SFM One vs All

[powerofdeath]

S-FM One vs All

Godfather
Random Town
Random Town
Random Town
Random Town
Random Town
Random Town

Possible Random Towns: Recruit, Escort, sheriff, doctor

Roles:

Godfather: Kill each night or recruit a recruit to become mafioso, or escort to become consort.
Recruiting requires targeting, and it doesnt automatically succeed
Can kill without mafioso.
Cannot be sent to kill with a mafioso
Immune to roleblock.
Lose immunity to roleblock if you have a consort.
Immune to detection.
Limited to 1 mafioso or 1 consort
May recruit again if your mafia buddy died

Consort: Roleblock someone each night. Cannot be sent to kill

Mafioso: kill someone each night

Recruit: Power in vote. Godfather may recruit you to become a mafioso for the mafia.

Escort: roleblock someone each night. May be recruited to become consort for the Mafia.
Is not informed target is immune to roleblocks
Victim do not know they are roleblocked

Sheriff: investigate someone each night. Target is either NS or mafia.

Doctor: heal someone each night
Informed if target is attacked
Target is infomed of attack

OoO

Escort/consort roleblocks
Mafioso or GF kills
Doctor heals
Gf recruit
Sheriff investigate

Rules:

24 hours day/24 hours night
Start on Day 1 Lynch
51 percent needed to lynch
Last wills are allowed
Death Notes are allowed
No editing or deleting posts
No invisible posts
Yes Pics
No autoplay
No videos
No skyping/PMing
Questions in green
People who are inactive or break rules will be replaced or modkilled

Win Conditions:

Mafia: Gains majority in town
Town: Lynch every mafia.

[RLVG]

What if the Godfather decides only to kill? He's immune to detection and roleblocks.

Sheriff : Useless, everyone NS unless Godfather recruits.
Escort : Useless, victim doesn't know RB and Escort doesn't know immune, can be recruited to Mafia.
Recruit : Useless, can be recruited to Mafia.
Doctor : Helpfull, prevents kills.



Suggestion :
- Make the Escort usefull, make the Godfather vulnerable to roleblocks, let victim know they are roleblocked.
- Maybe a sort of announcement if someone has become recruited?

[powerofdeath]

What if the Godfather decides only to kill? He's immune to detection and roleblocks.

Sheriff : Useless, everyone NS unless Godfather recruits.
Escort : Useless, victim doesn't know RB and Escort doesn't know immune, can be recruited to Mafia.
Recruit : Useless, can be recruited to Mafia.
Doctor : Helpfull, prevents kills.



Suggestion :
- Make the Escort usefull, make the Godfather vulnerable to roleblocks, let victim know they are roleblocked.
- Maybe a sort of announcement if someone has become recruited?

Then everybody is going to play like a citizen. Since when Citizens is not important?

[RLVG]

Then everybody is going to play like a citizen. Since when Citizens is not important?

Let's look at it from an Escort's view.

Escort: roleblock someone each night. May be recruited to become consort for the Mafia.
Is not informed target is immune to roleblocks
Victim do not know they are roleblocked

Godfather: Kill each night or recruit a recruit to become mafioso, or escort to become consort.
Immune to roleblock.
Limited to 1 mafioso or 1 consort
May recruit again if your mafia died

1. Not informed target is immune to roleblocks. The Godfather is the only immune.
2. Target doesn't know they are roleblocked.
3. Can be recruited to the mafia.

So let's see : Escort, more destructive than helping in any possible way.

[powerofdeath]

Let's look at it from an Escort's view.

Escort: roleblock someone each night. May be recruited to become consort for the Mafia.
Is not informed target is immune to roleblocks
Victim do not know they are roleblocked

Godfather: Kill each night or recruit a recruit to become mafioso, or escort to become consort.
Immune to roleblock.
Limited to 1 mafioso or 1 consort
May recruit again if your mafia died

1. Not informed target is immune to roleblocks. The Godfather is the only immune.
2. Target doesn't know they are roleblocked.
3. Can be recruited to the mafia.

So let's see : Escort, more destructive than helping in any possible way.

They are for roleblocking a mafioso

[RLVG]

They are for roleblocking a mafioso

That's the problem I'm seeing : What if The Godfather doesn't recruit at all?
- Everyone will be Citizen, no one can claim anything, no evidence other than kill patterns.
The game will grow into a troll game : Random lynching, everything will be random.

Unless, is the Doctor's Target informed of Attacked / Healed?

I can only read that the Doctor receives the feedback, but not the target.

[powerofdeath]

That's the problem I'm seeing : What if The Godfather doesn't recruit at all?
- Everyone will be Citizen, no one can claim anything, no evidence other than kill patterns.
The game will grow into a troll game : Random lynching, everything will be random.

Unless, is the Doctor's Target informed of Attacked / Healed?

I can only read that the Doctor receives the feedback, but not the target.

Yup

[Hypersniper]

Can I presign if I can/presign and

/blacklist escort

/prefer sheriff

[BorkBot]

Edit GF rolecard to make it explicitly clear that recruitment requires targeting, and that it doesn't automatically succeed by choosing the role you want to recruit.

GF kill and Doctor are missing from the OoO.

Doctor doesn't prevent recruitment, does he?


Recommend moving Sheriff check after GF recruit in the OoO. Sheriff already has the challenge here that he's going to have to double check people and the game will be pretty short.

I do agree Escort is more destructive to the town than he's useful. But with a slightly increased chance of sheriff detection, an escort might be able to get a good block off.

Yes Pics/autoplay
No videos

No video's, but autoplay is allowed?

[powerofdeath]

Edit GF rolecard to make it explicitly clear that recruitment requires targeting, and that it doesn't automatically succeed by choosing the role you want to recruit.

GF kill and Doctor are missing from the OoO.

Doctor doesn't prevent recruitment, does he?


Recommend moving Sheriff check after GF recruit in the OoO. Sheriff already has the challenge here that he's going to have to double check people and the game will be pretty short.

I do agree Escort is more destructive to the town than he's useful. But with a slightly increased chance of sheriff detection, an escort might be able to get a good block off.


No video's, but autoplay is allowed?

Edited GF rolecards
Edited OoO
Doc doesnt prevent recruiting
I dont watch videoes, it can be too long, and I cant listen to what it said

[Cryptonic]

Autoplay is not allowed in any section other than CJ.

[powerofdeath]

Alright no autoplays then

[BorkBot]

Approved.

Sorry for the delay.

[CarolinaCrown]

Does a recruit win a 1v1 tie with the mafia?

This would be enough incentive for a godfather to recruit people.