Search:

If I die lipstick is still town just stupid.

If I die lipstick is still town just stupid.

[QUOTE=FM-Lipstick;1010890]Didn't you already shoot?[/QUOTE]

That's a vote.

Originally Posted by FM-Lipstick

Didn't you already shoot?

That's a vote.

[QUOTE=FM-Autumn;1010882]their reaction when i suspected them (right before itas when i had them as tier 1 kill) seemed very towny tbh

like in the sense of "getting mad because they don't understand why they're being suspected, and then confbiasing themselves into believing my entire shotlist was bad as a result"

i have nothing else on them though[/QUOTE]

Did you already forget the post I quoted to you.

Originally Posted by FM-Autumn

their reaction when i suspected them (right before itas when i had them as tier 1 kill) seemed very towny tbh

like in the sense of "getting mad because they don't understand why they're being suspected, and then confbiasing themselves into believing my entire shotlist was bad as a result"

i have nothing else on them though

Did you already forget the post I quoted to you.

[B][COLOR="#FF0000"]-vote FM-Monet Rocket[/COLOR][/B]

[VOTE]unvote[/VOTE]


[B][SIZE=1][I][COLOR="#FF0000"]This post was edited by hosts in order to unvote with a dead player in a non-disruptive way.[/COLOR][/I][/SIZE][/B]

-vote FM-Monet Rocket

-vote unvote

This post was edited by hosts in order to unvote with a dead player in a non-disruptive way.

[QUOTE=FM-Ringmaster;1010861]I’ll sleep on the goblin stuff but later into the game when I’m dead I want people to remember to look into that slot considering how weird the post I quoted is if ZOMB was a wolf who wanted to inform disco of some small things to just throw golbin there[/QUOTE]

That was literally after I just hard questioned them. Lol.

Originally Posted by FM-Ringmaster

I’ll sleep on the goblin stuff but later into the game when I’m dead I want people to remember to look into that slot considering how weird the post I quoted is if ZOMB was a wolf who wanted to inform disco of some small things to just throw golbin there

That was literally after I just hard questioned them. Lol.

[QUOTE=FM-Goblin and Worg;1000694]And what do you make of that 'shit reaction'? Do you think Bad Hair is a wolf that has flown under the radar and you caught Disco for reacting badly for you starting a wagon on him, or do you have something else in mind?[/QUOTE]

[QUOTE=FM-ZOMG;1000711]I don't think in anonymous I can condemn anyone on one data point like what you're suggesting lol

the shit reaction was primarily a joke at their expense - though if bad ever flips scum then I think the phrasing of that reaction should be given consideration.

I think what is natural for town to do when they see a low poster vote like I did without context is to just... ask the context. Here it kind of gives TMI vibes with how exasperated, but that could just be how disco reacts generally to things like this.


as for Protag hair I think they


...

...

..........

I just realized mid post that I confused bad hair day and protagonist hair. just gonna hit send and curl into a ball in the corner tbh[/QUOTE]

This is a case of ZOMG trying to justify themselves to me, for people who care about the thoughts about me.

Originally Posted by FM-Goblin and Worg

And what do you make of that 'shit reaction'? Do you think Bad Hair is a wolf that has flown under the radar and you caught Disco for reacting badly for you starting a wagon on him, or do you have something else in mind?

Originally Posted by FM-ZOMG

I don't think in anonymous I can condemn anyone on one data point like what you're suggesting lol

the shit reaction was primarily a joke at their expense - though if bad ever flips scum then I think the phrasing of that reaction should be given consideration.

I think what is natural for town to do when they see a low poster vote like I did without context is to just... ask the context. Here it kind of gives TMI vibes with how exasperated, but that could just be how disco reacts generally to things like this.


as for Protag hair I think they


...

...

..........

I just realized mid post that I confused bad hair day and protagonist hair. just gonna hit send and curl into a ball in the corner tbh

This is a case of ZOMG trying to justify themselves to me, for people who care about the thoughts about me.

I also am revoking all the reads I made for RC cases. While their votes weren't in line with it Parei and ZOMG both cased Red Cross.

Both on D2.

I will say that the "At least 1 in 5" announcement might have spooked wolves into bussing them early. So maybe good to review who changed RC thoughts around then.

I also am revoking all the reads I made for RC cases. While their votes weren't in line with it Parei and ZOMG both cased Red Cross.

Both on D2.

I will say that the "At least 1 in 5" announcement might have spooked wolves into bussing them early. So maybe good to review who changed RC thoughts around then.

[QUOTE=FM-The Hat;1010777]not @me theorycrafting the entire scum team with EXODIA and wolf leader has armor :kekw:[/QUOTE]

I feel very bad for my push on you if that's true. You had a better idea of the game than anyone else on D2.

Originally Posted by FM-The Hat

not @me theorycrafting the entire scum team with EXODIA and wolf leader has armor

I feel very bad for my push on you if that's true. You had a better idea of the game than anyone else on D2.

[QUOTE=FM-Lipstick;1010751]Maybe Monet is wolf who is ITA immune
And that's why
They're like this[/QUOTE]

I kind of agree with this as a thought.

If this is true then Hat is lock town for the record. I believe he was the one to come up with the "Wolf Leader is Monet" theory with "Wolf leader has armour."

Originally Posted by FM-Lipstick

Maybe Monet is wolf who is ITA immune
And that's why
They're like this

I kind of agree with this as a thought.

If this is true then Hat is lock town for the record. I believe he was the one to come up with the "Wolf Leader is Monet" theory with "Wolf leader has armour."

[QUOTE=FM-Ringmaster;1010693]very weird they mentioned golbin out of nowhere to disco[/QUOTE]

That wasn't out of no where.

[QUOTE=FM-ZOMG;1000678]I want to see where this goes

[VOTE]FM-Bad Hair Day[/VOTE][/QUOTE]

[QUOTE=FM-Goblin and Worg;1000685]Of all the possible counterwagons to start, why go for someone who has vibed better than half of the thread in their interactions so far?[/QUOTE]

[QUOTE=FM-ZOMG;1000692]~~to bait people like disco into having shit reactions to voting there~~[/QUOTE]

[QUOTE=FM-Goblin and Worg;1000694]And what do you make of that 'shit reaction'? Do you think Bad Hair is a wolf that has flown under the radar and you caught Disco for reacting badly for you starting a wagon on him, or do you have something else in mind?[/QUOTE]


This was after this.

Which ZOMG then ignored my question.

Originally Posted by FM-Ringmaster

very weird they mentioned golbin out of nowhere to disco

That wasn't out of no where.

Originally Posted by FM-ZOMG

I want to see where this goes

-vote FM-Bad Hair Day

Originally Posted by FM-Goblin and Worg

Of all the possible counterwagons to start, why go for someone who has vibed better than half of the thread in their interactions so far?

Originally Posted by FM-ZOMG

~~to bait people like disco into having shit reactions to voting there~~

Originally Posted by FM-Goblin and Worg

And what do you make of that 'shit reaction'? Do you think Bad Hair is a wolf that has flown under the radar and you caught Disco for reacting badly for you starting a wagon on him, or do you have something else in mind?

This was after this.

Which ZOMG then ignored my question.

[QUOTE=FM-Lipstick;1010680]Yeah

I know what he said

But his dancing around ZOMG is bad[/QUOTE]

I will defend myself that I have had ZOMG on shot lists from D2 and my first part of D3.

But yes, the thought with RC end of day looks bad for me now.

Originally Posted by FM-Lipstick

Yeah

I know what he said

But his dancing around ZOMG is bad

I will defend myself that I have had ZOMG on shot lists from D2 and my first part of D3.

But yes, the thought with RC end of day looks bad for me now.

Also I acknowledge people are suspecting me off the ZOMG flip. I will say that if I hadn't had my last thought I had them on my sus list all game before that. (Including adding them to shot list in the past.)

But I accept that it looks horrible with the P2 shot as well.

(I still think P2 should be shot this ITA.)

Also I acknowledge people are suspecting me off the ZOMG flip. I will say that if I hadn't had my last thought I had them on my sus list all game before that. (Including adding them to shot list in the past.)

But I accept that it looks horrible with the P2 shot as well.

(I still think P2 should be shot this ITA.)

Autumn is definitely town off spew.

I actually think Protagonist is probably towny off the spew as well. There's a lot of interactions with Parei and it feels excessive for theatre.

Autumn is definitely town off spew.

I actually think Protagonist is probably towny off the spew as well. There's a lot of interactions with Parei and it feels excessive for theatre.

[QUOTE=FM-The Hat;1010607]It's almost like naptime was onto something LUL[/QUOTE]

I swear people miss me yelling about this because no one mentions me when people say this is a good idea. And I've spent more time in thread yelling about it than anyone.

My lord people are deaf.

Originally Posted by FM-The Hat

It's almost like naptime was onto something

I swear people miss me yelling about this because no one mentions me when people say this is a good idea. And I've spent more time in thread yelling about it than anyone.

My lord people are deaf.

We should have less people shoot during ITA1. ITA2 appears to be the time town actually gets shit done.

We should have less people shoot during ITA1. ITA2 appears to be the time town actually gets shit done.

[B][COLOR="#DAA520"]-ITA FM-Player 2[/COLOR][/B]

-ITA FM-Player 2

[QUOTE=FM-Catnip;1010495]has lassie been posting a lot? how active would you all say lassie was in the pages i missed. would you say they were a major player[/QUOTE]

They've been fairly quiet but they were the one behind the Matchstick bait which I townread heavily.

Originally Posted by FM-Catnip

has lassie been posting a lot? how active would you all say lassie was in the pages i missed. would you say they were a major player

They've been fairly quiet but they were the one behind the Matchstick bait which I townread heavily.

[QUOTE=FM-Peekaboo;1010491][MENTION=46676]FM-Goblin and Worg[/MENTION] did you ever follow up on this? I noticed you had doubts on Catnip in your iso and seem to still want Choo-Choo and Chroma dead, and are fine with me, but who is the fifth person?[/QUOTE]

Fifth person was Dredge. I wanted to see if he'd be anti-claimed.

I did follow up which is why you didn't appear in my daystart lists, compared to the others I felt your ISO was better.

I didn't post that because I find posting ISOs performative unless I'm trying to convince someone else of my read.

Originally Posted by FM-Peekaboo

@FM-Goblin and Worg did you ever follow up on this? I noticed you had doubts on Catnip in your iso and seem to still want Choo-Choo and Chroma dead, and are fine with me, but who is the fifth person?

Fifth person was Dredge. I wanted to see if he'd be anti-claimed.

I did follow up which is why you didn't appear in my daystart lists, compared to the others I felt your ISO was better.

I didn't post that because I find posting ISOs performative unless I'm trying to convince someone else of my read.

[QUOTE=FM-The Hat;1010475]For the record let me say i'm not [I]positive[/I] how I ended up being on the shotslist after being TR by consensus and flipped town Oink and Naptime, I know scarf is so hard tunneled on me that they decided that shooting me is somehow the best move, as for the others that I've seen, they don't like my vibe or something? Like, do these slots really believe that I have a wolf agenda, that I've been anti-town, that I've been partnered or have TMI? You know, [I]actual[/I] indicators of scum behavior?[/QUOTE]

I have honestly flipped on you several times.

Your red cross interactions are interesting and inconclusive. Your treatment of Legs on D1 was, and still is, something I scum read.

But I would be lying if I said that you have done nothing I townread. This is part of why I am generally okay with you being on shot lists, even if you're not a priority slot for me. I do think we will have to flip you before End of Game no matter your alignment. And I know that sounds callous, but you're too much of a contention slot that without some kind of mech that is overwhelmingly in your favour, the only way I'd let you reach endgame is if we just kill all the wolves too quickly to get to that point.

Originally Posted by FM-The Hat

For the record let me say i'm not positive how I ended up being on the shotslist after being TR by consensus and flipped town Oink and Naptime, I know scarf is so hard tunneled on me that they decided that shooting me is somehow the best move, as for the others that I've seen, they don't like my vibe or something? Like, do these slots really believe that I have a wolf agenda, that I've been anti-town, that I've been partnered or have TMI? You know, actual indicators of scum behavior?

I have honestly flipped on you several times.

Your red cross interactions are interesting and inconclusive. Your treatment of Legs on D1 was, and still is, something I scum read.

But I would be lying if I said that you have done nothing I townread. This is part of why I am generally okay with you being on shot lists, even if you're not a priority slot for me. I do think we will have to flip you before End of Game no matter your alignment. And I know that sounds callous, but you're too much of a contention slot that without some kind of mech that is overwhelmingly in your favour, the only way I'd let you reach endgame is if we just kill all the wolves too quickly to get to that point.

[QUOTE=FM-Dredge;1010477]yeah but joycat was shot at by a wolf if my notes are correct.

that's something[/QUOTE]

Lost wolf.

Why is that relevant.

(I agree Joycat shouldn't be on shot list.)

Originally Posted by FM-Dredge

yeah but joycat was shot at by a wolf if my notes are correct.

that's something

Lost wolf.

Why is that relevant.

(I agree Joycat shouldn't be on shot list.)

[QUOTE=FM-Breakup;1010474]thats not what the original post said. you said you wanted to wolfread me which heavily implies you wolfread me and think my slot is scummy but don't want to prusue that read or push it right now (an example of shading). if thats what you meant then sure but you couldve also ust been clearer at the start[/QUOTE]

I still think your interactions with a flipped wolf were bad, even if others disagreed with me.

Originally Posted by FM-Breakup

thats not what the original post said. you said you wanted to wolfread me which heavily implies you wolfread me and think my slot is scummy but don't want to prusue that read or push it right now (an example of shading). if thats what you meant then sure but you couldve also ust been clearer at the start

I still think your interactions with a flipped wolf were bad, even if others disagreed with me.

[QUOTE=FM-Autumn;1010473]i scumread choo choo and i don't want to kill them. and i'm aware i'm probably being stupid about both parts of that read but lmfao[/QUOTE]

What?

Originally Posted by FM-Autumn

i scumread choo choo and i don't want to kill them. and i'm aware i'm probably being stupid about both parts of that read but lmfao

What?

[QUOTE=FM-Ringmaster;1010461]I’m going to be honest I think ZOMB and the 3p claim have less connection than ice cream costs after a full moon[/QUOTE]

With the refresh of the context that it was actually during ITAs, I actually agree.

I had the 3p claim separated from the ITAs in my head.

Originally Posted by FM-Ringmaster

I’m going to be honest I think ZOMB and the 3p claim have less connection than ice cream costs after a full moon

With the refresh of the context that it was actually during ITAs, I actually agree.

I had the 3p claim separated from the ITAs in my head.

[QUOTE=FM-Autumn;1010451]probably good look for zomg then

... actually didnt red cross claim during the itas? maybe they just didn't want to get shot and werent really thinking more about what that means for the final wagons?[/QUOTE]

You are actually right.

Hm.

Originally Posted by FM-Autumn

probably good look for zomg then

... actually didnt red cross claim during the itas? maybe they just didn't want to get shot and werent really thinking more about what that means for the final wagons?

You are actually right.

Hm.

[QUOTE=FM-Four Past Seven;1010441]Or, alternatively, if their roles were somehow worse

or some combination of factors

I'd also argue its very likely the wolves are not uniform in their behavior. Their teamsize is at least 10 so I'd imagine some disagreement on them, maybe even some who though RC should have not claimed 3p. Who knows.[/QUOTE]

It's possible.

I don't think that would be what happens, but it's possible.

Originally Posted by FM-Four Past Seven

Or, alternatively, if their roles were somehow worse

or some combination of factors

I'd also argue its very likely the wolves are not uniform in their behavior. Their teamsize is at least 10 so I'd imagine some disagreement on them, maybe even some who though RC should have not claimed 3p. Who knows.

It's possible.

I don't think that would be what happens, but it's possible.

[QUOTE=FM-Old Lickilicky;1006625]Alright so, here’s my (probably) last post today, and honestly i still scumread peekaboo

he was playing way too careful during EoD yesterday, and I feel like hes one of those careful type of mafia player, even now he’s not ITAing anyone today

I know I’m getting lynched and that none of you are lynching him anytime soon, but when its like Day 4 or 5 with like 15 people left, please look into him, just keep it in your mind

I know I am going to die today because theres like 1% chance talking town out of not voting me today, which i understand and I won’t press any further.
[MENTION=46715]FM-ZOMG[/MENTION] will die today along with me when I get voted out, it was something I decided last night in the neighbor chat, and this cant be changed and I cant cancel it until tonight, so for you guys, it might as well be two birds with one stone killing both of us. I’m dead anyway and I hope zomg flip scum so its not in vain.

I plan to go to work then sleep, so i probably won’t be around much before EoD today. I know I played bad this game and I apologize to @FM Chibi-Minnie for those words, sorry I didn’t mean it[/QUOTE]

[QUOTE=FM-Red Cross;1006709]all right I give up, after thinking it for a bit idt I'll get my wincon with how things turned out if i don't claim

I'm benign 3p[/QUOTE]

[MENTION=46661]FM-Autumn[/MENTION]

The vengeful claim was in thread when RC claimed 3p yes.

Originally Posted by FM-Old Lickilicky

Alright so, here’s my (probably) last post today, and honestly i still scumread peekaboo

he was playing way too careful during EoD yesterday, and I feel like hes one of those careful type of mafia player, even now he’s not ITAing anyone today

I know I’m getting lynched and that none of you are lynching him anytime soon, but when its like Day 4 or 5 with like 15 people left, please look into him, just keep it in your mind

I know I am going to die today because theres like 1% chance talking town out of not voting me today, which i understand and I won’t press any further.
@FM-ZOMG will die today along with me when I get voted out, it was something I decided last night in the neighbor chat, and this cant be changed and I cant cancel it until tonight, so for you guys, it might as well be two birds with one stone killing both of us. I’m dead anyway and I hope zomg flip scum so its not in vain.

I plan to go to work then sleep, so i probably won’t be around much before EoD today. I know I played bad this game and I apologize to @FM Chibi-Minnie for those words, sorry I didn’t mean it

Originally Posted by FM-Red Cross

all right I give up, after thinking it for a bit idt I'll get my wincon with how things turned out if i don't claim

I'm benign 3p

@FM-Autumn

The vengeful claim was in thread when RC claimed 3p yes.

[QUOTE=FM-The Hat;1010428]Did ZOMG check in today? During ITAs or after that is[/QUOTE]

Not yet from what I've seen.

Originally Posted by FM-The Hat

Did ZOMG check in today? During ITAs or after that is

Not yet from what I've seen.

Though either way I think Licky looks good from it.

Though either way I think Licky looks good from it.

[QUOTE=FM-Autumn;1010422]if zomg is wolf, maybe wolves thought that it's still better to get licky killed, because losing 1 town + 1 wolf is better than just losing 1 wolf?

tho that is a good look for them probably (depends on the timings of the claims though, when exactly did red cross claim, and at what point of the day did people start pushing them as obviously fake? was licky already the top wagon there, and had they already claimed the vengeful on zomg?)[/QUOTE]

Licky was the top wagon by 3 votes when the 3p was claimed.

However Nap HAD just said "This is the end of Red's game" so it's very likely that without the claim Licky wouldn't have been top wagon for long.

And I would need to double check but I think they had.

I will do that now, because if I'm wrong then my entire point is wasted.

Originally Posted by FM-Autumn

if zomg is wolf, maybe wolves thought that it's still better to get licky killed, because losing 1 town + 1 wolf is better than just losing 1 wolf?

tho that is a good look for them probably (depends on the timings of the claims though, when exactly did red cross claim, and at what point of the day did people start pushing them as obviously fake? was licky already the top wagon there, and had they already claimed the vengeful on zomg?)

Licky was the top wagon by 3 votes when the 3p was claimed.

However Nap HAD just said "This is the end of Red's game" so it's very likely that without the claim Licky wouldn't have been top wagon for long.

And I would need to double check but I think they had.

I will do that now, because if I'm wrong then my entire point is wasted.

[QUOTE=FM-Autumn;1010413]tier 1 shots: zomg, monet, parei

tier 2 shots: player 2, the hat, choo choo

if you want to try to be hero shoot here i guess, but many enough people disagree with these shots: joycat, catnip
(actually with catnip its just me who disagrees lol but whatever)

chroma/platypus removed because of the recent discussion


this is what i have rn, if ppl have different opinions just say it tbh[/QUOTE]

I want P2 on the tier 1 section.

I also will be shooting them.

Originally Posted by FM-Autumn

tier 1 shots: zomg, monet, parei

tier 2 shots: player 2, the hat, choo choo

if you want to try to be hero shoot here i guess, but many enough people disagree with these shots: joycat, catnip
(actually with catnip its just me who disagrees lol but whatever)

chroma/platypus removed because of the recent discussion


this is what i have rn, if ppl have different opinions just say it tbh

I want P2 on the tier 1 section.

I also will be shooting them.

[QUOTE=FM-Goldfish Bowl;1010402]Where’s the shot list[/QUOTE]

Try following your quote chain.

Originally Posted by FM-Goldfish Bowl

Where’s the shot list

Try following your quote chain.

Regarding end of day yesterday:

If Red Cross claimed 3p it is because they wanted to survive another phase. (Rather than just open wolf)

Given the "I win on phase 4", I feel very much like it was an attempt to eke more phases out.

Given Licky was the alternative, would wolves actually try to keep RC alive with a 3p claim if Licky was wolf with them? This reasoning also applies to ZOMG, which is the only reason I'm bringing it up.

It does feel not super strong, as wolves (if Licky or ZOMG are wolf) may have been hoping for Nap to start a crusade on someone else.

Regarding end of day yesterday:

If Red Cross claimed 3p it is because they wanted to survive another phase. (Rather than just open wolf)

Given the "I win on phase 4", I feel very much like it was an attempt to eke more phases out.

Given Licky was the alternative, would wolves actually try to keep RC alive with a 3p claim if Licky was wolf with them? This reasoning also applies to ZOMG, which is the only reason I'm bringing it up.

It does feel not super strong, as wolves (if Licky or ZOMG are wolf) may have been hoping for Nap to start a crusade on someone else.

[QUOTE=FM-Autumn;1010383]it's not about "not wanting to read"

i do want to read but you literally posted like 30 new pages or something while i was at work and it's so close to the ita start now i just don't have time to read[/QUOTE]

I empathise with this a lot.

I am obsessive about researching things before I post (especially centric around crux points like ITA windows), however the volume of posts in this game makes it VERY hard to catch every single post in this game.

Pointing out important things should always be fine, to be honest. The worst that can happen is that Autumn (or whichever other player) says they've seen it already.

Originally Posted by FM-Autumn

it's not about "not wanting to read"

i do want to read but you literally posted like 30 new pages or something while i was at work and it's so close to the ita start now i just don't have time to read

I empathise with this a lot.

I am obsessive about researching things before I post (especially centric around crux points like ITA windows), however the volume of posts in this game makes it VERY hard to catch every single post in this game.

Pointing out important things should always be fine, to be honest. The worst that can happen is that Autumn (or whichever other player) says they've seen it already.

[QUOTE=FM-Autumn;1010379]did they say why they wanted to fake poison people instead of just killing someone in poe?[/QUOTE]

They were going to real poison Snuggles but then decided to fake when "some of their posts gave them pause" and wanted to see how Snuggles would react to poison, if I recall correctly.

Originally Posted by FM-Autumn

did they say why they wanted to fake poison people instead of just killing someone in poe?

They were going to real poison Snuggles but then decided to fake when "some of their posts gave them pause" and wanted to see how Snuggles would react to poison, if I recall correctly.

I am aware this is not a good read.

However, I am obnoxiously aware that the moment I'm advocating for Catnip on shot lists, they show up.

I am aware this is not a good read.

However, I am obnoxiously aware that the moment I'm advocating for Catnip on shot lists, they show up.

[QUOTE=FM-Lipstick;1010372]If Plat fake poisoned Snuggles
Isn't that kind of towny
To fake poison a town
Especially if you can real poison

Unless someone healed
But nobody has claimed that[/QUOTE]

This is part of why I'm not on board with Plat on shot lists, yes.

Although I don't think it's that towny as fake poison for towncred is a strategy I would definitely consider in this kind of game.

Originally Posted by FM-Lipstick

If Plat fake poisoned Snuggles
Isn't that kind of towny
To fake poison a town
Especially if you can real poison

Unless someone healed
But nobody has claimed that

This is part of why I'm not on board with Plat on shot lists, yes.

Although I don't think it's that towny as fake poison for towncred is a strategy I would definitely consider in this kind of game.

Platypus' claim is that each poison could be fake or real and they decided it when they send it at night.

Platypus' claim is that each poison could be fake or real and they decided it when they send it at night.

[QUOTE=FM-Catnip;1010364]im dead weight rn and i apologize for it. i hope i will be feeling better tomorrow and in the next couple days. did platypus claim the poisons[/QUOTE]

Yes.

Originally Posted by FM-Catnip

im dead weight rn and i apologize for it. i hope i will be feeling better tomorrow and in the next couple days. did platypus claim the poisons

Yes.

[QUOTE=FM-Peekaboo;1010352]Personally:
Joycat, P2 out
ZOMG Monet Chroma Parei Tier 1
Catnip can be on a shotslist but not in tier 1
[B]just so my thoughts are clear I know you didn't ask[/B][/QUOTE]

I personally encourage everyone to give thoughts on shot lists. Even if their words don't impact the end result.

That way we have people's position on record.

Originally Posted by FM-Peekaboo

Personally:
Joycat, P2 out
ZOMG Monet Chroma Parei Tier 1
Catnip can be on a shotslist but not in tier 1
just so my thoughts are clear I know you didn't ask

I personally encourage everyone to give thoughts on shot lists. Even if their words don't impact the end result.

That way we have people's position on record.

[QUOTE=FM-Autumn;1010346]catnip
monet rocket
joycat
zomg
hat
player 2
pareidolia
choo choo
platypus
chroma

this is what i have as possible shotlist now tbh

(dont want catnip in there really, i dont fully trust them but i still am not sure thats a slot i want killed just yet tbh)[/QUOTE]

I don't like Joycat in there.

And I feel like Platypus is chained to towny-ish poisons now so I don't think we need to kill them when they can help clear POE slots.

Originally Posted by FM-Autumn

catnip
monet rocket
joycat
zomg
hat
player 2
pareidolia
choo choo
platypus
chroma

this is what i have as possible shotlist now tbh

(dont want catnip in there really, i dont fully trust them but i still am not sure thats a slot i want killed just yet tbh)

I don't like Joycat in there.

And I feel like Platypus is chained to towny-ish poisons now so I don't think we need to kill them when they can help clear POE slots.

Also yes I was about to comment about this.

Do ISO's here cap? Because there are now a few slots where the ISO isn't loading all the way. This is annoying if true.

Also yes I was about to comment about this.

Do ISO's here cap? Because there are now a few slots where the ISO isn't loading all the way. This is annoying if true.

[QUOTE=FM-Breakup;1010340]Honestly don't remember what youre talking about[/QUOTE]

You don't remember Not Enough Legs getting shot during ITA1 D2?

Or the fallout that happened when I yelled about it while you were asking for your vig target?

Originally Posted by FM-Breakup

Honestly don't remember what youre talking about

You don't remember Not Enough Legs getting shot during ITA1 D2?

Or the fallout that happened when I yelled about it while you were asking for your vig target?

[QUOTE=FM-Breakup;1010335]if somebody else tries that I feel pretty justified in killing them
we're not setting a precedent or anything like that, p2 shouldn't live long btu they don't deserve to be policied evne if it was an objectively terrible shot[/QUOTE]

So you didn't think it was enough to set a precedent to kill the next person to do it when Legs got shot?

Originally Posted by FM-Breakup

if somebody else tries that I feel pretty justified in killing them
we're not setting a precedent or anything like that, p2 shouldn't live long btu they don't deserve to be policied evne if it was an objectively terrible shot

So you didn't think it was enough to set a precedent to kill the next person to do it when Legs got shot?

[QUOTE=FM-Peekaboo;1010324]I think P2's freakout with shooting Snuggles was villagery (not good, but villagery). I get the vibe that I am in the minority for that since the shot was pretty bad so I understand dissenting opinions[/QUOTE]

Even if P2 is town.

We're giving a precedent for any wolf who thinks they can emote half effectively to shoot off list and then freak out when they kill a town.

This is a terrible precedent.

Originally Posted by FM-Peekaboo

I think P2's freakout with shooting Snuggles was villagery (not good, but villagery). I get the vibe that I am in the minority for that since the shot was pretty bad so I understand dissenting opinions

Even if P2 is town.

We're giving a precedent for any wolf who thinks they can emote half effectively to shoot off list and then freak out when they kill a town.

This is a terrible precedent.

[QUOTE=FM-Peekaboo;1010305]Personally, P2 out plus you never flip BHD when you have protag as your top town why is BHD even in there[/QUOTE]

I agree on BHD.

Why would you take P2 out?

Originally Posted by FM-Peekaboo

Personally, P2 out plus you never flip BHD when you have protag as your top town why is BHD even in there

I agree on BHD.

Why would you take P2 out?

[QUOTE=FM-Autumn;1010299]do people have any major disagreements with that list?

i honestly kinda want to just take the bottom two tiers (maybe the third also but idk) and say that it's the shotlist lol[/QUOTE]

See my post above about Great Flood

[URL="https://www.sc2mafia.com/forum/showthread.php/51399-KRC-Sc2Mafia-13th-Anniversary-Game-(S-FM-357)?p=1010294&viewfull=1#post1010294"]Here if you want to be lazy.[/URL]

Joycat should be higher. Catnip should be lower. Goldfish Bowl shouldn't be on shots because of poison.

Originally Posted by FM-Autumn

do people have any major disagreements with that list?

i honestly kinda want to just take the bottom two tiers (maybe the third also but idk) and say that it's the shotlist lol

See my post above about Great Flood

Here if you want to be lazy.

Joycat should be higher. Catnip should be lower. Goldfish Bowl shouldn't be on shots because of poison.

[QUOTE=FM-The Hat;1010291]Fuck hero shots
Fuck your scum reads we will make a consensus Poe and we WILL shoot in it
If you are hero shooting you are anti-town I don't give a fuck about your scum reads because literally the only time that worked out was when space pizza shot[/QUOTE]

I have been saying this for days now at this point.

Originally Posted by FM-The Hat

Fuck hero shots
Fuck your scum reads we will make a consensus Poe and we WILL shoot in it
If you are hero shooting you are anti-town I don't give a fuck about your scum reads because literally the only time that worked out was when space pizza shot

I have been saying this for days now at this point.

[QUOTE=FM-Breakup;1010289]to me it looks like they may have quoted posts and written a bit and then asked chat gpt or something to write their conclusions[/QUOTE]

That was, funnily enough, exactly the thought I had. Hence the "Half-written report" commentary.

Originally Posted by FM-Breakup

to me it looks like they may have quoted posts and written a bit and then asked chat gpt or something to write their conclusions

That was, funnily enough, exactly the thought I had. Hence the "Half-written report" commentary.

[QUOTE=FM-Autumn;1010276]do people have valid reasons to have great flood as town, or should that slot just go to the ita list?[/QUOTE]

I have Great Flood as town for how they were one of the few players echoing my sus on Red Cross consistently. Others would mention it but Flood was voting there early D1 (Before any ITA) and talked about it even D1 if I remember right.

They also had this post:
[QUOTE=FM-The Great Flood;1003799]I think we cant let ITA's pass and not do some cleaning from this list tbh . Maybe scratch choochoo cause at EoD they said they were villa
Matchstick has the conditional green, and licki us claiming to be dead and hopefully tonight I can check that

So Im thinking

[B][COLOR="#FF0000"]Red Cross
Thumbs Up[/COLOR][/B]
Eyescream
[B][COLOR="#006400"]Angry Rectangle [/COLOR][/B]


Joycat
[B][COLOR="#FF0000"]Pyramid [/COLOR][/B]
Chromatography


Whose names are towny from here?[/QUOTE]

Which was one of the earliest attempts to make an ITA1 shot list on D2.

I just don't believe a wolf tries to propose this as a starting point for ITA1 on D2.

Originally Posted by FM-Autumn

do people have valid reasons to have great flood as town, or should that slot just go to the ita list?

I have Great Flood as town for how they were one of the few players echoing my sus on Red Cross consistently. Others would mention it but Flood was voting there early D1 (Before any ITA) and talked about it even D1 if I remember right.

They also had this post:

Originally Posted by FM-The Great Flood

I think we cant let ITA's pass and not do some cleaning from this list tbh . Maybe scratch choochoo cause at EoD they said they were villa
Matchstick has the conditional green, and licki us claiming to be dead and hopefully tonight I can check that

So Im thinking

Red Cross
Thumbs Up
Eyescream
Angry Rectangle


Joycat
Pyramid
Chromatography


Whose names are towny from here?

Which was one of the earliest attempts to make an ITA1 shot list on D2.

I just don't believe a wolf tries to propose this as a starting point for ITA1 on D2.

[QUOTE=FM-Breakup;1010274]wait please show me their walls I wanna see this[/QUOTE]

[SPOILER=Parei walls][QUOTE=FM-Pareidolia;1003723]Okey, let's dig into Waifu 2.0 and her Day 1 activity.

[SIZE=5][B]Protagonist Hair[/B][/SIZE]

Entered the game with RP and blue font. NAI.



LIE!!!1111 LYNCH ASAP!!!!!!!
jk.

First townread (without reasoning):


Talking about role powers. NAI.



Okey :(


I don't understand whether I should taking this seriously or not?


Meanwhile, attempts of involving into the game solution stars at page 29.


I should say Protag paying attention to things happens around.


But after that Protag suddenly jumps to Pilgrim without any reasoning and any valuable interraction with him. Protag even pinged everyone to join that. This is, probably, the very beginning of Pilgrim train.




Some reasoning comes later:


I should notice, at that moment I ISO'ed Pilgrim and I was mostly agree that he is scummy. I was okey to vote him. But Protag was already in my scumlist: this kind of roleplaying is good scum strat and it's works (remember Anime Waifu from previous game), also Protag has very low game investment at that moment.

After that point, the whole Protag game was about "lynch Pilgrim at all cost":




Around this time, I began to suspect that the confrontation between Protag and Pilgrim could be either a show played by the mafia, or an ordinary TvT. I'm still not sure of my conclusions.

Until the end of the first day, Protag continues to push Pilgrim, simultaneously adding everyone who agrees with her to her townread.

My opinion on this slot:

1. Protag stays in my scumlist.
2. Protag was more interested in fast train of Pilgrim, not in solving the game.
3. Protag's "towncore" consist of players who interracted and agreed with her at some points.

Maybe important: comparing to Naptime, interracted with other players of "yellow post", Protag was not very involved in such interractions.

I will write my final conclusions when I read the ISOs of the other players in yellow post.[/QUOTE]

[QUOTE=FM-Pareidolia;1003810]Well, now for another yellow.
[SIZE=5][B]Bad Hair Day[/B][/SIZE]

Entered the game with townreading SSS.


And protecting him.


One more situation:



Kinda we thinking alike at this point. Okey.


Well, maybe it's his temperament, but this guy likes to make quick decisions and involved in game with every post. Looks townie from me.


Also he is ready to communicate and cooperate.


Again, pretty close to my thoughts. I should have been more attentive to this player and his messages.


He had unpopular point on Pilgrim.


And still very quick in his reads.



His read on Protag is kinda mechanical. I don't know why "Protag has a skill that instakills me if they figure out who I am" = "Protag is town". But I accept this. Okey.




Also he is quick in changing his opinion based on new posts appears.


Fun fact:


And Mr Clean pointed that (+1 town pts to Mr Clean in my list)


My opinion on this slot:

1. Bad Hair Day is very involved in the game from first post and his activity is all about solving the game. Reason to townread him.
2. Bad Hair Day is quick in his reading. Despite the fact that they sometimes coincided with mine, I still see his decisions as somewhat hasty.
3. I see no strong connections between him and some other person.
4. The only thing that looks wolfish to me is that he is too confident in his quick conclusions. For the uninformed player, this is a bit presumptuous.

I will write my final conclusions when I read the ISOs of the other players in yellow post.[/QUOTE]

[QUOTE=FM-Goblin and Worg;1003815]I'm holding judgement for the conclusion but so far reading Parei's walls has reminded me of when I'm handed a report half-written by ChatGPT.[/QUOTE]

[/SPOILER]

There were more but these were the ones I found with a quick search that were around when I made that commentary.

Originally Posted by FM-Breakup

wait please show me their walls I wanna see this

Spoiler : Parei walls :

Originally Posted by FM-Pareidolia

Okey, let's dig into Waifu 2.0 and her Day 1 activity.

Protagonist Hair

Entered the game with RP and blue font. NAI.



LIE!!!1111 LYNCH ASAP!!!!!!!
jk.

First townread (without reasoning):


Talking about role powers. NAI.



Okey


I don't understand whether I should taking this seriously or not?


Meanwhile, attempts of involving into the game solution stars at page 29.


I should say Protag paying attention to things happens around.


But after that Protag suddenly jumps to Pilgrim without any reasoning and any valuable interraction with him. Protag even pinged everyone to join that. This is, probably, the very beginning of Pilgrim train.




Some reasoning comes later:


I should notice, at that moment I ISO'ed Pilgrim and I was mostly agree that he is scummy. I was okey to vote him. But Protag was already in my scumlist: this kind of roleplaying is good scum strat and it's works (remember Anime Waifu from previous game), also Protag has very low game investment at that moment.

After that point, the whole Protag game was about "lynch Pilgrim at all cost":




Around this time, I began to suspect that the confrontation between Protag and Pilgrim could be either a show played by the mafia, or an ordinary TvT. I'm still not sure of my conclusions.

Until the end of the first day, Protag continues to push Pilgrim, simultaneously adding everyone who agrees with her to her townread.

My opinion on this slot:

1. Protag stays in my scumlist.
2. Protag was more interested in fast train of Pilgrim, not in solving the game.
3. Protag's "towncore" consist of players who interracted and agreed with her at some points.

Maybe important: comparing to Naptime, interracted with other players of "yellow post", Protag was not very involved in such interractions.

I will write my final conclusions when I read the ISOs of the other players in yellow post.

Originally Posted by FM-Pareidolia

Well, now for another yellow.
Bad Hair Day

Entered the game with townreading SSS.


And protecting him.


One more situation:



Kinda we thinking alike at this point. Okey.


Well, maybe it's his temperament, but this guy likes to make quick decisions and involved in game with every post. Looks townie from me.


Also he is ready to communicate and cooperate.


Again, pretty close to my thoughts. I should have been more attentive to this player and his messages.


He had unpopular point on Pilgrim.


And still very quick in his reads.



His read on Protag is kinda mechanical. I don't know why "Protag has a skill that instakills me if they figure out who I am" = "Protag is town". But I accept this. Okey.




Also he is quick in changing his opinion based on new posts appears.


Fun fact:


And Mr Clean pointed that (+1 town pts to Mr Clean in my list)


My opinion on this slot:

1. Bad Hair Day is very involved in the game from first post and his activity is all about solving the game. Reason to townread him.
2. Bad Hair Day is quick in his reading. Despite the fact that they sometimes coincided with mine, I still see his decisions as somewhat hasty.
3. I see no strong connections between him and some other person.
4. The only thing that looks wolfish to me is that he is too confident in his quick conclusions. For the uninformed player, this is a bit presumptuous.

I will write my final conclusions when I read the ISOs of the other players in yellow post.

Originally Posted by FM-Goblin and Worg

I'm holding judgement for the conclusion but so far reading Parei's walls has reminded me of when I'm handed a report half-written by ChatGPT.

There were more but these were the ones I found with a quick search that were around when I made that commentary.