Register

User Tag List

View Poll Results: What Role do you Want?

Voters
60. You may not vote on this poll
  • Armorsmith

    4 6.67%
  • Crier

    18 30.00%
  • Enchantress

    7 11.67%
  • Marshall

    18 30.00%
  • Architect

    10 16.67%
  • Hunter/Snitch

    1 1.67%
  • Timestopper

    2 3.33%
Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 LastLast
Results 1 to 50 of 126
  1. ISO #1

    Commisioned Town Roles Voting Thread

    You will all get 1 vote towards the role you want to see added. The 2 roles with the highest votes will be added into the game, provided Dark.Revenant is able to code them in. We reserve the right to exclude a winning role and move to the next in line should it not be able to be added within the set timeline/at all.

    The roles and their descriptions are included below for your convenience. Please note, the Names of these roles and the wording of their descriptions are subject to change. Their abilities are not.




    ** We're trying to blend these guys together because alone they're horrible. I still think a role that exists only to die is retarded but there it is.

    The poll will expire after 7 days.
    Last edited by Elixir; April 8th, 2013 at 06:52 PM.
    Photobucket in 2017
    Quote Originally Posted by Brendan View Post
    if you have elixir to contend with gl hf

  2. ISO #2

    Re: Commisioned Town Roles Voting Thread

    Quote Originally Posted by Cryptonic View Post
    if crier is ever implemented, pls make it a unique role.
    This is my entire case. Roles that need to be unique based on game-play, not RP (like Mayor/Godfather, there are only 1 of those) should not exist.

  3. ISO #3

    Re: Commisioned Town Roles Voting Thread

    I voted Architect.
    However, I would prefer if the Architect couldn't enter/view the chat, and it only being between his 2 targets. But I like the idea of the role a lot.

    Quote Originally Posted by S-FM Blue Masquerader View Post
    Hey moron. shut the fuck up or I will shut you up, k? I'm not the person your going to insult and live happily ever after. K? Understand that,

  4. ISO #4

  5. ISO #5

    Re: Commisioned Town Roles Voting Thread

    Why only one vote?

    Quote Originally Posted by Slaol View Post
    This is my entire case. Roles that need to be unique based on game-play, not RP (like Mayor/Godfather, there are only 1 of those) should not exist.
    Spy.










    also Godfather is also gameplay unique since usually it's so damn strong

    and because kill controlling
    Last edited by Lazers; April 8th, 2013 at 07:11 PM.


  6. ISO #6

  7. ISO #7

    Re: Commisioned Town Roles Voting Thread

    I'm surprised your letting Hunter into the poll:P

    Edit:
    Quote Originally Posted by Elixir View Post
    ** We're trying to blend these guys together because alone they're horrible. I still think a role that exists only to die is retarded but there it is.
    There it is.


    Marshall is my top choice, Architect is my second. I'll wait a bit before voting in case a point difference occurs.
    Last edited by Auckmid; April 8th, 2013 at 07:17 PM.

  8. ISO #8

  9. ISO #9

  10. ISO #10

    Re: Commisioned Town Roles Voting Thread

    I still need someone to explain to me how an architect benefits the game when nights are 45 secs long. Does a mafia have to attend 2 night chats when he gets invited? How does this work with the U.I.?
    Spoiler : fm history :
    FM 6: Commoner/Legionare(roman)/Legionare(Sin) FM8: Stan Investigator FM9:Yakov German(Sapper) FM10: Fm Rumpel Vigilante FM11: Renekton: Serial Killer FM12: Sandor: citizen = scum FM13: Wicket : Devourer FM14: Torynn: Andrew Ryan (GF)

  11. ISO #11

  12. ISO #12

    Re: Commisioned Town Roles Voting Thread

    Not really sure why you would need an architect if the town already has PMs that can be used to chat with whoever you want to during the day.

    Since I only get one vote, I'll have to think about it, but I think the architect is a waste of coding space.
    The haters gonna hate, hate, hate, hate, hate
    Baby, I'm just gonna shake, shake, shake, shake, shake
    I shake it off, I shake it off

  13. ISO #13

  14. ISO #14

  15. ISO #15

    Re: Commisioned Town Roles Voting Thread

    Quote Originally Posted by clementine View Post
    Not really sure why you would need an architect if the town already has PMs that can be used to chat with whoever you want to during the day.
    Not all setups necessarily have pm's enabled, and if the conversation is anonymous there's some room for lying that doesn't exist in pm's.

  16. ISO #16

    Re: Commisioned Town Roles Voting Thread

    All setups have pms enabled on NA. What are you talking about? Wut?
    Spoiler : fm history :
    FM 6: Commoner/Legionare(roman)/Legionare(Sin) FM8: Stan Investigator FM9:Yakov German(Sapper) FM10: Fm Rumpel Vigilante FM11: Renekton: Serial Killer FM12: Sandor: citizen = scum FM13: Wicket : Devourer FM14: Torynn: Andrew Ryan (GF)

  17. ISO #17

    Re: Commisioned Town Roles Voting Thread

    Quote Originally Posted by clementine View Post
    Not really sure why you would need an architect if the town already has PMs that can be used to chat with whoever you want to during the day.

    Since I only get one vote, I'll have to think about it, but I think the architect is a waste of coding space.
    Actually, yea. I don't see it adding much thanks to 35 second nights and the 100% chance for PMs. Enchantress it is.

  18. ISO #18

  19. ISO #19

  20. ISO #20

    Re: Commisioned Town Roles Voting Thread

    can I still make more suggestion? I think

    my suggestion, activist

    https://www.sc2mafia.com/forum/showth...838-Activitist

    deserve as much chance as crier and hunter.
    When we talked about pubs, we are talking about us.
    When they talked about pubs, they exclude themselves.
    They say only bad players want to modify citizens, and they do not satisfy bad players.
    Are we bad players? We include bad players, but that is just a part of us.
    ---They put veteran, mayor, allowed jester to visit for nothing, and they regretted and say those things are brainless.

  21. ISO #21

  22. ISO #22

    Re: Commisioned Town Roles Voting Thread

    Quote Originally Posted by creedkingsx View Post
    they don't really deserve a chance, though.

    We made it pretty clear to leave suggestions in the previous thread.
    I left suggestion last week, no one updated the thread.

    ---
    #183 on previous thread.
    Last edited by louiswill; April 8th, 2013 at 11:20 PM.
    When we talked about pubs, we are talking about us.
    When they talked about pubs, they exclude themselves.
    They say only bad players want to modify citizens, and they do not satisfy bad players.
    Are we bad players? We include bad players, but that is just a part of us.
    ---They put veteran, mayor, allowed jester to visit for nothing, and they regretted and say those things are brainless.

  23. ISO #23

    Re: Commisioned Town Roles Voting Thread

    Quote Originally Posted by louiswill View Post
    I left suggestion last week, no one updated the thread.

    ---
    #183 on previous thread.
    You left suggestions for Vote Clerk which nobody backed you on.
    I left suggestion for PhD and Boss backed me on it, and I believe someone else did as well and it didn't make it in.

  24. ISO #24

    Re: Commisioned Town Roles Voting Thread

    Quote Originally Posted by creedkingsx View Post
    You left suggestions for Vote Clerk which nobody backed you on.
    I left suggestion for PhD and Boss backed me on it, and I believe someone else did as well and it didn't make it in.
    Yes, I also asked DR, he said vote clerk is easy to code, as I intended(many of the suggestions are hard to code...), but it is not favored. So I changed to Activist.

    Isn't it wierd enough that my suggestion doesn't even get flamed at all?
    When we talked about pubs, we are talking about us.
    When they talked about pubs, they exclude themselves.
    They say only bad players want to modify citizens, and they do not satisfy bad players.
    Are we bad players? We include bad players, but that is just a part of us.
    ---They put veteran, mayor, allowed jester to visit for nothing, and they regretted and say those things are brainless.

  25. ISO #25

    Re: Commisioned Town Roles Voting Thread

    out of all the roles in the poll... i like Crier best... but still feel that Crier need some work... and maybe a better name...

    other then that... not a huge fan of the roles in the poll...

    still think a Lawyer or something like that... that messes with vote counts would be interesting... like whoever the Lawyer visit at night... will start on the voting with -1... in other words... the person would need one vote extra to be put on the stand/lynch... and/or so they have a INNO vote extra coming from nowhere
    rather to be Mafia, Town, or Neutral... no idea... but a way of protecting people from being lynched
    Last edited by Deantwo; April 9th, 2013 at 02:02 AM.

    Wiki User: Deantwo

    the SC2Mafia Wiki is my playground!
    Spoiler : FM History :


    FM18: Bushwalter (Drug Dealer)

  26. ISO #26

    Re: Commisioned Town Roles Voting Thread

    Quote Originally Posted by Elixir View Post
    [/quote]
    lmfao thats probably like the only role i've ever suggested...
    Spoiler : Forum Mafia :

    FM VI: Ash (Sinner) FM VII: Glen (Drug Dealer) FM VIII: Liane (Vigilante) FM IX: Andrei (Reserved Proletarian) FM X: fm Deathfire123 (Modkilled Blacksmith) FM XI: Corki (Citizen) FM XIII: Phoebe (Bodyguard) FM XIV: Helena (Grave Robber) FM XV: FM Pikachu (Mayor) FM XVI: FM Master Chef (Escort)

  27. ISO #27

  28. ISO #28

  29. ISO #29

    Re: Commisioned Town Roles Voting Thread

    Well, since Crier is gonna lose and since the concept of getting instafucked by an enchantress as scum is retarded (much like escort and jailor instantly dooming SK n1, because that's so much fun and deep), I'm voting Marshall

    Architect is coo', although I can't see it helping the currently dead Mafia chat

    Marshall + Mayor saves would be interesting to say the least
    Last edited by Lazers; April 9th, 2013 at 11:57 AM.


  30. ISO #30

    Re: Commisioned Town Roles Voting Thread

    Quote Originally Posted by Lazers View Post
    Well, since Crier is gonna lose and since the concept of getting instafucked by an enchantress as scum is retarded (much like escort and jailor instantly dooming SK n1, because that's so much fun and deep), I'm voting Marshall

    Architect is coo', although I can't see it helping the currently dead Mafia chat

    Marshall + Mayor saves would be interesting to say the least
    i agree... the roles in this poll aren't all that interesting...

    Wiki User: Deantwo

    the SC2Mafia Wiki is my playground!
    Spoiler : FM History :


    FM18: Bushwalter (Drug Dealer)

  31. ISO #31

    Re: Commisioned Town Roles Voting Thread

    Quote Originally Posted by Deantwo View Post
    i agree... the roles in this poll aren't all that interesting...
    Thats because town is already strong as fuck with the roles which are already in game. I never felt like. "Damn town needs this and that. Because town is lacking" A wider varity of benign , evil neuts is more fun i guess. They can add a lot more game changing mechanics than town roles.

    I wonder if it will be like Marshall automaticly excludes Mayor in setups. We will see. It probably should.
    Spoiler : fm history :
    FM 6: Commoner/Legionare(roman)/Legionare(Sin) FM8: Stan Investigator FM9:Yakov German(Sapper) FM10: Fm Rumpel Vigilante FM11: Renekton: Serial Killer FM12: Sandor: citizen = scum FM13: Wicket : Devourer FM14: Torynn: Andrew Ryan (GF)

  32. ISO #32

    Re: Commisioned Town Roles Voting Thread

    Quote Originally Posted by CmG View Post
    Thats because town is already strong as fuck with the roles which are already in game. I never felt like. "Damn town needs this and that. Because town is lacking" A wider varity of benign , evil neuts is more fun i guess. They can add a lot more game changing mechanics than town roles.
    +1, new neutrals would be cool. but still town loses too often because of the noobs ;) *misses ranked*

  33. ISO #33

    Re: Commisioned Town Roles Voting Thread

    Quote Originally Posted by CmG View Post
    Thats because town is already strong as fuck with the roles which are already in game. I never felt like. "Damn town needs this and that. Because town is lacking" A wider varity of benign , evil neuts is more fun i guess. They can add a lot more game changing mechanics than town roles.

    I wonder if it will be like Marshall automaticly excludes Mayor in setups. We will see. It probably should.
    why should it?

    FM XVII: Bonney Jewelry (Journalist)
    FM XVIII: Kalou (Savage Godfather)
    FM XX: Joseph Bertrand (Marshall)
    FM XXI: USA (Escort)
    FM XV: Whiskey (Whore)

  34. ISO #34

  35. ISO #35

    Re: Commisioned Town Roles Voting Thread

    Quote Originally Posted by Boss View Post
    why should it?
    Because neuts are factionless. So you can give them abilities which benefit just them to achieve their goals. Also their abilities can be stronger as well. You have just more free room designing them.
    Spoiler : fm history :
    FM 6: Commoner/Legionare(roman)/Legionare(Sin) FM8: Stan Investigator FM9:Yakov German(Sapper) FM10: Fm Rumpel Vigilante FM11: Renekton: Serial Killer FM12: Sandor: citizen = scum FM13: Wicket : Devourer FM14: Torynn: Andrew Ryan (GF)

  36. ISO #36

    Re: Commisioned Town Roles Voting Thread

    The original architect was a lot more complicated than simply creating a night chat, and entirely impossible from a practical standpoint. The simplified version proposed at the end of the thread was this: the architect creates a partial roleblock effect. People inside the architect chat can only target each other (and possibly can't be targeted from the outside, much like jail chat).
    FMII: Armorsmith | FMIII: Napoli Godfather | FMIV: Arsonist | FMV: Doctor | FMVI: Greed | FMVIII: Consigliere | FMXVI: Citizen | MFMXVII: Bus Driver | FMXX: Mason

    Il giusto è solo chi sa fingerlo meglio

  37. ISO #37

    Re: Commisioned Town Roles Voting Thread

    Quote Originally Posted by CmG View Post
    I still need someone to explain to me how an architect benefits the game when nights are 45 secs long. Does a mafia have to attend 2 night chats when he gets invited? How does this work with the U.I.?
    The biggest problem would seem to me if a kidnapper got invited.

    3 chats at once.

    And spy would see mafia talk in architect chat (lol)

    Tbh, spy needs its option to disable "see mafia night chat" back. Seeing other people's night chats breaks this game at its core. It's fine just seeing mafia targets.
    [FMVI: Angel FMVIII: Gunsmith FMIX: Peasant FMX: Blacksmith
    MFM-I: Serial Killer MFM-II: Citizen MFM-III: Detective MFM-IV: Godfather/Witch MFM-V: Emperor MFM-VI:Host
    SFM-I: Spy SFM-II: Bandit SFM-III: Host SFM-VI: Skeleton Knight
    Awards: MFM-IV MVP SFM-VI MVP]

  38. ISO #38

  39. ISO #39

  40. ISO #40

    Re: Commisioned Town Roles Voting Thread

    Quote Originally Posted by creedkingsx View Post
    Spy: See ALL the chats.
    Arf. Totally borked.

    I used to find it fun to include spies in my setups because of nice dynamics with lookout and detective. But seeing night chats, it's just a game breaker.
    [FMVI: Angel FMVIII: Gunsmith FMIX: Peasant FMX: Blacksmith
    MFM-I: Serial Killer MFM-II: Citizen MFM-III: Detective MFM-IV: Godfather/Witch MFM-V: Emperor MFM-VI:Host
    SFM-I: Spy SFM-II: Bandit SFM-III: Host SFM-VI: Skeleton Knight
    Awards: MFM-IV MVP SFM-VI MVP]

  41. ISO #41

    Re: Commisioned Town Roles Voting Thread

    What's to prevent the crier from being another mayor cheat? "Hey guys, this is "Name Here", send me all your roles tomorrow and I'll leave it all in LW. Only the town sees his message, and the town knows he's a confirmed town crier, so there's absolute trust both ways and there's no reason for lies. Sounds like a game breaker, to me.

  42. ISO #42

    Re: Commisioned Town Roles Voting Thread

    Quote Originally Posted by Logante View Post
    What's to prevent the crier from being another mayor cheat? "Hey guys, this is "Name Here", send me all your roles tomorrow and I'll leave it all in LW. Only the town sees his message, and the town knows he's a confirmed town crier, so there's absolute trust both ways and there's no reason for lies. Sounds like a game breaker, to me.
    Quote Originally Posted by Logante View Post
    What's to prevent the crier from being another mayor cheat?
    Quote Originally Posted by Logante View Post
    cheat?
    Wut?

    It isn't a 'cheat'. However...

    Quote Originally Posted by Logante View Post
    Sounds like a game breaker, to me.
    It is this. ^

  43. ISO #43

    Re: Commisioned Town Roles Voting Thread

    who said crier gonna lose????
    When we talked about pubs, we are talking about us.
    When they talked about pubs, they exclude themselves.
    They say only bad players want to modify citizens, and they do not satisfy bad players.
    Are we bad players? We include bad players, but that is just a part of us.
    ---They put veteran, mayor, allowed jester to visit for nothing, and they regretted and say those things are brainless.

  44. ISO #44

  45. ISO #45

    Re: Commisioned Town Roles Voting Thread

    Quote Originally Posted by Logante View Post
    What's to prevent the crier from being another mayor cheat? "Hey guys, this is "Name Here", send me all your roles tomorrow and I'll leave it all in LW. Only the town sees his message, and the town knows he's a confirmed town crier, so there's absolute trust both ways and there's no reason for lies. Sounds like a game breaker, to me.
    Quote Originally Posted by Elixir View Post
    when it says "entire town" it's meant as "EVERYONE IN GAME" not just Townies... it's a common thing to confuse...

    Wiki User: Deantwo

    the SC2Mafia Wiki is my playground!
    Spoiler : FM History :


    FM18: Bushwalter (Drug Dealer)

  46. ISO #46

  47. ISO #47

    Re: Commisioned Town Roles Voting Thread

    Quote Originally Posted by Numbertwo View Post
    It would be a disaster if both crier and marshall was implemented. 2 Roles that can Instantly confirm themselves as town if they want to.
    The new troll setup:
    Mayor
    Marshall
    Crier
    Spy
    Bodyguard
    Bodyguard
    Bodyguard
    Bodyguard
    Bodyguard
    Mafia
    Mafia
    Mafia
    Neut
    Neut
    Neut
    [FMVI: Angel FMVIII: Gunsmith FMIX: Peasant FMX: Blacksmith
    MFM-I: Serial Killer MFM-II: Citizen MFM-III: Detective MFM-IV: Godfather/Witch MFM-V: Emperor MFM-VI:Host
    SFM-I: Spy SFM-II: Bandit SFM-III: Host SFM-VI: Skeleton Knight
    Awards: MFM-IV MVP SFM-VI MVP]

  48. ISO #48

    Re: Commisioned Town Roles Voting Thread

    AHHHH Pls no Crier unless Jester is given the Crier ability.... Confirmed towns r teh lame.
    Also, I miss the days when Spy could partake in Mason chat =[ Can we bring back that setting? lol


    Also, Architect would be awesome imo. But, I turn off PMs in my games (so funny to see mayor reveal d2 and go "PM me roles" LOL). But also, I think Architect can connect town members anonymously without scum knowing that this information had passed between them. Seriously, if ppl are PMing in your game, the smartest thing to do as scum is kill them. So if you can secretly be talking to eachother without scum knowing, then it would be beneficial towards the town.

    Quote Originally Posted by S-FM Blue Masquerader View Post
    Hey moron. shut the fuck up or I will shut you up, k? I'm not the person your going to insult and live happily ever after. K? Understand that,

  49. ISO #49

  50. ISO #50

    Re: Commisioned Town Roles Voting Thread

    Quote Originally Posted by Cryptonic View Post
    AHHHH Pls no Crier unless Jester is given the Crier ability.... Confirmed towns r teh lame.
    Also, I miss the days when Spy could partake in Mason chat =[ Can we bring back that setting? lol


    Also, Architect would be awesome imo. But, I turn off PMs in my games (so funny to see mayor reveal d2 and go "PM me roles" LOL). But also, I think Architect can connect town members anonymously without scum knowing that this information had passed between them. Seriously, if ppl are PMing in your game, the smartest thing to do as scum is kill them. So if you can secretly be talking to eachother without scum knowing, then it would be beneficial towards the town.
    I agree with the anti-crier suggestion and endorse it

    could be interesting

    Quote Originally Posted by Numbertwo View Post
    I think we should be allowed to have 2 choices, i doubt people that vote for marshall will have crier as their 2nd choice.
    I think a single vote is more representative of what people want the most, although I will agree that Marshall + Crier isn't a very great combo

    but honestly if it means enshitress not getting in I'm fine with it


 

 

Similar Threads

  1. New Town Roles Discussion Thread
    By Sinclair in forum Mafia Discussion
    Replies: 20
    Last Post: April 24th, 2013, 08:26 AM
  2. Too lazy to do it myself (voting roles)
    By FireTruK in forum Mafia Discussion
    Replies: 1
    Last Post: February 26th, 2012, 01:25 AM
  3. Recruitment Voting Thread
    By monster in forum Forum Mafia II
    Replies: 10
    Last Post: August 10th, 2011, 05:48 AM

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •