S-FM The Cold War III

[Ganelon]

Aren't you some kind of an detective?

What do you mean by this?

[blinkskater]

What do you mean by this?

What do you mean by asking him what he means by this?

[Lenneth]

Aren't you some kind of an detective?

I don't know what to think about that xD

[Ganelon]

What do you mean by this?

Ok thank you for confirming Lenneth as town, I no longer wish to Lynch Lenneth. I want to kill Dunna. after MM, that is.
Is anyone other than myself finding Dunna incredibly suspicious atm?

[Dunna]

What do you mean by this?

I mean, he/she state a kinda' obvious thing known by everybody, so I could say "Captain Obvious", so the Intellectuals would be able to get it too.

[Ganelon]

I mean, he/she state a kinda' obvious thing known by everybody, so I could say "Captain Obvious", so the Intellectuals would be able to get it too.

Ya, I don't buy this. Die.

[yzb25]

I mean, he/she state a kinda' obvious thing known by everybody, so I could say "Captain Obvious", so the Intellectuals would be able to get it too.

ohhh I thought you confused him with rumox. I was thinking "holy shit" XDD

[Ganelon]

What do you mean by asking him what he means by this?

To hell with your WIFOM, scum.

[Dunna]

Well, I was making a corny joke since Lenneth is so obnoxious for me for stating an obvious thing. But, why thank you Magoroth, your shining intellect finally brought light to the darkness lol.

Obviously the first sentence is wrong, so guys, just ignore it, right?

[naz]

Oh you've already voted him, wtf.

Something is very wrong here.

Since nobody else is doing this, I'm throwing it in the wind. Also... I'm unvoting MM for a second 'cuz I need to go read something... Unknown left the vote count in a post at one point.

• Marshmallow Marshall (5 [L-2]):
  Magoroth, Fielzanks, blinkskater, rumox, yzb25
  

  ---

  rumox (2 [L-5]):
  Marshmallow Marshall, naz

Somebody DID do this, if you would stop shitposting and read. Or is that your goal? To drown out all useful posts and make everyone stop playing

[Fielzanks]

I'm feeling a little tired. Could you re-explain the post you made about Mag. Dumber this time? And also throw me a bone or two on why you hold your views on MM. I'm really not getting it.

Mag has a sheepish personality. Of that, everyone, even him, knows that. Throughout the day, Mag added fuel to the fire with naz / rumox and constantly flip-flopped, never HOLDING A STANCE. As if he was too afraid to commit to one. After several posts of him saying 'flip flopping is town!' and being dissed, he's taking a more pratical approach in a 'lynch everyone that isnt me' based on current tendancies. He's been on MM, he's been on blink, and now seemingly on lenneth while 'being drunk'. He also 'faked a breakdown' to see who would go after him. I did, to a full extent, but now he's town reading me after a SECOND breakdown (fake too? idk) and is now being drunk. I'd say that while he tend to get emotional when his life is threatened (we all do it to an extent) he knows very well to manipulate his input to appear a certain way. By being overly confused he's constructing an immunity based on 'Distorted is not on, I do not know who to sheep'. It's also worth noting that he did not heavily pressure anyone that I can remember, just making comments and directing the finger without committing. It's really coming off as scum to me, because town mag, even if he cannot sheep, would be able to sort through a lot of things he did and/or I did, which he doesn't.

Oh, I don't know if it's dumber. Well...
TL;DR : Mag is scummy to me because he tried to force my roleclaim, added confusion into town without being in the middle of the heat and playing off a bit as 'I'm dumb I can't figure things on my own forgive me' card which I don't buy.


As for MM, he's a good town read for me since the beginning of the game (which is a bit of time now) at first because his intention to bring the neutral out was good, but also because he heavily forced town to not roleclaim, even if he WIFOM'd after that. He may have been a bit opportunistic, but he was one of the first on rumox and his position hasn't changed, and he did not try to get away from the spotlight, even if his name came often as 'scummy' in the mouth of others. It's either MM really improved at being scum (which would rock!) or he simply isn't.

[yzb25]

Mag seems so much like a found scum who's fed up with being stuck in this game. He's tempting me to switch trains again, but I'll refrain until I hear what Fiel has to say about MM, at least.

I've alternated between them so many times now omg XD

[naz]

I don't know what to think about that xD

He means "no shit, sherlock" LOL

dunna, town has vig, so u might get shot. lol

[yzb25]

Mag has a sheepish personality. Of that, everyone, even him, knows that. Throughout the day, Mag added fuel to the fire with naz / rumox and constantly flip-flopped, never HOLDING A STANCE. As if he was too afraid to commit to one. After several posts of him saying 'flip flopping is town!' and being dissed, he's taking a more pratical approach in a 'lynch everyone that isnt me' based on current tendancies. He's been on MM, he's been on blink, and now seemingly on lenneth while 'being drunk'. He also 'faked a breakdown' to see who would go after him. I did, to a full extent, but now he's town reading me after a SECOND breakdown (fake too? idk) and is now being drunk. I'd say that while he tend to get emotional when his life is threatened (we all do it to an extent) he knows very well to manipulate his input to appear a certain way. By being overly confused he's constructing an immunity based on 'Distorted is not on, I do not know who to sheep'. It's also worth noting that he did not heavily pressure anyone that I can remember, just making comments and directing the finger without committing. It's really coming off as scum to me, because town mag, even if he cannot sheep, would be able to sort through a lot of things he did and/or I did, which he doesn't.

Oh, I don't know if it's dumber. Well...
TL;DR : Mag is scummy to me because he tried to force my roleclaim, added confusion into town without being in the middle of the heat and playing off a bit as 'I'm dumb I can't figure things on my own forgive me' card which I don't buy.


As for MM, he's a good town read for me since the beginning of the game (which is a bit of time now) at first because his intention to bring the neutral out was good, but also because he heavily forced town to not roleclaim, even if he WIFOM'd after that. He may have been a bit opportunistic, but he was one of the first on rumox and his position hasn't changed, and he did not try to get away from the spotlight, even if his name came often as 'scummy' in the mouth of others. It's either MM really improved at being scum (which would rock!) or he simply isn't.

Ahh speak of the devil. Gimme a sec . . .

[Ganelon]

What do you mean by asking him what he means by this?

I want your reads again.

[Fielzanks]

Are you underage or something? smh

I think the best way to play this game is drunk! There are colors there that have never seen daylight.
For real, Lenneth is I believe scum lol for a number of reasons.

I honestly would not be able to read a screen (or read at all) when I get drunk. Sorry !

[Ganelon]

I honestly would not be able to read a screen (or read at all) when I get drunk. Sorry !

That depends on how drunk you get

[Dunna]

He means "no shit, sherlock" LOL

dunna, town has vig, so u might get shot. lol

Finally someone who got it other than blink. Also, you've used a creative way to promote my, morale, so, guess I'll be inclined on taking a stance!!!

[Fielzanks]

What do you mean by asking him what he means by this?

What do you mean by asking him what does he mean by asking what does Dunna meant by this?

[Ganelon]

I'm going to start typing up a LW, PLEASE do not kill me yet because I need a full day to think this through.

[Fielzanks]

That depends on how drunk you get

Oh, you mean playing with an usual pack of guinness? I do that everytime, helps me focus on the game.

[blinkskater]

I want your reads again.

Sure you are summy asf mm will most likley flip scum unk is prob NK or your scum mate rumox yz fielz and naz are towny naz being towon 100% dunna is null lenny and aamirus are semi scummy

[DJarJar]

Back and reading

[blinkskater]

What do you mean by asking him what does he mean by asking what does Dunna meant by this?

You catch on quick

[Dunna]

Magoroth, are you LARP-ing right now?

[Lenneth]

He means "no shit, sherlock" LOL

dunna, town has vig, so u might get shot. lol

Shit happens

[yzb25]

Mag has a sheepish personality. Of that, everyone, even him, knows that. Throughout the day, Mag added fuel to the fire with naz / rumox and constantly flip-flopped, never HOLDING A STANCE. As if he was too afraid to commit to one. After several posts of him saying 'flip flopping is town!' and being dissed, he's taking a more pratical approach in a 'lynch everyone that isnt me' based on current tendancies. He's been on MM, he's been on blink, and now seemingly on lenneth while 'being drunk'. He also 'faked a breakdown' to see who would go after him. I did, to a full extent, but now he's town reading me after a SECOND breakdown (fake too? idk) and is now being drunk. I'd say that while he tend to get emotional when his life is threatened (we all do it to an extent) he knows very well to manipulate his input to appear a certain way. By being overly confused he's constructing an immunity based on 'Distorted is not on, I do not know who to sheep'. It's also worth noting that he did not heavily pressure anyone that I can remember, just making comments and directing the finger without committing. It's really coming off as scum to me, because town mag, even if he cannot sheep, would be able to sort through a lot of things he did and/or I did, which he doesn't.

Oh, I don't know if it's dumber. Well...
TL;DR : Mag is scummy to me because he tried to force my roleclaim, added confusion into town without being in the middle of the heat and playing off a bit as 'I'm dumb I can't figure things on my own forgive me' card which I don't buy.


As for MM, he's a good town read for me since the beginning of the game (which is a bit of time now) at first because his intention to bring the neutral out was good, but also because he heavily forced town to not roleclaim, even if he WIFOM'd after that. He may have been a bit opportunistic, but he was one of the first on rumox and his position hasn't changed, and he did not try to get away from the spotlight, even if his name came often as 'scummy' in the mouth of others. It's either MM really improved at being scum (which would rock!) or he simply isn't.

What do you think of MM's reads then? Are these reads also typical town MM? That's the main thing that ticks me off about him. I don't view him as scummy for his supposed "opportunism" regarding the Rumox train either. And wouldn't you regard stating basic town strategy like "mass roleclaim day 1 is a bad idea" as a little common-sensical anyway? I certainly don't scumread it, but I wouldn't give him townpoints for it either.

I respect the spotlight part. He seems like quite an agreeable character, the sort of person that might be scared to put himself out there as scum even if it would benefit his town meta.

[Dunna]

Shit happens

Hahah, Lenneth, we might be able to work something out despite partially making fun of you. I mean, I don't want to bite the dust, y'know what I'm saying?

[naz]

Sure you are summy asf mm will most likley flip scum unk is prob NK or your scum mate rumox yz fielz and naz are towny naz being towon 100% dunna is null lenny and aamirus are semi scummy

>100%

[Lenneth]

What do you think of MM's reads then? Are these reads also typical town MM? That's the main thing that ticks me off about him. I don't view him as scummy for his supposed "opportunism" regarding the Rumox train either. And wouldn't you regard stating basic town strategy like "mass roleclaim day 1 is a bad idea" as a little common-sensical anyway? I certainly don't scumread it, but I wouldn't give him townpoints for it either.

I respect the spotlight part. He seems like quite an agreeable character, the sort of person that might be scared to put himself out there as scum even if it would benefit his town meta.

But still, your vote (and fiel vote) are still on him.
I don't feel really confortable putting him at L-1. And he is still not there omg.

[DJarJar]

Who were the people SK hunting? Mag was one of them I know that, were there others? If anyone knows it would save me trolling through an insane post count.

Mag and MM

[yzb25]

Hahah, Lenneth, we might be able to work something out despite partially making fun of you. I mean, I don't want to bite the dust, y'know what I'm saying?

lol this guy

[naz]

But still, your vote (and fiel vote) are still on him.
I don't feel really confortable putting him at L-1. And he is still not there omg.

ok ya at this point he is probably gone lol
come back u squishy square @Marshmallow Marshall

[Lenneth]

Hahah, Lenneth, we might be able to work something out despite partially making fun of you. I mean, I don't want to bite the dust, y'know what I'm saying?

Yep, bitting the dust will make you thirsty af !

[blinkskater]

ok ya at this point he is probably gone lol
come back u squishy square @Marshmallow Marshall

He posted in another thread and did not post here FYI

[Fielzanks]

What do you think of MM's reads then? Are these reads also typical town MM? That's the main thing that ticks me off about him. I don't view him as scummy for his supposed "opportunism" regarding the Rumox train either. And wouldn't you regard stating basic town strategy like "mass roleclaim day 1 is a bad idea" as a little common-sensical anyway? I certainly don't scumread it, but I wouldn't give him townpoints for it either.

I respect the spotlight part. He seems like quite an agreeable character, the sort of person that might be scared to put himself out there as scum even if it would benefit his town meta.

I agree that about mass roleclaiming is a little sensical, and he's also one to always bring this point up in games I've seen him play; even as scum. However, his intentions about warning a particular scenario which might harm town that wasn't straightforward are towny. Which would be a good thing to do as scum, as WIFOM implies. I do believe that his citizen claim is useless however, and that particular piece of information is extremely important to figure the game out later on. His reads are kind of weak on the scumside, looks like he did not have the time to think about potential teamings. I'm quite surprised he isn't scum reading Blink and is scumreading Unknown.

[Dunna]

Yep, bitting the dust will make you thirsty af !

So I should Tread Lightly, or else you'll make me the part of this hallowed ground.

https://c-7npsfqifvt34x24e2v6q4m5x78...a=1&i10c.dv=14

[yzb25]

-vote Magoroth

My scumread on MM remains, but Mago is my stronger scumread at this point.

[yzb25]

I agree that about mass roleclaiming is a little sensical, and he's also one to always bring this point up in games I've seen him play; even as scum. However, his intentions about warning a particular scenario which might harm town that wasn't straightforward are towny. Which would be a good thing to do as scum, as WIFOM implies. I do believe that his citizen claim is useless however, and that particular piece of information is extremely important to figure the game out later on. His reads are kind of weak on the scumside, looks like he did not have the time to think about potential teamings. I'm quite surprised he isn't scum reading Blink and is scumreading Unknown.

Honestly, I didn't find this response 100% convincing. But tbh your first reply made me comfortably fall onto Mag anyway. May as well stop playing coy.

[Fielzanks]

List of people currently voting MM :
Magoroth, Fielzanks, blinkskater, rumox, yzb25
^Worth noting here that I'm voting without an intent to lynch

List of people currently not voting MM :
Unknown1234 (unvoted him before logging off)
naz (would prefer rumox)
Lenneth (don't want to put him at L-1)
aamirus
David (has he put his vote somewhere in the game?)
Dunna

[Fielzanks]

Honestly, I didn't find this response 100% convincing. But tbh your first reply made me comfortably fall onto Mag anyway. May as well stop playing coy.

It's also worth noting that while Magoroth threw shade at MM through the day, MM rarely addressed him about it.

[Fielzanks]

Well, since Marshmallow Marshall won't be coming soon, let's go on the Mag train!

-vote Magoroth

[Lenneth]

List of people currently voting MM :
Magoroth, Fielzanks, blinkskater, rumox, yzb25
^Worth noting here that I'm voting without an intent to lynch

List of people currently not voting MM :
Unknown1234 (unvoted him before logging off)
naz (would prefer rumox)
Lenneth (don't want to put him at L-1)
aamirus
David (has he put his vote somewhere in the game?)
Dunna

aamirus, David and Dunna are really too cautious and didn't vote.
What are our choices?
I have the feeling it's between Mag and MM.

[Ganelon]

Well, since Marshmallow Marshall won't be coming soon, let's go on the Mag train!

-vote Magoroth

Can I explain for a second?

[Lenneth]

Can I explain for a second?

You can.

[Fielzanks]

Honestly, I didn't find this response 100% convincing. But tbh your first reply made me comfortably fall onto Mag anyway. May as well stop playing coy.

My answer could not convince you as it's basically how I explain my thoughts, and some of them on the MM subject are not based on logical reading of this day but also knowledge of previous games, which is more of a gut feeling than something that can be mathematically analyzed. As such, it would have been able to persuade you, not convince, but even then it wasn't my goal as much as to explain my PoV on this as I believe you're way able to think things through alone and that different PoV are actually necessary to see one's fault.

[Fielzanks]

Can I explain for a second?

Explain yourself.

[Fielzanks]

aamirus, David and Dunna are really too cautious and didn't vote.
What are our choices?
I have the feeling it's between Mag and MM.

To be honest I made that post for me.
Our choices are to use our votes and not hold them, and to not be scared of putting them / removing them and doing that on and off again through EoD.

[yzb25]

Mag is pretty much everyone's first or second pick, as far as I can tell (sorry if I'm projecting and misrepping people's POV). I think this should be a fair lynch for everyone to agree on.

[Fielzanks]

The only people who are afraid to vote aren't the town.