S-FM: ???? Gamethread

[Forum Mafia GM]

Day 1

Setup

Sixteen people find themselves in a strange place, white walls and strange rooms. No one seems to know their true identities, or what they are doing here. There is a single needle filled with a strange liquid in the middle of the common room, labeled lethal. The group decides to use it today on someone who they deem to have malicious intent.

Players: 1. Spruance 2. Mr.StoleUrGurl as Twentytwo and Fury 3. Gyrlander 4. Otakudweeb69 5. Reemus 6. Suntax 7. Voss 8. GoatseOntheCupboard 9. RLVG 10. Hybrid 11. Marshmallow Marshall 12. SuperJack 13. NoctiZ 14. Stealthbomber16 15. widomakr 16. Rachyl

Role List: [DATA CORRUPT] [DATA CORRUPT] [DATA CORRUPT] [DATA CORRUPT] [DATA CORRUPT] [DATA CORRUPT] [DATA CORRUPT] [DATA CORRUPT] [DATA CORRUPT] [DATA CORRUPT] [DATA CORRUPT] [DATA CORRUPT] [DATA CORRUPT] [DATA CORRUPT] [DATA CORRUPT] [DATA CORRUPT]

Day will end in 24 hours.

9 votes to hammer.

[NoctiZ]

Looks like I'm the first. I'll use this post to make a small disclaimer: It's pretty late for me right now so don't expect me to always be there at the beginning of the day. The next time I'll be able to post is in many hours.

Now let's see..

[RLVG]

Now let's see..

What is there to see?

[Forum Mafia GM]

Day was closed for a small part of the day, day will be extended by twenty minutes to compromise.

[Hybrid]

Looks like I'm the first. I'll use this post to make a small disclaimer: It's pretty late for me right now so don't expect me to always be there at the beginning of the day. The next time I'll be able to post is in many hours.

Now let's see..

said and gone like a true mvp

[Gyrlander]

Maybe this is a traditional 10-3-3 setup. Who knows.

[RLVG]

Maybe this is a traditional 10-3-3 setup. Who knows.

It could also be reverse mafia, haven't seen those in ages.

[Spruance]

Did anyone get a town role?

[RLVG]

Did anyone get a town role?

Is that a subtle statement of not having one yourself?

[Spruance]

Is that a subtle statement of not having one yourself?

Is it?

[Gyrlander]

Is it?

-vote Spruance

Is it?

[Spruance]

-vote Spruance

Is it?

Tis is not but what it is.

[Mr.StoleUrGurl]

Did anyone get a town role?

I didn't

[Hybrid]

-vote Fleeting Thoughts

I challange the gods! Reveal our roles or we lynch you!

jk
I kinda get how this works but it s better you guys to figgure it out. I think there is at least 6 townies with lots of shitizens

[Hybrid]

lemme unvote before i get modkilled

-unvote

[widomakr]

Hello all... That does seem like a suspect thing to say spruce...

[Spruance]

Hello all... That does seem like a suspect thing to say spruce...

Why there is no role list?

[Hybrid]

Why there is no role list?

:sigh:

Check out the rules and try to figgure it out k?

[Mr.StoleUrGurl]

Hello all... That does seem like a suspect thing to say spruce...

Spruce said something incredibly odd, though this post actually accomplishes nothing due to the lack of a vote or further questioning. It's possible you had no gut feelings about anyone else aside from Spruce, so reads lacking elsewhere is fine. Though, I'm concerned that you said, in essence:

"This is weird."

Thereby later allowing you to later point to your oh so effortful scum hunting while actually doing nothing. Scummy. No pressure on your sole read.

-vote widomakr

[Hybrid]

Spruce said something incredibly odd, though this post actually accomplishes nothing due to the lack of a vote or further questioning. It's possible you had no gut feelings about anyone else aside from Spruce, so reads lacking elsewhere is fine. Though, I'm concerned that you said, in essence:

"This is weird."

Thereby later allowing you to later point to your oh so effortful scum hunting while actually doing nothing. Scummy. No pressure on your sole read.

-vote widomakr

Too early to make assumptions
Of course we wouldnt lose that much of thing if we lynch a townie but that's just weird to go after 1 post... He didn't even vote. Also he isn't witch hunting so your assumption him being "evil" is wrong.

[Mr.StoleUrGurl]

Too early to make assumptions
Of course we wouldnt lose that much of thing if we lynch a townie but that's just weird to go after 1 post... He didn't even vote. Also he isn't witch hunting so your assumption him being "evil" is wrong.

It's day 1, we have no evidence. No information will present itself in a greater way than is present at the start of day 1. Therefore, the entirety of day 1 lynches is based on gut feeling pushes and other's reactions to such gut feeling pushes.

What I am doing is generating reactions and pressure in order for us to make informed voting decisions. This is not weird play. Also, you so readily ascribe him the role of town. If I am wrong to assume him evil off of one post, why do you assume him town off of one post?

Scummy.

[Hybrid]

It's day 1, we have no evidence. No information will present itself in a greater way than is present at the start of day 1. Therefore, the entirety of day 1 lynches is based on gut feeling pushes and other's reactions to such gut feeling pushes.

What I am doing is generating reactions and pressure in order for us to make informed voting decisions. This is not weird play. Also, you so readily ascribe him the role of town. If I am wrong to assume him evil off of one post, why do you assume him town off of one post?

Scummy.

In your opinion everyone is scummy x). You might regret these assumptions you making later on the game 22, you really might. So for now shut up and trash talk ^^

[widomakr]

Too early to make assumptions
Of course we wouldnt lose that much of thing if we lynch a townie but that's just weird to go after 1 post... He didn't even vote. Also he isn't witch hunting so your assumption him being "evil" is wrong.

Tks... And yes I am town...

This guys is suspect in my book...

[widomakr]

Spruce said something incredibly odd, though this post actually accomplishes nothing due to the lack of a vote or further questioning. It's possible you had no gut feelings about anyone else aside from Spruce, so reads lacking elsewhere is fine. Though, I'm concerned that you said, in essence:

"This is weird."

Thereby later allowing you to later point to your oh so effortful scum hunting while actually doing nothing. Scummy. No pressure on your sole read.

-vote widomakr

I would invite you to change your vote should you be town... Or else give a good reason as to why you voted me as scum...

[Stealthbomber16]

I would invite you to change your vote should you be town... Or else give a good reason as to why you voted me as scum...

This sticks to me more than most
it seems you didn't read the post

He gave the reasoning literally there
then you asked why and I'm tearing out hair

[widomakr]

This sticks to me more than most
it seems you didn't read the post

He gave the reasoning literally there
then you asked why and I'm tearing out hair

Other then what he said... I wanted something more then what he said... Given the new information

[Hybrid]

c'mon guys, don t be so agressive from the start
lets have some trash talk first xD

[Spruance]

So does anyone claim town?

[Hybrid]

shut up spruance, you are getting yourself deeper in the pit...

[Spruance]

shut up spruance, you are getting yourself deeper in the pit...

Maybe that's where I want to be.

[Hybrid]

@Fleeting Thoughts
Can Rachyl play or not?
Is it 16 people or not?

[Forum Mafia GM]

@Fleeting Thoughts
Can Rachyl play or not?
Is it 16 people or not?

Sixteen players, @Rachyl is a player.

[Rachyl]

hay guys im here, its great that im actually able to play. i thought id have to sit this one out

[Gyrlander]

Just noticed that days last 24 hours. This game won't last long then.

Ah, and I claim MADAFACKING town.

[Hybrid]

Ok, hi i am town.

[Spruance]

Ok, hi i am town.

Kk I am town.

[Hybrid]

You can be pretty sure i am town because i am town

[Gyrlander]

You can be pretty sure i am town because i am town

Last time people claimed town the second one to do it wasn't town. (YOU)

[Hybrid]

Last time people claimed town the second one to do it wasn't town. (YOU)

No last time i was citizen and you were consort i think which you claimed doc
if sj wasnt stupid enough to vote me town woulda win lmao

[Spruance]

No last time i was citizen and you were consort i think which you claimed doc
if sj wasnt stupid enough to vote me town woulda win lmao

Kk I am town.

[SuperJack]

No last time i was citizen and you were consort i think which you claimed doc
if sj wasnt stupid enough to vote me town woulda win lmao

If you wasn't stupid enough to make yourself more scummy than Gyrlander I wouldn't of voted you.

[Spruance]

Kinda wish this wasn't a generic setup. Would be much more interesting.

[Mr.StoleUrGurl]

Actually, after laughing quite a bit off of that initial post, I decided I should probably play seriously.

Across a few sites for non-turbo games, I have like a 0/7 win rate on town.

Super serious Fury in the house.

[Hybrid]

Actually, after laughing quite a bit off of that initial post, I decided I should probably play seriously.

Across a few sites for non-turbo games, I have like a 0/7 win rate on town.

Super serious Fury in the house.

well there wont be any difference between you playing serious or not for both of you guys so it doesnt matter troll as much asd you want

[Gyrlander]

TBH, I feel quite lost. Like, evils have much more advantage as we don't have any idea about them lmao

[Mr.StoleUrGurl]

TBH, I feel quite lost. Like, evils have much more advantage as we don't have any idea about them lmao

Blind setups are so much more enojoyable. I am certain you'll agree with me once the scum hunting the meta theorizing goes into full effect

-F (I've decided to mark my posts from now on, since 22 plays rather differently from me I feel)

[Marshmallow Marshall]

TBH, I feel quite lost. Like, evils have much more advantage as we don't have any idea about them lmao

Ikr.

[Otakudweeb69]

oh so are we claiming town then? I claim town as well

[Mr.StoleUrGurl]

oh so are we claiming town then? I claim town as well

Claiming town naked like this accomplishes nothing.

If I may borrow from the American legal system, "Everyone is innocent until proven guilty."
In parallel, everyone is town until proven scum.

Do you have any substantive comments to add?

[SuperJack]

Claiming town naked like this accomplishes nothing.

If I may borrow from the American legal system, "Everyone is innocent until proven guilty."
In parallel, everyone is town until proven scum.

Do you have any substantive comments to add?

Why not everyone is scum until proven town?