[23:19:33] DarknessB: Sino is Mass Murderer -- I don't care if there isn't one in the setup!
[23:19:39] DarknessB:-vote Sino
@ika
Update your thoughts on SW. A conversation between us on SW makes a lot of sense right now. If you're town, I can probably get lots of useful intel on SW because I don't know her scumplay or much about her generally. If you're scum, there's a chance you'll fuck up trying to make a sincere read on your wife and your wife will pick up on it, assuming she isn't scum too lol.
Also shit like this makes me feel like yzb is informed. It's like he knows things and is looking down on players.
It's kinda how I felt about Unknown in Spirits where he would make these weird TMI-ish comments about town players like Mesk.
This is mostly a tone thing so I wouldn't lynch based on this. yzb hasn't said anything egregiously bad, but he's not blown me away either. He's still in the same place as RLVG.
Well, yzb that read on me is complete garbage. I already told you why I don't like you pinging me on the SP post. Your explanation is no better. But to say you think my reads are null because I can fake reads as scum, then later saying they are townie, then saying you'd lynch me anyway, then later saying you don't know my play, is all over the map.
For one thing, reading someone off reads is super important if you are town. That's one of the best ways I use to read a person. Completely discounting them because you seem to think I can fabricate them is complete bullshit. You also say you don't know me so how the hell do you know that? It looks like spreading paranoia.
In other words, this scumread is garbage and has no basis considering everything I've done this game.
1)Even if you're self-aware of how you can fuck-up, that doesn't mean you won't fuck-up again.
"If anything, it's actually a town tell for me because I give more fucks about how I look as scum."
That argument can be applied to all things that look scummy. Stop with the retarded copouts
Alternatively, you can just explain what made you hypocrite-d.
2) Do scums actually do that in daychat? They have a nightchat, you know.
3) No. I scumread her for my original post. The post you yourself read and replied to. I repeated this in the section you're responding to.
4) Working on it.
5) Rude.
Can you pls just respond to my criticisms without firing low-blows for no reason? You don't seem to actually scumread me, so I dunno why you're responding like this.
My train? There is currently two people on me.
MattZed- who has been busy with life or something has yet to come back. His read upon my answer to him is bad. I don't think he think it does though, which is something I probably can't persuade him about. Before he left, he made a few posts that basically told me he was considering me as town in some areas. I think he'll come around.
deathworlds- He made some uncharacteristically abrasive posts. I don't really know why he made them, and I can only conclude he does not truly feel that way. When I asked him about it, his answer seems to suggest he was genuine. Not quite sure on what he actually thinks. His vote is simplistic but differs from SilverWolf's.
(SilverWolf, not on my train currently)- made some probing posts elsewhere that I really liked. She's kinda of a basic scum hunter. I don't think she looks too deep into things.
________________
I've been told at times that my town game is better sometimes. This happens when I'm detached. Unfortunately, it's also very boring.
There's snow outside my house, its warm in here. I just drank some soup and life is good. I'm also working on a document, maybe that explains it?
Yes, I literally said that my argument was NAI...because my argument was that my hypocrisy is NAI. Please read.
Uh, where did you get the impression that scum have daychat from? That's not in the setup...
What criticisms? Your posts are worded in such a way that I can't remember a single thing that you say and have to keep scrolling back up.
I don't town-read you and it's annoying me. I was hoping that you'd be obvious town for POE purposes but you're being weird and shady which makes me think that you rolled non-town for once.
I just reread your wallpost and realised why it was so boring. You just tell people to do shit but you're not doing anything yourself.
Take this one. Regardless of your alignment, this post is such contrived bullshit:
So many words, so little said.Update your thoughts on SW. A conversation between us on SW makes a lot of sense right now. If you're town, I can probably get lots of useful intel on SW because I don't know her scumplay or much about her generally. If you're scum, there's a chance you'll fuck up trying to make a sincere read on your wife and your wife will pick up on it, assuming she isn't scum too lol.
If you feel so sure SP is scum that you think the chances SP flips town are "once in a blue moon", then how can I have prior knowledge that he is town? You either scumread SP, or you townread him and think I'm white-knighting him. Which is it? Why are you throwing all this shade on me for giving my opinion on you?
Honestly, this implies you have knowledge that SP will flip town and are projecting onto me LOL.
Yeah, my read on you is unrelated to your reads. That doesn't invalidate it at all. I also often use reads to read people, that doesn't make them necessary.
I don't know much about you, but I've still gotta try and read you. It wasn't that strong of a read at first. It's just being exacerbated by the fact you don't seem to be responding to the actual point I'm making. That read on SP looked like circle-jerking. Going "gross, join the scumpile", looks like an edgy show to me.
I'm not spreading paranoia for having a scumread on you. Seriously, I'm not some puppetmaster toying with people's emotions. That's crazy.
Someone throw me a bone, I swear SW and Calix are responding badly or something lol.
I love how your response is "no u"
If you actually read the chat then you would have seen that my SP scum-read was weakened due to SW making a good point about SP/ Unknown. Your point is also trying to criticise me for considering other possibilities. Obviously you being scum would imply that SP isn't on your team but I never said that you two were on a team in the first place.
No, yzb. You're just spewing bullshit out of your arse. lol
So, yzb. deathworlds yay/nay?
-vote deathworldsCHOO CHOO
Instead of responding to 'defend' yourself or whatever, maybe give reads? I still don't know your opinion on half the shit in the game.
If you're town then that's way more productive than bickering with us.
If you think I'm the Big Bad Calix trying to defuse someone scum-reading me, summarise your points and then give reads.
Either way, you're doing it
Fine, I won't get an explanation, fuck it. I guess your hypocrisy is NAI because of the Calix-meta-read you've forbidden the rest of us to use.
You misread me.
Eh, thanks for letting me know. I guess I'll have to rewrite if it's fucking unreadable.
Could you be more specific?
This is the contradiction I don't like. You say I can fabricate reads as scum so you are gonna discount them.
Then say you don't know my scumplay or much about me generally.
Regarding you thinking I was putting on a show, that was one post out of many and there is no reason to pick out that one out of all the people hating SP's vote and ignoring my reads or anything else I'm saying to call me scum.
You may think this is a bad response but I'm thinking your scumread on me is scummy in and of itself.
I'll await your reads.
I'll ask RLVG in a bit to vote with us, but I'll let him be lazy for a bit more.
Deathworlds - If I was forced to choose someone lynched right now. It would be him. I feel so far his play feels just like his d2 scum play from earlier. And I've come to trust my thoughts more after the past few games being quite accurate.
MattZed - Our confrontation from earlier has yet to come to a Conclusion, and I am in Need of a re-read of his posts. But I will stick with my guns for now.
Sino - From our previous interactions, I fell he had commented on thins such as my votes, but not bothered to explain why. I have a feeling I'm going to be his attempt of a scapegoat. I've kept out of pressuring him as other have done a fine jobs, and I am understanding of their reason-sings.
These two players are currently active, and I will not consider lynching them until after the discussion have held.
SilverWolf -
yzb25 -
These two players I need to re-read and they need to post more before I make my decision.
RLVG -
ika -
Unknown1234 - Starting to move closer away from the Nulls, Unknown has not said anything that has raised any flags
secondpassing - I felt that the L2 vote was over-dramatised, no one could of quick hammered especially early in the day & with active voters around. They are also playing like they don give much fucks about being lynched. Which to me is more of a Town tell than a Scum tell.
Calix - Even if she is scum, the amount of discussion being generated by her is pro-town and a lynch on her will result in much less day activity.
Mesk514 - Voting this slot would just be a PL, too easy to vote up and will give little information from it.
Yoour Turn Sino =)
Also, I'm gonna be gone for an hour or two, and will return before I sleep. Because I want to spend my time elsewhere.
@MattZed please call me scum whilst I'm gone again, you need to make it a third time.
Just got off work. Silver is driving me home then I will be on computer to catch up.
Give me like an Hr to get home and settled and eat and crap then I'll post
I really hate it when everyone is drunk and they start screaming randomly for no reason at all.
I see that you're going out so I can wait for you to return before responding to the following:
Which reasons about Sino do you agree with?
Can you expand a bit on the Unknown read?
Can you give an actual read on Mesk and I? If it's null then I'd like it explicitly stated.
ok now that i am home. does anyone have anything immitate that is needed?
im gonna get me some dinner and then come downstairs again an read up on what i have missed. ill have my phone to pop in and out to check
Yes ika, I need you to explain your readslist and expand on your reads and also tell me who you would vote for/lynch today.
Here are the players i'm fine with being lynched :
-Calix : She did suggest for the neutral to do something he'd never do, plus the fact she's not asking Mesk to participate, i know she generates a lot of discussion, but the town's goal is to lynch scum.
-RLVG : In his few posts, he didn't really give his opinion about anything that has happened in this game, his posts do nothing for town.
-Mesk : Yeah, she claimed citizen, so what ? That's mostly personal, but why would she given a free pass for her "plays" every game ?
Here are the players i'm not sure about and need to re-read :
-SilverWolf : She made some good points in her interaction with yzb earlier, not sure how i read her.
-ika : I'll wait for him to post his opinions before making a decision.
-SuperJack : I'm currently second-guessing what i said earlier.
-secondpassing : Except for his "reaction test" nothing strikes me as scummy in this slot, i admit that's mostly meta, comparing his play now with his WoM play.
-deathworlds : Mostly a null to me, his play here reminds me of his Fringe play.
-yzb25 : His interaction with SW seemed careless, asking someone to update their reads like he did isn't something scum would do when he's been absent for half the day.
Here are the players i'm not willing to lynch :
-Unknown : Same vibe as in Fringe.
-MattZed : His early interaction with Calix feels genuine, going with her at first to suddenly calling her neutral
[23:19:33] DarknessB: Sino is Mass Murderer -- I don't care if there isn't one in the setup!
[23:19:39] DarknessB:-vote Sino
how about you explain to me why we need to interact more when we have had quite a bit and quite a few people have commented on it already
also explain your scum read don silver cus it looks like a bunch of bullshit and a weak reason to try to get a lynch off her
-vote yzb25
this is my top scum read right now (yes im skimming a bunch)
calix seems like her town self (in b4 i get called out for meta) but when she was scum she seems more agreeable and more passsive almost form what i recall. her basicly being argo to everyone and everything is similar to masqurade
gonna read some more bb ina bit with more reads and stuff
Fucking hell, mate.
1. You only have TWO players who you're not willing to lynch...and neither of them are being discussed for the lynch anyway. Keeping your options open, I see.
2. You call that a scum-read? Your reasons are "I didn't like her setup spec" and "she doesn't thread-police Mesk and doesn't share my creepy obsession with her" and "she generates discussion which apparently doesn't help with scum-hunting"
Bitch what. You have got to be fucking kidding me. I'm getting a series of terminal illnesses from this post already and I'm only on the second line.
3. You are so ridiculously biased towards Mesk. It's not even AI. I'm just calling you out on this. Get the fuck over yourself. She's just some random teenager drifting through life, having no impact on anything. Who cares?
4. I don't know what your earlier SJ read was.
5. Why wouldn't scum!yzb do that?
6. Do you actually have any fucking scum-reads? lol. Your reasons for me suck, RLVG can be summed up as anti-town and you have a vendetta against Mesk.
And 2/3 of those are inactive fuckers. The third one only cropped up again after I voted for you.
Try again.
Couple of post I picked out while I was catching up, I have a few thoughts about em.
This entire post is pretty incriminating in my opinion.
First, we start off with a classic discredit, while reinforcing previous claim. Mesk should realize that if she makes the "I am Citizen" claim every game, then it is truly irrelevant. She also completely disregards every scum read on her, without actually interacting with the players that make these scum reads on her. At best, it's lazy anti-town play; at worse, it's an attempt to draw attention away from herself, and on the people who scum read her.
She uses the phrase "Point is" yet hasn't said anything relating to her voting, and as basically a side-note she adds "btw its fine if you think I'm scumbuddys with unknown". Strange, wanted to point it out.
Another discredit on Sino, in a very informal fashion. Not sure how I feel about this.
Basically blackmailing the town into not lynching her, it's probably the most anti-town part of this post. Promises to act worse if she's lynched, discourages votes upon her from others, but without actually providing reasoning why those votes would be invalid.
not sure how to feel about this post, but I thought I should bring it up again.
ika-I need to know your read on me because you voted me earlier and said you were paranoid of me but you are also defending me so I need this clarified.
i think it was the one game where it was multiball who has porfesser zoom. it had sen and the two scum teams ro seomthing. i know me and silverwolf had a dicssuion about your scum meta after the game and how you appreared more agreeable.
yes i know the game is super outdated and it could be old meta but if you have a more recent scum game that would tell me otherwise feel free to point it out. i know you do play elsewhere, but i dont have time right now to go find another scum game of yorus to see if its relevant.
the big thing i see overall with you as well is this:
if your scum you will be lynched for living too long/killed by neutral
if your town you could easily be shot by the neutral or scum if the neutral gets their wincon
if your neutral you would either get wincon or be lynched for never dying
in a nutshell, if your scum, your going to be outed by surviving too long, as neutral same thing but you could also get wincon. as town you would prob eat a nk at one point or anohter.