How does one know exact role of each player in the game?

[DoubleX]

Hello, I was in a game, I was playing mafia, and a town fellow was able to name everyone member of mafia of correct role when he was being lynched. How is this possible?

[Blazer]

Hello, I was in a game, I was playing mafia, and a town fellow was able to name everyone member of mafia of correct role when he was being lynched. How is this possible?

Possibly cheating. If you wish, you can make a formal report. (Click my signature for the link to the guidelines.)

[MissingNo]

Also maybe he figured it out and made an educated guess with the information he gathered.

[DoubleX]

Hmm, I don't bother reporting because the save is pretty long ago, I would have to go through all the replays to get the right one. Btw the person's name is fred, the color code guide guy, if that helps. Does he always cheat?

[Blazer]

Hmm, I don't bother reporting because the save is pretty long ago, I would have to go through all the replays to get the right one. Btw the person's name is fred, the color code guide guy, if that helps. Does he always cheat?

Oh ok. Well never mind then. And nope, that doesn't help at all.

[Ash]

Hmm, I don't bother reporting because the save is pretty long ago, I would have to go through all the replays to get the right one. Btw the person's name is fred, the color code guide guy, if that helps. Does he always cheat?

Lol you think he cheats?...
Fred is a keeper.
'nuff said.

[DoubleX]

Lol you think he cheats?...
Fred is a keeper.
'nuff said.

What is a keeper exactly? He gets inside view of the game of who is what role? By the way he had about 30k points, I was in one game with him the first time we were both mafia, and he game threw by lynching me, then the second game I found out which of the player is fred, I went all "he is mafia!" on him, when he was being lynched he was able to mention all of the exact roles of which player are mafia, which is impossible if you ask me, without being able to get access.

[creedkingsx]

Replay or it didn't happen. Fred is a good person and would never abuse his powers. So until I see proof, I am calling bullshit.
Raptor, infract me if you must.

[DoubleX]

so if I were able to find proof, what will happen to him then?

[AppleyNO]

so if I were able to find proof, what will happen to him then?

I AM NOT A MODERATOR


I would assume fred would be stripped of his power, because that is Abuse.

However, I agree with creed right now, of all mods, fred wouldn't be the one to do it.
Replay please.

[Nick]

Herp. That is hacking, not abuse. Permaban.

Also, false reporting is also permaban.

[AppleyNO]

Herp. That is hacking, not abuse. Permaban.

Also, false reporting is also permaban.

*Insert picture of farmer to indicate post farming*

Keepers can see the role list and player names with a command, remember?

[DoubleX]

Well I must know what I am getting into, I'm not gonna spend 2 hours looking for replays for 7 days suspend, he messed up two of my games, which he might be having lots of fun, but made other players feel very unfair. I think stripped him of his power and reset the account should be enough. Although I think he knows how to hack....

[creedkingsx]

If you file a report on Mod Abuse, it will get thoroughly anazlyzed by a supermod, not normal moderator like myself.
Decisions would be made then.

[DoubleX]

I did some research on how the mods operate, it is likely fred is a troll, he has about 100 wins and 900 loses, if you check his profile he loses every mafia game, and the reviews on mafia on starcraft 2 are players ranting about the troll mods that randomly bans player, and if a player submits a replay it would be removed by other mods, mafia is as corrupted as it's name. I fear this thread will be removed as well.

[AppleyNO]

I did some research on how the mods operate, it is likely fred is a troll, he has about 100 wins and 900 loses, if you check his profile he loses every mafia game, and the reviews on mafia on starcraft 2 are players ranting about the troll mods that randomly bans player, and if a player submits a replay it would be removed by other mods, mafia is as corrupted as it's name. I fear this thread will be removed as well.

I think you fell for the Trolls who actually got banned.

Everyone who is banned is banned for a reason. The Mods are not corrupt in handling reports and don't randomly ban people, nor are reports removed because it is reporting a mod.

[Raptorblaze]

Creed, I don't infract for contributing to a conversation -.-

DoubleX, You can't see a person's account name during the course of a game, it gets revealed to you at the end. I find it rather hard to believe if this game was really a long time ago that you still remembered the account name who was behind revealing the mafia and not just the in game name, so forgive me if I'm rather skeptical. Especially when fred is the one accused.

[Raptorblaze]

I did some research on how the mods operate, it is likely fred is a troll, he has about 100 wins and 900 loses, if you check his profile he loses every mafia game, and the reviews on mafia on starcraft 2 are players ranting about the troll mods that randomly bans player, and if a player submits a replay it would be removed by other mods, mafia is as corrupted as it's name. I fear this thread will be removed as well.

Those players were banned with several replays showing their offenses and are publicly available.

But yes, if you provide proof and it's legitimate there would be consequences.