FMI
Game Result: Cult Victory
Host(s): Dark.Revenant
Theme: Classic Mafia
MVP(s): Narks (Cult Leader)
Setup: 2 Mafia + Cult
FMII
Game Result: Town Victory
Host(s): Elixir
Theme: Classic Mafia
MVP(s): Vornskr (Mason) and JackofSpades (Godfather)
Setup: 2 Mafia + Cult
FMIII
Game Result: Serial Killer Victory
Host(s): FalseTruth and Goonswarm
Theme: Ancient Rome
MVP(s): Yayap (Sheriff) and Illidan (Mayor)
Setup: 2 Mafia + Cult
FMIV
Game Result: Broken due to Game-Throw
Host(s): Oops_ur_dead and Clawtrocity
Theme: Warcraft
MVP(s): Raiden (Citizen)
Setup: (Unknown)
FMV
Game Result: Town Victory
Host(s): Elixir
Theme: Infamous
MVP(s): Illidan (Vigilante)
Setup: 2 Mafia + Cult
FMVII
Game Result: Town Victory
Host(s): Illidan and Raiden
Theme: Final Fantasy
MVP(s): Philie (Escort)
Setup: 2 Mafia + Cult
FMVI
Game Result: Sin Victory (Special Faction)
Host(s): Dark.Revenant
Theme: Christian Theology
MVP(s): Vornskr (Mammon)
Setup: Unique
FMVIII
Game Result: Town Victory
Host(s): Falsetruth
Theme: West-Side Story
MVP(s): Capitaliar (Arsonist)
Setup: 2 Mafia
FMIX
Game Result: Bolshevik Victory (Revolution)
Host(s): Oops_ur_dead and Philie
Theme: Russian Revolution
MVP(s): Clawtrocity (Godfather)
Setup: 1 Mafia + Revolution
FMX
Game Result: Town Victory
Host(s): Yayap
Theme: Custom
MVP(s): [removed]
Setup: 1 Mafia + Evil Neutrals (Powerful enough to be considered major faction)
FMXI
Game Result: Town Victory
Host(s): Elixir and Ambient
Theme: Assassins Creed
MVP(s): None (No Epilogue)
Setup: 1 Mafia + Revolution
FMXII
Game Result: Nosferatu Victory (Mafia)
Host(s): JackofSpades and Capitaliar
Theme: Vampires
MVP(s): BorkBot (Citizen)
Setup: 2 Mafia + Cult
FMXIII
Game Result: Enclave Victory (Mafia)
Host(s): Luna and Yayap
Theme: Fallout
MVP(s): CmG (Devourer)
Setup: 2 Mafia
FMXIV
Game Result: Town Victory
Host(s): Ambient
Theme: Bioshock
MVP(s): AppleyNo (Serial Killer)
Setup: 2 Mafia + Revolution
FMXV
Game Result: Town Victory
Host(s): Blazer
Theme: Star Wars
MVP(s): No one (MVC doesn't count unless Blazer specifies it as MVP)
Setup: 1 Mafia + Evil Neutrals (Powerful enough to be considered major faction)
FMXVI
Game Result: Town Victory
Host(s): Yayap
Theme: None (Not even custom, lol:P)
MVP(s): Auckmid (Blacksmith) and Gerik (Framer)
Setup: Town vs Scum (1 Mafia + Evil Neutrals)
FMXVII
Game Result: Town Victory
Host(s): Raptorblaze and Fragos
Theme: One Piece
MVP(s): Boss (Journalist) and Gerik (Witch)
Setup: 5-Sided Mafia (Unique)
*I plan to add more to the list. I do care about any factual errors, I care not about spelling errors!
Statistics
Victory Composition (Not counting unique set-ups)
Town: 9 = 64.2%
Mafia: 2 = 14.2%
Cult/Revolution: 2 = 14.2%
Serial Killer: 1 = 7.1%
MVP Role Composition
Citizen: 2 (Raiden + Borkbot)
Escort: 2 (Philie + Muso)
Mason: 1 (Vornskr)
Sheriff: 1 (Yayap)
Mayor: 1 (Illidan)
Vigilante: 1 (Illidan)
Blacksmith: 1 (Auckmid)
Journalist 1 (Boss)
Godfather: 2 (JackofSpades + Claw)
Framer: 1 (Gerik)
Cult Leader: 1 (Narks)
Witch: 1 (Gerik)
Serial Killer: 1 (AppleyNo)
Arsonist: 1 (Capitiliar)
Devourer: 1 (CmG)
Fun Fact: Excluding the MVPs from last FM (Boss and Gerik), Narks (Troll) is the only MVP not to become a staff member