The only right side is town's side. There are no scum factions, so there's no scum-driven trains.
Banana is scum, and it's in everyone's interests (town, benigns, and the other scum) to kill him, as he goes against everyone else's win condition. It's a no-brainer, really.
In spite of their "anti-town" behaviors, there are quite a few players who have committed one way or another. While some of their play would seem questionable, I can come up with plausibilities of what they could feel it would be a good play.
Then there were those who were initially committed to the town side but have since fallen and either become complacent and well sort of useless on the town-reading front. I think the majority of successful deception happens at this level, so I'll be keeping these players under scrutiny.
Then there are the players we should just yeet off. If I was a marshall this group of people would just die. Like right now.
______
I don't really see the votes moving much more without a separate development.
What did you guys' die roll to? Just ask google to roll your dice for you.
I got a 5.
I'll summarize my case, because I don't feel like typing all of it again:
- He hasn't done a single pro-town thing in over 300 posts.
- He's been buddying with active and power players, which pushing easy trains on inactive and new ones.
- His only non-fluff posts started once he was put at L-2, all while pretending to not care about being lynched. Not being fluff doesn't mean that he's started contributing or helping the town; all of the content has been misdirections with the single goal of self-preservation.
He is scum. Scum must die. Put that vote back where it was.
It's not one wall post (unless you count his very convincing defense when he showed how the train against him formed, which is actually pro-town if he's town, but that's begging the question), but his game as a whole. The claiming stuff, the creation of interactions that are not NAI for once, all of this is pro-town and it's because of him.
Well, you said he was fluffing, which implied he lacked content because he shitposted.
I'll pull a Light_Yagami here: I don't believe I stuttered. I used the words you used: "feigning indifference". You then said that being [in truth, not feigning to be] indifferent to your own lynch is a scum tell. My post explains why it doesn't work. No ??? here.
Pssh, a discredit. Picking a side on what seems to be the hot topic of the moment is not useless, sorry. My vote stays where it is. If you're not happy with it, convince me you're town instead of throwing stones at me, hm?
In that case, blame my not understanding the setup at first. I still don’t, and yeah what I said at the start was a dumb comment - but I’ve not been as apathetic as him. I have a clear stance on some people - I don’t know if Varcron does.
I don’t have a neutral evil rolecard. I can see why you’d come to that conclusion, though. Frankly at the start I was more terrified of the reverse - what if I’m scum and act pro-town and end up lynching the other scum? That would obviously not be advantageous from my point of view. That being said, I can well assure you that I am no longer in that mindset; I’m simply sometimes confused as to who I should be voting. I think my switching to Banana randomly speaks more to that than anything else. Scum don’t benefit from not explaining their lynch vote and being openly opportunistic.
And I like to think that I’d act pro town as a neutral evil in this setup.
I feel like you're disrespecting his scum game lol. He's perfectly able to look all active and contributive as scum, and does it so well that people all townread him last game before mechanical claims got in the way.
This looks like an honest tunnel.
Ah, yes, trying to out TPRs on D1 in a setup with 3 possible roles that can convert town into non-town is very pro-town, right. I don't know if you're usually this slow or if it's an intentional misdirection.
because he only shitposted. Everyone shitposts, but most do other things as well. His fluff only stopped now that he noticed that he's really being lynched today, and he's done nothing but throw weak arguments to defend himself, while still not doing anything of use.Well, you said he was fluffing, which implied he lacked content because he shitposted.
Yes, he feigned indifference and then he only stopped feigning it to try and help himself, while still not contributing anything of use. It's not an either/or scenario nor rocket science.I'll pull a Light_Yagami here: I don't believe I stuttered. I used the words you used: "feigning indifference". You then said that being [in truth, not feigning to be] indifferent to your own lynch is a scum tell. My post explains why it doesn't work. No ??? here.
I don't need to convince anyone of me being town. I have never been lynched as town and will never be. What bothers me is you distracting people away from banana's lynch.Pssh, a discredit. Picking a side on what seems to be the hot topic of the moment is not useless, sorry. My vote stays where it is. If you're not happy with it, convince me you're town instead of throwing stones at me, hm?
Jesus Chriat @Sen look
This was the most pro town post I've made this game. Can you wrap your head around why?
Originally Posted by BananaCucho
Copy/pasting the votes is the most pro-town move?
Let's see:
Ganelon (2 [L-5]):
Frinckles, secondpassing
BananaCucho (2 [L-5]):
SuperJack, Sen
Frinckles (3 [L-4]):
Ganelon, yzb25, BananaCucho
Sen (2 [L-5]):
Marshmallow Marshall, Light_Yagami
renegade (1 [L-6]):
theoneceko
Alright. I'm confirmed mayor now. Vote banana.
Up in your arms, too late to beg you - or cancel it though I know it must be, the killing time.
(๑˃̵ᴗ˂̵)ﻭ 레드벨벳 ! ! ٩(♡ε♡ )۶
@deathworlds got a discord set up so we can see the retroactive saltiness? Thats my favorite.
(๑˃̵ᴗ˂̵)ﻭ 레드벨벳 ! ! ٩(♡ε♡ )۶
Whoops, I think I misposted. I meant that the claiming stuff, while bad by itself, is not worth risking his life from Banana's point of view, whatever he is unless he's jester.
Getting everyone to claim isn't called shitposting. Creating meaningful interactions is DEFINETLY NOT called shitposting.
I'm literally saying that being indifferent to your own lynch is weird, but not inherently scummy, because scums don't want to die more than townies do. Stop ignoring the argument and then discrediting me lol.
Clarification: I'm not distracting from Banana's lynch. I'm DEFENDING Banana because he is not scummy in my eyes. Is that clearer?
Sen had just posted this really weak vote on SJ, and here is BC's response:
This seemed like a very level-headed reaction to the vote. A reaction that wasn't trying to overstate or understate how bad it was. Then, when in my sleep-deprived state, I posted a rather bad vote on Sen:
BC again gave a very level-headed response to that:
I don't necessarily agree with every sentiment, but I thought his mentality here was very sincere.
There, examples of contributions before Sen's vote lol.
How did I get three votes? Thats memes fellas. Imagine lynching the claim of the only TPR that can unfuck your mind. I mean, I could kill you at night, but I don't know that.
(๑˃̵ᴗ˂̵)ﻭ 레드벨벳 ! ! ٩(♡ε♡ )۶
Again; what meaningful interaction? A page of votespam with an inactive player claiming and two others making up a random claim?
And unless you failed to read what has been said -which is becoming more apparent with every post-, his votes are not the main reason why he's being lynched. He's being lynched due to being scum.
And again, if you take a moment to read, you'll notice that feigning indifference isn't the same as being indifferent; he's clearly not indifferent to being lynched, but he's indifferent to doing anything that achieves something more than self-preservation.I'm literally saying that being indifferent to your own lynch is weird, but not inherently scummy, because scums don't want to die more than townies do. Stop ignoring the argument and then discrediting me lol.
Same result.Clarification: I'm not distracting from Banana's lynch. I'm DEFENDING Banana because he is not scummy in my eyes. Is that clearer?
Ganelon (2 [L-5]):
Frinckles, secondpassing
BananaCucho (2 [L-5]):
SuperJack, Sen
Frinckles (3 [L-4]):
Ganelon, yzb25, BananaCucho
Sen (2 [L-5]):
Marshmallow Marshall, Light_Yagami
renegade (1 [L-6]):
theoneceko
Okay, so looking at this we can decipher a few things which may be fairly important
SJ/Sen team is still there
Ceko is still being useless
We can also see that MM and Yagami disagree with the Banana push, so by that process of elimination I can safely assume that MM/Banana/Yagami are on the same page which is fairly peculiar
That leaves a few variables:
Me, Ceko, Ganelon, and Renegade (Ceko being basically irrelevant, except I digress)
I personally dislike how Ganelon is acting, as he is somewhat mirroring my early game play which is wayyy unlike him considering how he plays town in a normal game
My reads as of now are as follows:
Town: MM, Ren, secondpassing
Neutral/so so: SJ, Pringles,Ganelon,Sen, yzb25
Scum: Ceko
Orange means iffy/scummy but not full scum, dark green means leaning town side.
Yo everyone roll your die tell me what you get.
secondpassing: 5 Gyrlander
BananaCucho: 2 Ganelon
Not yet rolled:
Marshmallow Marshall
Ganelon
renegade
Bananacucho
Gyrlander
Varcron
Sen
theoneceko
Light_Yagami
SuperJack
yzb25
Frinckles
Spoiler : VOTE TABLE :
I did read, thank you very much. The vote spam was an event that generated meaningful discussion about itself, and that was 100 % previsible for Banana. That is why it is towny. Also, "he's scummy because he's scum, you're so uninformed"... really lol? You're killing your own case with that last sentence.
But you said that BEING INDIFFERENT was scummy. I said you were excluding it yourself (which you are confirming here), and therefore could not use "being actually indifferent" as an argument. That's all.
Nope: one is a scumpaint, the other is not inherently alignment indicative without context (and of course I'm biased, but I think it's town indicative atm).
Since you seem to require crayons to understand simple concepts:
If you are town and are getting lynched, you do the most out of your remaining time to help he town win even after fucking up and mislynching you, because we aren't some babies holding grudges and you want the town to win, whether you lie or not.
Not being indifferent to getting lynched has nothing to do with that; that's just self-preservation which only the scum care about, since they're the only ones who lose by dying.