Also saying this right now, I'll be talking more. the first game was me watching to see how it's played here. (inb4 i lurk...AGAIN)
"I don't take advice from people less successful than me"
~Kanye West
Hi don't vote me lol I was eating! Yeezus.
Thoughts on a role call Day 1? Worst case scenario if everyone participates we get 3 citizen claims and 4 hunter claims. Will let us narrow it down. Only 2 people have an incentive to lie out of 7.
I suggest this because the numbers are low enough where just 2 or 3 people state roles would have a large effect on the game.
Going to state this now:
Due to how crucial this game is we need everyone to communicate day 1 - Lurkers or people who do not talk and just delay the game will be my #1 choice for a lynch.
how crucial the lynches in this game are* lol
Yeah, one mistake and we are at LyLo w/out lynching scum if they have a nightkill. I personally think we should treat it as if they have a Nightkill
"I don't take advice from people less successful than me"
~Kanye West
Sadly this is not how FM works... And even if only the scums were lying about their roles, I'd be against this.
There is why: TPRs (Town Power Roles) will probably want to claim Citizen in order to survive at night. You can't be 100% sure townies won't lie about their roles.
But the next this is that a mass rolecall only reveals TPRs in such a setup. I've played a very very very similar setup called Super Basic, 7 players with two TPRs two mafia (one mafioso one consig/consort) and 3 citizens. A massive rolecall was ordered, and all the TPRs (two detectives, I was one ) died. Then our dear host Gyrlander won as scum, even if (s?)he had claimed doctor before. Gyrlander managed to convince players that she had claimed Doctor in order to act as a meat shield, so the real TPRs wouldn't get killed. The game ended on a Mafia win. I don't want to see such a thing again.
So short story: NO MASS ROLE CALL ON DAY ONE.
Also id like to state that in my very humble opinion we dont really need a lynch today,
@Magoroth get your vote off sovietlove please. Just so the day doesn't get ruined by a turbo L-1.
Here is what I think:
Evils win no matter what IF they make town mislynch on D2.
(Obvious exception is if town lynch an evil on D1)
So as far as I can tell, we have 2 options only:
1. Lynch neither on D1 nor on D2 and hope we remain 3v2 on D3 with a lot of info to work with.
2. We lynch someone on D1 whom half players find evil, other half find him good - making our D2 lynch much easier.
If we don't lynch on D1, then we agree to not lynch on D2 either and hope that only 0-2 townies died before D3.
If we mislynch on day D1, then we lynch on D2 and evil or gg.
Of the two options that I mentioned: 2nd one can be worked around by the evils with mindgames.
I advocate we abstain for D1 and D2. Unless someone can come up with a reason why more than 2 townies could die before D3.
--------------------------
I love FM lol. Every post makes me paranoid. Like this question of yours - it makes me wonder if you do that on purpose so others think that you can't possibly be a witch.
I get more and more paranoid during this FM lol
--------------------------
@Marshmallow Marshall , I have procrastinated all the reading till this point. I expect myself to have read it all of FM Guides before D1 ends.
Grandmaster. There is also the possibility of Anti-Mage (Vigilante) that can add a death to the count. Plus, I feel like the experienced players are gonna die first (RIP me and Distorted). You're not that right about the D2 MYLO: Pyromancer can't kill N1, and GM might miss a kill. Let's not lynch D1. I did not take what you guys have said in account when I said we had to lynch today.
Also I KNOW FM IS SO FUN XD
It's all good, you seem to already think correctly and you are being good for a new player
Wait, THAT'S ALL?! And I'm the only one browsing this thread?!!! Crap... We need more than that, guys! Communication is critical. 5 pages (assuming you have pages of 20 posts) isn't enough let's get this started better tomorrow IRL day.
I apologize for the inactivity. I only got home about an hour ago. I am going to cancel my vote on Soviet Love in a moment.
-vote unvote
Last edited by ; February 23rd, 2018 at 07:16 AM.
hmm I think we should still decide someone to lynch. Whether we follow through with that lynch or not will be decided later.
@OzyWho you are my strongest town read due to your post. However, it is 1 post and then leaving. anyone can post a good town strategy in 1 post and afk so will want to hear more from you as this day progresses.
@Noz_Bugz would like to see more from you as well and @Soviet_Love
Let's start pressure, start getting information.
-vote noz_bugs
What is your take on what town should do today?
-vote noz_bugz
mis-spelled name.
My opinion is that we shouldn't lynch D1 unless we have a solid lead. One misslynch and we are fucked imo
"I don't take advice from people less successful than me"
~Kanye West
Hi I am just posting to post. You say you want to hear more from me but idk what we can do d1 if people don't claim roles... someone in the last game I played (Rumox) did this and I thought it was really helpful.
So far, the only claim I brought out was blink claiming citizen. Then he later claimed he may be lying, and given that he was Arsonist last game and claimed doctor I'm wary about it. But I really don't get why a town would claim a role.
So far:
Hidden Witch
Hidden Witch
Hidden Witch Hunter
Hidden Witch Hunter
Citizen - Blinkskater
Citizen
Citizen