Starting a member-based anime ratings thingy here.
Simply post the name of an anime and what you rate it, i'll list the ratings and put an average for each one.
Angel Beats - 10.0 (Roflcopter)
Average - 10
Kara no Kyoukai: 10 (marinebase7), 10 Capitalier
Average - 10
Excel Saga - 9.25 (Roflcopter)
Average - 9.25
Trigun - 9.25 (Capitalier)
Average - 9.25
Puella Magi Madoka Magica - 9.25 (Capitalier)
Average - 9.25
Death note - 10 (Chane) 9 (marinebase7) 8.5 (RLVG)
Average - 9.16
Elfen Lied - 10 (Brendan) 8 (Roflcopter) 9.1 (RLVG)
Average - 9.03
Bodacious Space Pirates - 9.0 (Roflcopter)
Average - 9
Ghost in the Shell - 9 (Capitalier)
Average - 9
FMA: Brotherhood - 8.0 (RLVG) 10 (marinebase7)
Average - 9
Steins gate - 8 (Chane) 10 (marinebase7)
Average - 9
Baccano - 9 (Chane)
Average - 9
No. 6 - 9 (Chane)
Average - 9
Samurai Champloo: 9 (marinebase7)
Average - 9
Dragonball Z: 10 (Ash) 6 (RLVG) (10) Timetrx
Average - 9
Slayers - 9 (Roflcopter)
Average - 9
Sword Art Online - 9.5 (Roflcopter) 9.4 (RLVG) 7 (marinebase7)
Average - 8.63
Eden of the east - 8.5 (Roflcopter)
Average - 8.5
Cowboy Bebop - 8.5 (Capitalier)
Average - 8.5
Dragon Ball GT - 8.5 (Timetrx)
Average - 8.5
Fate/Zero - 8.75 (Capitalier) 8 (marinebase7)
Average - 8.325
Hellsing - 8.3 (RLVG)
Average - 8.3
Paranoia Agent - 8.25 (Capitalier)
Average - 8.25
Pokemon: 10 (Ash) 6.5 (RLVG)
Average - 8.25
Mirai Nikki - 9.0 (Roflcopter) 7 (marinebase7)
Average - 8
FMA: Brotherhood - 8 (Capitalier)
Average - 8
Code Geass: 8 (marinebase7)
Average - 8
Bleach (soul society arc): 8 (marinebase7)
Average - 8
Eureka Seven: 8 (Raptorblaze)
Average - 8
Spice and Wolf - 7.5 (RLVG) 8.5 (Roflcopter)
Average - 8
Kyoukai Senjou no Horizon - 7.9 (RLVG)
Average - 7.9
Darker than black - 7.7 (RLVG)
Average - 7.7
Gurran Lagann - 7.5 (Roflcopter)
Average - 7.5
hayate no gotoku - 7.5 (Roflcopter)
Average - 7.5
Suzumiya Haruhi no Shoushitsu - 7.4 (RLVG)
Average - 7.4
Amaenaideyo - 7.2 (RLVG)
Average - 7.2
Yu Yu Hakusho - 7 (Capitalier)
Average - 7
Eureka Seven AO: 7 (Raptorblaze)
Average - 7
Claymore: 7 (marinebase7)
Average - 7
nichijou - 6.5 (Chane)
Average - 6.5
k-on - 5 (Chane)
Average - 5
hetalia - 3.5 (Chane)
Average - 3.5
digimon: 0 (Ash) 6 (RLVG)
Average - 3
yu-gi-oh: 0 (Ash) 4 (RLVG)
Average - 2
naruto: 0 (Ash) 1 (RLVG)
Average - 0.5