ObamaCare 1-S2-1-2909541; ROFLzealot 1-S2-1-1962827

[PowersThatBe]

Account Name: ObamaCare
Account ID: 1-S2-1-2909541
In-Game Name: MedowLark

Account Name: ROFLzealot
Account ID: 1-S2-1-1962827
In-Game Name: Nuncio Giordano

Crimes Committed: Game throwing (possible skyping) townandtriadthrow.SC2Replay

Your Account Name: PowersThatBe
Summary: Near the end of the game we had 3 town left, 1 triad, 1 arson, and 1 judge. 5 would not vote with the town and the evils that voted as well. The next day the 3rd town dies, leaving 2 vets *both confirmed* (and according to them had alerts left), 1 DH, and the judge *out of courts* ... The ROLFzealot decides to vote with the judge and the DH to lynch the other confirmed townie because he said "we lost just accept it." Even though they each had alerts left, according to their statements arguing back and forth. 5 lynches 14, 2 votes inno, if 5 voted inno 14 would have been spared and forced into night. 14 is lynched and 5 exclaims he is trolling. At this point triad has won. 2 pm'd 9 (judge) then it went to night sequence, both 2 and 5 committed suicide at night and gave 9 an achievement, throwing game for both teams respectively.

Additionally: In the next lobby the judge said in reference to what happened at the end of this game "I guess they were skyping and decided to give me an achievement."

[AIVION]

SC ID VERIFICATION
1. ObamaCare: Correct. 1-S2-1-2909541
2. ROFLzealot: Correct. 1-S2-1-1962827

Players ADDED
3. Ezoteric: Correct. 1-S2-1-7858865
4. sswillkill: Correct. 1-S2-1-6014895

Respective Hotkeys
1. 7
2. 5
3. 6
4. Ctrl + 2

Was the Game Result altered?
Yes, It certainly was. The suicide pact gave the Neutral evil (Judge) the Win.

Previous Offenses
1. ObamaCare: Skyping (Ignored): https://www.sc2mafia.com/forum/showth...hrowing-report , Griefing (On Hold): https://www.sc2mafia.com/forum/showth...1-S2-1-2909541
2. ROFLzealot: Skyping (Ignored): https://www.sc2mafia.com/forum/showth...hrowing-report
3. Ezoteric: None
4. sswillkill: None

Player Offenses
1. Intentional Game Throwing
2. Intentional Game Throwing
3. Role Quitting
4. Role Quitting

Summary
Ezoteric Rolls Escort and Role quits D1. sswillkill Rolls Lookout and Role quits D1.
Day 5, 5 (ROFLzealot) starts to claim 9 is judge, with 9 admitting to being the Judge. In light of this evidence, the town votes 9... yet 5 votes 15 instead, missing the chance to vote the Judge up.

Day 6, 5 starts to say 14 is DH, even with evidence that proves his role. After voting him up, he starts to say "They just don't visit, we lost this. can't throw what's already lost lol." That following night, both 5 and 2 commit suicide, giving the Judge a solo victory.

In retrospect, the voting of 14 being ROFLzealot's biggest gamethrow move is actually debatable, considering if 2 actually decide to wait for 2+ days with the judge in tow, chances are they would have no alerts left. The DH + Judge would of also won the tie if they decided to take it that far. However, the fact 5 didn't actually vote the judge he called out (That also admitted it too.) was the biggest throw. If the town voted guilty and lynched the judge... the following day the two veterans could of easily lynched 2 and Won the game for the town.
However 2, (ObamaCare) Definetly throwed the game for triad here. If he didn't suicide and instead shot the safest target (9), Triad would of easily won that game.

Recommended Action
1. ObamaCare: Watch List X4
2. ROFLzealot: Watch List X2
3. Ezoteric: . On Hold
4. sswillkill: . On Hold

Additional Notes
Thank you for the report! This game was pretty painful to watch with all the misplays and troll behavoir, but ROFLzealot not voting up the confirmed Judge alongside lynching the confirmed veteran near the end was the hardest to watch. Especially with him suiciding. He could of easily turned this game around for town, yet he decided to throw that away. Since this is his first gamethrowing offense, I recommend Him being put on the Watch list for X2
ObamaCare also Threw hard for his faction. His suicide near the end was both uncalled for and unneccesary to say the least. The fact that 5 also suicided too could suggest these two players use some sort of out of game communication (I.E. Skype.), but without a lot of evidence this is inconclusive. Given the throw though and his prior offenses, I recommend putting him on the Watch list for X4
As for Ezoteric and sswillkill, this is their first Role Quitting report, so this report will be used against them for future reference.

[Arrow]

Punished as recommended.