Mafia, role rankings. My god I had nothing to do that day.

[Slaol]

My opinion might have changed since I made this. Might have just missed some things. Enjoy.

Spoiler : Yea. :

Mafia – Mega Rankings – All Roles – All Host Setups

1. Veteran - Infinite Nights, Ignore Immunity
2. Jailor - Infinite Executions, start on day
3. Jailor - Infinite Executions
4. Mass Murderer - Invulnerable, no nights, can target self
5. Mass Murderer - No nights, can target self
6. Cultist - None, Mafia not in game
7. Cultist - None, Mafia in game
8. Cultist - Immunity prevents, Mafia not in game
9. Cultist - Immunity prevents, Mafia in game
10. Jailor - 3 Executions, start on day
11. Jailor - 3 Executions
12. Veteran - 3 Nights, Ignore Immunity
13. Godfather - Immune to death, immune to detection, immune to role blocking, can kill without Mafioso
14. Serial Killer - Invulnerable, kills blockers, wins ties
15. Arsonist - Ignores immunity, immune to death, ignores healing
16. Arsonist - Immune to death, ignores healing
17. Arsonist - Immune to death, ignores immunity
18. Godfather - Can kill without Mafioso, immune to death, immune to detection
19. Godfather - Can kill without Mafioso, immune to detection, immune to role blocking
20. Mass Murderer - Invulnerable, 1 night, can target self
21. Mass Murderer - Invulnerable, 2 nights, can target self
22. Godfather - Can kill without Mafioso, immune to death, immune to role blocking
23. Serial Killer - Invulnerable, kills blockers
24. Mass Murderer - Invulnerable, no nights
25. Arsonist - Immune to death, ignores immunity, ignores healing, target knows he is doused
26. Arsonist - Immune to death, ignores healing, target knows he is doused
27. Arsonist - Immune to death, ignores immunity, target knows he is doused
28. Serial Killer - Invulnerable, wins ties
29. Mass Murderer - Invulnerable, 1 night
30. Serial Killer - Invulnerable
31. Arsonist - Immune to death
32. Arsonist - Immune to death, target knows he is doused
33. Mass Murderer - Invulnerable, 2 nights
34. Veteran - Infinite Nights
35. Janitor - Becomes Mafioso, infinite cleanings
36. Janitor - Becomes Mafioso, 3 cleanings
37. Janitor - Becomes Mafioso, 2 cleanings
38. Janitor - Infinite cleanings
39. Consigliere - Detects Exact, Replaces Godfather
40. Consigliere - Replaces Godfather
41. Consigliere - Detects Exact, Becomes Mafioso
42. Investigator - Detects exact role
43. Witch - Can cause self targets
44. Framer - Immune to detection, becomes Mafioso
45. Mass Murderer - 1 night, can target self
46. Mass Murderer - 2 nights, can target self
47. Framer - Becomes Mafioso
48. Framer - Immune to detection
49. Jailor - 2 Executions, start on day
50. Jailor - 2 Executions
51. Veteran - 2 Nights, Ignore Immunity
52. Bodyguard - Can be healed, prevents conversion, ignores immunity
53. Bodyguard - Can be healed, ignores immunity
54. Bus Driver - Can Swap Self
55. Witch - No Powers
56. Spy - Can see Mafia Targets, Mafias kill, Hear PMs
57. Spy - Can see Mafia Targets, Hear PMs
58. Spy - Can see Mafia Targets
59. Mass Murderer - No nights
60. Lookout - Ignore immunity, can watch self
61. Lookout - Ignore immunity
62. Lookout - Can watch self
63. Lookout - No Powers
64. Serial Killer - Kills blockers, wins ties
65. Serial Killer - Kills blockers
66. Consort - Can not be role blocked, detects role block immunity, becomes Mafioso
67. Consort - Can not be role blocked, detects role block immunity
68. Escort - Cannot be role blocked, detects immunity
69. Consort - Detects role block immunity
70. Escort - Detects immunity
71. Consort - Can not be role blocked, becomes Mafioso
72. Consort - Can not be role blocked
73. Escort - Cannot be role blocked
74. Bodyguard - Ignores immunity, prevents conversion
75. Bodyguard - Ignores immunity
76. Bodyguard - Can be healed, prevents conversion
77. Bodyguard - Can be healed
78. Janitor - 3 cleanings
79. Disguiser - Becomes Mafioso, Cleans role
80. Arsonist - Ignores immunity, ignores healing
81. Arsonist - Ignores healing
82. Mayor - 4 Votes, can be healed, keeps votes
83. Mayor - 4 Votes, can be healed
84. Consigliere - Becomes Mafioso
85. Consigliere - No Powers
86. Arsonist - Ignores immunity
87. Godfather - Immune to detection, immune to death, immune to role blocking
88. Godfather - Immune to detection, immune to death
89. Janitor - 2 cleanings
90. Godfather - Immune to detection, immune to role blocking
91. Sheriff - Detects all
92. Investigator - No Powers
93. Sheriff - Detects Cult, Mass Murderer, Serial Killer
94. Sheriff - Detects Cult, Mass Murderer, Arsonist
95. Sheriff - Detects Cult, Serial Killer, Arsonist
96. Sheriff - Detects Cult, Mass Murderer
97. Sheriff - Detects Cult, Serial Killer
98. Sheriff - Detect Cult, Arsonist
99. Sheriff - Detect Mass Murderer, Serial Killer, Arsonist
100. Sheriff - Detects Cult
101. Cultist - 1 night, Mafia not in game
102. Cultist - 1 night, mafia in game
103. Cultist - 1 night, immunity prevents, mafia not in game
104. Cultist - 1 night, immunity prevents, mafia in game
105. Detective - Ignore Detection Immunity
106. Sheriff - Detects Mass Murderer, Serial Killer
107. Sheriff - Detects Mass Murderer, Arsonist
108. Sheriff - Detects Serial Killer, Arsonist
109. Sheriff - Detects Mass Murderer
110. Sheriff - Detects Serial Killer
111. Sheriff - Detect Arsonist
112. Detective - No Powers
113. Sheriff - No Detections but Mafia.
114. Doctor - Knows if target is attacked, prevents cultist conversion, knows if target is converted
115. Mason Leader - 4 Recruits, 4 Citizens, Cult in game
116. Mason Leader - 4 Recruits, 4 Citizens
117. Mayor - 3 Votes, can be healed, keeps votes
118. Mayor - 3 Votes, can be healed
119. Mayor - 2 Votes, can be healed, keeps votes
120. Mayor - 2 Votes, can be healed
121. Mayor - 4 Votes, keeps votes
122. Mason Leader - 4 Recruits, 3 Citizens, Cult in game
123. Mason Leader - 3 recruits, 3 Citizens, Cult in game
124. Mason Leader - 4 Recruits, 3 Citizens
125. Mason Leader - 3 Recruits, 3 Citizens
126. Mayor - 4 Votes
127. Mayor - 3 Votes, keeps votes
128. Mason Leader - 4 Recruits, 2 Citizens, Cult in game
129. Mason Leader - 3 Recruits, 2 Citizens, Cult in game
130. Mason Leader - 2 Recruits, 2 Citizens, Cult in game
131. Mason Leader - 4 Recruits, 2 Citizens
132. Mason Leader - 3 Recruits, 2 Citizens
133. Mason Leader - 2 Recruits, 2 Citizens
134. Mayor - 3 Votes
135. Mayor - 2 Votes, keep votes
136. Mason Leader - 4 Recruits, 1 Citizen, Cult in game
137. Mason Leader - 3 Recruits, 1 Citizen, Cult in game
138. Mason Leader - 2 Recruits, 1 Citizen, Cult in game
139. Mayor - 2 Votes
140. Spy - Can see Mafias kill, Hear Pms
141. Spy - Can Hear PMs
142. Bus Driver - Can NOT Swap Self
143. Coroner - Discovers all targets, discovers last will, discovers death type
144. Coroner - Discovers all targets, discovers last will
145. Consort - Becomes Mafioso
146. Consort - No Powers
147. Escort - No Powers
148. Mass Murderer - 1 night
149. Mafioso – No Powers
150. Serial Killer - Wins ties
151. Serial Killer – No Powers
152. Mass Murderer - 2 nights
153. Vigilante - Infinite shots
154. Arsonist - No Powers
155. Coroner - Discovers all target, discovers death type
156. Coroner - Discovers all target
157. Godfather - Immune to death
158. Godfather - Immune to death, immune to role blocking
159. Doctor - Knows if target is attacked, prevents cultist
160. Doctor - Knows if attacked, knows if converted
161. Doctor - Knows if attacked
162. Doctor - Prevents cultist, knows if converted
163. Doctor - Prevents cultist
164. Doctor - Knows if converted
165. Cultist - 2 nights, mafia not in game
166. Cultist - 2 nights mafia in game
167. Arsonist - Ignores immunity, ignores healing, target knows he is doused
168. Arsonist - Ignores healing, target knows he is doused
169. Arsonist - Ignores immunity, target knows he is doused
170. Doctor - No Power
171. Executioner - Invulnerable, becomes Jester, target is Jester
172. Executioner - Invulnerable, becomes jester
173. Jester - Kill is ON
174. Executioner - Becomes jester
175. Jester - Kill is OFF
176. Executioner - Invulnerable, target is town, becomes jester
177. Executioner - Invulnerable, must survive, become jester
178. Executioner - Invulnerable, must survive, target is town, becomes jester
179. Executioner - Invulnerable
180. Executioner - Invulnerable, target is town
181. Executioner - Invulnerable, must survive
182. Cultist - 2 nights, immunity prevents, mafia not in game
183. Cultist - 2 nights, immunity prevents, mafia in game
184. Vigilante - 4 shots
185. Survivor - 4 Vests
186. Mason Leader - 4 Recruits, Cult in game
187. Vigilante - 3 shots
188. Veteran - 3 Nights
189. Survivor - 3 Vests
190. Mason Leader - 3 Recruits, Cult in game
191. Executioner - Invulnerable, must survive, target is town
192. Vigilante - 2 shots
193. Veteran - 2 Nights
194. Survivor - 2 Vests
195. Mason Leader - 2 Recruits, Cult in game
196. Mason - Becomes Leader if Alone
197. Coroner - Discovers last will, discovers death type
198. Coroner - Discovers last will
199. Blackmailer - Becomes Mafioso
200. Blackmailer - Becomes Mafioso, Victim Can talk
201. Blackmailer - No Powers
202. Blackmailer - Victim Can talk
203. Spy - Can see Mafia Kill
204. Spy - No Powers
205. Godfather – No Powers
206. Mason - No Powers
207. Godfather - Immune to role blocking
208. Amnesiac - Can become all roles, new role NOT revealed
209. Amnesiac - Can become all roles, New role revealed to town
210. Amnesiac - Can become Town, can become killing, new role NOT revealed
211. Amnesiac - Can become Town, can become Killing, new role revealed
212. Amnesiac - Can becomes Town, can become Mafia, new role NOT revealed
213. Amnesiac - Can become Town, can become Mafia, new role revealed
214. Amnesiac - Can become mafia, can become killing, new role NOT revealed
215. Amnesiac - Can become Mafia, can become killing, new role revealed
216. Amnesiac - Can become Town, new role revealed
217. Amnesiac - Can become killing, new role not revealed
218. Amnesiac - Can be Mafia, new role not revealed
219. Amnesiac - Can become Town, new role not revealed
220. Amnesiac - Can become killing, new role revealed
221. Amnesiac - Can become mafia, new role revealed
222. Amnesiac - Can not become anything, new role not revealed
223. Amnesiac - Can not become anything, role revealed.
224. Jailor - 1 Executions, start on day
225. Disguiser - Becomes Mafioso, doesn’t clean role
226. Arsonist - Target knows he is doused
227. Witch - Can cause self targets, target knows they have been manipulated
228. Witch - Target knows they have been manipulated
229. Disguiser - Doesn’t clean role
230. Jailor - 1 Execution
231. Bodyguard - Prevents conversion
232. Bodyguard - No Powers
233. Vigilante - 1 shot
234. Citizen - Vest, wins ties
235. Citizen - Wins ties
236. Citizen - Vest
237. Survivor - 1 Vest
238. Citizen - No Powers
239. Coroner - Discoverer death type
240. Coroner - No Powers
241. Survivor - No Vests
242. Executioner - Target is town, becomes jester
243. Executioner - Must survive to end, becomes jester
244. Executioner - No Power
245. Executioner - Target is town
246. Executioner - Must survive to end
247. Executioner - Must survive to end, target is town

[Fatalis]

JESTER>EVERYTHING

[Ash]

Nah, citizens should be number one

[Slaol]

Nah, citizens should be number one

This is a power rankings, not a value-to-the-game ranking. Citizen, Jester, Mafioso, and maybe Exec would be top 4 if it were.

[Ash]

lol amnesiac takes a shitton of ranking places. like a boss

[Brendan]

wow...

[MissingNo]

This makes 0 sense.

[Roflcopter]

It's what role settings contribute to the "Power" ratings at the end of a game.

[Cryptonic]

It's what role settings contribute to the "Power" ratings at the end of a game.

lol no i'm pretty sure this is just his opinion.

[Roflcopter]

oh?

Someone should make a list of the power rankings then.

[Cryptonic]

oh?

Someone should make a list of the power rankings then.

I agree. I don't even know what affects it other than #s lol

[Lysergic]

oh?

Someone should make a list of the power rankings then.

Only DR knows them, and the team power ranking depends on a lot other than just role settings.

[Auckmid]

God, this is a long list.

As far as most powerful goes, it would obviously be infi-shot Vigilante. The only reason people never think of Vigilante as the most powerful role is because it back-fires most easily, and no one knows how to play it.

[Lysergic]

God, this is a long list.

As far as most powerful goes, it would obviously be infi-shot Vigilante. The only reason people never think of Vigilante as the most powerful role is because it back-fires most easily, and no one knows how to play it.

Yeah, Vig seems more powerful than Vet because Vet has no control of who he actually kills. Inf Alert Vet will kill a lot of town; Inf Shot Vig is a scalpel for the surgical elimination of the Mafia/other Scum.

[Slaol]

God, this is a long list.

As far as most powerful goes, it would obviously be infi-shot Vigilante. The only reason people never think of Vigilante as the most powerful role is because it back-fires most easily, and no one knows how to play it.

I am OK with this idea. But would force myself to put Mafioso, Serial Killer, and (max) Godfather above him. As all consist of a night kill, but can attack on n1. Mafioso and Godfather having the night chat as well.