Serial Killer or Arsonist? Who deserves to win?

[gaspiden]

As the post title suggests, who do you think deserves more to win in a tie, SK or Arson?

[Damus_Graves]

by preformace during the game. thats how i do it (im usually survivor)

[SirBlayzalot]

depends... if arson is not night immune.. I say arson... if he is... I say sk

[kyle1234513]

last 2 ppl alive, serial killer and arson, arson runs at you with a gas can, serial killer runs at you with a knife, i wonder whos gunna win that 1v1.

the reason for it is arson takes 2 nights to kill 1 target whereas the sk can kill every night

[Damus_Graves]

last 2 ppl alive, serial killer and arson, arson runs at you with a gas can, serial killer runs at you with a knife, i wonder whos gunna win that 1v1.

the reason for it is arson takes 2 nights to kill 1 target whereas the sk can kill every night

unless both are immune.

[Pokemon Trainer Red]

Arson. Harder to win as.

[Damus_Graves]

Arson. Harder to win as.

Sometimes true. Neutral killers are tough wins regardless tho

[SirBlayzalot]

last 2 ppl alive, serial killer and arson, arson runs at you with a gas can, serial killer runs at you with a knife, i wonder whos gunna win that 1v1.

the reason for it is arson takes 2 nights to kill 1 target whereas the sk can kill every night

if someone was running at me with a gas can and a zippo.... I'd be getting the fuck outah dodge... knife or not..

[Ambient]

Depends who played better in the game. I generally give it to the better liar.

[EagleMan]

Sometimes true. Neutral killers are tough wins regardless tho

Mathematically the SK has more killing power, so if the Arsonist manages to be around at the end, he should win the tie to balance out SK's inherent advantage.

[EliteMarine]

Honestly, if the setup is like this:

Arson = Immune
Arson = Victims know they are doused

SK = Immune


Then I would give it to the arsonist. SK can hide as potiential doc which town has SOME kind of respect for. Bus Drivers are like fodder. Someone has gas, they die. Done deal.

I am considering for my save that either victims won't know they are doused or undetectable by Sheriff. That may give a bit of a safety net for arson.

[gaspiden]

Wait was sirblayzalot really banned? What's with the description beneath his name?

[creedkingsx]

Wait was sirblayzalot really banned? What's with the description beneath his name?

He was spamming advertisements to people.
The infractions from that along with previous infractions led to a ban.

[Chane]

Arsonist. hell i never won as that role up until now. I just can't refuse to make my first arson win be disco inferno :P

[Voss]

Honestly, if the setup is like this:

Arson = Immune
Arson = Victims know they are doused

SK = Immune


Then I would give it to the arsonist. SK can hide as potiential doc which town has SOME kind of respect for. Bus Drivers are like fodder. Someone has gas, they die. Done deal.

I am considering for my save that either victims won't know they are doused or undetectable by Sheriff. That may give a bit of a safety net for arson.

+1

arsonist, unless you make him undetectable

[Damus_Graves]

i agree

+1

arsonist, unless you make him undetectable

[Azuriae]

As said above; If victims knows they are doused, yet the Arsonist still lives 'till the end, He'd deserve the win over the SK.
Victims knows they are doused: OFF = SK probably deserves it more.

[EagleMan]

Even in that case, if Arso is just as detectable as SK and they're both immune, SK still has more killing power, so I think Arsonist deserves the win more.

[Beerwolf]

Arsonist surely, as it's harder to win as one... SK can kill a Sheriff / Investigator potentially each night... Arsonist doesn't.