allow Janitor to forge a last will
Register

User Tag List

View Poll Results: what do you think about this change?

Voters
20. You may not vote on this poll
  • I like it, default should be on

    8 40.00%
  • I like it, default should be off

    5 25.00%
  • I don't like it, (comment down below)

    7 35.00%
Results 1 to 34 of 34
  1. ISO #1

    allow Janitor to forge a last will

    simple addition based on FM.

    Option:
    -the Janitor can forge a last will for the target but leave the role open on/off default: off

    if the option is turned on the janitor will have 2 buttons to choose from per name. the first one erasing name and lw and the second one revealing role but forging a last will.

    when the forge button is pressed a -lw box appears where you can write a custom lw for the target. you will not see the targets current last will. if the janitor does not finish the lw by pressing the square button that writes it the target will simply be cleaned

    Meta implications: will make the Janitor a more skillful role to play, because you must decide between the 2. also adds a whole new layer of WIFOM. if a sheriff dies and you forge a -lw in which mob members are ns that can help, but if one of these dies and the role is shown town knows it was a forged last will. also if the target was lets say and escort and you give him a sheriff -lw then you wasted a clean.

    this means it's equal in power to the normal clean as you can set up plans at this cost. it will be a fun addition imo.

    pro's:
    -adds a new layer of WIFOM
    -makes janitor more fun/versatile to play
    -is balanced because of the 2 drawbacks
    -risk reward
    -its an option so you can choose to have it or not.

    con's
    -pubs might misuse this and not know how to forge the last will. (in this case a normal clean happens so this is countered)
    -makes janitor harder to learn for pubs

    I would like to /discuss the option and if it should be default on/off

    I have the opinion that it should be off in default so hosts can choose so I will vote for that
    Last edited by Chane; September 22nd, 2012 at 05:20 AM.
    G: 15 | W: 13 | MVP: 2
    S-FM Casino: Town (WIN) S-FM BSDL:Detective (WIN)S-FM PCS: Subject X (Arsonist) (WIN/MVP) S-FM Mani: Citizen (WIN) FM-XV Rebel/Haunter (WIN) S-FM Prelude: doctor (WIN/MVP) S-FM HotD: (town/loss) S-FM L&D: Lookout (WIN) S-FM BL: Framer (WIN) M-FM XIII Vigilante/Subject XVI (WIN/MVRIP) S-FM SE: Mafioso: (WIN) S-FM Flashmob 1: Doctor (Win) Fmob 2: SK (Coulda/Woulda/Shoulda) S-FM BT: Sheriff (WIN) S-FM Websites: Citizen (WIN)

  2. ISO #2

  3. ISO #3

  4. ISO #4

    Re: allow Janitor to forge a last will

    Quote Originally Posted by MrMostache View Post
    A consi+janitor would be very powerful with this. Not to metion it's already powerful as it is.
    it would, but this allows a host to balance his set-up based on this. maybe he has cons+janitor+mafioso, sacing the power of a godfather for more deception

    its meant as an option for this reason
    G: 15 | W: 13 | MVP: 2
    S-FM Casino: Town (WIN) S-FM BSDL:Detective (WIN)S-FM PCS: Subject X (Arsonist) (WIN/MVP) S-FM Mani: Citizen (WIN) FM-XV Rebel/Haunter (WIN) S-FM Prelude: doctor (WIN/MVP) S-FM HotD: (town/loss) S-FM L&D: Lookout (WIN) S-FM BL: Framer (WIN) M-FM XIII Vigilante/Subject XVI (WIN/MVRIP) S-FM SE: Mafioso: (WIN) S-FM Flashmob 1: Doctor (Win) Fmob 2: SK (Coulda/Woulda/Shoulda) S-FM BT: Sheriff (WIN) S-FM Websites: Citizen (WIN)

  5. ISO #5

  6. ISO #6

    Re: allow Janitor to forge a last will

    Quote Originally Posted by Fatalis View Post
    1. It is overpowered
    2. It will mindfck the pubs
    exactly how would this be overpowered? just wondering but the 2 main drawbacks balance it if you compare it with the normal clean + erase if
    G: 15 | W: 13 | MVP: 2
    S-FM Casino: Town (WIN) S-FM BSDL:Detective (WIN)S-FM PCS: Subject X (Arsonist) (WIN/MVP) S-FM Mani: Citizen (WIN) FM-XV Rebel/Haunter (WIN) S-FM Prelude: doctor (WIN/MVP) S-FM HotD: (town/loss) S-FM L&D: Lookout (WIN) S-FM BL: Framer (WIN) M-FM XIII Vigilante/Subject XVI (WIN/MVRIP) S-FM SE: Mafioso: (WIN) S-FM Flashmob 1: Doctor (Win) Fmob 2: SK (Coulda/Woulda/Shoulda) S-FM BT: Sheriff (WIN) S-FM Websites: Citizen (WIN)

  7. ISO #7

    Re: allow Janitor to forge a last will

    Quote Originally Posted by Chane View Post
    exactly how would this be overpowered? just wondering but the 2 main drawbacks balance it if you compare it with the normal clean + erase if
    Here, if you erase the role, people will know that it is either cleaned or disguiser.
    If you know that X is a trusted person/sheriff/detective/lookout/whatever, you can forge the last will claiming Y to be innocent or stuffs like that. And normally in Pubs if they see a dead Sheriff with a last will they will 90% believe it. You get what I'm trying to say?

  8. ISO #8

  9. ISO #9

    Re: allow Janitor to forge a last will

    Quote Originally Posted by TRINITY View Post
    I suppose you could reveal dead roles, not change lw at all and try to tell them that it indeed is a fake lw.
    WIFOM

    G: 15 | W: 13 | MVP: 2
    S-FM Casino: Town (WIN) S-FM BSDL:Detective (WIN)S-FM PCS: Subject X (Arsonist) (WIN/MVP) S-FM Mani: Citizen (WIN) FM-XV Rebel/Haunter (WIN) S-FM Prelude: doctor (WIN/MVP) S-FM HotD: (town/loss) S-FM L&D: Lookout (WIN) S-FM BL: Framer (WIN) M-FM XIII Vigilante/Subject XVI (WIN/MVRIP) S-FM SE: Mafioso: (WIN) S-FM Flashmob 1: Doctor (Win) Fmob 2: SK (Coulda/Woulda/Shoulda) S-FM BT: Sheriff (WIN) S-FM Websites: Citizen (WIN)

  10. ISO #10

  11. ISO #11

    Re: allow Janitor to forge a last will

    Quote Originally Posted by LeaD View Post
    Fabricator needed :9
    i'd rather have a fabricator, cuz it increases the coroners usefulness by atleast 50%.
    never heard of that role, you aren't leaking aren't you :o searching for it now
    G: 15 | W: 13 | MVP: 2
    S-FM Casino: Town (WIN) S-FM BSDL:Detective (WIN)S-FM PCS: Subject X (Arsonist) (WIN/MVP) S-FM Mani: Citizen (WIN) FM-XV Rebel/Haunter (WIN) S-FM Prelude: doctor (WIN/MVP) S-FM HotD: (town/loss) S-FM L&D: Lookout (WIN) S-FM BL: Framer (WIN) M-FM XIII Vigilante/Subject XVI (WIN/MVRIP) S-FM SE: Mafioso: (WIN) S-FM Flashmob 1: Doctor (Win) Fmob 2: SK (Coulda/Woulda/Shoulda) S-FM BT: Sheriff (WIN) S-FM Websites: Citizen (WIN)

  12. ISO #12

  13. ISO #13

  14. ISO #14

  15. ISO #15

    Re: allow Janitor to forge a last will

    Quote Originally Posted by Slaol View Post
    Nice concept. Just need a Mafia role that does this and nothing else. But wouldn't it be apparent, since the last will showed up, instead of being cleaned?
    no because the role is not cleaned ;)
    G: 15 | W: 13 | MVP: 2
    S-FM Casino: Town (WIN) S-FM BSDL:Detective (WIN)S-FM PCS: Subject X (Arsonist) (WIN/MVP) S-FM Mani: Citizen (WIN) FM-XV Rebel/Haunter (WIN) S-FM Prelude: doctor (WIN/MVP) S-FM HotD: (town/loss) S-FM L&D: Lookout (WIN) S-FM BL: Framer (WIN) M-FM XIII Vigilante/Subject XVI (WIN/MVRIP) S-FM SE: Mafioso: (WIN) S-FM Flashmob 1: Doctor (Win) Fmob 2: SK (Coulda/Woulda/Shoulda) S-FM BT: Sheriff (WIN) S-FM Websites: Citizen (WIN)

  16. ISO #16

  17. ISO #17

    Re: Re : allow Janitor to forge a last will

    Quote Originally Posted by Tensa View Post
    It's a good idea but maybe you should have charge for this ability cause if you have unlimited charge you can abuse and maybe coroner should have same but for discover the true lw like someone said highter
    its limited to the same charge system as clean
    G: 15 | W: 13 | MVP: 2
    S-FM Casino: Town (WIN) S-FM BSDL:Detective (WIN)S-FM PCS: Subject X (Arsonist) (WIN/MVP) S-FM Mani: Citizen (WIN) FM-XV Rebel/Haunter (WIN) S-FM Prelude: doctor (WIN/MVP) S-FM HotD: (town/loss) S-FM L&D: Lookout (WIN) S-FM BL: Framer (WIN) M-FM XIII Vigilante/Subject XVI (WIN/MVRIP) S-FM SE: Mafioso: (WIN) S-FM Flashmob 1: Doctor (Win) Fmob 2: SK (Coulda/Woulda/Shoulda) S-FM BT: Sheriff (WIN) S-FM Websites: Citizen (WIN)

  18. ISO #18

  19. ISO #19

  20. ISO #20

  21. ISO #21

    Re: allow Janitor to forge a last will

    Quote Originally Posted by Chane View Post
    no because the role is not cleaned ;)
    Missed that. Would still be kind of apparent if Janitor hadn't cleaned if he was around. Would kind of need to use all forges first before cleaning. I would much rather this idea be it's own role. If it gets in that isn't that OP, but giving Janitor; which i tend to think of as the 2nd best Mafia role (behind Godfather), more options just is too much, i think.

    I support the mechanic, but would prefer a 'Forger' role, or this going on Framer.

  22. ISO #22

    Re: allow Janitor to forge a last will

    Janitor is already a very powerful role, I recommend you give this to a framer which has become under powered since he doesn't affect 2 of the investigative roles and he is supposed to be good at forgery.

    You wouldn't even need to add buttons, give him one charge and if he has written a forged will and his target dies then he forges the will, otherwise he just frames the player he targeted.

  23. ISO #23

    Re: allow Janitor to forge a last will

    Quote Originally Posted by maccabbe View Post
    Janitor is already a very powerful role, I recommend you give this to a framer which has become under powered since he doesn't affect 2 of the investigative roles and he is supposed to be good at forgery.

    You wouldn't even need to add buttons, give him one charge and if he has written a forged will and his target dies then he forges the will, otherwise he just frames the player he targeted.
    This is an idea i can support.

  24. ISO #24

  25. ISO #25

    Re: allow Janitor to forge a last will

    Quote Originally Posted by creedkingsx View Post
    This is something that would be useless to most pubs. They would sheep around like herp tards.
    Meh, not too for it just because of that.
    I don't like it for SC2. It's great for FM though.
    Pubs can't handle it.
    Quote Originally Posted by Kusco View Post
    Dirty fucking swiss neutral

  26. ISO #26

  27. ISO #27

  28. ISO #28

    Re: allow Janitor to forge a last will

    Quote Originally Posted by Damus_Graves View Post
    I dont know what your talking about
    Quote Originally Posted by S-FM Revenge Of The Trolls
    Janitor: Cleanse the body of whoever was killed that night or forge a last will.
    its been in my setups for a while now.
    Quote Originally Posted by Kusco View Post
    Dirty fucking swiss neutral

  29. ISO #29

  30. ISO #30

    Re: allow Janitor to forge a last will

    Quote Originally Posted by creedkingsx View Post
    This is something that would be useless to most pubs. They would sheep around like herp tards.
    Meh, not too for it just because of that.
    I vote we force pubs to learn to be smart.

    I also vote that it makes more sense as part of the Framer role (or part of a new role entirely) instead of the Janitor role.

  31. ISO #31

    Re: allow Janitor to forge a last will

    Quote Originally Posted by RLVG View Post
    Imagine public.

    Confirmed Sheriff :
    "7 Gasoline, 4 Knives, 12 Arsenal, 14 Loner"
    I'd be like: "How the fuck did a Sheriff get these results?"

    Quote Originally Posted by S-FM Blue Masquerader View Post
    Hey moron. shut the fuck up or I will shut you up, k? I'm not the person your going to insult and live happily ever after. K? Understand that,

  32. ISO #32

  33. ISO #33

  34. ISO #34

    Re: allow Janitor to forge a last will

    Quote Originally Posted by Glip View Post
    I'd hypothetically be like: "Lol, fail framer"

    Or janitor, or whatever hypothetical role would hypothetically have this hypothetical ability.

    fixed

    Quote Originally Posted by S-FM Blue Masquerader View Post
    Hey moron. shut the fuck up or I will shut you up, k? I'm not the person your going to insult and live happily ever after. K? Understand that,

 

 

Similar Threads

  1. s-fm Forge
    By Chane in forum Setup Workshop
    Replies: 18
    Last Post: January 25th, 2013, 06:33 AM
  2. Janitor change
    By Chane in forum Mafia Discussion
    Replies: 26
    Last Post: September 7th, 2012, 06:24 AM
  3. Janitor isn't manly enough.
    By Bazar in forum Mafia Bug Archive
    Replies: 8
    Last Post: March 6th, 2012, 08:04 AM
  4. Janitor discussion
    By Searix in forum Mafia Discussion
    Replies: 5
    Last Post: April 28th, 2011, 03:33 PM

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •