S-FM 98 One vs All

[Dagaen]

With Golden Hammer +2 (+4 against Townies) I have the power of death!

-vote CarolinaCrown

Thank you for pronouncing my name correctly

[The Godfather]

CarolinaCrown has been lynched! Stand by for the host's review and day-end post!


CarolinaCrown (4 [L-0]): RLVG, ika, Dagaen, Damus_Graves
Orpz (1 [L-3]): CarolinaCrown
RLVG (1 [L-3]): Orpz

[powerofdeath]

7 men was gathered together to talk it out. Each one of them are trying to figure out who launched the nuke.
They all suspected CarolinaCrown. He and Ika counterclaimed eachother. In the end, they all turned against CarolinaCrown.
He tried to use his FBI skill to escape. He called for a helicopter. It landed quickly, he jumped in and then the helicopter flied up and drove away to somewhere else. Frostbyte took out his RPG7 and aim at the helicopter. He then fired his RPG7. It was a direct hit. The helicopter crashed. They found CarolinaCrown dead on the ground.

Carolina was the escort. Frostbyte was fired for launching the RPG7. Chane came in and replaced him.

1. Damus_Grave
2. Ika
3. Dagaen
4. Orpz
5. CarolinaCrown - Escort
6. Frostbyte Chane
7. RLVG


Day begin at this time

[powerofdeath]

Day 2 has begun!

People are still searching everywhere for this man.
Nobody was killed last night.

I am beginning this earlier because Im busy in few hours and everyone submitted their night actions early.

Alive players
1. Damus_Grave
2. Ika
3. Dagaen
4. Orpz
5. CarolinaCrown - Escort
6. Frostbyte Chane
7. RLVG

Day end at this time!

[ika]

FIRST BITCH

[Damus_Graves]

I'd like to open up aggressively here. I went back and read a few posts of certain members and found them mostly wanting. I believe that because of his lack of a position in the day chat but such willingness to hammer leads me to believe that Dagaen has been recruited, which he was showing tells of being a recruit yesterday, and is now mafia aligned. I believe that ika is still escort-ly, I am clearly town still, and Chane is a nonentity here, with the host confirming everyone sent in actions thus making him townish due to outside the game meta. That leaves Dagaen and Orpz as the possible mafia.

-vote Orpz

[ika]

with still 4 votes to lynch i am tempted to vote with damus but the day begun. I dont want to see a blitz hammer and us losing game. i havework soon so if none come on i will put my vote down but for now i rather wait for others.

[RLVG]

Greetings.

I am the Sheriff.

I knew what would happen, so I investigated ika this night.
He came up as Mafia.



Since ika is now confirmed Mafia, I want to request ignoring him as the GF can re-recruit.
We'll lynch ika the Consort after the GF has been lynched.

[ika]

AFK now. this game is dead to me

[Damus_Graves]

RLVG if you knew it was gonna happen why did you check him?
RLVG why would you reveal knowing ika was a consort now?

[RLVG]

RLVG if you knew it was gonna happen why did you check him?
RLVG why would you reveal knowing ika was a consort now?

1. He claimed Consort. GF can recruit a Consort.
2. The GF is immune to investigations.

From 2, we need to out the GF and lynch him. It's confirmed GG if we lynch the GF and then ika the Consort since Consort's can't recruit.
If we lynch ika, the GF will recruit someone - since I already confirmed myself Sheriff, he'll avoid attempting to recruit me as it fails.

[RLVG]

1. He claimed Consort.

Escort, pardon. But he's now a Consort.

[Damus_Graves]

I suppose. You are now useless as a sheriff since ika shall just roleblock you if we fail to lynch gf.

Rlvg, who do you suspect?

[RLVG]

I suppose. You are now useless as a sheriff since ika shall just roleblock you if we fail to lynch gf.

Rlvg, who do you suspect?

We'll lose if we mislynch.

4v2
- Lynch
3v2
- Kill
2v2

From my analyzis, I suspect Damus_Graves and Orpz.

Hi I'm Town

Excuse me. I misspoke.

Godfather
Escort
Sheriff
Doctor
Doctor
Recruit
Recruit

I do have a claim I can make. However there is no need for me to make it.

[Damus_Graves]

Ah I see. Interesting I suppose. Why dont you suspect Dagaeon or Chane?

[ika]

-vote skip

[RLVG]

I want Damus and Orpz to claim their roles. Damus apparantly soft-claims Doctor in my view.

[Damus_Graves]

I want Damus and Orpz to claim their roles. Damus apparantly soft-claims Doctor in my view.

Recruit

[RLVG]

Recruit

Yet you put two doctors. Why?

[RLVG]

Role List :
- Godfather
- Escort
- Escort
- Sheriff
- Doctor
- Recruit
- Recruit
That's what I personally think.
2X escort and 1X sheriff confirmed, having a third Escort is too stupid and 2X doctors with 1 Recruit would be imbalanced.

[Damus_Graves]

Yet you put two doctors. Why?

To cause the Godfather to miscalculate. Ika ruined it.

[RLVG]

To cause the Godfather to miscalculate. Ika ruined it.

That took long enough to respond.
However: The Godfather should know his role first before others.

That means he know about this line :
Lose immunity to roleblock if you have a consort.

= No witch or bus driver. This mechanic explicitly says "There is 2X escorts."

[Damus_Graves]

That took long enough to respond.
However: The Godfather should know his role first before others.

That means he know about this line :
Lose immunity to roleblock if you have a consort.

= No witch or bus driver. This mechanic explicitly says "There is 2X escorts."

I was talking to fred about keeper stuff lol.

I knew that when the game started. I was banking on the GF to not. Once agian. Ika

[RLVG]

I was talking to fred about keeper stuff lol.

I knew that when the game started. I was banking on the GF to not. Once agian. Ika

That's enough for now.

-vote orpz

Frostbyte was replaced, bad meta but the GF did an action. Ika confirmed Consort. I'm the sheriff.
= Damus, Dagaen, Orpz.

From understanding Damus, I'd like to put him off the list.

Orpz did a trollish "I'm town." which is a higher alert than Dagaen.

[Dagaen]

Ok, I guess this is a role-call day.

I am a Recruit.

I didn't try to pass as Town yesterday and did my best to attract attention - I am still Town, so that means my strategy was succesful.

So New Guy is GF after all?

[Orpz]

Recruit. I don't believe I trolled D1 this time at all, wtf?

Frostbyte is Doctor from lack of Doctor claims, and I FoS Damus.
Dagaen's overly aggressiveness with the votes is not the play of a cautious Mafia, and from this setup I highly expect the Mafia to be cautious on Day 1 and then be more aggressive when they have a buddy, as a mistake on the first day can cost them the game. Damus played much more cautiously than Dagaen.

-vote Damus_Graves

[Damus_Graves]

Recruit. I don't believe I trolled D1 this time at all, wtf?

Frostbyte is Doctor from lack of Doctor claims, and I FoS Damus.
Dagaen's overly aggressiveness with the votes is not the play of a cautious Mafia, and from this setup I highly expect the Mafia to be cautious on Day 1 and then be more aggressive when they have a buddy, as a mistake on the first day can cost them the game. Damus played much more cautiously than Dagaen.

-vote Damus_Graves

Lol

[Dagaen]

It's 4v2 right now so I won't get further than L-2.

Chane, your thoughts?

[RLVG]

Recruit. I don't believe I trolled D1 this time at all, wtf?

Frostbyte is Doctor from lack of Doctor claims, and I FoS Damus.
Dagaen's overly aggressiveness with the votes is not the play of a cautious Mafia, and from this setup I highly expect the Mafia to be cautious on Day 1 and then be more aggressive when they have a buddy, as a mistake on the first day can cost them the game. Damus played much more cautiously than Dagaen.

-vote Damus_Graves

Well, it's a gamble between you and Damus.

[Orpz]

Well, it's a gamble between you and Damus.

I don't think it's a hard choice. I put down my suspicions and Damus didn't try to refute it.

[Damus_Graves]

I work bro.

[Damus_Graves]

tl;dr The reason its Orpz for me is because he instantly focused on me without stopping to consider anything else thats in the realm of possibilities. While it is logical to deduce the scum between the two of us it is more likely to be Orpz than it would be to have myself as mafia. Additionally, I placed my votes first and foremost which is above all things the riskiest thing for a scum to do as it does attract attention. A town however fears no attention and thus I am town.

[Chane]

just got back from diner, I have mixed thoughts atm. I am not entirely confinced that Orpz is GF just yet however his defense post seemed rather aggressive in nature. Based on Damus his play and if I remember him correctly this is his town playstyle.

furthermore I have observed that Damus has been actively scumhunting a lot more then Orpz, it is hard to explain but Orpz seems more scumish in his reaction.

RLVG is confirmed to me as Sher, I haven't gotten a full read on Dagon yet, however I found one post to be a tad weird:

"Ok, I guess this is a role-call day.

I am a Recruit.

I didn't try to pass as Town yesterday and did my best to attract attention - I am still Town, so that means my strategy was succesful.

So New Guy is GF after all?"

I think the claim was a bit early and a bit to preemptive, however I am not drawing conclusions just yet, I think I will vote on Orpz but I'd like to discuss this a bit more to not put him in lynch range of Ika + gf.

I suspect that role list to be like this:

GF
Consort
Escort
Doctor
Sheriff
Recruit/Doctor
Recruit

I heard somebody say he random.org'd the roles, anybody has confirmation on this?

[Chane]

that pretty much summed up my thoughts of the game so far, I haven't been able to scumhunt day1 as I am a replacement but I'll now consider both Damus and Orpz and see if I draw any conclusions when reading it better.

[Dagaen]

Another person calling me Dagon. Damn you Ika.

As I said: I didn't try to pass as town yesterday because I am a Recruit. I'm not a good troll, but I did my best to be worst possible target for Mafs. Anyway, we have no reason to doubt Sheriff that Ika is Mafia so you know I wasn't recruited last night. And it would be hell of a gamble to troll as gf.

"I do have a claim I can make. However there is no need for me to make it. " - That's a weird thing to say as a Recruit, but Damus was always a mystery for me.

Chane, I don't know what's weird with my claim - looks like everybody claimed their roles already. Your turn now.

List of claims:

Dagaen - Recruit
RLVG - Sheriff
Damus_Graves - Recrut
Oprz - Recruit
Ika - Escort/Consort
Chane - ???

Claim or die, dude.

[Chane]

It seems to me that Orpz is soft-claiming recruit (if I am not mistaken, he doesn't specify it but I am gathering it from his posts) and damus and dagon as well, one of them is a false-claim, damus has been a lot more open and dagon has a decent town-claim (although I still find it a bit quick to claim) as it is likely to be damus or Orpz, call it bouncing the ball but I would like Dagon's opinion on Damus and Orpz before committing to a possible loss here, today is gonna be risky however you look at it.

3v2 if we misslynch
2v2 after kill
3v2 if heal

furthermore I'd like both Orpz and Damus his opinion on all the remaining players (besides RLVG as his claim wasn't contested)

[RLVG]

Dagaen - Recruit
RLVG - Sheriff
Damus_Graves - Recrut
Oprz - Recruit
Ika - Escort/Consort
Chane - ???

Claim or die, dude.

3 recruits are logically stupid. There should be one doctor. Dragonite and Damus is the recruits, Chane should be the doctor (Meta: Replacement).

[Chane]

Another person calling me Dagon. Damn you Ika.

As I said: I didn't try to pass as town yesterday because I am a Recruit. I'm not a good troll, but I did my best to be worst possible target for Mafs. Anyway, we have no reason to doubt Sheriff that Ika is Mafia so you know I wasn't recruited last night. And it would be hell of a gamble to troll as gf.

"I do have a claim I can make. However there is no need for me to make it. " - That's a weird thing to say as a Recruit, but Damus was always a mystery for me.

Chane, I don't know what's weird with my claim - looks like everybody claimed their roles already. Your turn now.

List of claims:

Dagaen - Recruit
RLVG - Sheriff
Damus_Graves - Recrut
Oprz - Recruit
Ika - Escort/Consort
Chane - ???

Claim or die, dude.

my claim should come to no surprise, I am doctor.

[Chane]

I actually healed RLVG last night as I highly suspected him to be sheriff (just following instinct besides that he stayed a bit passive day1 yet didn't seem like a lurking gf)

[RLVG]

my claim should come to no surprise, I am doctor.

There's no CC here.

[Chane]

There's no CC here.

IF we have 2 doctors one of the Recruit claims might be a doctor as well, but one of them is also the GF, Orpz has a point that Damus didn't solidly dispute his claim yet which is why I haven't voted him yet, I find Dagon's claim to be the strongest, his townclaim that is.

[Dagaen]

Right now I think Damus is better target than Orpz, but I have little experience with both of them.

Also: we can lynch Ika, making it 4v1. We know that GF probably claimed Recruit.

Tomorrow it will be 3v2, but Sheriff will check one of the Recruits so we will know who lies. And it will be 50-50 chance to lynch GF. How that sounds for you?

Sure, today is also 50-50, because GF is probably Damus or Orpz, but it's 50-50 only for me, because I know I am Recruit. Also Chane could be easily GF, seeing that nobody claimed Doc.

[Chane]

Right now I think Damus is better target than Orpz, but I have little experience with both of them.

Also: we can lynch Ika, making it 4v1. We know that GF probably claimed Recruit.

Tomorrow it will be 3v2, but Sheriff will check one of the Recruits so we will know who lies. And it will be 50-50 chance to lynch GF. How that sounds for you?

Sure, today is also 50-50, because GF is probably Damus or Orpz, but it's 50-50 only for me, because I know I am Recruit. Also Chane could be easily GF, seeing that nobody claimed Doc.

lyncing Ika is an option as well as it would shut off the Role block, however I don't really like the idea of granting GF another new recruit, he already knows who the sheriff and doctor are by now and he will probably recruit rather then kill if we lynch Ika.

[RLVG]

lyncing Ika is an option as well as it would shut off the Role block, however I don't really like the idea of granting GF another new recruit, he already knows who the sheriff and doctor are by now and he will probably recruit rather then kill if we lynch Ika.

Exactly, that's why I've been suggesting to ignore Ika the consort.
We should focus on finding the GF. Sadly, it's an outright gamble.

[Dagaen]

It's a MYLO today (4v2) and it will be MYLO tomorrow (3v2). Choosing between both I'll chose one with more information for Town.

-vote ika

[Dagaen]

Tomorrow we will have the same amount of data, but at least we will know which Recruit is still Town. That's quite an advantage for us.

[Chane]

if we allow Ika to live I think I'll be dead at night if we don't lynch the right one, I am waiting for Damus his counter to Orpz as he has a point in Damus not defending his claim.

I actually considered you to be a doc/rec before you claimed dagon, I still hope you might just be a wifoming doc but little chance of that, that would grant us much more flexibility during tonight if we might misslynch.

hmmm this is a hard one and I'm almost forced to shut down, I'd love Damus to provide a response, otherwise I deem it savest to lynch Ika as it might be to big of a gamble.

[Orpz]

I already considered other players before I made my post. Ika was confirmed Mafia, RLVG unCC'd Sheriff, Chane probably Doctor because it would make sense for at least 1 Doctor and there were no claims. As far as I was concerned, it was Dagaen or Damus, and like Damus mentioned, scum would fear attention so I eliminated Dagaen as his hammering post was meant for attention. I also feel like recruiting Ika was a risky move that involved thinking in several layers of wifom, so it would make sense that Damus would recruit him. I preferred not to include this as it's meta and would therefore weaken my next point. So all that was left was going back and looking for particular scummy trends such as Day 1 cautiousness and Day 2 aggressiveness and I did that and included these results in my first post of this day.

[Dagaen]

I'm not that great with psycho-analysis - this is internet after all, I'm not even sure of your gender. If I can avoid relying on psycho-staff, I will.

Lynching Ika seems like a safest route so I'm choosing it.

[Chane]

It's a MYLO today (4v2) and it will be MYLO tomorrow (3v2). Choosing between both I'll chose one with more information for Town.

-vote ika

this is a solid point, from my perspective either you damus or O could possibly be GF, one of you will get recruited (if he recruits which is most likely) leaving one town Recruit, I might be miscalculating but would that provide an advantage?