Investigator Scenario

[stochastic]

Hey People,

I have a question regarding a particulare experience I just had in a game as investigator.

I was an Investigator and invested a player who seemed to had gas (either a bus driver or arsonist),
so the next day, I say: "Player-Name, what role are you?" - and he answers "I am Vigilante"
Then I say "Sorry mate, but it says that you have gas so you are either a Bus Driver or an Arsonist"
...and then he gets to trail, when he claims that he is Vigilante, and he starts trolling and seems very upset.
People votes him inno 5 against 4, and he survives. Then it gets night, and I get killed by the vigilante (which is a bit funny, but not at that givin' time).
Next day people is reading my lw, and it says that he is arso/bus driver and that I am Investigator.
So he get lynched again, because a Sheriff also claims him to be Arso, and somehow he is not trialed. Which results in him shooting the Sheriff the next night.
And I am really confused at this givin time, and the player is turning crazy - and calls the Sheriff and I for noobs, yadda yadda etc.

Then suddenly the Bus Driver is killed at night, and he has been switching the vigilante with the arsonist 3 nights in a row.

So here is my question, if the "vigilante" was lynched, would it not have been his own mistake, not to mention that he was swapped the night I invested him,
and then the bus driver could have confirmed. If both of them were more awake, they could have said, hey I switched player X with player Y, so therefor player Y is Arso.

Am I the bad Investigator here, or was it the Vigilante who should have told that he was swapped as well as the Bus Driver that should have woke up???

Thansk,

Yours Sincerely
Stochastic

[Damus_Graves]

He should have said i was bussed and the bus driver should have said i bussed him.

[creedkingsx]

Bus Driver is stupid, and the town is stupid.
And, specifically, that Vigilante is stupid.
You were fine, just reading investigative results.