OK, so players in this game that have viewed day 2:
ceko, blink, lag, oberon, pqr, wrath, frinckles, crichard, yuesford
players that have not viewed day 2:
varcron, numbertwo, MM, ZZ
Admittedly it does seem unlikely that any of those last 4 were the ones that were leveled up. But Magus could easily have chosen Ozy, or a shadow, the darkness, or templar
Not to mention:
blink is directly contradicting the host on the way the game works.