Thanks, I am going to continue being a try hard as my entrance suggested.
Have any thoughts you want to add as of this moment?
Want to answer my question I asked earlier?
Such as if you were Mafia what woudl be your play assuming you thought that there was illuminati?
-Fire
In my opinion, the Mafia shouldn't use their names in the night chat. They should just name themselves "Godfather" and "Consort" and type differently to make it harder for the Illuminati to know who they are. Even if there is no Illuminati, this doesn't hurt the Mafia much.
Also there's some WIFOM when it comes to kills because the Mafia might actually...want to hit scummy players if they think they're Illuminati.
I don't think that the mafia would play all too much differently.
This setup encourages safe scum play, not risky ones.
As said in speculation, mafia should keep quiet and kill everyone on site. It works toward both their win-cons.
You haven't addressed your inconsistency.
Also as a tip to new players, it's a good idea to assume there's an Illuminati because MattZed ran this setup before with no Illuminati. It was a town steamroll and he got mocked hard for it
Guess I'll also say SecondPassing will do a good majority of the pushing and valuating...
I'm sorta here to uh.. Learn I guess. And try my best!
FOR I AM A MAD SCIENTIST!!
Or you could do a simple -C, -B, -D
To the end of every post. Or not, I can't tell the troll posts sometimes from real. I am sorry about that, its just hard.
That wasn't a answer you said you didn't want to coach, that was avoidance. I won't hold it against you, but I do want an answer
-Fire
You are a try hard, only trying to establish town cred early with your questions thsg benefit only scum, and your "reads" to try to clear town through PoE when the game has just started. You are off to a bad start if scum, which is becoming obvious.
Get on my level, or get behind me and follow my lead.
-unvote
I feel bad for Funcall, don't want him to die D1 again.
-vote GoatseOntheCupboard
Hey Goat, see you're finally here to the party!
Care to make some imput?!
Hey guys! It's me, Goatse radio-ing in from my first FM-game !!!! DD I have a few points/questions to make :
1. Hey guys! It's my first FM, and I am used to a much faster format from the sc2 mafia mod, although ironically you are playing very "fast" considering it is day 1, and no leads, rolls, kills or night actions have happened, you are still voting players with this lack of information.
2. Is it normal for players to claim their role very early on? Because although it isn't in the mod, I feel this is a much higher level of play and I am sure you metagame as hard as you can, and are all trying to get a win, as opposed to just playing for "teh lulz" liek in the mod, where all players claiming day 1 would most likely result in a Town win.
3. I claim citizen
4. Do we normally take advantage of the day 1 lynch? Because I feel playing with more high skillcap players would highly benefit from pressuring players early on, although obviously they would be better/faster at coming up with lies. Anyways I will cast a random vote in the hopes of leading a day 1 town lynch
5. Hey rintarou! I notice you are random voting me, and I think this is an excellent course of action since I have been "lurking" up until now. I will cast my vote along with you because I don't think a scum would start random voting this early (although, coming from the mod I am obviously several levels behind you professional FM players). Further bulletins as events warrant,
-vote Funcall
To vote, do [vote]NAME[ /vote]
But remove the space.
First off, you have to use a vote tag, this is like : [.vote][./vote]
1) Forum mafia is more about reads which is jsut trying to see motivation in posts, not so much on claims like normal Sc2Mafia.
2) No, its actually deteriment to the town to claim early.
3) Bad...but you are likely the most town right now for doing it.
4) Normally it is advantageous to do so, because we have better odds to lynch scum, but if you have no good reads its better to no lynch.
5) No strong opinion, this game is usually very casual compared to mod, you haven't been lurking really.
You are fine, mate.
-Fire
1. I'm semi new too. We vote fast, yea. Not always to lynch but for "pressure." Better people could explain it easier.
2. Not Always... usually they don't. Like in this setup we definetly don't want to since if there's Illuminati they could claim basically anything.
3. (I really hope you are trolling here...)
4. Usually from what I've seen Day 1 lynches are a common thing.
5. Yes, hi. Indeed, but I am also pressure voting you. I would like your honest imput.. Like for example... What do you think of the setup so far? Do you like it? Dislike it? Any commments? Questions? We would like your feedback good sir!
1. Yes, we're currently in RVS (Random Voting Stage) where we vote for players based on minor things in the hopes that this spurs on some more substantial discussion. Don't worry about being wrong, because most players are on Day 1. We focus more on HOW someone came to the conclusions they did.
2. It happens in role madness games but it's not a good idea in this setup, given that it's vanilla. Secondly, we can't trust role claims in case they are Illuminati and even if they are not, you are giving the scum more information on the setup.
3. Interesting, I don't see scum locking themselves down in a claim early like that.
4. Yes, absolutely. By 'town lynch' what do you mean exactly?
5. Why do you think the scum wouldn't cast a vote early?