Vectra: 2-S2-1-2287863; TheBrute: 2-S2-1-2274583

[Johny Muffin]

Account Name: Vectra
Account ID: 2-S2-1-2287863
In-Game Name: Darth Tyrannos

Account Name: TheBrute
Account ID: 2-S2-1-2274583
In-Game Name: Pio Koon

Crimes Committed: Cheating(skyping)
Your Account Name: JohnyMuffin
Summary: My role was Serial killer. On N1 jailor jailed me. I've had my defense: claiming role of veteran. Shortly after that jailor said:"My friend in skype says that he is veteran". And after that i'm getting executed. Some things like that happened to godfather(auron).

[Capitalier]

This seems like a pretty clear-cut cheating case, as one player admits and the other partied member instantly goes on the defensive against any threats: suggesting other communication mediums and then insulting them for having no proof.

Vectra admitted to Skyping, and his Veteran pal TheBrute just loved to defend him. He did not hesitate against executing any veteran claims. (They were also right next to each other, as the icing on the cake.)


Attachment 5187Attachment 5188Attachment 5189Attachment 5190

Approved and 1-WK Watch List suggested for both of them, due to intent.

[Vectra]

I appeal this.

You need to learn to play your own game..

Mafia is a game of deception. i jailed the guy, told him a lie to see if he would give up his real role, it worked as intended, i execute him.

i am playing the game as intended, decieve other players and try to survive to the end.

unfairly on watch list, mods very unproffessional.

[Yayap]

After reviewing the replay, I agree with Capitaliers decision. In a game with a confirmed veteran on the role list, and no way for the jailor to know who it was, Skype is a very high probability.

The only thing I would add is TheBrute asking for role card reading before the latest update with the cards at the top.

[Mugy]

I appeal this.

You need to learn to play your own game..

Mafia is a game of deception. i jailed the guy, told him a lie to see if he would give up his real role, it worked as intended, i execute him.

i am playing the game as intended, decieve other players and try to survive to the end.

unfairly on watch list, mods very unproffessional.

Insulting a moderator isn't the best way for your appeal to be approved, even if you're right. Which in this case you're clearly not.

[Vectra]

Insulting a moderator isn't the best way for your appeal to be approved, even if you're right. Which in this case you're clearly not.

Were you sitting at my pc with me? watching?

you know nothing, so you can clearly get lost.

I don't even have skype.

you should state in the game loading screen that your not allowed to decieve your opponents, just under where it says about mafia being a game of deception

[Cryptonic]

Not Skype? How did you know he was vet then? Same room? Phone?

[creedkingsx]

I'm a little confused on what "ploy" you are talking about lol. He said his role, you said you were skyping he said the same role. there was no reason to execute him. You did nothing ingenious, you just acted like a scrub. Either that or you were using out of game communication. Take your pick.

[Dmpk]

I'm a little confused on what "ploy" you are talking about lol. He said his role, you said you were skyping he said the same role. there was no reason to execute him. You did nothing ingenious, you just acted like a scrub. Either that or you were using out of game communication. Take your pick.

Agreed.

I am not sitting at your computer. I am not even talking crap... but the guy never revealed any role other than vet.

You chose to kill him anyways, based on a statement you made that you were skyping (its in the game replay..)

With no evidence and your "partner" in crime in an adjacent slot, plus the obvious player favoring between you and him... How did you expect to appeal this?

It's just watchlist. you'll come off soon enough.