[QUOTE=Stealthbomber16;910777]Out of ren/mesk I'd be more inclined to vote renegade here because it aligns with my previous beliefs but I don't really care about that interaction right now.
Right now we need to figure out what's up with Auwt and then we can figure out what's up with Mesk vs Renegade. Very suspicious that Matt isn't acknowledging the Auwt check?[/QUOTE]
Auwt is offline right now, and I'm trying to put Mesk in the hotseat. We spent most of D1 without a single serious train building. Frinckles was TPR hunting and may have Illuminati slipped. He would have made a better yeet than a no-yeet, but the fact that the biggest train had so little evidence was shit.
We're not doing that again today. If we just wait around to hear more from Auwt, we could be wasting half the day before we possibly come to realize we're just in setups A/D. I'd much rather have the question "how do we feel about Mesk v. Renegade?" settled BEFORE it's almost EoD.
If Auwt looks like plausible Illuminati, we're yeeting him. But if he doesn't, I want a viable backup plan. Mesk has looked scummy all game. Even MM didn't give her a "too bad to be scum" pass like he did for DM. If Auwt is town, Mesk's flip could resolve the game.
[QUOTE=Marshmallow Marshall;910778]Well, Team Occam's Razor tends to mislynch LHF townies all the time, whereas Team Intent Behind Actions tends to preserve them and sometimes (but quite rarely) give free passes to scum due to misreading intent.
~~~~~~~~~~
[SPOILER=My N1 thoughts that I put in my last will]I want to townread Mattzed, I really do, because he has done a lot of actually pro-town work; we wouldn't have that much info if it hadn't been of him, and he could very well have participated in the shitpost time and delayed information gathering as much as possible. I'm just not sure it's right because of the SB thing. It's not unbelievable that he felt bad about lynching Stealth at first, but it's quite unlikely: he showed rather clear intent to change his read in his very mind (or at least in what he claimed to be his very mind) when decided not to push Stealth at first. Could be a half-conscious bias in Stealth's favor, though, so nothing is set in stone about him. Honestly, I think Mattzed might be a non-Illuminati Mafia trying to figure out if there are Illuminati or not, and that is why he was truly pro-town early on. Anyway, MattZed is a minefield when it comes to reading him, so I can't have a final read on him; hopefully this helps.
I'm pretty sure SB is town due to his slot's history and due to his behavior when he replaced in, saying what his slot did was understable (since he has the information of being town himself).
Auwt's reasonings are relatable, and I tend to believe he's town because of how natural his progression seemed.
Frinckles is scummy: where are his reasonings? His focus was entirely on Martin until I called him out on it, point at which he started scumreading me even though he claims to have a townlean on me if he disregards my meta of always being hard to read for him...[/SPOILER]
I saw Martin claimed to have an Illuminati check on Auwt. Well uh, either my read on him is shit or we simply don't have illuminati. Both are possible, and I'll have to check that out.
The Frinckles kill actually makes me think I may have been right about Mattzed with my conspiracy theory of him being mafia trying to get rid of potential illuminati XD. Of course there's no evidence of that, but I'm slowly gaining confidence in that theory.[/QUOTE]
I really don't see how in the world you're distinguishing between the "too scummy to be scum" camp and "actually scum." Why was Mesk missing the context between us yesterday scummy but, say, DM asking us questions *we had already answered* wasn't?
Originally Posted by Stealthbomber16
Out of ren/mesk I'd be more inclined to vote renegade here because it aligns with my previous beliefs but I don't really care about that interaction right now.
Right now we need to figure out what's up with Auwt and then we can figure out what's up with Mesk vs Renegade. Very suspicious that Matt isn't acknowledging the Auwt check?
Auwt is offline right now, and I'm trying to put Mesk in the hotseat. We spent most of D1 without a single serious train building. Frinckles was TPR hunting and may have Illuminati slipped. He would have made a better yeet than a no-yeet, but the fact that the biggest train had so little evidence was shit.
We're not doing that again today. If we just wait around to hear more from Auwt, we could be wasting half the day before we possibly come to realize we're just in setups A/D. I'd much rather have the question "how do we feel about Mesk v. Renegade?" settled BEFORE it's almost EoD.
If Auwt looks like plausible Illuminati, we're yeeting him. But if he doesn't, I want a viable backup plan. Mesk has looked scummy all game. Even MM didn't give her a "too bad to be scum" pass like he did for DM. If Auwt is town, Mesk's flip could resolve the game.
Originally Posted by Marshmallow Marshall
Well, Team Occam's Razor tends to mislynch LHF townies all the time, whereas Team Intent Behind Actions tends to preserve them and sometimes (but quite rarely) give free passes to scum due to misreading intent.
~~~~~~~~~~
Spoiler : My N1 thoughts that I put in my last will :
I want to townread Mattzed, I really do, because he has done a lot of actually pro-town work; we wouldn't have that much info if it hadn't been of him, and he could very well have participated in the shitpost time and delayed information gathering as much as possible. I'm just not sure it's right because of the SB thing. It's not unbelievable that he felt bad about lynching Stealth at first, but it's quite unlikely: he showed rather clear intent to change his read in his very mind (or at least in what he claimed to be his very mind) when decided not to push Stealth at first. Could be a half-conscious bias in Stealth's favor, though, so nothing is set in stone about him. Honestly, I think Mattzed might be a non-Illuminati Mafia trying to figure out if there are Illuminati or not, and that is why he was truly pro-town early on. Anyway, MattZed is a minefield when it comes to reading him, so I can't have a final read on him; hopefully this helps.
I'm pretty sure SB is town due to his slot's history and due to his behavior when he replaced in, saying what his slot did was understable (since he has the information of being town himself).
Auwt's reasonings are relatable, and I tend to believe he's town because of how natural his progression seemed.
Frinckles is scummy: where are his reasonings? His focus was entirely on Martin until I called him out on it, point at which he started scumreading me even though he claims to have a townlean on me if he disregards my meta of always being hard to read for him...
I saw Martin claimed to have an Illuminati check on Auwt. Well uh, either my read on him is shit or we simply don't have illuminati. Both are possible, and I'll have to check that out.
The Frinckles kill actually makes me think I may have been right about Mattzed with my conspiracy theory of him being mafia trying to get rid of potential illuminati XD. Of course there's no evidence of that, but I'm slowly gaining confidence in that theory.
I really don't see how in the world you're distinguishing between the "too scummy to be scum" camp and "actually scum." Why was Mesk missing the context between us yesterday scummy but, say, DM asking us questions *we had already answered* wasn't?
[MENTION=29377]Marshmallow Marshall[/MENTION] , to give a fuller answer to "but Matt, why the 180 on SB yesterday???": It's because I stopped thinking about how is *SB* playing and started thinking about how the *slot* is playing. I cannot remotely fathom how you thought DM was playing too poorly to be scum. I'm much more on team "Occam's Razor."
@Marshmallow Marshall
, to give a fuller answer to "but Matt, why the 180 on SB yesterday???": It's because I stopped thinking about how is *SB* playing and started thinking about how the *slot* is playing. I cannot remotely fathom how you thought DM was playing too poorly to be scum. I'm much more on team "Occam's Razor."
Even if you're not 100% sold on yeeting Mesk right now, AT LEAST VOTE. If we're in an Illuminati setup right now, it's 5v3. We literally need all of the non-Illuminati to vote.
Even if you're not 100% sold on yeeting Mesk right now, AT LEAST VOTE. If we're in an Illuminati setup right now, it's 5v3. We literally need all of the non-Illuminati to vote.
There's something incredibly fake about the Renegade-Mesk interactions right now. They're suspicious of each other but aren't voting it.
Of the two, I'm *definitely* voting Mesk. She may have legit scumslipped by revealing that Renegade is "consig." We can find out when she dies if she's a consig or a purple sheriff who didn't read her rolecard. Mesk has been suspicious all game, and Renegade has generally been on the same page as me/MM. This isn't a hard vote for me, and it shouldn't be for the rest of y'all either.
[vote]Mesk514[/vote]
There's something incredibly fake about the Renegade-Mesk interactions right now. They're suspicious of each other but aren't voting it.
Of the two, I'm *definitely* voting Mesk. She may have legit scumslipped by revealing that Renegade is "consig." We can find out when she dies if she's a consig or a purple sheriff who didn't read her rolecard. Mesk has been suspicious all game, and Renegade has generally been on the same page as me/MM. This isn't a hard vote for me, and it shouldn't be for the rest of y'all either.
Frinckles seemed before like he thought I was cit and wanted to make me a more attractive night kill. Idk why he’s abandoned that. Was he actually TPR hunting instead of making NK WIFOM?
Frinckles seemed before like he thought I was cit and wanted to make me a more attractive night kill. Idk why he’s abandoned that. Was he actually TPR hunting instead of making NK WIFOM?
I don’t know how else to say I legit felt guilty about the possibility of yeeting SB right after he replaced in. I was hoping someone else would end up being scummier, but that didnt happen
I don’t know how else to say I legit felt guilty about the possibility of yeeting SB right after he replaced in. I was hoping someone else would end up being scummier, but that didnt happen
Mesk and Frinckles both full of OMGUS. Their suspects are literally just the people who have voted them. They both townread DM. (But so did Martin so *maybe* theres something Im missing)
Mesk and Frinckles both full of OMGUS. Their suspects are literally just the people who have voted them. They both townread DM. (But so did Martin so *maybe* theres something Im missing)
On my phone. At this point, I can get behind a Mesk or Frinckles yeet if y’all REALLY think SB is non-Illuminati town.
For the pings on “why did you switch from giving SB a pass to voting for him?” Two reasons: 1. I was hoping we’d have enough pressure to trial one of Mesk/Frinckles/Auwt/yzb, but that didnt happen. 2. I realized the math ONLY supports a no-yeet if I think there’s an Illuminati but the top suspects aren’t in it.
On my phone. At this point, I can get behind a Mesk or Frinckles yeet if y’all REALLY think SB is non-Illuminati town.
For the pings on “why did you switch from giving SB a pass to voting for him?” Two reasons: 1. I was hoping we’d have enough pressure to trial one of Mesk/Frinckles/Auwt/yzb, but that didnt happen. 2. I realized the math ONLY supports a no-yeet if I think there’s an Illuminati but the top suspects aren’t in it.
[QUOTE=MattZed;910510]I'm off for now. I will *probably* be back in time for EoD, but if I'm not, I completely stand by yeeting SB. Unless SB has secretly been *mayor* this whole time, I don't think there's anything that could happen in the next 6 hours that could convince me there's a better target.[/QUOTE]
Actually, I would 100% yeet SB if he revealed as mayor. A town mayor knows for a fact we're in setup D. DM spent waaaaaay too much time actively speculating that there's an Illuminati to be a town mayor.
Originally Posted by MattZed
I'm off for now. I will *probably* be back in time for EoD, but if I'm not, I completely stand by yeeting SB. Unless SB has secretly been *mayor* this whole time, I don't think there's anything that could happen in the next 6 hours that could convince me there's a better target.
Actually, I would 100% yeet SB if he revealed as mayor. A town mayor knows for a fact we're in setup D. DM spent waaaaaay too much time actively speculating that there's an Illuminati to be a town mayor.
I'm off for now. I will *probably* be back in time for EoD, but if I'm not, I completely stand by yeeting SB. Unless SB has secretly been *mayor* this whole time, I don't think there's anything that could happen in the next 6 hours that could convince me there's a better target.
I'm off for now. I will *probably* be back in time for EoD, but if I'm not, I completely stand by yeeting SB. Unless SB has secretly been *mayor* this whole time, I don't think there's anything that could happen in the next 6 hours that could convince me there's a better target.
No yeet only makes sense if we think there's an Illuminati AND SB isn't in it. I actually find this hard to believe. So it's between yeeting SB and going for a random/policy yeet.
Yeah, I'm going with SB. The only way this can come back to kill us is if there's an Illuminati and SB's not in it.
[vote]Stealthbomber16[/vote]
To repeat the case on DM/SB one last time: DM hasn't made sense, he didn't use his top-poster status to steer town productively, his reads make no sense, everything he says is really just to back up what he said in his third post (that me and MM are scum together), and he's discredited me, MM, and Renegade several times.
If you want more details on any of the above, just look through my posts. I've spelled out each of these in more detail at least once.
If we're in setup A/D, a no-yeet is just throwing away a chance to yeet mafia. If we're in B/C/E/F, we're in trouble only if we yeet non-Illuminati. I know I'm not Illuminati, and I know Martin isn't. Of the 7 of you left, THREE would be Illuminati. There's just no way DM/SB isn't one of them if that's the case.
No yeet only makes sense if we think there's an Illuminati AND SB isn't in it. I actually find this hard to believe. So it's between yeeting SB and going for a random/policy yeet.
Yeah, I'm going with SB. The only way this can come back to kill us is if there's an Illuminati and SB's not in it.
-vote Stealthbomber16
To repeat the case on DM/SB one last time: DM hasn't made sense, he didn't use his top-poster status to steer town productively, his reads make no sense, everything he says is really just to back up what he said in his third post (that me and MM are scum together), and he's discredited me, MM, and Renegade several times.
If you want more details on any of the above, just look through my posts. I've spelled out each of these in more detail at least once.
If we're in setup A/D, a no-yeet is just throwing away a chance to yeet mafia. If we're in B/C/E/F, we're in trouble only if we yeet non-Illuminati. I know I'm not Illuminati, and I know Martin isn't. Of the 7 of you left, THREE would be Illuminati. There's just no way DM/SB isn't one of them if that's the case.
We're less than 7 hours to EoD. As far as I see, we only have about 3 options:
1. Yeet SB anyways because his slot was looking incredibly scummy before
2. Random/policy yeet someone
3. No yeet
I'm honestly torn between all three, but I'm leaning toward the first one. I don't think any amount of pressure is going to make someone look as scummy as DM was. There's no point in going after someone for being scummy if we're just going to ignore DM's slot. If Martin's not checking SB, then we're not going to get any information on him and still have this problem to resolve tomorrow.
If there is an Illuminati, we might not be able to afford to misyeet today. (setups E/F could give Illuminati the ability to instahammer D2 by revealing their Mayor) But we *could* afford to no-yeet. It just means, assuming the Mafia NK doesn't hit Illuminati, we're in a 5v3 tomorrow and need to unanimously vote to yeet Illuminati. If we no-yeet today, I would 100% yeet anyone who turns up as Illuminati to Martin.
If there isn't an Illuminati, a misyeet today probably leaves us 4v2v1 tomorrow as opposed to 5v2v1. I'd personally prefer to have two opportunities to yeet Mafia (D1 and D2) as opposed to having to rely on Martin recanting and townsiding.
But then again, my gut answer to "why didn't DM get more votes?" is that he's in an Illuminati and his partners weren't voting him.
We're less than 7 hours to EoD. As far as I see, we only have about 3 options:
1. Yeet SB anyways because his slot was looking incredibly scummy before
2. Random/policy yeet someone
3. No yeet
I'm honestly torn between all three, but I'm leaning toward the first one. I don't think any amount of pressure is going to make someone look as scummy as DM was. There's no point in going after someone for being scummy if we're just going to ignore DM's slot. If Martin's not checking SB, then we're not going to get any information on him and still have this problem to resolve tomorrow.
If there is an Illuminati, we might not be able to afford to misyeet today. (setups E/F could give Illuminati the ability to instahammer D2 by revealing their Mayor) But we *could* afford to no-yeet. It just means, assuming the Mafia NK doesn't hit Illuminati, we're in a 5v3 tomorrow and need to unanimously vote to yeet Illuminati. If we no-yeet today, I would 100% yeet anyone who turns up as Illuminati to Martin.
If there isn't an Illuminati, a misyeet today probably leaves us 4v2v1 tomorrow as opposed to 5v2v1. I'd personally prefer to have two opportunities to yeet Mafia (D1 and D2) as opposed to having to rely on Martin recanting and townsiding.
But then again, my gut answer to "why didn't DM get more votes?" is that he's in an Illuminati and his partners weren't voting him.
[QUOTE=Auwt;910485]I actually believe there is at least 1 scum between Mesk and Frinckles.
Those are my current suspections.
You can have fun looking yzb or me but I don't think there will be much interest of doing it.[/QUOTE]
nvm I'm bad at scrolling up.
Auwt, why aren't you voting either of them?
Originally Posted by Auwt
I actually believe there is at least 1 scum between Mesk and Frinckles.
Those are my current suspections.
You can have fun looking yzb or me but I don't think there will be much interest of doing it.
I'm just burned out at this point.
[MENTION=29012]Auwt[/MENTION], while you're here, who are your top scumreads? (or, if you're still only reading people as town/null, who are your least-town nullreads?)
I'm just burned out at this point.
@Auwt
, while you're here, who are your top scumreads? (or, if you're still only reading people as town/null, who are your least-town nullreads?)
1. Matt and MM share a night chat, and AT LEAST Matt is Illuminati
2. Frinckles and Renegade share a night chat AND Renegade is the one in the Illuminati but Frinckles isn't
3. yzb is town and is thus removed from the picture
That's how I think he built his scenarios. For the scenarios where the above assumptions didn't fill in the entire Illuminati, he figured Mesk was the last Illuminati. But he didn't mention why it had to be Mesk instead of you, the other person he hadn't cleared. (this was not the only part of his logic I couldn't follow)
Originally Posted by Auwt
Wait what?
DM's thought process seemed to be this:
1. Matt and MM share a night chat, and AT LEAST Matt is Illuminati
2. Frinckles and Renegade share a night chat AND Renegade is the one in the Illuminati but Frinckles isn't
3. yzb is town and is thus removed from the picture
That's how I think he built his scenarios. For the scenarios where the above assumptions didn't fill in the entire Illuminati, he figured Mesk was the last Illuminati. But he didn't mention why it had to be Mesk instead of you, the other person he hadn't cleared. (this was not the only part of his logic I couldn't follow)
[QUOTE=MartinGG99;910447]I would press X to doubt.
After all, I did say that I thought (and still do) believe you + DM's slot were town.
But if quite a few people want me to then I guess I can check his slot instead of the person I thought of earlier today.[/QUOTE]
Your sole job is find Illuminati if they exist. If you think someone is more likely to be Illuminati, go ahead and check them instead. I think DM was scummy and was more likely Illuminati than Mafia. I'd be very interested in having a better idea if he's Illuminati or not.
Like I said when you were busdriver, follow your own reads. If there's an Illuminati, there are THREE of them, and they really don't want you checking them. If checking Stealth wouldn't give you useful information, you don't have to. (For the record, if there is an Illuminati, I think they're not willing to take the risk and be all "oh no you shouldn't waste your time checking me." I think MM is town, and him being willing to agree with your lists reinforces my townread on him. If you want to keep to your original list, I think it was a good list and you wouldn't really go wrong.)
I'm off for real now.
Originally Posted by MartinGG99
I would press X to doubt.
After all, I did say that I thought (and still do) believe you + DM's slot were town.
But if quite a few people want me to then I guess I can check his slot instead of the person I thought of earlier today.
Your sole job is find Illuminati if they exist. If you think someone is more likely to be Illuminati, go ahead and check them instead. I think DM was scummy and was more likely Illuminati than Mafia. I'd be very interested in having a better idea if he's Illuminati or not.
Like I said when you were busdriver, follow your own reads. If there's an Illuminati, there are THREE of them, and they really don't want you checking them. If checking Stealth wouldn't give you useful information, you don't have to. (For the record, if there is an Illuminati, I think they're not willing to take the risk and be all "oh no you shouldn't waste your time checking me." I think MM is town, and him being willing to agree with your lists reinforces my townread on him. If you want to keep to your original list, I think it was a good list and you wouldn't really go wrong.)
I'm going to bed now. In the morning, I'm going to re-read Mesk in light of DM's replacement. I haven't liked anything she's posted, but I honestly stopped paying attention when DM started hard pinging my scumdar.
In the meantime, I'm appointing MM to lead the pressure trains.
[vote]Frinckles[/vote]
[MENTION=29377]Marshmallow Marshall[/MENTION], I'm trusting you to unvote if he gets to L-2 before I get back.
I'm going to bed now. In the morning, I'm going to re-read Mesk in light of DM's replacement. I haven't liked anything she's posted, but I honestly stopped paying attention when DM started hard pinging my scumdar.
In the meantime, I'm appointing MM to lead the pressure trains.
-vote Frinckles
@Marshmallow Marshall
, I'm trusting you to unvote if he gets to L-2 before I get back.
[QUOTE=Stealthbomber16;910439]Probably the game where unknown replaced in and correctly wildly guessed the doctor visited a specific target n1 and confirmed himself as “lookout” when he was a goon[/QUOTE]
That sounds about right, actually.
Originally Posted by Stealthbomber16
Probably the game where unknown replaced in and correctly wildly guessed the doctor visited a specific target n1 and confirmed himself as “lookout” when he was a goon
[QUOTE=Stealthbomber16;910433]Nah DMs play makes sense if you view it from someone who is incredibly tilted.
1. Playing his least favorite role in the game by a wide margin
2. Setup has a 50% chance to not have accurate flips (remember Magellan?)
3. Getting incorrectly pushed as cit
4. Nobody agrees with his reads or sees what he sees
I don’t agree with what he said and understand why he was being scumread but from the POV of knowing he was a citizen (even before I officially learned his role I knew he would be one since he was replacing out) his actions, although flawed, still make sense.[/QUOTE]
Yeah, you get to live at least one more day. This is exactly the sort of response I'd expect if someone replaced into DM's slot and was actually town.
If Martin gets an Illuminati check on you, prepare to defend your ass.
Originally Posted by Stealthbomber16
Nah DMs play makes sense if you view it from someone who is incredibly tilted.
1. Playing his least favorite role in the game by a wide margin
2. Setup has a 50% chance to not have accurate flips (remember Magellan?)
3. Getting incorrectly pushed as cit
4. Nobody agrees with his reads or sees what he sees
I don’t agree with what he said and understand why he was being scumread but from the POV of knowing he was a citizen (even before I officially learned his role I knew he would be one since he was replacing out) his actions, although flawed, still make sense.
Yeah, you get to live at least one more day. This is exactly the sort of response I'd expect if someone replaced into DM's slot and was actually town.
If Martin gets an Illuminati check on you, prepare to defend your ass.
[QUOTE=Marshmallow Marshall;910431]...Mesk works in mysterious ways, and I'd like to understand the move and to know the amount of seriousness behind it.[/QUOTE]
I'm also *deeply* interested in Mesk's thinking here. I think anyone, town or scum, can see that I'm not today's yeet. So why even bother pushing?
Originally Posted by Marshmallow Marshall
...Mesk works in mysterious ways, and I'd like to understand the move and to know the amount of seriousness behind it.
I'm also *deeply* interested in Mesk's thinking here. I think anyone, town or scum, can see that I'm not today's yeet. So why even bother pushing?
I... instinctively trust that SB is telling the truth. I like MM's test, but then again I recall a pre-retirement game where scum won because someone had a very specific roleclaim on the spot. (@Mesk514, I think we were in that game, and that scum may have been you)
As much as I had a hard scumread on DM, I think the best play at this point is to have Martin check Stealth tonight. I was suspecting DM being more likely Illuminati than Mafia, and I'd really like to find out. We can resolve his slot D2.
I... instinctively trust that SB is telling the truth. I like MM's test, but then again I recall a pre-retirement game where scum won because someone had a very specific roleclaim on the spot. (@Mesk514, I think we were in that game, and that scum may have been you)
As much as I had a hard scumread on DM, I think the best play at this point is to have Martin check Stealth tonight. I was suspecting DM being more likely Illuminati than Mafia, and I'd really like to find out. We can resolve his slot D2.
[QUOTE=Renegade;910364]Well I think DM slot will solve itself soon enough. He is fixated on the worlds he has built, very narrow mind you, so I'm not sure he needs to be lynched today. But I can be convinced.[/QUOTE]
I'm going to ISO him in about 14 hours. (unless I can get to it IRL tonight) If I can't convince you by then, you're not sincere in being suspicious of DM.
[QUOTE=Renegade;910368]Again, his [DM] first post and extreme whiplash pivot are the most suspicious things to me, not that he scum reads me. He got an insanely poor reaction to his opener and so did a 180.
Who hands out town points for someone saying "i am the best mis lynch today"???[/QUOTE]
Who hands out town points to someone who won't even bother to find a post where someone allegedly scumslipped? Who hands out town points to someone who only townreads people who are suspicious of him? Who gives out townpoints to someone who asks "give me your top TR" to two people [I]who already gave reads on everyone[/I]? Who hands out townpoints to someone who accuses his townread of lying about their roleclaim? Who hands out town points to someone who pretends to not read the setup?
Originally Posted by Renegade
Well I think DM slot will solve itself soon enough. He is fixated on the worlds he has built, very narrow mind you, so I'm not sure he needs to be lynched today. But I can be convinced.
I'm going to ISO him in about 14 hours. (unless I can get to it IRL tonight) If I can't convince you by then, you're not sincere in being suspicious of DM.
Originally Posted by Renegade
Again, his [DM] first post and extreme whiplash pivot are the most suspicious things to me, not that he scum reads me. He got an insanely poor reaction to his opener and so did a 180.
Who hands out town points for someone saying "i am the best mis lynch today"???
Who hands out town points to someone who won't even bother to find a post where someone allegedly scumslipped? Who hands out town points to someone who only townreads people who are suspicious of him? Who gives out townpoints to someone who asks "give me your top TR" to two people who already gave reads on everyone? Who hands out townpoints to someone who accuses his townread of lying about their roleclaim? Who hands out town points to someone who pretends to not read the setup?
I simply do not understand how the highest-poster is being read as a lazy/confused town. Is it because y'all are too lazy to ISO him? Is it because of some kind of meta read?
I simply do not understand how the highest-poster is being read as a lazy/confused town. Is it because y'all are too lazy to ISO him? Is it because of some kind of meta read?
[QUOTE=Mesk514;910357]Omg yes, you caught us, congratulations, mvp right here [/QUOTE]
Bruh, why are you only voting me for pressuring you instead of voting DM for accusing you of being the last scum with almost no basis? (How in the world DM is putting Mesk on a scumteam with me instead of filling in Auwt with the PoE...)
Originally Posted by Mesk514
Omg yes, you caught us, congratulations, mvp right here
Bruh, why are you only voting me for pressuring you instead of voting DM for accusing you of being the last scum with almost no basis? (How in the world DM is putting Mesk on a scumteam with me instead of filling in Auwt with the PoE...)
@MarshmallowMarshall, [MENTION=30852]Renegade[/MENTION], I know you're at least a little suspicious of DM. Why stay on a Frinckles train right now?
[MENTION=28193]Mesk514[/MENTION], if you're town, I'm willing to re-read you if you take another look at DM's posts.
@MarshmallowMarshall,
@Renegade
, I know you're at least a little suspicious of DM. Why stay on a Frinckles train right now?
@Mesk514
, if you're town, I'm willing to re-read you if you take another look at DM's posts.
tbh, I'm deeply suspicious of the fact that DM's train only has two people on it. [MENTION=29012]Auwt[/MENTION], [MENTION=8570]yzb25[/MENTION], [MENTION=34329]Frinckles[/MENTION], do you *really* townread this man?
tbh, I'm deeply suspicious of the fact that DM's train only has two people on it.
@Auwt
,
@yzb25
,
@Frinckles
, do you *really* townread this man?
[QUOTE=Dark Magician;910342]Well then how TF am I suppose to get credit when you don’t even flip your scum role.[/QUOTE]
Playing stupid now to play to everyone's "DM just makes shitty plays without thinking them through" bias isn't helping your case.
If you're town, there's no reason for the charade. If you actually think I'm scum, just make the case. Don't feign ignorance to deflect attention off of yourself.
Originally Posted by Dark Magician
Well then how TF am I suppose to get credit when you don’t even flip your scum role.
Playing stupid now to play to everyone's "DM just makes shitty plays without thinking them through" bias isn't helping your case.
If you're town, there's no reason for the charade. If you actually think I'm scum, just make the case. Don't feign ignorance to deflect attention off of yourself.
I'm heading off for a while. I'm still *very* interested in hearing a defense of DM other than "if he were scum he wouldn't be this bad at it." (from MM)
I'm heading off for a while. I'm still *very* interested in hearing a defense of DM other than "if he were scum he wouldn't be this bad at it." (from MM)
For the record, I think I'm scumreading Mesk for different reasons than MM: My scumread is based on Mesk's OMGUS reaction and lack of willingness to vote DM for doing something that made her "weary." MM seems more inclined to think MM is powerwolfing by intentionally misrepping me and MM. tbh, I think Mesk genuinely missed the context of the screenshot I posted. Mesk said she was on her phone last night, and I'm inclined to believe the screenshot simply didn't display well on her device.
For the record, I think I'm scumreading Mesk for different reasons than MM: My scumread is based on Mesk's OMGUS reaction and lack of willingness to vote DM for doing something that made her "weary." MM seems more inclined to think MM is powerwolfing by intentionally misrepping me and MM. tbh, I think Mesk genuinely missed the context of the screenshot I posted. Mesk said she was on her phone last night, and I'm inclined to believe the screenshot simply didn't display well on her device.
[QUOTE=yzb25;910308]I guess I was thinking of that specific post when I voted you. (#351) It didn't look genuine. And it just seemed like a weird thing to take away from mesk's votes back there. Pushing anyone is great I guess. Maybe I'm just pulling shit out my ass to justify what my gut feels lol.[/QUOTE]
Very interesting choice of words for a man with a toilet avatar.
Originally Posted by yzb25
I guess I was thinking of that specific post when I voted you. (#351) It didn't look genuine. And it just seemed like a weird thing to take away from mesk's votes back there. Pushing anyone is great I guess. Maybe I'm just pulling shit out my ass to justify what my gut feels lol.
Very interesting choice of words for a man with a toilet avatar.
[QUOTE=yzb25;910304]are you sure you're understanding MM's post. If anything the post is a defense of you.[/QUOTE]
I'm pretty sure Mesk was accusing MM of being inconsistent by going from scumreading me to suddenly joining me on the Mesk train. Mesk was going after me, but *MM's* post was about how MM getting on the train wasn't a wild inconsistency.
Originally Posted by yzb25
are you sure you're understanding MM's post. If anything the post is a defense of you.
I'm pretty sure Mesk was accusing MM of being inconsistent by going from scumreading me to suddenly joining me on the Mesk train. Mesk was going after me, but *MM's* post was about how MM getting on the train wasn't a wild inconsistency.
To followup: I think missing context after it's been pointed out several times is scummy. When MM says Mesk is experienced, he's implying experienced town try to tell the truth and avoid misreps, while experienced scum actively try to distort the narrative. (instead of just "pretending to be town" like inexperienced scum). [MENTION=29377]Marshmallow Marshall[/MENTION], is this an accurate summary of what you meant there?
I also don't think he's only focused on Mesk atm. (notice the talk about DM and the vote being on Frinckles)
To followup: I think missing context after it's been pointed out several times is scummy. When MM says Mesk is experienced, he's implying experienced town try to tell the truth and avoid misreps, while experienced scum actively try to distort the narrative. (instead of just "pretending to be town" like inexperienced scum).
@Marshmallow Marshall
, is this an accurate summary of what you meant there?
I also don't think he's only focused on Mesk atm. (notice the talk about DM and the vote being on Frinckles)