North American League Scoring

[SPazZTiK]

Please vote to help determine what scoring method we will use for league play.

[creedkingsx]

Do it by win in regards to tie order.
1 point for town/benign neutrals
2 for cult
3 for mafia/witch
4 for sk/Arson

[creedkingsx]

My problem with the suggested.
First doesn't account enough for the difficulty certain roles are compared to others.
Second doesn't account for it at all.
Third makes it so if something is overly strong in strength, they are easier to win as and will get an enormously greater amount of points.

[SPazZTiK]

Can you explain your suggestion in more detail?

[creedkingsx]

If you win as either Town or Benign Neutral, you receive 1 point toward the league points.
If you win as Cultist, you receive 2 points.
If you win as Mafia or Witch, you receive 3 points.
If you win as either Serial Killer/Mass Murderer/ Arsonist, you receive 4(5?) points.

Edit: I misread the third option, but it still seems overly complicated.

[SPazZTiK]

I think something like that could be worked out. We might need to figure out some probabilities and tweak it the points/role a bit, but that's viable.

[creedkingsx]

I think something like that could be worked out. We might need to figure out some probabilities and tweak it the points/role a bit, but that's viable.

Agreed, but I just think it doesn't need to be over complicated as recipricoling a number and multiplying and all that. Just be like, "Oh Arson? okay, you get 5 points. 3+5=8. ez."

[SPazZTiK]

I agree, the third method's probably too complicated for long term play. Whole numbers and addition would work best.

[creedkingsx]

[Mokyx]

I'll change the EU model, with something like 1 town jester amne, 2 survi mafia, 3 exe cultist, 4 sk arso mass murderer witch

[Damus_Graves]

Do it by strength.
If town is underpowered in a game and they win 2 points.
same with mafia if underpowered.
if everyone is equal (more or less) 1 point for the winners. (mafia and town only
1 point for survivior/ witch/ amnesiac wins.
1 point for executioner/ jester win.
2 points for serial killer/ arson win since their all alone

[Fatalis]

Do it by strength.
If town is underpowered in a game and they win 2 points.
same with mafia if underpowered.
if everyone is equal (more or less) 1 point for the winners. (mafia and town only
1 point for survivior/ witch/ amnesiac wins.
1 point for executioner/ jester win.
2 points for serial killer/ arson win since their all alone

How do you deterimine underpowered or not

[Mokyx]

ye mafia and down must be equal.
Exe is more hard since he have to survive all the game (if the setup say it).

[Damus_Graves]

ye mafia and down must be equal.
Exe is more hard since he have to survive all the game (if the setup say it).

most games dont require it.

[creedkingsx]

Well, presumably the setups would be pre approved and noted in here.
I suggest we do something like that, submit setup ideas and have people make those their saves. That way we know everything going into the night and we can make 1 simple system that doesn't need to be reliant on all this complicated stuff.

[Damus_Graves]

Well, presumably the setups would be pre approved and noted in here.
I suggest we do something like that, submit setup ideas and have people make those their saves. That way we know everything going into the night and we can make 1 simple system that doesn't need to be reliant on all this complicated stuff.

i can accept this.
y u so smart creed?

[creedkingsx]

i can accept this.
y u so smart creed?

Efficiency is what I do.

[Gingerape]

So how is this gonna work?
Will there be a leaderboard?

[SPazZTiK]

So how is this gonna work?
Will there be a leaderboard?

Yes, leaderboard is in the League[NA] thread.

[SPazZTiK]

I think a good argument has been made for awarding points based on the difficulty of the role and/or alignment. Europe has changed so a similar model as well, so we'll go with that for season 1. If we feel it needs to be tweaked after the first season, we can make those changes then.