[Legal Discussion 4] Serious Keg gamethrow

[louiswill]

Ok, I meant Serial Killer.
I'm not so sure this time btw.


Serial Killer: be the last person left alive.

Definition of Gamethrow : SK effectively let a (initial majority) faction win.

Full fill 5 Conditions to determine a gamethrower:

1. The SK lived longer than 5 nights.

2. Without redirections, Except day 1, SK never attacked any claimed investigative players whole game in a game of possible.

3. Without redirections, Except day 1, SK killed 2 times more people from initial minority than from initial majority, in any setup.

4. Without redirections, Except the last few trash time days in a game, SK targeted the people who are said to be scum during day time.

5. SK is lynched by initial majority faction, which lasted and remained the majority faction.

[louiswill]

ops posted in wrong forum.

[Admiral]

>Legal

[Gyver]

Ok, I meant Serial Killer.
I'm not so sure this time btw.


Serial Killer: be the last person left alive.

Definition of Gamethrow : SK effectively let a (initial majority) faction win.

Conditions:

1. The SK lived longer than 5 nights.

2. Without redirections, Except day 1, SK never attacked any claimed investigative players whole game in a game of possible.
Easy enough to explain that you thought mafia would attack them

3. Without redirections, Except day 1, SK killed 2 times more people from initial minority than from initial majority, in any setup.
We would have to be sure he knew he was attacking a minority

4. Without redirections, Except the last few trash time days in a game, SK targeted the people who are said to be scum during day time.

5. SK is lynched by initial majority faction.

I would argue that you can only really tell if a neut killer is throwing on the last two days. Any time before that is too open to interpretation.

[louiswill]

I would argue that you can only really tell if a neut killer is throwing on the last two days. Any time before that is too open to interpretation.

Agree. I also argue that the game has to be relative long enough.

Because neutr killer really doesn't know who is who but rather random killing, especially in short games which last only 3 nights or so.

Easy enough to explain that you thought mafia would attack them

True. But getting rid of investigative roles is important to all killers, if all evil factions never touch investigative roles, it is just leading to a town win, unless evil KPN is much greater than town lynch speed.

For SK, it is a great and effective way to game throw simply let all investigator alive.

For mafia, such action will be watched by teammates.

It is hard to read, but if a person intended to do so, we should put this attitude in consideration.

The point is, If a SK attacked investigative role, the SK is definitely not game throwing. Thus the condition will work.