm obviously open to suggestions: my idea was to introduce a role that could hinder the performance of any faction without being as disruptive as, say, a SK, while also causing some strategic changes (as mentioned in the first post, a faction might want to kill him/protect him depending on who he targeted, plus i was going to add a couple things later on). and the guy who is playing this role has to think very carefully before taking action. Anyways as i said to bunny, constructive feedback is always welcome.
Regards

[Gzz]

The forbidden thing is a Blizzard issue , some time ago , when you can choose execution , were some joking names , but were considered offensive ( like , gas were "jew" , snipe "JFK" and so on )


This idea is quite without basis , i suggest to reconsidered this role

[Chane]

sorry but its very very bad.

[Bunny]

How is this offensive? This is a game about murder, corruption (see Blackmailer), primitive law enforcement (lynching based on voting, regardless of actual evidence, leading to the execution of innocents) and all kinds of violence. How is rape more offensive than this? Also, i'm italian: should i feel offended because you guys play and have fun with a game that lets you impersonate a criminal organization that brings death and suffering to my people on a daily basis? I really don't understand your point: either you take this game for what it is (something to have fun with) or you don't, in which case you shouldn't play it to begin with. Anyways, if you want to suggest a better name you are more than welcome, i chose this because i found it fitting with his effects.



For the "bullshit" part refer to the above paragraph. I didn't know it was forbidden (i find it a bit odd actually), but since i'm not the one who implements the game ( him being DR), it is none of my business: what i'm interested in suggeting is the role/mechanic, not the name per se. On the contribution of this role to the game.....i'm obviously open to suggestions: my idea was to introduce a role that could hinder the performance of any faction without being as disruptive as, say, a SK, while also causing some strategic changes (as mentioned in the first post, a faction might want to kill him/protect him depending on who he targeted, plus i was going to add a couple things later on). and the guy who is playing this role has to think very carefully before taking action. Anyways as i said to bunny, constructive feedback is always welcome.
Regards

i find it offensive because i know what rape can do to a person and because it's only towards women. Also, its just a pointless role.

Edit: If you included supposed men roles in it I would find it less offensive.

[Lazers]

witch

female

no fuck you

also consorts and escorts aren't necessarily female

[Aganos]

i find it offensive because i know what rape can do to a person and because it's only towards women. Also, its just a pointless role.

Edit: If you included supposed men roles in it I would find it less offensive.

I might be wrong, but i think being killed isn't a pleasurable experience either. So, if you are offended by a fictional role because of its real life implications, do you find the existence of in-game roles such as Mafia, Serial Killer, Arsonist and Mass Murderer to be also offensive? If so, why do you play a game you find offensive? and if not, do you realize this is an obvious incoherence? From your posts (and profile picture) i think i can safely assume you are a woman, which would explain why you feel so touched by my suggestion, but then again, you should feel touched by themes such as murder too, as a human being. So, if you want to be incoherent and tolerate (and presumably even enjoy) the main theme of this game while feeling offended by another (suggested) one which is (at best) equivalent, good, this is none of my business, but have the decency to either:
A) refrain from posting on the matter
B) do it in a polite way, because i found your reply to be unwelcoming (this being my first post in these forums) to say the least

[Aganos]

no fuck you

also consorts and escorts aren't necessarily female

not necessarily, but the cases in which all these terms are used to define a woman rather than a man are overwhelmingly more frequent than the opposite. In the context of this suggestion it should be sufficiently clear to anyone why this approximation was made.

Also, is there a way to report users on these forums?

[Bunny]

I might be wrong, but i think being killed isn't a pleasurable experience either. So, if you are offended by a fictional role because of its real life implications, do you find the existence of in-game roles such as Mafia, Serial Killer, Arsonist and Mass Murderer to be also offensive? If so, why do you play a game you find offensive? and if not, do you realize this is an obvious incoherence? From your posts (and profile picture) i think i can safely assume you are a woman, which would explain why you feel so touched by my suggestion, but then again, you should feel touched by themes such as murder too, as a human being. So, if you want to be incoherent and tolerate (and presumably even enjoy) the main theme of this game while feeling offended by another (suggested) one which is (at best) equivalent, good, this is none of my business, but have the decency to either:
A) refrain from posting on the matter
B) do it in a polite way, because i found your reply to be unwelcoming (this being my first post in these forums) to say the least

No one seems to like your role. I'm sorry i had to be the first to say it.

[Aganos]

No one seems to like your role. I'm sorry i had to be the first to say it.

I have no problem with you guys not liking the suggestion, it's the hostility/ bad manners that come with it that i find quite uncalled for

[Bunny]

I have no problem with you guys not liking the suggestion, it's the hostility/ bad manners that come with it that i find quite uncalled for

well that's the internet for ya.

[Raptorblaze]

I think it's fairly justified in this case. Also closing thread because yeah...

Also blizzard bans offensive names like this (mostly in reference to sexual crimes)