PTB here:
I have been behind the scenes more this game. I've posted earlier, asked for reads and such to feel how everyone has interacted. My other personalities have kept me up to date.
This is what I've noticed and I will be pressing for a D1 lynch.
TOWN for sure.
BCD - Frustration and apathy emotions from Duck's posts is too town for me.
Duck - Clearly the final claim is needed to be confirmed, but a scum wouldn't make a claim that has to be confirmed. Even if they were trying to figure out the real GF/Consig, this would effectively lose them the game if they are successfully counter claimed, it would also wouldn't be counter claimed by scum because when they flipped, the counter claims would be lynched. To me this claim has to be legit.
Mesk Archon- is also confirmed by ducks claim.
Voss- actively trying to figure things out, and is preparing a long scum hunt post. Voss has seemed to town to me every interaction.
POD- is in the middle of mafia/town and FBI b/c he seems very flagrant with his posts and seemingly IDGAF attitude. Could be FBI knowing who is going to convert so fuck it.
Possible FBI:
AIVION/Quick archon
Sino
Fatalis.
Shifty
The AIVION team has been very suspect/trolly throughout the game, and it's possible they're FBI. Shifty and Sino have also been questionable. There is no where for me to put these three, and FB isn't around for me to get his take.
Definite scummates:
Unknown
G4slight.
So, you're asking yourself why these two? They have 0 interactions with each other. Now before you go, "but they've had no interactions!." And "Unknown has defended people in this game, who you've read as town." And the next thing counter to my argument. "But he ALWAYS defends people."
Unknown in the beginner's game spent all of his time defending anyone that was suspect to the town scum hunting, often times flipping the hunters logic back onto them, like a mirror. Also, he picked out small aspects or flaws in their arguments and tunneled that to keep them off balance. He's also focused on the person focusing on the person he's defending. While the person he defends looks scummier and he looks pro town, the accuser then looks scummy or is discredited as an idiot because of a mislynch. He then uses this tactic to carry himself into the final lynch. He will bus his own teammate to appear even more town. Now ask yourself, what has Unknown done this entire game, what were his reads? Did he make hard reads? Did he have no interaction with any one player?
HE DID. He did not interact with G4slight all game. This is telling because last time Unknown used this Meta, he did not vote the first day. The second day he jumped onto the town bandwagon only after the only remaining TPR claimed who he wanted to lynch. Unknown continued to have no to very little interaction with his scummate until the second to final day when he bussed him, then used that bus to force the lynch of an inactive player who essentially gave up.
Out of 100 plus pages Unknown has had little to no interaction with only 1 player. Also given, the fact that he soft claimed his reads, almost 40 pages into the game. He gave his scummate a null rating. He also didn't press me when I basically copied Sino's read, WHICH, I said Duck was town and our vote has been on DUCK the entire time/DUCK was scum to us at that time. Unknown failed that reaction test.
Before you say "well he wouldn't use that meta here again." Unknown has played 2 or 3 games since there, he's had an opportunity to refine this scum play..and given how badly I botched the last time, he could easy get me written off had I chose to focus him earlier. Hanging back, I allowed him to get comfortable and out himself by repeating this play. Sino noted this earlier as well somewhat.
G4 will or has come back (depending on what happens between me posting this, since we're doing 20 pages a min now.) and either try to bandwagon as he did earlier, or will hammer a vote. Unknown will not mislynch and use this information to then later bus G4 later if needed, all but confirming him.
Duck's claim kind've throws a wrench into this plan.
If for nothing else, but to confirm this or to gain more information. I suggest that we vote Unknown today.