Originally Posted by
thedougler
I -prefer amnes often and tend to side with scum as neutral unless it is absolutely disadvantageous due to an early rout of the mafia. In my unscientific observations scum tends to win most games I get amnesiac. But the amnesiac advantage is entirely dependent on the player who gets the role, and as Crypt says could just as easily be a lesser though significant boon to the town. Either amnes is an unhealthy role altogether or a just a marginal boost to either side, but forcing amnes to act pro town would introduce a whole new imbalance.