Group Discussion Mafia Game #1

[Escaho]

So, I have an on-going puzzle thread going, but then I had the thought: what if the forum collectively made the decision as to what occurred next? Everyone could attempt to puzzle out what would happen next and I would control the normal flow of things (i.e. - based on who dies, I'll do what I think the mafia/SK/fellow Town PRs would naturally do based on the previous day's events).

To begin, here is your role card!

You are Pandora!

Your role is Bus Driver!

You have the ability to swap the places of two players at night, re-directing all actions from one player to the other and vice versa (including yourself!).

You (the forum) may collectively decide as a group who to use your action on for the upcoming night.

Every 24 hours (approximately) I will update with the previous night's events.

If you die, you (the forum) will become a different Town Power role until all Town Powers have died (this includes Sheriff/Doctor/Investigator). If all the Town Powers die, you will become a Citizen.

To win: Make the Town win the game.

Here is the possible Role List:

Godfather
Hidden Mafia
Hidden Mafia
Sheriff
Doctor
Investigator
Hidden Town Power
Hidden Town Power
Hidden Town Power
Hidden Town Power
Citizen
Citizen
Evil Neutral
Benign Neutral
Benign Neutral

Possible Hidden Mafia roles: Consigliere, Consort, Framer, Janitor, Mafioso, Blackmailer, Disguiser

Possible Hidden Town Power roles: Bodyguard, Bus Driver, Citizen, Coroner, Detective, Doctor, Escort, Investigator, Jailor, Lookout, Mason, Mason Leader, Sheriff, Spy, Veteran, Vigilante

Possible Evil Neutral roles: Arsonist, Cult Leader, Serial Killer

Possible Benign Neutral roles: Amnesiac, Executioner, Jester, Survivor, Witch



Game Settings

-Godfather is immune to detection (except for Detectives/Lookouts).
-Godfather, Serial Killer, Arsonist, and Executioner are all immune at night.
-Serial Killer will kill role-blockers.
-Blackmailing silences a player, allowing them to only say, "I am blackmailed" once each day.
-Janitor is limited to 2 cleanings.
-Disguiser cleans role and last will when disguising.
-Healing does not prevent dousing, nor igniting.
-Dousing/Igniting bypasses night immunity.
-Target will not be notified if doused.
-Target will be notified if successfully healed/protected at night.
-Target will be notified if witched.
-Target will be notified if bus driven.
-Target will be notified if role-blocked.
-Mason Leader can attempt to recruit each night.
-Targeting a Cultist will kill him/her.
-Bus Driver can self-target.
-Spy will see who mafia visits, but not who is doing the visiting.
-Spy will see night chats at night.
-Jailing provides complete immunity at night.
-Jailor can jail on a lynch day, but not execute.
-Jailor has two executions.
-Vigilante cannot day shoot.
-Vigilante cannot shoot on Night One.
-Vigilante has three shots.
-Veteran can go on alert a total of 2 times.
-Survivor has 3 bulletproof vests.
-Executioner must get a random Town lynched.
-Amnesiac's role will be told to the Town once remembered.
-Jester, if lynched, will force one random voter to commit suicide the following night.
-Witch will force Jailor to execute (even on lynch day), force Vigilante to shoot, force Bus Driver to swap only chosen target, force SK/GF to kill.
-Witch wins with Mafia.
-Citizens have 1 bulletproof vest.
-Sheriff detects all Evil Neutrals and mafia (except Godfather). Views Benign Neutrals as Not Suspicious.
-Investigator/Consigliere receives the usual pairings.
-Order of Operations are equal to SC2Mafia.
-In the event of the tie, the tie-breaker is the following order: Arsonist / Serial Killer / Witch / Citizen / Mafia / Town



Player List (all roles/spot on player list are randomized)
1 ) Angry Caterpillar
2 ) Pandora
3 ) DONT KILL ME PLZ
4 ) E.T.
5 ) Conformist
6 ) Difficult Problem
7 ) Trolololololo
8 ) Fluffy Magpie
9 ) U GOT SERVED
10) Riceroni
11) Trifecta
12) Beetlejuiced
13) Tuna Casserole
14) wat
15) Ascension



The game started off on Day One.

The following is a transcript of Day One:

Beetlejuiced: Hello everyone.
Tuna Casserole: A fine day we are having here.
Trifecta: Indeed.
DONT KILL ME PLZ: PLZ DONT KILL ME.
Trolololololo: Trolololololololo.
Fluffy Magpie: I like things that are fluffy.
E.T.: I role claim Godfather.
Ascension: Bullshit, I'm the Godfather.
Trolololololo: No, I'm the Godfather!
wat: wat
Pandora: This day has gone to shit.
Riceroni: Derpy town is derpy.
Tuna Casserole: A most amusing first day.
Trifecta: Indeed.
Difficult Problem: Problem?
Angry Caterpillar: not really
Trolololololo: ya rly
DONT KILL ME PLZ: I DONT WANT TO DIE.
U GOT SERVED: HEY, ONLY *I* AM ALLOWED TO TALK IN CAPS.
DONT KILL ME PLZ: DOES THIS MEAN U'LL KILL ME?!
DONT KILL ME PLZ: PLZ NO!
Conformist: Sigh...
Trolololololo: Kill red!
wat: wat
E.T.: This is just...I don't even...
Riceroni: Agreed. Kill red.
Conformist: Not this again...
Trolololololo: Tough luck red! You dead!
Trifecta: Indeed.
Tuna Casserole: This day is terribly uninformative.
Ascension: You expected information?
Tuna Casserole: Not particularly, no.
Beetlejuiced: Then stop bitching.
Fluffy Magpie: Fluffy things are fluffy.
Angry Caterpillar: Can we just skip this day...
Angry Caterpillar has voted to skip day.
Tuna Casserole has voted to skip day.
Riceroni has voted to skip day.
Pandora has voted to skip day.
Conformist has voted to skip day.
Ascension has voted to skip day.
Beetlejuiced has voted to skip day.
E.T. has voted to skip day.
The day has been skipped.

Collectively, you may now submit your night action! Choose two players to swap for the night! If you'd like, you may vote for your preferred action in red (i.e. - "-swap Escaho and Pandora). The action with the highest number of votes shall win (unless it is generally agreed upon what action to take).

A majority of -skip action will skip your action for the night.

If you have any questions about the setup, please ask them in green!

[Nick]

-skip action

[Escaho]

I may speed Night One along since there's not much to talk about.

Once we reach 5 of the same action (i.e. - 5 -skips, 5 agreed upon swap), I'll put up the Day Two transcript.

[Phyr]

-swap wat and Tuna Casserole (in this order)

Early skipper vs useless lurk poster

[creedkingsx]

E.T. is Escacho.
Metagame that shit
why not
-swap wat and Tuna Casserole

[Brendan]

I actually had this idea when I saw your puzzle thread. Are you just going to make this up as it goes along though?

[Escaho]

I actually had this idea when I saw your puzzle thread. Are you just going to make this up as it goes along though?

As soon as I upload the Day Chat transcript, I immediately perform the actions of all the other players for the upcoming night. This way, answering your questions will not effect anything that happens at night, though performing your action might impact night results.

I'll basically be making up the Day Chat transcript based upon previous night actions (for hints and clues as to people's identities or how I think they would act given their personality and role).

[Ash]

E.T. is Escacho.
Metagame that shit
why not
-swap wat and Tuna Casserole

Btw its not Escacho its Escuckaracho. Type his name right plz.

L2typehisname, Creed.

[creedkingsx]

Escachopanda? :o

[creedkingsx]

Can Witch win with town?
Other than Witch being Neutral, does the game pretty much follow SC2mafia game-style?
If so, do we assume pub intelligence, or in-house game kind of intelligence?

[Ash]

Can Witch win with town?
Other than Witch being Neutral, does the game pretty much follow SC2mafia game-style?
If so, do we assume pub intelligence, or in-house game kind of intelligence?

Lol, I'd lol if Escaho makes this whole game-puzzle end up into gamethrowing style.

[Escaho]

Can Witch win with town?

Nope. However, she will win against them in a tie.

Other than Witch being Neutral, does the game pretty much follow SC2mafia game-style?

Pretty much. 15 players. Standard set-up.

If so, do we assume pub intelligence, or in-house game kind of intelligence?

Generally pub intelligence. The players in this game are not substitutes for forum members.

However, you can still expect meta, lies, and false claims, as usual.

[creedkingsx]

Initially, I think wat, oj, and trololol for mafia.

[Escaho]

NIGHT ONE ACTION:

You decided to swap wat with Tuna Casserole.

NIGHT ONE RESULTS:

-Nothing happened to you last night.

DAY TWO

Fluffy Magpie was killed last night! She was shot!

Here is her last will:

Clouds are fluffy too. I like those.

Graveyard:
Fluffy Magpie (Citizen) (Shot on Night One)



Here is the Day Two transcript:

8 votes are required to lynch.

U GOT SERVED: SERVED.
DONT KILL ME PLZ: PHEW, I SURVIVE ONE NIGHT.
Beetlejuiced: Unfortunately, yes, you did.
Trifecta: Indeed.
Angry Caterpillar: Anything happen to anyone last night?
Conformist: Surprisingly, no.
Tuna Casserole: I was bus driven last night.
Difficult Problem: No, nothing.
Pandora: Nope.
Ascension: Negative.
U GOT SERVED: YA, I GOT ROLEBLOCKED. POSSIBLE CONSORT IN TOWN.
Trolololololo: I checked Pandora last night and she came up Mafia!!
*Trolololololo votes to lynch Pandora
Pandora: That’s not true.

*wat votes to lynch Pandora

E.T.: Do we trust the guy with the troll name?
wat: wat
Tuna Casserole: Hmm...
Angry Caterpillar: I don’t know...

*Angry Caterpillar votes to lynch Pandora

*U GOT SERVED votes to lynch Pandora

Riceroni: Guys, stop.
Tuna Casserole: ?
Difficult Problem: Problem?
Riceroni: Pandora is innocent.

*Angry Caterpillar unvotes Pandora

Riceroni: I am the Investigator. Pandora came up Arsonist/Bus Driver, so there is no way she could be Mafia.
Pandora: Sigh…I’m the Bus Driver. Doc on me, please.

*U GOT SERVED unvotes Pandora

Riceroni: Which means Trolololololo is lying.
Trolololololo: Unless you are his mafia buddy trying to save him.

*Riceroni votes to lynch Trolololololo

*Beetlejuiced votes to lynch Trolololololo

*Tuna Casserole votes to lynch Trolololololo

Pandora: Wait, he might be Jester.

*wat votes to lynch Trolololololo

E.T.: She’s right, I wouldn’t vote him.

*Tuna Casserole unvotes Trolololololo

Trolololololo: Trolololololo.
Ascension: Okay…so, any other info? We have a possible Jester/Exec and possibly an Arsonist.
Pandora: I’m not the Arsonist. I bussed wat and Tuna Casserole last night.
Conformist: wat, is this true?
wat: wat?
Conformist: Did Pandora bus you?
wat: maybe.
Conformist: Why maybe? It’s either yes or no or we’ll just kill you.
wat: plz dont kill me, I’m Survivor.
DONT KILL ME PLZ: DONT KILL ME EITHER!
Tuna Casserole: So many PRs in the open…
E.T.: Well, the Doctor can heal Pandora and we can have her prove herself tomorrow. We know there’s a bus driver (if Tuna is telling the truth).
Tuna Casserole: And the “investigator?”
E.T.: Can be bussed? I don’t know.
Angry Caterpillar: Was anyone attacked/healed last night? We’re missing a kill.
Ascension: Not if there’s an Arsonist.
Beetlejuiced: ...
Beetlejuiced: Sigh…just skip day. Someone kill the Jester tonight (hopefully we have a killing role), heal the BD, BD busses Invest, and we’ll see what happens. We haven’t found any scum yet, really. Though we could lynch the Survivor…
Riceroni: Gets rid of a neutral…for sure.
Tuna Casserole: Should we start up a lynch train?
U GOT SERVED: YA.
wat: no, plz!
Angry Caterpillar: I don’t know…

You have several options for today (and may perform them all):

1) Do you want to start up a lynch train on “wat”? If so, he will be lynched.

2) You may submit your action for the upcoming night. Majority will win (most of these “nights” will now last the full 24 hours since day one is always a little slow).

3) Feel free to collectively leave a last will in the event that you die.

[Ash]

wat?

[MANgerine]

pandora should change to MANly MAN name
like MINOTAUR

[Phyr]

Question: Is there a trial (inno/guilty votes) or will a majority vote hammer (expecting the latter, first is kinda standard in sc2mafia)? Asking this because of the random guilty voter dying to Jester grief. When it comes to trial, I'd go for a lynch on the Jester and ask everybody to abstain except for a Citizen (who should claim that he will do it).
How many shots does the Vigilante have?

1)wat doesn't seem to be really helpful. He might also be a Jester/Witch/Amnesiac besides Survivor. Amnesiac can choose to take any role, this includes Mafia and (Neutral) killing roles. wat never really confirmed the bus driving. Jailor may still jail on lynch days. My decision is lynch wat.

2)Confirm protection on Investigator in day chat. Actual action kinda depends on the lynch (and what wat flips). I'd like the Scum to think that we follow through with what we say. So I'd like to drive the Investigator tonight.
swap Riceroni Trifecta

3)

Night 1 action: swap wat with Tuna Casserole
Night 2 action: swap Riceroni Trifecta

[Escaho]

Question: Is there a trial (inno/guilty votes) or will a majority vote hammer (expecting the latter, first is kinda standard in sc2mafia)? Asking this because of the random guilty voter dying to Jester grief. When it comes to trial, I'd go for a lynch on the Jester and ask everybody to abstain except for a Citizen (who should claim that he will do it).

Due to the difficulty trying to have forum members actively participate in day chat, there will be no trial.

You have the option of starting a lynch train, which will get "wat" lynched (you will be informed who voted for him and in what order). If you opt not to start the lynch train, he will not be lynched due to you being the mostly confirmed Town at the moment, so people will follow your lead.

NOTE: As 5 votes is a forum majority, if option 1 reaches 5 votes (either "lynch wat" or "don't lynch wat") before night ends, you will have wat's role/voting information at your disposal when performing your other actions.

How many shots does the Vigilante have?

Vigilante has three shots.

[Phyr]

NOTE: As 5 votes is a forum majority, if option 1 reaches 5 votes (either "lynch wat" or "don't lynch wat") before night ends, you will have wat's role/voting information at your disposal when performing your other actions.

Lynch the "maybe" Survivor! Better than skipping day, as the Jailor can still jail and get a role claim out of somebody (if there is a Jailor).

[LeaD]

witch is evil not benign

[Escaho]

witch is evil not benign

In this set-up, Witch is Benign Neutral.

[ajkei]

can we try to lynch someone other than wat?

(namely tunacassarole)

[ajkei]

If not, vote -lynch wat
for night actions, switch self and tuna cassanub

[Escaho]

DAY TWO ACTION:

You decided to start up a lynch train against wat. You were successful!

Votes were as followed (in this order):

*Pandora votes to lynch wat
*Angry Caterpillar votes to lynch wat
*Tuna Casserole votes to lynch wat
*U GOT SERVED votes to lynch wat
*Trolololololo votes to lynch wat
*Riceroni votes to lynch wat
*Conformist votes to lynch wat
*E.T. votes to lynch wat

wat has been hammered!

wat's role was Survivor!

NIGHT TWO ACTION:

You could not come to a consensus. Therefore, your action was randomized between all possible actions discussed for the night.

Possibilities included:
-swap Riceroni and Trifecta
-swap Pandora and Tuna Casserole

Your action was: -swap Riceroni and Trifecta

NIGHT TWO RESULTS:

Nothing happened to you last night.

DAY THREE

Conformist was killed last night! We could not determine his role nor if he left a last will.

Trolololololo was shot last night! There was a death note left next to his body:

Just your friendly neighborhood vigilante. 1

Trolololololo also left a last will:

You guys suck. LEARN TO PLAY, FFS. RICERONI I HOPE U DIE!!!! TROLOLOLOLOLOLO!!!11!!

GRAVEYARD

Fluffy Magpie (Citizen) (Shot on Night One)
wat (Survivor) (Lynched on Day Two)
Conformist (???) (Killed on Night Two)
Trolololololo (Jester) (Shot on Night Two)



Here is the Day Three transcript:

6 votes are required to lynch.

Pandora: Riceroni, is that proof enough?
Ascension: Rice, you were bussed?
Riceroni: Yes, I was bussed last night.
Trifecta: With me!
Tuna Casserole: At least the Jester is dead.
Beetlejuiced: It's nice when the trolls die.
Trifecta: Indeed.
Beetlejuiced: ...
DONT KILL ME PLZ: IM STILL HERE.
Beetlejuiced: Sadly.
U GOT SERVED: NOT FOR LONG. U DIE NAO.
Beetlejuiced: It appears I spoke too soon. =\
Ascension: So...there's still three mafia and an evil neut out there. Thoughts?
E.T.: I'm thinking we have an Arsonist in play. No word from any Masons, so I doubt there's a Cult Leader.
Tuna Casserole: And you're sure about that?
E.T.: Well, no, but someone asked for my thoughts...
Angry Caterpillar: DifficultProblem's been lurking...
Difficult Problem: Problem?
Angry Caterpillar: Well...you haven't been saying anything...
Tuna Casserole: Trifecta also hasn't said much other than "Indeed" this whole time.
Angry Caterpillar: That's true.
Trifecta: Indeed.
Beetlejuiced: So...nothing constructive, as usual.
*Beetlejuiced votes to lynch Ascension
Ascension: Why me?
Beetlejuiced: Please, the whole "ask people for their thoughts" routine? It's been done. Get out of here, scum.
Ascension: I'm not mafia.
Beetlejuiced: Arsonist, then?
Ascension: Nope.
Beetlejuiced: Cult Leader? Fail SK?
Ascension: Wrong again.
Trifecta: Hopefully Red was the Evil Neutral
Pandora: They all have night immunity except the Cult Leader.
Trifecta: Well, that sucks.
Beetlejuiced: =\
Ascension: What about E.T.? Tuna Casserole? Dont kill me plz?
Tuna Casserole: I don't have any worthwhile information right now...
E.T.: Should I role claim?
Beetlejuiced: If you're a PR, not the best idea.
DONT KILL ME PLZ: PLZ DONT HURT ME.
Beetlejuiced: Mafia, please kill him tonight.
DONT KILL ME PLZ: Y U WANT ME DEAD?
U GOT SERVED: BECAUSE UR NO HELP TO ANY1.
DONT KILL ME PLZ: I GIVE COOKIES.
*Beetlejuiced has voted to -skip day

Options for Day/Night Three:

1) Do you want to attempt to pressure vote another player? If so, who? A maximum of 3 votes must be met to net this information before night is over.

2) Do you have anything to say to the Town before day ends? You may compose a short message to say to the Town and see their reactions. If at least 3 people agree upon what to say before night ends, you will have this information at your disposal before confirming your night action.

3) Choose your action for the night. Who would you like to swap places?

4) You may choose to leave a last will. If various last wills are created, one will be chosen at random from the various selections.

[Phyr]

1) pressure DONT KILL ME PLZ Difficult Problem (was afraid we aren't getting to 3 votes on time)
2) Doc keep healing me. I keep the Investigator safe. I will not drive Trifecta next night.
3) swap Difficult Problem with E.T.
4)

Night 1 action: swap wat with Tuna Casserole
Night 2 action: swap Riceroni with Trifecta
Night 3 action: swap Difficult Problem with E.T.

[ajkei]

pressure problem?

[straykiwi]

lynch train on angry caterpillar

coz i love random lunches

"wat"

[Phyr]

One more vote on Difficult Problem pls. :P
So we can plan night actions accordingly.

[straykiwi]

k vote to pressure diffult problem

[Escaho]

Pandora: I recommend pressuring Difficult Problem for information.

*Pandora votes to lynch Difficult Problem
*Angry Caterpillar votes to lynch Difficult Problem
*Ascension votes to lynch Difficult Problem

Difficult Problem: Wtf?
Pandora: I'd hold off at L-2 or we might accidentally lynch him.

*Trifecta votes to lynch Difficult Problem

Difficult Problem: I'm not evil.
Trifecta: Problem? :P
Difficult Problem: You really want me to claim?
Trifecta: Yes, please!
Difficult Problem: Fine, you asked for it. I am the Doctor. I healed Pandora on night two, unsuccessfully, I might add.
Angry Caterpillar: Hmm...
Pandora: Well, since you claimed, who did you heal on Night One?
Difficult Problem: I healed Conformist since he was red.
Riceroni: I suppose it's possible...

You have an additional 24 hours to make the remainder of your decisions.

In addition, you now have the opportunity to lynch Difficult Problem. There is not enough time left in the day to start up a lynch on someone else.

[straykiwi]

Don't lynch him, if he doesn't die tonight by mafia we can lynch him tomorrow

[Burnteskimo IIl.]

this belongs in the puzzle forum.

[Phyr]

Do not lynch!
Message to the Town:

I will protect the Investigator as he is proven, while the Difficult Problem should keep healing me. If we were to die, then Town should just lynch the Doctor. Any additional protection available (second Doctor/Bodyguard) may go to Difficult Problem.

Plan to claim to have driven Ascention and Ricerino tomorrow.
swap Ascension with Difficult Problem

[Phyr]

I guess Escaho is busy with FMXIII - and I can't blame him. It's awesomesauce.

[Escaho]

DAY THREE ACTION:

Pandora sent this message to the town before day ended:

"I will protect the Investigator as he is proven, while the Difficult Problem should keep healing me. If we were to die, then Town should just lynch the Doctor. Any additional protection available (second Doctor/Bodyguard) may go to Difficult Problem."

The Town decided not to lynch anyone on Day Three.

NIGHT THREE ACTION:

-swap Ascension with Difficult Problem

NIGHT THREE RESULTS:

You were killed last night!

DAY FOUR

DONT KILL ME PLZ was murdered last night! He was shot in the back. His role was Jailor.

He left a last will:

Y U KILL ME? I TOLD U NOT TO!!!!

ACTIONS:
NIGHT ONE I JAILED TRIFECTA. HE CLAIMED CITIZEN.
NIGHT TWO I JAILED ASCENSION. HE CLAIMED DR.
NIGHT THREE I JAIL U GOT SERVED. HE DEAD!!!

ALSO, I TOLD ALL PRISONERS NOT TO SAY THEY WERE JAILED.

Pandora was also killed last night! Cause of death appeared to be due to serious burns all over her body! Her role was Bus Driver.

Pandora left this last will:

Night 1 action: swap wat with Tuna Casserole
Night 2 action: swap Riceroni with Trifecta
Night 3 action: swap Difficult Problem with E.T.

Beetlejuiced was killed last night! His cause of death also appeared to be due to serious burns! His role was Vigilante.

He left a last will:

I shot Trolololololo. Didn't get to shoot anyone else. =\

U GOT SERVED was killed last night. He was executed in a jail cell. He did not leave a last will. His role was Janitor.





GRAVEYARD

Fluffy Magpie (Citizen) (Shot on Night One)
wat (Survivor) (Lynched on Day Two)
Conformist (???) (Killed on Night Two)
Trolololololo (Jester) (Shot on Night Two)
DONT KILL ME PLZ (Jailor) (Shot on Night Three)
Pandora (Bus Driver) (Burned to death on Night Three)
Beetlejuiced (Vigilante) (Burned to death on Night Three)
U GOT SERVED (Janitor) (Executed in a jail cell on Night Three)



Because you have been killed, you have randomly rolled into another surviving Town Power Role! Here is your new role card!

You are Riceroni!

Your role is Investigator!

You have the ability to investigate another player at night to learn what possible roles they could be.

You (the forum) may collectively decide as a group who to use your action on for the upcoming night.

Every 24 hours (approximately) I will update with the previous night's events.

If you die, you (the forum) will become a different Town Power role until all Town Powers have died (this includes Sheriff/Doctor/Investigator). If all the Town Powers die, you will become a Citizen.

To win: Make the Town win the game.

Here are your previous night action results:

NIGHT ONE RESULTS:

You attempted to investigated Pandora!

Your target is a Bus Driver/Arsonist!

NIGHT TWO RESULTS:

You were bus driven!

You attempted to investigate Angry Caterpillar!

Your target is a Doctor/Serial Killer!

NIGHT THREE RESULTS:

You attempted to investigate Ascension!

Your target is a Bus Driver/Arsonist!

Here is the Day Four transcript:

4 votes are required to lynch.

Riceroni: Ascension is the Arsonist. He came up Bus Driver/Arsonist in my investigation result.

*Riceroni votes to lynch Ascension.

Ascension: What? I am not the Arsonist.
Riceroni: Well, my investigation results say otherwise.
Ascension: I was bus driven last night.
Riceroni: Look at Pandora's last will. It says she switched E.T. with Difficult Problem.
Difficult Problem: Problem?
E.T.: Hold on a second there. I wasn't bussed last night.
Riceroni: What?
E.T.: Yeah, I wasn't bussed last night.
Riceroni: Well then, who the hell was?
Ascension: I was.
Trifecta: I wasn't bussed.
Tuna Casserole: Neither was I.
Angry Caterpillar: I wasn't bussed.
Difficult Problem: I also wasn't bussed.
Riceroni: Bullshit. One of you is lying. Probably E.T.
E.T.: I am not lying.
Riceroni: Well, today is going to be discussion day! I'm going to figure out exactly what happened last night.

Options for Day/Night Four:

1) Pressure a player for a role claim. There is only enough time to do this for one player.

2) Suggest a role claim day to see what people say.

3) Suggest someone to lynch. This player will be lynched.

4) Choose your action for the night. Who would you like to investigate?

5) You may choose to leave a last will. If various last wills are created, one will be chosen at random from the various selections.

[Escaho]

Apologies for the late update. Went out on Friday and Saturday night (hence the extended delay for your actions), hosted Ultimate Frisbee and spent the rest of Sunday with friends, then worked today. Throw FMXIII into the middle of that and it's busy!

Phew.

[Nick]

Godfather
Hidden Mafia
Hidden Mafia (Janitor)
Sheriff
Doctor
Investigator
Hidden Town Power
Hidden Town Power (Bus Driver)
Hidden Town Power (Vigilante)
Hidden Town Power (Jailor)
Citizen
Citizen
Evil Neutral (Arsonist)
Benign Neutral (Jester)
Benign Neutral (Survivor)
One less due to cleaning.

Spoiler : :

If Ascension is the Arsonist and was jailed N2, how is it possible that two were burned?

No witch. And no signs of two bus drivers. Unless the jailor or bus driver was lying in their last will.

GF either hit the Arsonist or got run over by bus N3. The remaining town hidden role is vigilante. And citizen was killed and cleaned. Unless the vigilante is lying in his last will. Trifecta is GF.

From Riceroni's point of view:
IF jailor lw TRUE = Ascension NOT arsonist = Pandora lw FALSE
IF Pandora lw TRUE = Ascension arsonist = jailor lw FALSE
IF Trifecta citizen = Difficult Problem arsonist/mafia = vigilante lw FALSE
IF Difficult Problem doctor = Trifecta GF = vigilante lw FALSE
IF vigilante lw TRUE = Difficult Problem arsonist/mafia
IF jailor lw TRUE AND vigilante lw TRUE = Trifecta GF AND Difficult Problem arsonist/mafia

Notes:
(1) Trifecta did not contest jailor's last will
(2) Difficult Problem did not contest bus driver's last will and Riceroni's statement at first chance
(3) There might be a consort?

Send Trifecta or Difficult Problem up for lynching.

[AppleyNO]

Well, I have to refocus from BD to Invest.
Pressure Ascension into revealing role.
From the towns perspective, the BD didn't touch Ascension, but I don't want to risk a lynch if we are wrong and kill a towny.
If Ascension claims something that is dead, or if he claims a role that someone else is AND they reveal themselves, we could lynch him.
-Invest E.T.


Also, I wished you guys had not lied in the BD Last Will

[AppleyNO]

Disregard ^^^^^^^^^^^^^
I didn't notice the Spoiler button, Good points nick.
I threw the Jailor's and the Vigi's Last Will out on my last post.
-Invest Difficult Problem
I Will Second Nick
-Lynch Trifecta

[Pokemon Trainer Red]

Godfather
Hidden Mafia
Hidden Mafia (Janitor)
Sheriff
Doctor
Investigator
Hidden Town Power
Hidden Town Power (Bus Driver)
Hidden Town Power (Vigilante)
Hidden Town Power (Jailor)
Citizen
Citizen
Evil Neutral (Arsonist)
Benign Neutral (Jester)
Benign Neutral (Survivor)
One less due to cleaning.

Spoiler : :

If Ascension is the Arsonist and was jailed N2, how is it possible that two were burned?

No witch. And no signs of two bus drivers. Unless the jailor or bus driver was lying in their last will.

GF either hit the Arsonist or got run over by bus N3. The remaining town hidden role is vigilante. And citizen was killed and cleaned. Unless the vigilante is lying in his last will. Trifecta is GF.

From Riceroni's point of view:
IF jailor lw TRUE = Ascension NOT arsonist = Pandora lw FALSE
IF Pandora lw TRUE = Ascension arsonist = jailor lw FALSE
IF Trifecta citizen = Difficult Problem arsonist/mafia = vigilante lw FALSE
IF Difficult Problem doctor = Trifecta GF = vigilante lw FALSE
IF vigilante lw TRUE = Difficult Problem arsonist/mafia
IF jailor lw TRUE AND vigilante lw TRUE = Trifecta GF AND Difficult Problem arsonist/mafia

Notes:
(1) Trifecta did not contest jailor's last will
(2) Difficult Problem did not contest bus driver's last will and Riceroni's statement at first chance
(3) There might be a consort?

Send Trifecta or Difficult Problem up for lynching.

Dang, this guy knows what he is doing.

[Phyr]

My bad. I thought for sure I added "update lw with night actions" to my last post.
What a mess now -.-
Arsonist can't kill next night. So I suggest trying to find Mafia and unravel the confusion surrounding the Arsonist through night actions.
A mass role claim should prove helpful (night actions included!).
What's DR? Doc?

Plan:
1. Ask all jailees to claim their jail (to make sure that Jailor's lw isn't wrong).
2. Ask everybody to role-claim. E.T. and Tuna first.
3. Find overlapping claims.
4. Lynch Mafia.

@Nick: How can Vigi lw be fake in any way?
The remaining town hidden role is vigilante. Why?
IF Trifecta citizen = Difficult Problem arsonist/mafia = vigilante lw FALSE Not sure about this either.


Godfather
Hidden Mafia
Sheriff
Doctor - Angry Caterpillar
Investigator - Riceroni
Hidden Town Power - Difficult Problem (Doctor)?, Ascension (Doctor)?
Citizen - Trifecta?
Evil Neutral (Arsonist)
Missing: Tuna Casserol, E.T.
One less due to cleaning.

I think the Sheriff got cleaned. He would have jumped in by now.
If Trifecta is Godfather, the missing Mafia is a Mafioso.

So yeah. Vote for role claim day.

[Nick]

@Nick: How can Vigi lw be fake in any way?
The remaining town hidden role is vigilante. Why?
IF Trifecta citizen = Difficult Problem arsonist/mafia = vigilante lw FALSE Not sure about this either.

Three vigilante kills. Vigilante can shoot three times. But the dead vigilante said he only killed the Jester. But there are three vigilante kills.

Damn. Missed four points. Need to reanalyze.
(1) Ascension claimed doctor
(2) Sheriff can be cleaned
(3) No claims of being attacked
(4) Vigilante cannot shoot N1? Are there any difference between mafia and vigilante kills?

[Nick]

Lets try this again...

Spoiler : :

From Riceroni's point of view:
IF jailor lw TRUE = Ascension NOT arsonist AND Trifecta NOT arsonist = Pandora lw FALSE
IF Difficult Problem doctor = Ascension mafia/arsonist
IF Ascension doctor = Difficult Problem mafia/arsonist
IF jailor lw TRUE AND Difficult Problem doctor = Ascension mafia
IF Pandora lw TRUE = Ascension arsonist = jailor lw FALSE
IF hidden mafia NOT mafioso = Trifecta NOT gf
IF hidden mafia NOT mafioso AND hidden mafia NOT disguiser = Trifecta NOT gf AND Ascension NOT gf
...

Lynch Ascension or Difficult Problem. Role claim is too late. Lynch or lose for town.

[Escaho]

My bad. I thought for sure I added "update lw with night actions" to my last post.

I should point out to the others that Phyr's last will for Pandora is the one that appears as her last will, which was not updated with her most recent night actions.

Admittedly, you would not normally have access to this information, but I do not want you to be confused that her action was changed.

[Phyr]

Man, that Bus Driver... Such a derp...
Well, the Jailor's last will and the Bus Driver's Last Will are mutually exclusive. That means somebody messed up. Considering that both E.T. and Ascension claimed that the bd's action went down differently, we can assume that the Bus Driver messed up. imsosryguys

Is a mass role claim and a lynch mutually exclusive today?

We only need Tuna's and E.T.'s claim to have all of them.

[Escaho]

Is a mass role claim and a lynch mutually exclusive today?

Not if the mass role claim acquires three votes before day ends.

[Escaho]

Vigilante cannot shoot N1? Are there any difference between mafia and vigilante kills?

No, there are no differences.

[Phyr]

Not if the mass role claim acquires three votes before day ends.

So be it! vote Mass Role Claim

[creedkingsx]

I vote mass role claim as well!

[Nick]

Between Difficult Problem and Ascension, I'm leaning towards Difficult Problem for not being town.
(1) Not denying being bussed early
(2) Unhelpful

Similarly for Trifecta not being citizen.
(1) Unhelpful

Mass role claim then lynch Difficult Problem.

EDIT: Don't even need to know what the BD did.