
Originally Posted by
SickBoy is IntE
Some of these ideas would lead to people strictly going for them and potentially ruining a game in the process. However most seem pretty fun. Killing jester as vigi sounds awesome, but then again it will make a vigi random shoot anyone who shows the slightest bit of trolling. You know? I'm not directly opposing them, but gotta look at both sided.
^ agreed, encourages people to not play the game as a team, but to go out of their way and win achievements, in the metagame where pubs are already hard enough to get a gg. and some are just pointless. why has everyone gone on an achievement craze these past couple of years? even flash games are loaded with them, so pointless..the ones up now are cool just to see accomplishments.
"Eavesdropper - Listen to the Mafia for 3 nights as a Spy." why not just call this, survive three nights as spy?
"Clock - Investigate a person as Consigliere"
"Whack Em - Kill 3 townies as a Mafioso/Godfather."
"Taking the Shot - Protect somebody from a killing role as a Bodyguard." why wouldn't you do these anyway? isn't the point of achievements to do something out of the ordinary, or accomplish a difficult goal?
"Prepared - Write a last will." what's even the point of adding this in? it's like games that have the achievement: start the game, achievement unlocked.
tldr just had to let out a rant Lol..